Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The housing market is experiencing high mortgage rates, rising rents, and a projected decline in house building. The Prime Minister previously admitted to dropping housing targets.
We are facing a severe housing situation with soaring mortgages, increasing rents, and an anticipated reduction in new constructions. Given the Prime Minister's acknowledgment of his decision to lower housing goals, will he explain why the preferences of 1,000 party members outweigh those of families hoping to become homeowners?
On the Government side of the House we believe in empowering local communities to make decisions that are right for them, protecting their green spaces. In areas where house building is insufficient to meet demand, such as Labour-controlled London, this issue persists.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The response did not provide a specific explanation or commitment regarding the prioritization of party member opinions over public needs.
Changed Subject
General Principles
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Welsh Labour Government proposed offering £1,600 monthly to asylum seekers. The questioner seeks assurance that such a scheme will not be replicated in the UK's small boats Bill.
It has been reported that the Welsh Labour Government are providing £1,600 monthly to asylum seekers through taxpayers' money. Can my right hon. Friend assure me that our small boats Bill will not adopt this idea?
My noble Friend Lord Bellamy and the Secretary of State for Wales confirmed to the Welsh Government yesterday that we would not undertake their request. The Labour leader has stated that the Welsh Labour Government are his blueprint; however, they propose paying illegal migrants £1,600 monthly.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Conservative Party Chair stated public services are in good shape, despite reports of rising NHS waiting lists and low conviction rates for crimes.
The Tory party chair claims that public services are well-managed. Has the Prime Minister encountered any member of the public who would agree with this assessment?
Due to record investment in public services like the NHS, we are reducing waiting lists. Our reforms in education have increased good and outstanding schools. We deliver more funding, reform, and better outcomes for Britain compared to Labour's track record.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The response did not provide evidence of public agreement or disagreement with the claim about public service conditions.
General Principles
Comparison
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Criticism of the government's handling of the criminal justice system, with issues such as long waiting times for ambulances, low rape conviction rates, and high small boat arrivals.
How can anyone think services are in good shape when people wait days for an ambulance, only one percent of rapists face trial, and a record number of boats cross the channel seeking asylum?
Since 2010, crime rates have dropped by 50%, we have increased police numbers to 20,000 and toughened sentencing laws. Labour opposes these measures.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The response did not address the specific issues raised about public service conditions.
Comparison
Statistical Data
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A case where a violent attacker's sentence was suspended due to delays in the court system.
The problem is, Prime Minister, that Arie Ali's sentence ended up being suspended. Anyone watching this would wonder why someone who violently attacks a key worker is not behind bars. It took 16 months for him to be charged and two years before sentencing—completely unacceptable. Is he letting violent criminals go free due to the government's loss of control over court services?
Our record shows we toughened laws on sex offenders, increased rape convictions by over 60%, and opposed watering down punishments at Sentencing Council meetings. That is why they call me Sir Softie: soft on crime, soft on criminals.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The response did not address the specific issue of court delays leading to suspended sentences for violent offenders.
Comparison
Statistical Data
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The government's actions on prison overcrowding have led to courts being advised to consider current prison population levels when sentencing.
I prosecuted thousands of sex offenders. The Prime Minister's misunderstanding of how the criminal justice system works is evident. No wonder he cannot fix it. In Arie Ali's case, a letter from the Justice Secretary about prison overcrowding contributed to suspending his sentence.
We are building 20,000 more prison places and toughening sentencing to put more people behind bars. When I read the right hon. and learned Gentleman's work as a lawyer, people were 'really disappointed' that his organization had been letting down victims.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The response did not address the specific issue of prison overcrowding affecting sentencing decisions.
Comparison
Personal Attack
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
In 2013, the Home Affairs Committee commended Keir Starmer's efforts as Director of Public Prosecutions.
When I was in office as Director of Public Prosecution, those on the Benches opposite were my greatest supporters. In 2013, the Home Affairs Committee said: 'We would like to commend the work of the Director for Public Prosecution, Keir Starmer'.
I think the right hon. and learned Gentleman started by talking about 2013, a year in which he got his own special law called The Pensions Increase Act, while being 'really disappointed' that his organization had been letting down victims.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Personal Attack
Response accuracy
Q8
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlighted the recognition of local community members for their volunteer work, emphasizing the importance of acknowledging such contributions.
Recently I presented a Prime Minister's Points of Light award to Joan Willett and two other Hastings and Rye residents were celebrated as community champions at No. 10. Will the Prime Minister join me in thanking all our fantastic volunteers and community champions, not only in Hastings and Rye but throughout the United Kingdom, and will he continue to bring them together in celebration?
I thank my hon. Friend and I am absolutely delighted that Joan received her Points of Light award. Volunteers and community champions such as Joan, Anthony and Alastair all make important contributions to their local community and we are all grateful to them. Every month, millions do the same thing and they deserve our praise. Their generosity is integral to what makes our country and our communities special, and it is right that we do everything we can to celebrate them.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP questioned the government's focus and approach to delivering services in Scotland, highlighting the importance of community support.
Mr Speaker—[Interruption.] What we are talking about is the fact that this Government is not getting distracted by the things that are going on elsewhere; they are focused on delivering for the people of Scotland. The Prime Minister has been fined by the polis not once but twice, they take donations from Russian-backed donors and they have stuffed the House of Lords with people like Baroness Mone. But let us be clear: what we are talking about is the fact that the leader of the Scottish Conservatives believes that the people of Scotland should return Labour party Members of Parliament to this House rather than Scottish National party Members. So is not the message for the people of Scotland quite clear? Don't give the Tories what they want.
What we are doing is not getting distracted by the things that are going on elsewhere; we are focused on delivering for the people of Scotland. We are making sure that we fund public services well, with £1.5 billion extra in Barnett consequentials. We are making sure that we provide support with the cost of living.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The questioner's criticism and request for specific alignment on political strategy was not directly addressed
Under Review
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP criticized the government for its handling of public services, accusing it of failing to support communities and taking donations from Russian-backed sources.
Let me be clear: we will take no lectures from a party that has not had a mandate to govern in Scotland since 1955, that went through three Prime Ministers in the course of just a matter of months, that crashed the economy, that sent mortgage rates soaring and that has taken energy support away from families most in need. The Prime Minister has been fined by the polis not once but twice, they take donations from Russian-backed donors and they have stuffed the House of Lords with people like Baroness Mone. But let us be clear: what we are talking about is the fact that the leader of the Scottish Conservatives believes that the people of Scotland should return Labour party Members of Parliament to this House rather than Scottish National party Members. So is not the message for the people of Scotland quite clear? Don't give the Tories what they want.
Actually, the Scottish Conservatives deserve enormous praise for forcing the SNP into abandoning its completely unworkable, fundamentally flawed deposit return scheme. So it is good that the SNP U-turned and listened to the voices of the Scottish Conservatives and to business, and we look forward to working with them on delivering something that actually works to deliver for the people of Scotland.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP questioned the Prime Minister about the ongoing junior doctors' strike, emphasizing its potential risks to patient safety.
It seems clear that the junior doctors' strike is causing a serious risk of loss of life, and certainly causing harm and pain to thousands of our constituents. The first line of the Hippocratic oath is “First, do no harm”. When does the Prime Minister think the British Medical Association abandoned this central tenet of its profession?
We value the work of junior doctors and are keen to find a fair and reasonable settlement that recognises their role and the wider economic context facing the UK. My right hon. Friend is right to highlight the impact on patient safety, and that is why this Government have brought forward minimum safety legislation to ensure that patients can rely on a core level of emergency service to protect vital patient care.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q12
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlighted the high incidence of tooth decay among young children, emphasizing the need to increase dental check-up access.
Tooth decay is the No. 1 reason that children over the age of four end up in hospital. Regular dental check-ups could prevent it, but too many parents cannot get one for their child. In the East Riding of Yorkshire, there are now almost 3,000 people per NHS dentist. In places such as Herefordshire and Norfolk, fewer than two in five children have been seen by a dentist in the past year. This is a scandal, so will the Prime Minister take up the Liberal Democrat plan to end this crisis and make sure people can get an NHS dentist when they need one?
The NHS recently reformed dentistry contracts, which will improve access for patients. Dentistry receives about £3 billion a year, and there were around 500 more dentists delivering care in the NHS last year than in the previous year. I am pleased to say that almost 45% more children saw an NHS dentist last year compared with the year before.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP referenced a previous Prime Minister's commitment to improving the Dawlish railway line and questioned its current funding status.
At Prime Minister's Question Time on 4 February 2015, David Cameron said he was determined to do whatever it took to fix the Dawlish railway line—the only route to the south-west. Phase 4 risks losing part of its agreed funding, while phase 5 has fallen foul of a 10-year moratorium on new funding. The line is only as resilient as its weakest link. Will the Prime Minister commit to getting this resilience programme back on track and fully funded?
We are committed to improving the resilience of this iconic stretch of railway, which provides a vital link for people in the south-west. That is why, to date, we have invested more than £165 million in delivering solutions to protect the line. Network Rail continues to develop the case for further investment, and my hon. Friend will be keen to feed into that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Scottish Government has committed to making Dundee and Scotland a major world economy, but the UK Government seems opposed. The UK Government instructed ambassadors and diplomats to obstruct Scotland's international engagement.
This week, not only has my city of Dundee announced that its flights will connect with Heathrow but the Scottish Government have committed to Dundee being at the forefront of making Scotland a major world economy, bringing investment, jobs and opportunity. However, the UK Government seem to have a problem with this. Scotland's international engagement is to be reduced. Despite being paid for through Scotland's wealth and taxes, UK ambassadors and diplomats have been instructed to obstruct the Scottish Government's international engagement, with every foreign nation told not to deal with the Scottish Government directly. This has already been described as “smacking of a parent trying, and failing, to control a teenager.” Will the Prime Minister assure me and the businesses, the wealth creators and, most importantly, my constituents who want to see Dundee and Scotland prosper that, during this short time that Scotland remains in this unequal Union, Scotland will neither be put back in a box nor bend a knee?
I am pleased to say that we are supporting the communities of Dundee, which received £14 million from the levelling-up fund to support a green transport hub in the city centre. This demonstrates that the UK Government want to invest in the communities of Scotland and to deliver for Scottish people.
▸
Assessment & feedback
UK Government's instructions to diplomats obstructing Scottish international engagement
Changed Subject To Funding
Response accuracy
Q15
Direct Answer
▸
Context
A 17-year-old constituent, Alfie Ford, is walking to raise funds for the National Autistic Society, aiming to walk 15,000 steps every day in April.
On Saturday, I joined my 17-year-old constituent Alfie Ford in walking to raise funds for the National Autistic Society. Alfie's mission is to walk 15,000 steps every day in the month of April to raise awareness of autism and to show that every autistic person deserves the best chance in life. This Saturday, he is walking from Birmingham City football club to Edgbaston stadium and back again. Will the Prime Minister join me in wishing Alfie the very best for his walk, and for his noble mission to change for good how people think about autism?
I praise Alfie for his fantastic efforts. He is an inspiration not just for his community but for many others, and I wish him the best of luck for Saturday. Our autism strategy sets out our ambition to ensure that autistic people across all parts of the country get the support they need to live fulfilling and happy lives, and I look forward to seeing Alfie's progress on the rest of his journey.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent, Lisa, is frustrated by the government's imposition of derisory 2% and now 4.5% pay rises despite years of pay restraint and double-digit inflation.
My constituent Lisa and her civil service colleagues have worked tirelessly and with distinction during some of the most challenging times, but she is fed up with Ministers patting them on the back while imposing derisory 2% and, now, 4.5% pay rises, despite years of pay restraint and, now, double-digit inflation. She asks simply: “Why should I keep working for a UK government that treats its workers with such contempt?” Will the Prime Minister stop with the myths and excuses, and start negotiating a fair deal with the unions?
I pay tribute to all our hard-working public sector workers for the job they do. We have a well-established independent pay review body process for making sure that we can have pay settlements that are fair and affordable. I am very pleased that we have reached agreement with many unions on those pay settlements and I hope that those members vote in support of them.
▸
Assessment & feedback
negotiations for fair deal with the unions
Reference To Well-Established Process
Response accuracy
Q17
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The questioner challenges the opposition to look at their own record when criticizing the Conservative Government's record on law and order.
Does my right hon. Friend agree that those who seek to criticise the Conservative record on law and order should look in the mirror and ask, “Who was Director of Public Prosecutions for some of those years?”
My right hon. Friend is absolutely right. Our record is clear. We have halved crime since 2010; neighbourhood crime has fallen by 25% just in the last few years; criminals are spending longer in prison; and, crucially, we, unlike the Labour party, are giving the police the powers they need to tackle violent protests.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q18
Direct Answer
▸
Context
A constituent, Anne, and her husband are stuck in Turkey after a medical emergency. Their insurance company, Staysure, has refused to pay medical bills.
My elderly constituent Anne has been in Turkey for five weeks now after her husband suffered a devastating brain bleed—he is now in intensive care. Their holiday insurance company, Staysure, has refused to pay medical bills and has so far refused to engage with me. This has resulted in Anne being stuck with extortionate medical bills and surgery costs, which she has covered by using their life savings. With finances now running out, they are both stranded and have been advised that they will need to find at least £50,000 to pay for an air ambulance to bring them home. Will the Prime Minister meet me to consider all possible options to support constituents such as Anne and her husband in difficult situations such as that, especially where insurance companies abdicate all responsibility?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his question. I am very sorry to hear about the case that he raises. My thoughts are with Anne and her husband, as I am sure everyone's will be, at this difficult time. I will ensure that the hon. Gentleman gets a meeting as soon as possible with the relevant Minister to discuss and progress this case further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q19
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The questioner highlights the difference in council tax rates between Conservative-controlled and Labour-controlled councils, suggesting that voting Conservative would be beneficial for constituents.
Can I tell a tale of two councils? My constituents who live in Conservative-controlled Wychavon District Council have enjoyed six years of council tax freezes and excellent public services, while my constituents who live in the Malvern Hills District Council area, which is run by a rag-tag-bag of so-called independents and Greens, pay nearly 50% more in council tax for a band D property. Does the Prime Minister agree that the best thing my constituents can do on the cost of living is to vote Conservative on 4 May?
My hon. Friend is of course right. Right across the country, those who live in Conservative council areas pay lower council tax than those in Labour council areas. The choice at this election is clear: it is the Conservatives who deliver for you and it is Labour that costs you.
▸
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Women's Rights Network published a report revealing 6,539 reported rapes and sexual assaults in UK hospital settings from January 2019 to October 2022. Eight police forces did not provide data, suggesting the real figures are higher.
This week, the Women's Rights Network published a report by criminologist Professor Jo Phoenix called “When we are at our most vulnerable”. It revealed that there were 6,539 reported rapes and sexual assaults in UK hospital settings from January 2019 to October 2022. What can the Prime Minister and his Government do to ensure that all women, staff and patients are safe in Britain's hospitals?
I was deeply shocked and appalled to hear about the cases of sexual assault and abuse in the NHS. NHS organisations are responsible for protecting their staff and patients from sexual harassment and conduct. They have recently established a domestic abuse and sexual violence programme to build more robust safeguarding processes for protecting patients, and we will work very closely with them to ensure that this is implemented.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Corwen station on the Llangollen steam railway will be officially reopened on June 2, 60 years after it was closed under the Beeching axe. The levelling-up fund granted to Clwyd South has paid for a new roof at Corwen station.
On 2 June, Corwen station on the Llangollen steam railway will be officially reopened, having been closed 60 years ago under the Beeching axe. Will the Prime Minister join me in congratulating the volunteers, the local community and the funders who have made that possible, and take his own share of the credit for granting the levelling-up fund to Clwyd South when he was Chancellor, which has paid for the magnificent new roof on Corwen station?
I pay tribute to my hon. Friend for all his campaigning on this. I am delighted that the levelling-up fund has delivered for Corwen station. It is a huge boost to local ambitions to see trains returning there.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Supermarket workers expect to suffer a violent assault every day at work. The Prime Minister is being asked about measures in place to ensure workplace safety.
Over recess, I was invited to visit one of the major supermarkets in my constituency to discuss food waste. What struck me most was the experience of shop workers on the frontline. They told me that they expect to suffer a violent assault every single day that they go to work. Although more maths might always be helpful, what is this out-of-touch Prime Minister doing to make sure that people can be safe in their workplace?
Everyone deserves to be safe in their workplace, which is why we are making sure that, through our sentencing Act, we have appropriate sentencing in place and, more generally, that we have police officers and community support officers across the country to help combat crime.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Bolton Wanderers won a trophy match, the Bolton College of Medical Sciences has been delivered, and Ayyub Patel won the Rumworth by-election. The Prime Minister is asked for his message to local campaigners and candidates.
Leadership and teamwork delivered Bolton Wanderers a superb 4-0 victory in the Papa John's trophy match at Wembley. It is delivering the Bolton College of Medical Sciences and delivered Ayyub Patel's superb Rumworth by-election victory. What message does my right hon. Friend have for Councillor Patel and all the campaigners, candidates and activists, as we run into this festival of democracy, our local elections?
I share in my hon. Friend's congratulations for all those in Bolton, but also offer my commiserations to those in Plymouth, especially to our party chairman who is an avid supporter of the green army. Most importantly, I welcome the election of Councillor Patel and look forward to his joining our other councillors in delivering for their local areas, with less crime, lower council tax and, importantly, filling more potholes.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Home Office announced it would not set up a bespoke visa scheme for the fishing industry, affecting crew availability in fishing ports around the coast.
Last week, the Home Office announced that it would not be setting up a bespoke visa scheme for the fishing industry of the sort that is already available for people working in fish farms and in offshore wind farms. It also told skippers that crew previously employed by them under a temporary scheme had to stop working immediately. As a consequence of that announcement, in fishing ports around the coast today, many fishing boats are tied up unable to go to sea. What is the point of a sea of opportunity if they cannot get crew to fish in it?
We are proud champions of the UK's fishing industry, not least with our £100 million investment in fishing communities. We are always looking to engage with those communities to make sure that they get the support that they need.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A community allotment was established with the help of local churches and Lorna and Shirley from the Marios Tinenti Centre.
Will the Prime Minister join me in thanking Lorna and Shirley of the Marios Tinenti Centre and the local churches in Loughborough for all their hard work in establishing a community allotment? Local people use the facility as a great place to get outdoors as well as to relax.
I pay tribute to Lorna and Shirley for all their fantastic work. Allotments can do wonders not just for providing food but also for wellbeing and providing a place of sanctuary for people around the country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy