Immigration Policies Impact on Scotland 2022-12-19
2022-12-19
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question arises from concerns about the potential adverse effects of government immigration policies on the demographic balance and workforce availability in Scotland.
What assessment she has made with Cabinet colleagues of the potential impact of the Government's immigration policies on the (a) population of and (b) availability of labour in Scotland?
Our points-based system, with a wide range of eligible occupations spanning many economic sectors, works for the whole of the United Kingdom by welcoming people to fill skills gaps, support our public services and boost our economy. As noted by the Migration Advisory Committee's annual report, immigration policy cannot be a complete solution to population movements within the UK, or labour shortages. It is for the Scottish Government to use their policy levers to address those issues more effectively.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not provide a direct assessment of the impact on Scotland's population and labor market but refers to overall immigration policy effectiveness.
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent from Scotland is a renewable energy researcher who is an asylum seeker facing employment and study restrictions imposed by the government, which impacts labour shortages in various sectors.
One of my constituents is a renewable energy researcher from Syria, and he is struggling with the Government's restrictive policies on the employment of asylum seekers. He is unable to work or pursue further study in his field. Given that the shortage of labour impacts all sectors of the economy, does the Minister agree that the UK Government should make the rules on asylum seekers seeking employment less restrictive to support the Scottish labour market?
No, I do not, because we want to ensure that deterrence is diffused throughout our asylum system. That means making the UK a significantly less attractive destination for asylum seekers, and particularly for those asylum shopping, than our EU neighbours. For that reason, we do not want to see asylum seekers working in the British economy. We want to see their cases decided as quickly as possible. If they are approved, of course they should be welcomed into the UK and make a positive contribution to British society. If they are declined, they should be removed.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer avoids addressing whether employment rules for asylum seekers should be relaxed to support the labour market in Scotland.
Response accuracy