PMQs 2023-07-12

2023-07-12

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
Labour's plans to tax private education could lead to 40,000 pupils being sent into the state sector and cost £300 million. English language schools in Craig Mackinlay's constituency are concerned about this.
Does the Deputy Prime Minister share my disgust at Labour's plans to tax education of choice which could lead to 40,000 pupils being sent into the state sector, with a cost to the taxpayer? A number of English language schools in my constituency are concerned that this will also apply to them, as well as to out-of-hours tuition and sports training.
Once again, we have seen the Labour party putting the politics of envy above the interests of children in this country. As my hon. Friend rightly highlights, recent analysis shows that it could lead to over 40,000 pupils leaving the schools they are in, placing further burdens on existing schools and costing £300 million.
Assessment & feedback
Putting The Politics Of Envy Above The Interests Of Children
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
John Prescott asked why tens of thousands of families are facing repossession, negative equity, and homelessness under the current government. Angela Rayner is questioning Oliver Dowden about the same issue.
Why is it that in Tory Britain, tens of thousands of families are facing repossession, negative equity and homelessness? Can the Deputy Prime Minister tell us, 27 years later, why I am having to ask the same question?
Clearly, the right hon. Lady did not listen to my previous comments. The Prime Minister is at NATO. Of course, that would not be a problem if she had had her way. Her old boss wanted to abandon Ukraine, abolish the Army and withdraw from NATO, and he certainly would not be going to any summit.
Assessment & feedback
Prime Minister Is At Nato Referring To Labour'S Previous Actions
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
The number of homeless children has risen by 75% under the current government, according to recent figures. Angela Rayner is questioning Oliver Dowden about this issue.
I think the right hon. Gentleman is taking lessons from the former Prime Minister on telling the facts. The last Labour Government worked hard to dramatically reduce the number of children in temporary accommodation, but under the Tories the number of homeless children has risen by 75%. I am proud of our record on tackling child poverty. Does the right hon. Gentleman feel ashamed of his?
I will take no lectures from the Labour party on home ownership. My parents would not have been able to buy their own home if it were not for Margaret Thatcher and the reforms introduced by her Government, and this Government are building on those with record house building.
Assessment & feedback
Home Ownership Referring To Margaret Thatcher'S Reforms
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
The Children's Commissioner warned the other Prime Minister about peddling false narratives on child poverty. Angela Rayner is questioning Oliver Dowden about rising bills, soaring mortgages, and plummeting real wages pushing more families to the brink.
Rising bills, soaring mortgages and plummeting real wages are pushing more and more families to the brink. Those already struggling are being hit hardest by the Tory mortgage bombshell and rising food costs. How many primary school children have been pushed into poverty since his Government took power?
I say to the right hon. Lady that it was this Conservative party, not the Labour party, that extended free school meals to all five, six and seven-year-olds—something the Labour party failed to do—and that sits alongside many measures we are taking to help people with the cost of living.
Assessment & feedback
Extended Free School Meals
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
New research shows that 400,000 more primary school-age children are growing up in poverty since the current government came to office. Angela Rayner is questioning Oliver Dowden about this issue.
Once again, the right hon. Gentleman talks about balancing the books. His party crashed the economy and he seems oblivious to what it is like for working people in this country at the moment. New research shows that 400,000 more primary school-age children are growing up in poverty since his Government came to office. Why does he think that is?
I will take absolutely no lectures whatsoever from the Labour party about how we help children in the most need. It is record investment from this Government in education—£2 billion more this year, £2 billion next year—which is giving those very children the best possible start in life.
Assessment & feedback
Record Investment In Education
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
The right hon. Gentleman does not acknowledge that child poverty is rising, let alone explain why. Angela Rayner is questioning Oliver Dowden about the number of kids without a permanent address compared to when Labour left office in 2010.
What hope has he got of solving it? Let me try a simpler question: how many kids do not have a permanent address today compared with when Labour left office in 2010?
We can exchange all these numbers across the Dispatch Boxes, but these are the numbers that matter. There are 1.7 million fewer people in absolute poverty under this Government, 400,000 fewer children, 200,000 fewer pensioners and 1 million fewer people of working age.
Assessment & feedback
Number Of People In Absolute Poverty
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Angela Rayner Lab
Ashton-under-Lyne
Context
The questioner references a significant increase in child homelessness, with 55,000 more children without permanent addresses since the Conservative government took office 13 years ago. She also mentions Labour's focus on tackling child poverty compared to the current government.
There are 55,000 more children without a permanent address today compared with when the Tories took office 13 years ago. How can you be so complacent in the face of this increase in child homelessness and poverty?
This Government has lifted 400,000 children out of poverty. The current high mortgage rates and inflation are driven by factors such as Russia's invasion of Ukraine and post-covid supply chain issues.
Assessment & feedback
The increase in child homelessness was not directly addressed
Deflection
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
Concerns over the lack of investment by pension funds specifically into UK companies, especially climate technology start-ups, leading to them seeking funding abroad.
What more can be done to encourage our pension funds to invest specifically in British companies and climate technology start-ups?
The Chancellor's pension compact will unlock £75 billion of additional investment, much of which is expected to go to UK companies. Measures like the Edinburgh reforms also aim to improve financial services in this country.
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures to encourage pension funds to invest in British companies were not detailed
Deflection
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Context
The Deputy Prime Minister dismissed warnings about rising mortgage rates due to inflation. The Bank of England predicts that mortgage payments will rise by at least £500 for a million households.
How high do mortgage rates need to go before the Government takes this seriously?
Higher mortgage rates are driven by inflation, caused mainly by Russia's invasion of Ukraine and post-covid supply chain issues. The focus is on halving inflation to reduce mortgage rates.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions to address rising mortgage rates were not detailed
Deflection
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
Concerns about the government's response to rising mortgage rates. The Bank of England predicts that mortgage payments will rise by at least £500 for a million households.
Does the Deputy Prime Minister understand the immediate need for help due to increasing mortgage rates?
We are taking action through the mortgage charter, signed by 90% of providers, which helps people extend terms and reduce monthly payments. We also support Martin Lewis's advice for money-saving.
Assessment & feedback
Immediate help was not specifically addressed
Deflection
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
Concerns about the potential closure of Abbeyfield House, a charity providing assisted living for older people. The charity cannot meet the cost to update their estate.
Will my right hon. Friend meet me to see what support can be offered to Abbeyfield so that residents do not have to leave?
We are providing £7.5 billion of additional funding for social care and discharge, including energy advice services and pilot audit and grant schemes that may help.
Assessment & feedback
Specific support for Abbeyfield House was not detailed
Deflection
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Edward Davey Lib Dem
Kingston and Surbiton
Context
Concerns about the closure of local dentists, leaving patients without a dentist to see.
When can people get an appointment with a local NHS dentist?
Our NHS workforce plan invests £2.4 billion into training and retaining crucial staff, including dentists and GPs, with a 40% rise in the number of dentists.
Assessment & feedback
Specific timeline for increasing dental appointments was not provided
Deflection
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Kit Malthouse Con
North West Hampshire
Context
Concerns about the allocation of funds from round 3 of the levelling-up fund and ensuring all parts of the country benefit, particularly Andover.
When can we expect allocations from round 3 of the levelling-up fund?
We will shortly announce the new approach to the third round and further details will follow shortly.
Assessment & feedback
Specific timeline was not provided
Deflection
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Pete Wishart SNP
Perth and Kinross-shire
Context
The Home Office painted over a children's Mickey Mouse mural at a detention centre in Kent.
There are things we encounter in political life that are certain to horrify, appal and sicken us, but I do not think I have ever seen anything quite so grotesque as the painting over of a children's Mickey Mouse mural, as the Home Office did at a detention centre in Kent. No Minister has, so far, roused the necessary compassion or concern to speak out about this. Will the Deputy Prime Minister look into the deeper recesses of his soul and simply condemn it?
I will tell the hon. Gentleman what real compassion looks like: stopping the vile people-smuggling trade across the channel that is condemning women and children to death. This Government are taking action to deal with it through our “stop the boats” Bill, which the Scottish National party shamefully voted against 18 times last night.
Assessment & feedback
The Deputy Prime Minister did not address the mural painting issue and instead criticized the opposition's stance on immigration.
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Context
According to a recent estimate by Barclays, it now takes eight years for the average first-time buyer to save for a deposit, and in parts of London and the south-east it can take longer.
As the party of aspiration, we know the importance of home ownership. According to a recent estimate by Barclays, it now takes eight years for the average first-time buyer to save for a deposit, and in parts of London and the south-east it can take longer. What are the Deputy Prime Minister and the Government doing to improve the prospects for younger people who want to own their own home?
I know my hon. Friend is passionate in championing this issue. Almost 850,000 households have been helped to purchase a home since 2010. In 2021, the number of people getting on to the property ladder for the first time was at a 20-year high, thanks to initiatives such as First Homes and the Help to Buy scheme. Of course, that stands in contrast to the Labour party, which oversaw the lowest level of house building since the 1920s.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Cat Smith Lab
Lancaster and Wyre
Context
Many of the constituents find they can get the best-value fare by going to the staffed ticket office at Lancaster station.
With rising ticket prices, many of my constituents find they can get the best-value fare by going to the staffed ticket office at Lancaster station, which is perhaps why so many of them have signed my petition to save staffing at the station. Is the closure of ticket offices just yet another cost of living bombshell hitting my hard-working constituents?
It is important that the railways continue to reform after the record amount of money we gave them during covid. If the hon. Lady is concerned about her constituents getting anywhere on the railways, I gently say that she should condemn the totally unjustified strikes that close them down week after week.
Assessment & feedback
The Deputy Prime Minister did not address the closure of ticket offices and instead criticized strikes.
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The unprecedented climate change-driven heatwave caused irreparable damage to Chelmsford's flyover. Since then, people from across Essex have been getting stuck in Chelmsford's traffic jams.
Four summers ago, the unprecedented climate change-driven heatwave caused irreparable damage to Chelmsford's flyover. Since then, people from across Essex have been getting stuck in Chelmsford's traffic jams, which are wasting time and hitting our economic growth. We badly need a new junction at the Army and Navy, but the funding decision has been stuck in Whitehall. Will my right hon. Friend use his cross-Cabinet convening power to get the Treasury and the Department for Transport to agree to the money so that we can deliver a new junction, stop the traffic jams and get Chelmsford moving again?
My right hon. Friend has been making a powerful case for this scheme, and she does so once again. The Chancellor is sitting next to me and will have heard her. I understand that the outline business case submitted by Essex County Council is being considered by Ministers right now, and all relevant Ministers will have heard her injunction.
Assessment & feedback
The Deputy Prime Minister did not commit to using his convening power but acknowledged the Chancellor's presence.
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Context
Scottish Ambulance Service statistics show a more than 30% increase in hypothermic call-outs across Scotland last winter, including an 84% increase in the north.
Scottish Ambulance Service statistics show a more than 30% increase in hypothermic call-outs across Scotland last winter, including a staggering 84% increase in the north in December. Although fuel prices have fallen slightly, food and other costs have risen exponentially. To end the perversity of energy-rich Scotland seeing a third of Scots freezing in fuel poverty, when will the Government bring in a social tariff to ensure that the poor and vulnerable can get through this winter without calling out the ambulance service because they are freezing?
As my right hon. Friend the Chancellor set out in his autumn statement, we are exploring the best approach to consumer protection from April 2024 as part of wider retail market reforms. I reiterate that we paid half of energy bills in Scotland last winter, thanks to the strength of our Union.
Assessment & feedback
The Deputy Prime Minister did not address bringing in a social tariff but mentioned exploring consumer protection measures.
Response accuracy
Q19 Direct Answer
Context
Yesterday was National Remembering Srebrenica Day. British soldiers took about 2,000 civilians out of Srebrenica in April 1993.
May I remind the Deputy Prime Minister and the House that yesterday was National Remembering Srebrenica Day? May I particularly point out a little-known fact? British soldiers took about 2,000 civilians out of Srebrenica in April 1993. Those British soldiers were from B Squadron 9th/12th Lancers. It is not widely known, but, under my command, they saved a huge number of lives by taking those people out of Srebrenica. They, too, should be remembered for their very gallant actions, because it was very dangerous.
I pay tribute to my right hon. and gallant Friend and to all those whom he commanded in the 1990s. We must honour the memory of those killed, and pay tribute to the extraordinary courage shown by their families, survivors and all those members of our armed forces, who served so gallantly in that situation.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Context
The Welsh Affairs Committee asked the Chief Secretary to the Treasury about the varying comparability factors for Wales of Crossrail, Thameslink and HS2.
In the Welsh Affairs Committee, my hon. Friend the Member for Ceredigion (Ben Lake) asked the Chief Secretary to the Treasury about the varying comparability factors for Wales of Crossrail, Thameslink and HS2. His answer began: “you are dragging me into quite complex technical details.” Then, he gave no complex technical details. I am sure that the people of Wales would be delighted to tackle any complex technical details were the Deputy Prime Minister to explain to the House why we are paying £5 billion for a white elephant in HS2, which, by now, comes nowhere near our country.
It is thanks to the strength of our United Kingdom that record sums are going to Wales under the Barnett consequentials. Indeed, in the spring Budget we increased devolved Administration funding by £630 million, which included £180 million for the Welsh Government. We are ensuring that resources are going to Wales, so that they can enhance their transport infrastructure.
Assessment & feedback
The Deputy Prime Minister did not address HS2 funding and instead highlighted general funding increases for Wales.
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
A mobile phone signal mast in Horning, Norfolk has been rendered unusable by nesting seagulls. This is expected to cut off residents and tourists from emergency communication services until August.
If it were not so serious, it would be comical, but in Horning on the Norfolk broads, a whole area is to be totally cut off from a mobile signal until—wait for it—August, because of nesting seagulls taking up residency in the new telecoms mast. Gulls are protected and the nest cannot be moved, but if a family holidaying on the broads gets into distress this summer, they will not be able to make an emergency call. That could be life-threatening, so will the Deputy Prime Minister please help me by calling on Natural England to be sensible and make sure that, for public safety reasons, we can get a mobile phone mast working in a prime holiday location?
We all love the diversity of wildlife in this country and particularly on the North Norfolk coast, which my hon. Friend represents. He makes a strong point about the balance between that and ensuring that people have access to modern communication facilities, and I shall certainly take that up with Natural England.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Context
There has been speculation about a government reshuffle, possibly due to incompetence or obstruction in the civil service.
Day in, day out, the public and businesses are hit by endless chaos and confusion across Government Departments—for them, clearly, Britain is not working. Paraphrasing what the Deputy Prime Minister said earlier, we know there is a Government reshuffle coming up. So will he tell us: is this down to obstruction and incompetence in the civil service, or is it, rather, that so many of their Ministers are just not up to the job?
We can see from the record of this Government, whether on cutting NHS waiting lists, or on providing record funding for our schools and hospitals, that we have an excellent team who will continue to serve.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner asked about civil service issues or ministerial performance leading to a reshuffle; the answer did not address this but instead highlighted achievements of the current government.
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Context
The NHS celebrated its 75th anniversary alongside the 75th anniversary of Newton Aycliffe, a town designed by William Beveridge.
Last week, we all celebrated the 75th anniversary of the NHS, but hon. Members may not be aware that it is also the 75th anniversary of Newton Aycliffe, a new town in my constituency designed by William Beveridge. Will the Deputy Prime Minister ask the Prime Minister to come and visit me, as his constituency neighbour, and celebrate these 75 years, and indeed the 60 years of the community newspaper provided by the Howarth family?
I cannot speak to the Prime Minister's diary, although I will make representations. I would be delighted to visit my hon. Friend's constituency, if he wishes me to attend instead.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Context
The questioner experienced difficulties accessing mortgage support due to low income.
The day I had to phone my bank to tell it that I was having difficulty paying my mortgage was one that has lived with me for years. I found that because my income was so low at the time, ironically, I was not eligible to switch to an interest-only mortgage or get any help. I never want my constituents to feel the terror and abandonment that I felt that day. Can the Deputy Prime Minister understand that? The complete lack of empathy in his responses to the deputy leader of the SNP group suggests not. I welcome the temporary measures, but they are temporary. This mortgage crisis has been two years in the making. Do he and the Prime Minister really think they are going to fix it in 12 months?
It is deeply disturbing, upsetting and worrying for anyone to contemplate losing their home. That is exactly why my right hon. Friend the Chancellor has introduced the mortgage charter, which 90% of the mortgage market has now signed up to and which will provide support to people. In addition, after three months, people on universal credit can apply for further support.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Context
A Government survey showed that 75% of British businesses support improvements to the sick pay system.
A Government survey has shown that 75% of British businesses support improvements to the UK's sick pay system. Yesterday, my right hon. and learned Friend the Member for South Swindon (Sir Robert Buckland) launched a report, alongside WPI Economics and the Centre for Progressive Change, with ideas about how that could be done. Will my right hon. Friend the Deputy Prime Minister ensure that we get a meeting with the Chancellor, ahead of the autumn Budget, to see what ideas can be developed? They could provide an economic boost of £4 billion to the UK economy.
As ever, my hon. Friend has made a strong case. The Chancellor is sitting next to me and I am quite sure he would be delighted to meet with him.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q26 Partial Answer
Dan Carden Lab
Liverpool Walton
Context
The Care Supporters Bill would guarantee that care supporters have access to loved ones in care homes and hospitals.
The forced isolation of people in care homes or hospitals from their loved ones from the beginning of the pandemic, and its terrible consequences, as well as the many who died alone, has left a profound trauma. We have learned the hard way that the care of a loved one is not an optional extra; it is an essential part of dignified care. My Care Supporters Bill would guarantee that fundamental right. While the Government recognise that there is a problem, their recently announced consultation relates to visiting and not a legal right to a care supporter at all times. Would the Deputy Prime Minister speak to the Prime Minister about bringing forward legislation in the next King's Speech?
The hon. Gentleman is right to highlight the need for care supporters to be able to have that kind of access. I will take away the points he has raised, and raise them with my ministerial colleagues.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q27 Direct Answer
Karen Bradley Con
Staffordshire Moorlands
Context
The Inter-Parliamentary Union, founded nearly 135 years ago in the UK, has its president visiting this week.
Mr Speaker, you know the value of inter-parliamentary relations and, in particular, the Inter-Parliamentary Union, which was founded nearly 135 years ago in this place. We are honoured this week to be joined by the president of the Inter-Parliamentary Union, Mr Duarte Pacheco. Would my right hon. Friend join his campaign to get the USA to rejoin this important international organisation?
As my right hon. Friend knows, the United Kingdom was a founding member of the Inter-Parliamentary Union. I would very much like the United States to rejoin and I am happy to help make that case.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q28 Partial Answer
Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem
Bath
Context
The Bill on workplace protections from harassment has full Government support but is currently stuck in the House of Lords. A compromise is now in sight to allow the Bill to pass through the House of Lords.
Not a day goes by without serious sexual harassment allegations in organisations up and down the country. My private Member's Bill on workplace protections from harassment could go a long way to address some of these serious issues. Indeed, the Bill has full Government support. It is currently stuck in the other place, but a compromise is now in sight, so that the Bill can pass through the House of Lords. Our rules require that any amendment made in the House of Lords needs to come back to the House of Commons. Will the Deputy Prime Minister ensure that a small amount of Government time is made available in this place, between now and the end of the parliamentary Session, to ensure that this important Bill will become law?
As the hon. Lady knows, we have supported the Bill and we are working on it. My right hon. Friend the Minister for Women and Equalities is very happy to meet the hon. Lady to discuss the measures further.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask for Government time was not addressed.
Response accuracy