Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Scottish electricity exports to the UK grid increased last year, yet Scottish households face among Europe's highest connection charges. Concerns are raised about subsidising other parts of the UK.
Last year, Scotland exported 19 trillion Wh of electricity, worth £4 billion, to the UK grid. Despite this, Scottish generators pay the highest grid connection charges in Europe and Scots face among the highest standing charges compared to London's lowest. Should Scottish households be forced to endure harsh winters due to these disparities?
Standing charges are a matter for Ofgem. The Government provides an annual cross-subsidy worth £60 to a typical household in Scotland, plus considerable support this year. This is on top of the cross-subsidy already provided.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about Scottish households subsidising other parts of the UK was not directly addressed.
Provides General Context Without Addressing Subsidy Specifics
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Abigail Mor Edan, a four-year-old orphan released from Hamas captivity last weekend, was freed as part of an agreement involving the release of convicted terrorists.
To secure Abigail's freedom and other hostages, Israel is releasing convicted terrorists. What steps is my right hon. Friend taking to continue his welcome support for Israel against Hamas and Iran-backed terror groups?
We support Israel's right to defend itself, secure hostages, and deter further incursions. We welcome the extension of a ceasefire agreement for humanitarian aid and hostage release negotiations are ongoing.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
In the 2019 election, all parties promised to reduce immigration numbers.
How is the Prime Minister's promise of reducing migration levels going?
Migration levels are too high. We have asked the Migration Advisory Committee to review certain elements of the system and will bring forward next steps. The toughest action ever taken to reduce student dependant migration was announced earlier this year, impacting 150,000 people.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about reducing legal migration levels is not directly addressed in terms of outcomes.
General Statements Without Concrete Progress Details
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister cancelled a meeting with the Greek Prime Minister at the last minute.
Why did the Prime Minister cancel a meeting with an important ally like Greece?
The purpose of the meeting was not to discuss substantive issues but to grandstand and relitigate past issues. Specific commitments made were broken, thus it was deemed inappropriate.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about reasons for cancelling is avoided by discussing purposes and past commitments instead.
Changed Subject To Past Commitments
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister claims no plan on boat crossings while migration levels are at record highs.
How has the government's policy contributed to high immigration levels?
Illegal boat crossings are down by a third this year due to our actions. The right hon. and learned Gentleman backed an EU country over Britain on migration issues.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about policy contribution is not addressed; instead, it criticises Labour's position.
Criticising Opposition Without Addressing The Question
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP references the Prime Minister's stance on immigration policies, highlighting criticism from within his party.
The Government has lost control of borders; Members are in turmoil and revolt. The Home Secretary admits failure due to 'magical thinking'. Why should the public trust this PM given such chaos?
The Government has taken significant measures and will bring forward more. Recent estimates show slowing immigration due to these measures. The immigration health surcharge will increase by more than two thirds next year.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Keir Starmer's specific ask regarding public trust was not directly addressed with concrete steps or commitments.
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP criticises the Prime Minister's handling of immigration, mentioning a trebling of migration under this Government.
Migration has tripled on this Government's watch. The PM claims control but NHS waiting lists and taxes have increased contrary to his promises. He now lectures about targets when he failed previously. Will he warn us what is next?
The Government has taken significant measures and will take further steps, showing recent estimates indicate slowing immigration. The immigration health surcharge will increase by more than two thirds next year.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Keir Starmer's specific ask about future plans was not directly addressed with concrete commitments.
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP notes the rise in antisemitism and asks about funding for tackling Islamophobia.
44% of religiously aggravated offences were against Muslims last year. The independent adviser on Islamophobia role has been vacant over a year, despite discussions with the Prime Minister. Will the Government take action now?
The Government does not tolerate anti-Muslim hatred and expects it to be dealt with wherever it occurs. They have supported Tell MAMA with over £6 million since its inception, doubling funding for protective security measures through the scheme.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Rehman Chishti's specific ask about filling the vacant role was not directly addressed with a commitment to action.
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlights the financial burden on families due to energy costs in winter, with children's delight at snow contrasting parental dread.
Families look out of windows this morning and see snow but are filled with dread from high energy bills. Does the Prime Minister regret offering no financial mechanism for these families this winter?
Support has been considerable this year for energy bills. Pensioner households will receive up to £300 alongside their winter fuel payment, right at a difficult time.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Stephen Flynn's specific ask about regret was not directly addressed with an explicit admission or denial of regret.
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP mentions the joy children feel at seeing snow contrasting with parents' dread over high energy bills in winter.
Children see snow this morning and are delighted, but their parents look out and are filled with dread due to unaffordable energy bills. Does the Prime Minister regret offering no financial mechanism for these families?
There has been considerable support this year for energy bills. Pensioner households will receive up to £300 alongside their winter fuel payment, right at a difficult time.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Stephen Flynn's specific ask about regret was not directly addressed with an explicit admission or denial of regret.
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Scotland produces six times more gas than it consumes and two thirds of its electricity comes from renewable resources. This situation is seen as a consequence of failed energy policies by the Westminster government.
I appreciate that it is difficult for the Prime Minister to empathise when he quite clearly cannot understand, but to be clear to him and, indeed, the whole House: this is not a matter of energy production. Scotland produces six times more gas than we consume and around two thirds of our electricity already comes from renewable resources. This is a consequence of decades of failed energy policy here in Westminster. Those of us on the Scottish National party Benches believe that Scotland's energy wealth and energy resource should benefit the people of Scotland. Why doesn't he?
The entire energy grid infrastructure in this country is integrated, which brings benefits to people in every part of our United Kingdom. When it comes to supporting people with energy bills, earlier this year we increased benefits to the highest rate on record. It is why we provided cost of living payments worth £900 on top of regular support. It was right not to wait until the last moment to give people that support; we gave it to them earlier this year so that they would have the security they need going into winter—as I said, on top of the money for pensioners. When there are cold snaps, we have cold weather payments that kick in and the warm home discount, which provides an extra £150 to the most vulnerable households. All that is the most considerable action taken by any Government to help people with their energy bills.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The question was about Scotland's energy resources benefiting its own population due to historical underinvestment, but the response focused on general UK-wide support measures without addressing specific Scottish concerns or commitments.
General Statements About Uk-Wide Benefits
Failure To Address Specific Scottish Energy Issues
Response accuracy
Q12
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The redevelopment of Kettering General Hospital, which includes a £50 million new energy plant to power the expanded and improved hospital, is the No.1 investment priority for local residents.
The £400 million redevelopment of Kettering General Hospital is the No. 1 investment priority for local residents. The first part is a £50 million new energy plant to power the expanded and improved hospital. Will my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister please do all he can to ensure that the Department of Health gets spades in the ground on time next spring, so that we can get the construction of our redeveloped, much loved local hospital fully under way?
I thank my hon. Friend for continuing to champion the new hospital in Kettering. We are absolutely committed to delivering the scheme for Kettering General Hospital. As my hon. Friend will be aware, the new energy centre is vital to the delivery of the new hospital, and we expect that work to begin in the first quarter of next year. The new hospital programme is working closely with the trust to ensure that the plans are deliverable.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government committed to 40 new hospitals and significant upgrades, but many schemes are delayed. The Royal Berkshire Hospital is stuck at the development stage with no funding transferred for construction, while Harrogate District Hospital awaits £20 million for urgent upgrades.
Three years ago, the Government made a commitment to 40 new hospitals and significant upgrades to hospitals in most need, but today many schemes are badly delayed. The Royal Berkshire—stuck at the development stage, with not a single pound transferred for construction. Harrogate District Hospital—still waiting on £20 million for urgent upgrades after reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete was discovered. There are 25 more such schemes. Will the Prime Minister explain why his Government are happy to let patients, doctors and nurses suffer for years in such unfit and unsafe conditions?
We are delivering 40 hospitals by 2030. Good progress is already being made, and that programme is being backed by over £20 billion of investment. Three schemes are already open, two are opening this year, and 16 are in construction, or work has begun to prepare the site. It is absolutely right, though, that within that we prioritise RAAC hospitals. That required a reprioritisation, but that was the appropriate thing to do to ensure safety. Patients and staff are already benefiting from some of the improvements that we have made, which come on top of the largest capital programme for the NHS in its history, rolling out community diagnostic centres, urgent treatment centres and surgical hubs right across the country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The question was about specific delays but the response provided general progress updates without addressing the delay issue specifically.
General Statements On Nhs Investment
Acknowledgment Of Prioritization Needs
Response accuracy
Q14
Direct Answer
▸
Context
An entire town, Bakewell in the Derbyshire dales, is being debanked by National Westminster Bank, leaving no bank branches left in the area and impacting vulnerable elderly constituents and local businesses.
As disturbed as I was to learn that British politicians are being debanked by the National Westminster Bank, the Prime Minister can imagine my horror to find that an entire town—Bakewell in the Derbyshire dales—is being debanked by the National Westminster Bank. In the whole of the Derbyshire dales and the Peak district, there is not a bank left. Does my right hon. Friend share my concern, as we are the major shareholder, that the National Westminster Bank is ignoring my vulnerable elderly constituents, and my businessmen? Bakewell is a big, thriving market town.
My hon. Friend is right that all customers, wherever they live, should have appropriate access to banking and cash services. That is why we have legislated to protect access to cash, and the Financial Conduct Authority has issued guidance that seeks to ensure that branch closure decisions treat customers fairly. I know that there has been an assessment of access to cash in her area, and the financial services sector will provide a new cash deposit service for her community. Also, everyone can access the post office for regular banking services.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Cancer Research UK's manifesto “Longer, better lives” aims to save 20,000 lives a year by 2040 through increased research funding. There is currently a £1 billion funding gap in cancer research.
Yesterday, Cancer Research UK's manifesto 'Longer, better lives' set out a road map to save 20,000 lives a year by 2040. Research is key to that, and it has identified a funding gap of over £1 billion. Cancer Research UK has told me that, excluding research funded by industry, charities fund 62% of cancer research compared with the Government's 38%. Is the Prime Minister ashamed of that, and what will he do to address the gap?
Of course the Government must do more to continue preventing cancer deaths in our country. That is why we are focused on fighting cancer on all fronts—prevention, diagnosis, treatment, research and funding. Crucially, cancer is now being diagnosed at an earlier stage more often, with survival rates improving across all types of cancer, including the most common cancers, and through our treatment record we are rolling out community diagnostic centres everywhere to ensure that we can reach those people as quickly as possible.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The question asked about funding disparity and a specific £1 billion gap but did not receive detailed commitments on addressing this gap.
General Commitment To Cancer Prevention And Treatment
Response accuracy
Q16
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister hosted a reception to honour Sir Elton John for his work on HIV/AIDS. The government announced funding for HIV/hepatitis B and C opt-out testing in hospital emergency departments.
Can I thank you, Mr Speaker, on behalf of the all-party parliamentary group on HIV and AIDS, for hosting today's reception to honour the incredible contribution that Sir Elton John has made to the fight against AIDS? I very much welcome today's announcement of further funding for HIV and hepatitis B and C opt-out testing in hospital emergency departments as a critical step in fighting those diseases. I ask the Prime Minister to join me, and I am sure the whole House, in praising Sir Elton and his AIDS foundation for pioneering this work.
Sir Elton John has been a powerful voice for change in the UK and the world. Through the brilliant work of his foundation he has raised awareness of HIV, reduced stigma and saved lives. I am very pleased that that will be celebrated tonight at the HIV and AIDS all-party parliamentary group event. Ahead of World AIDS Day on Friday, I would also like to reaffirm this Government's commitment to ending new transmissions within England by 2030.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Pearl Melody Black died due to a car rolling off a private drive onto a highway, hitting a wall. The parents were frustrated that no charges could be brought due to a loophole in the law.
Pearl Melody Black was 22 months old when a car rolled off a private drive on to a highway and hit a wall, which fell and killed her while she was holding her daddy's hand. Her parents, my constituents Gemma and Paul, South Wales Police and the Crown Prosecution Service were all frustrated that no charges could be brought in the case due to a loophole in the law. My ten-minute rule Bill, the Driving Offences (Amendment) Bill, sought to amend the Road Traffic Act 1988, but it fell as it did not get parliamentary time. I know that colleagues across the House have had similar issues, so I ask the Prime Minister to meet me and meet my constituents to assist in finding a way forward.
I am incredibly sorry to hear about Pearl. My thoughts and, I know, those of the whole House will be with Gemma and Paul. I will make sure that the hon. Gentleman gets a meeting with the relevant Minister on the legislation as quickly as possible.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A report suggested that Labour-run Westminster Council is increasing parking charges for small electric vehicles by up to 1,800%, which could be detrimental to small businesses and the fight against climate change.
We know the Labour party has an aversion to white van man, but does the Prime Minister share my concerns that, according to a report in The Daily Telegraph today, Labour-run Westminster Council is increasing parking charges for small electric vehicles by up to 1,800%, demonstrating that it does not support small businesses or tackling climate change?
My hon. Friend is right to raise those concerns. It seems that Labour in London is yet again penalising hard-working people. First we had the ultra low emission zone, and now it seems Labour is hiking parking charges on white van drivers and small businesses.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions or commitments to address the issue were not provided.
Penalising Hard-Working People
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Reports suggest that the Prime Minister had a negative view towards taking action against deaths due to COVID-19.
I quote: “Rishi thinks just let people die and that's okay”. That was reportedly the Prime Minister's view of covid during late 2020, as recorded by the then chief scientific adviser in his diary. It came to light last week in the covid inquiry and I was shocked that Downing Street did not categorically deny it. I ask the Prime Minister today how it is that people who were closest to this issue, whom he worked with day in, day out at the top of Government, got the impression that the Prime Minister was okay with people in our country dying—
As the hon. Lady knows, there is an ongoing inquiry into covid. It is right that that is followed and I look forward to providing my own evidence. If she had taken the time to read the evidence submitted to the inquiry, she would have seen that the person she mentioned, the chief scientific adviser, confirmed that he did not hear me say that—and that is because I did not.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The reported view on letting people die was neither clarified nor denied directly.
Ongoing Inquiry
Take The Time To Read
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
1.3 million migrants over a period of two years are considered a catastrophe by the Prime Minister, and measures to tackle legal migration are under review.
That 1.3 million migrants over a period of two years is a catastrophe for Britain is obvious to everyone apart from guilt-ridden bourgeois liberals and greed-driven globalists. Given that the same kind of people are stymieing the Prime Minister's “stop the boats” campaign, will he bring urgent measures forward to deal with legal migration, and will he ensure that the Bill he has promised is in exactly the form recommended by his own Immigration Minister?
I am pleased to have my right hon. Friend's advice and support on all on our measures to tackle legal and illegal migration. As I said, we are reviewing the recommendations of the Migration Advisory Committee and we will be bringing forward measures on top of the very significant restrictions that we have already announced on student dependants.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Urgent measures to deal with legal migration were not explicitly outlined.
Reviewing Recommendations
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Reports suggest that over a million children experienced destitution in 2022 despite the Prime Minister's claim that having working parents is the best way to prevent child poverty.
Last week, in response to my hon. Friend the Member for Stockton North (Alex Cunningham), the Prime Minister claimed that the “best way” to stop children living in poverty is for them to have parents who work, but over 70% of poor children already live in a home where someone goes out to work. So I will give him another chance: can he explain why reports say that, in 2022, 1 million of our children experienced not just poverty but destitution?
No child should grow up in poverty. That is why I am pleased that, because of the measures we have taken, 1.7 million fewer people are living in poverty today than in 2010. I would also say to the hon. Lady that it is crystal clear that children growing up in workless households are four or five times more likely to be in poverty.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific reasons for child destitution were not provided.
Measures We Have Taken
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question pertains to a constituent, John Farringdon, who is 110 years old. The MP wants to express gratitude towards the staff of Cubbington Mill care home for their service.
I am concerned about the exceptional contribution that my constituent John Farringdon has made during his long life. May I also ask my right hon. Friend to try to find a moment or two to speak to John when he comes to Downing Street this afternoon?
I very much hope that I have a chance to meet John later on. I join my right hon. and learned Friend in paying tribute to the care provided by Cubbington Mill care home.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question concerns Dr Hadoura's mother who is trapped in Palestine and faces danger. The MP seeks help from the Foreign Office to bring her out of danger.
My constituent Dr Hadoura has made an exceptional contribution during a 30-year career in our health service but is now frantic with worry about her mum, who is trapped in Palestine. Will the Prime Minister work with the Foreign Office and the Home Office to find an urgent way to get vulnerable people out of danger?
I pay tribute to the hon. Gentleman's constituent for her long service in the health service. We are doing everything we can to ensure the safe passage of British nationals out of Gaza, and over 200 people have already been successfully evacuated.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question pertains to the investment and training places at the Alexandra Hospital in Redditch.
Thanks to this Conservative Government, the Alexandra Hospital has received nearly £19 million of investment. Does the Prime Minister agree that it is time to back my campaign to bring back services so local mums can give birth locally?
I welcome the investment that the Alexandra Hospital has had in recent years, but reconfigurations of services are clinically led decisions following engagement with patients and stakeholders.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question is about the Canadian Prime Minister's claim linking the Indian Government to an assassination attempt. The MP seeks assurance on raising these concerns with India.
The Canadian Prime Minister claimed that the Indian Government may be linked to the killing of a Canadian Sikh activist, and now it is reported that another assassination attempt was thwarted in the US. Will the Prime Minister reassure my Sikh constituents and raise their concerns with his counterpart in India?
We ensure the safety of all communities, including the Sikh community. We will continue to do everything we can for every community in our country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q26
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question concerns the economy's performance surpassing expectations, with unemployment rates being a focus.
With both the OBR and the ONS confirming that the British economy is now larger than previously estimated, does my right hon. Friend agree that the economy has proven detractors wrong? Will he do all he can to ensure we retain record employment?
My hon. Friend makes an excellent point about the economy's growth and investment in projects like Nissan's new plant in Sunderland, safeguarding thousands of jobs.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q27
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question deals with the Welsh Government's request for £600 million to make high-risk coal tips safe. The MP seeks assurance from the UK Government.
There are 2,500 disused coal tips in Wales, and Rhondda Cynon Taf has the most high-risk coal tips of any local authority. Does the Prime Minister think it is right that the UK took economic benefit from Welsh coal but will not fund its safety?
The UK Government are investing in Wales with record investments, including the north Wales line and Tata Steel job safeguarding. The Welsh Government have access to large Barnett consequentials over recent years.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q28
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Residents with free bus passes in Stoke-on-Tenton are facing unfair policies imposed by the local Labour-run city council, which denies them use of the pass before 9.30 am.
Thanks to this Conservative Government, the people of Stoke-on-Trent North, Kidsgrove and Talke will see over £200 million to fix our broken roads, the reopening of the Stoke to Leek line, and over £30 million to bus back better by introducing fairer fares and smarter routes to better connect our communities. However, residents who have a free bus pass are being denied the use of it before 9.30 am by Labour-run Stoke-on-Trent City Council, meaning that people cannot get to their GP appointments or to work. Will the Prime Minister back my campaign to end that unfair policy, which is being imposed on my residents?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right about the importance of high-quality bus services. That is why we have capped the cost of travelling on buses at £2 until the end of 2024 as a result of our decision on HS2, and why we have supported councils with £1 billion of funding. I urge all councils to ensure that people see the benefit of that investment, and I wholeheartedly back my hon. Friend's campaign.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific support for ending the local council's restriction on free bus pass usage before 9.30 am was not provided
Backing Of The Mp'S Campaign Without Addressing The Specific Issue
Response accuracy
Q29
Partial Answer
▸
Context
NHS England has awarded £330 million to Palantir, a controversial technology firm, to help it recover from its pandemic backlog despite concerns about privacy, ethics, and the safety of patient data.
NHS England has awarded £330 million to Palantir, a controversial technology firm, to help it recover from its pandemic backlog despite deep concerns among many healthcare professionals about privacy, ethics, and the safety of patient data. In light of the Government's recently commissioned report on unifying health data in the UK, can the Prime Minister confirm that no attempts will be made to force the Scottish Government to release the personal data of Scottish residents to any centralised system?
As the hon. Lady knows, healthcare is devolved, but we will look for every opportunity to improve patient care and reduce waiting lists in England. That is what we are doing in developing new technology that has a proven track record of bringing down waiting lists and improving the optimisation and efficiency of how theatres are scheduled.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific guarantee against forcing Scotland to share health data was not given
Changing Subject To Opportunities For Patient Care In England
Response accuracy
Q30
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The increasing use of AI-generated disinformation and deepfakes poses a threat to democracy, including the administration of justice.
The increasing proliferation of AI-generated disinformation and deepfakes poses a clear and present danger not only to our democratic process, but to the administration of justice itself. What further steps will my right hon. Friend take, following the Bletchley summit, to strengthen our domestic law when it comes to this threat to democracy, and to take international action to provide the guardrails that I believe are essential if we are to maintain integrity in the administration of justice?
I thank my right hon. and learned Friend for all the work he has done in this incredibly important area. He is right that we need to have guardrails around the successful exploitation of this technology, which is why the Online Safety Act 2023 gives the regulator significant new powers to regulate the content on social media companies, including some of the ones that he mentioned. We are also working internationally, following on from the summit, to ensure that we can all get the benefits of this technology, but in the process safeguard our democracy, which is so crucial to the functioning of our country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps taken following Bletchley summit were not detailed
Mentioning Existing Regulations And International Efforts Without Detailing New Steps
Response accuracy