Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Disabled people are facing a policy that requires them to work from home or lose benefits, despite a lack of suitable jobs.
Today the Prime Minister's Government will say disabled people have a duty to work from home or lose their benefits. Can you tell us how many of the 137,000 jobs on the Department for Work and Pensions 'Find a Job' website are roles that specify you can work from home?
It would not be right to pre-empt the Chancellor's autumn statement. However, we have closed the disability employment gap and increased the number of employers who are now disability confident. We also support those most vulnerable with cost of living payments this year including £150 for all on means-tested disability benefits.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Number of jobs on DWP 'Find a Job' website that specify working from home
Under Review
Supporting Disabled Individuals In Other Ways
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Measures taken to cope with economic shocks caused by the pandemic and Russian invasion need reevaluation.
Does the Prime Minister agree that measures taken during COVID and Putin's war were right for then but not a blueprint for future economies? It is about innovation, skills, and investment like Harrogate College rebuild or 12,000 local apprenticeships since 2010. Not Labour's fantasy borrowing.
My hon. Friend is right. Since 2010, we have created 5.5 million apprenticeships. Labour wants to halve apprenticeships if in office while we want an apprentice Education Secretary. Their plans to borrow £28 billion a year would push up inflation and taxes.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Recent pledges made by the Prime Minister include economic growth but not NHS improvements despite waiting lists increasing.
The latest version of the Prime Minister's five pledges includes economic growth. With 7.8 million people on waiting lists, how are they meant to help grow the economy if forced to wait a year for an operation?
We have injected record funding into the NHS and social care. We unveiled the first-ever long-term workforce plan in the 75-year history of the NHS. Three of the pledges are economic: we halved inflation, grew the economy, reduced debt.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Explanation on how people waiting for operations can contribute to economic growth
Economic Focus
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Waiting list numbers have increased since the Prime Minister took office despite previous promises to reduce them.
The Prime Minister has not addressed the NHS in his new pledges. With 7.8 million people on waiting lists, how can they contribute to economic growth if forced to wait a year for an operation?
We are doing enormous work to bring down waiting lists. We are expanding patient choice and rolling out new community diagnostic centres and surgical hubs, as well as putting more doctors and nurses on our wards.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Explanation of how people on NHS waiting lists can contribute to economic growth
Current Efforts
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
More than double the population of Wales are on waiting lists in England. There is a lack of responsibility taken by the Prime Minister.
The Prime Minister needs to take responsibility for 2.5 million people too sick to work, many with mental health issues, and his failures on waiting lists. How many people are waiting for mental health treatment?
We have injected record sums to expand the number of mental health treatments. Community diagnostic centres and surgical hubs are being rolled out, but union action has led to several hundred thousand cancelled appointments.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Number of people waiting for mental health treatment
Union Action
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The number of people waiting for mental health treatment is at 1.2 million, with 200,000 being children. Some are waiting nearly two years to be seen.
I asked the Prime Minister how many people were waiting for mental health treatment. The answer is 1.2 million, and 200,000 are children. Some are waiting nearly two years to be seen. Would the Prime Minister accept delays of that kind if it were one of his family or friends?
One of the key things that we are doing to bring down waiting lists is expand access to patient choice. It is a very straightforward idea to make sure that patients can choose where they are treated, and in that way we will bring down waiting lists for mental health and other treatments far faster.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly answer if he would accept delays for his family or friends
Changed Subject To Labour'S Policy Inconsistencies
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A nurse is struggling to find time to care for her son due to work demands, impacting his education. This reflects the situation of many families who cannot get necessary treatment.
I spoke to an NHS nurse named Cam who struggles to find time to see her 14-year-old son Mikey until he became seriously unwell, and now he has not been in mainstream education for over a year. How does the Prime Minister think they feel when they see him refusing to take responsibility?
We are doing absolutely everything we can to put money into the NHS to bring down the waiting lists. The right hon. and learned Gentleman is absolutely right: they do deserve it, but it is incredibly galling to hear this from someone who does not have the strength to condemn strikes happening in hospitals.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly answer how families feel about NHS delays
Criticised Labour'S Handling Of Strikes
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The suicide rate for 15 to 19-year-olds has doubled since 2010, highlighting the need for better mental health support. Scruppling tax loopholes could fund more staff and resources.
I am glad that in recent years real progress has been made in tackling the stigma surrounding mental health. However, suicide rates have risen and it means tough choices like scrapping tax loopholes to provide more staff and support in schools and communities. Will the Prime Minister back this approach?
It was this Government that for the first time in the NHS's history ensured that it had a long-term workforce plan, providing it with record funding to eliminate long waits and train record numbers of doctors and nurses. Labour failed on workforce planning.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to supporting Labour's mental health care plan
Criticised Labour'S Past Failures In Workforce Planning
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Cornwall faces challenges with affordable housing. The Leader of the Opposition has stated intentions to ignore local views on planning matters.
Access to housing that local people can afford is a challenge. We need houses available and affordable to locals, particularly in rural and coastal areas. Can you assure me and my constituents that under your Government, local communities will play a part in the planning process?
Our affordable homes programme is delivering hundreds of thousands of homes across the country. Crucially, on this side of the House we believe that local communities must be consulted, unlike Labour's plan for top-down housing targets.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a direct commitment to involve local communities
Compared Their Policy Favourably Against Labour'S
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Reports of a temporary pause in hostilities and hostage releases from Hamas have raised concerns about the future stability in Gaza. The MP references ongoing humanitarian crises.
I think all of us in the Chamber are united in our relief at reports that hostages are due to be released by Hamas in Gaza, but we cannot afford to lose sight of what will come at the other side of the temporary pause in hostilities that we are about to see. At the end of four days, will we simply see a return to the killing of children in Gaza every 10 minutes, or will we in this House choose instead to back a permanent ceasefire?
We welcome the agreement reached overnight. As I said, it is something that we have consistently pushed for and is a crucial first step as we try to resolve this situation and, indeed, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Of course, we want to see all hostages released as quickly as possible, including British nationals, and I urge all parties involved to deliver the agreement in full.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address backing a permanent ceasefire
Under Review
Consistent Push For Ceasefire
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Continued hostilities in Gaza prompt questions about the future direction of Middle Eastern diplomacy.
Ultimately, what we need is not a pause in the killing of children, but an end to the killing of children, and I can think of no better time than now for the Prime Minister to advocate a permanent ceasefire. Given that he will not currently do that, will he instead lay the foundations for a two-state solution by finally recognising the state of Palestine?
Actually, the agreement that has been reached demonstrates that it was not right to have a unilateral ceasefire. What was right was to do as we have done and consistently push for a pause that would allow not just for aid to reach the people in Gaza who desperately need it but for hostages to be released.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Diverged from question about Palestine recognition
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Network North initiative aims to improve transportation links, focusing on the midlands rail hub and Kings Norton station.
I welcome the Prime Minister's Network North project, which will see the full £1.7 billion put into the midlands rail hub. That will reopen the central platforms at Kings Norton station, which have been derelict for so long. Will he bring forward the cash so that we can increase capacity on the line and improve journey times? Will he also look at my campaign to extend the new Camp Hill line to Longbridge?
I am pleased that my hon. Friend's constituency will benefit from the decision on High Speed 2 and benefit significantly from new Network North funding—an additional billion pounds to deliver the midlands rail hub in full. Decisions about Kings Norton are due to be made later this year, which should be good news to him.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address extension of Camp Hill line to Longbridge
Decisions Pending
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
North Wales faces higher standing charges and older, poorly insulated houses compared to London.
I am sure the Prime Minister will join me and the communities I represent in sending heartfelt sympathies to the families and friends grieving at the loss of four young men in a tragic accident in Garreg Llanfrothen this week. People in north Wales pay the highest standing charges on energy bills, at £340 a year—a third more than in London—despite having lower average incomes and living in older, poorly insulated houses.
We have provided an extraordinary package of support for households across the country to help with energy bills, totalling almost £100 billion over the past year or two. The Ofgem price cap has also fallen to about £1,800 currently, and our price guarantee will remain in place until the spring of next year.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address specific unfair standing charges issue
Support Packages In Place
Response accuracy
Q14
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Discussion on defining peace and its prerequisites in the context of Middle Eastern stability.
Setting strategic aims for the middle east requires us to be precise about the terms we use, and that includes the word “peace”. Peace is not just the absence of war or conflict, but the freedom from the fear of conflict, oppression or terror. It requires mutual respect, freedom from persecution and living without fear of destitution.
I agree wholeheartedly with my right hon. Friend on that and thank him for what he says. I know that his advice will continue to be of value to the Government as we find a way for a peaceful, more secure future for everyone living in the region.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Scottish consumers pay higher energy standing charges compared to London, despite exporting electricity.
The Scottish surcharge on energy means, according to Ofgem, that people in Scotland pay 50% more in standing charges than Londoners do, despite exporting 3.2 million hours of electricity to England in the past two months alone. Meanwhile, Scottish green energy producers pay higher charges than English power companies to connect to the grid.
I refer to my previous answer about the considerable support we are providing to families across the United Kingdom with their energy bills. The hon. Lady mentions Scottish businesses, and it would be good if the Scottish National party realised that it should support the 200,000 people employed in Scotland's North sea oil and gas industry.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Criticised Opposition
Response accuracy
Q16
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The latest film from Torquay's Unleashed Theatre Company, “3 Steps”, highlights the impact of homelessness. The question stems from this awareness initiative.
I am concerned about the impact of homelessness as highlighted in a local theatre company's film and ask what further steps the Government plans to take to ensure everyone has a place of their own?
We are investing an unprecedented £2 billion over the next three years to tackle homelessness and rough sleeping, including by building thousands of move-on homes and implementing our landmark Homelessness Reduction Act 2017, which has already prevented or relieved almost 600,000 households from suffering from homelessness.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
34% of children in the constituency are living in poverty, a statistic that highlights significant socio-economic challenges.
Why is the percentage of children in my constituency living in poverty so high?
Across our country, 1.7 million fewer people are now living in poverty as a result of our actions.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures to address child poverty in the constituency were not provided
General Statement About National Reduction
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner seeks to establish an apprenticeship hub in Broxtowe for individuals of any age to train and retrain.
I am campaigning to establish an apprenticeship hub in Broxtowe. Will the Prime Minister work with me on this initiative?
We have delivered over 9,000 apprenticeships in great local businesses. While we continue to invest in apprenticeships, the Opposition wants to halve the number offered.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitment to supporting an apprenticeship hub was not made
Comparison With Opposition
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Supreme Court ruling on Rwanda has left the government's asylum system exposed, with chaos at borders.
Following 316 small boat arrivals this week, does the Prime Minister now intend to disapply human rights laws in response?
The number of arrivals is down by over 33% so far this year, thanks to our measures. Labour opposes each and every measure we have taken.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Disapplication of human rights laws was not addressed directly
Changing Subject To Statistics On Arrivals
Response accuracy
Q20
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The constituency has received significant investment, including £64 million for Huddersfield market and rail line upgrades.
Will the Prime Minister continue to invest in West Yorkshire given recent announcements like the Penistone rail line upgrade?
We are delighted with the third investment zone announced in West Yorkshire, and about the regeneration money for the Penistone rail line upgrade and Huddersfield open market.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q21
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Government's chief scientific adviser, Sir Patrick Vallance, contradicted the Prime Minister's previous statements on taking advice from advisers.
According to Sir Patrick Vallance, the current PM did not ask for advice regarding 'eat out to help out.' Who is correct?
The Government took advice from scientific advisers throughout the crisis, as highlighted in the ongoing inquiry.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A Staffordshire mother experienced birth trauma but the hospital will not investigate due to time elapsed. The MP received similar stories from mums across the UK.
Will the Prime Minister meet me urgently regarding a constituent's concerns about birth trauma and include it in the refreshed women's health strategy?
I am pleased that the first ever debate on birth trauma was held recently. The Department of Health is working to improve maternity care and related mental healthcare.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Urgent meeting request not addressed, specific inclusion in strategy not confirmed
Referencing Past Debate
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner highlights that in the past 13 years, six oil and gas licensing rounds produced only a small amount of oil and gas. The Scottish Government has invested £500 million in energy transition.
In the last 13 years, the six oil and gas licensing rounds by the Tories have produced 16 days-worth of oil and gas for the UK. Will the Prime Minister explain how doubling the number of licensing rounds will have any impact on insanely high energy bills? If he cared about energy security, jobs or the environment, he would surely be better matching the Scottish Government's £500 million investment in a just transition and providing a £400 rebate to bill payers.
It is not £500 million; we are investing tens of billions of pounds in energy transition, not least for things such as carbon capture and storage. In order to have energy security, it is right to exploit the resources that we have here at home. Even the independent Climate Change Committee projects that we will still need oil and gas as we make the transition.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address how doubling licensing rounds would impact high energy bills or whether a £400 rebate to bill payers is planned
Response accuracy
Q24
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The questioner mentions hosting Ukrainian teenage children whose parents are fighting Russians in Ukraine. Six of them have been orphaned.
Today, I am hosting—here in the House of Commons—14 Ukrainian teenage children whose parents have been and are fighting the Russians in Ukraine. Will the Prime Minister join me in paying tribute to the parents of these children and take this opportunity to reiterate our steadfast support for the people of Ukraine in their fight for their independence, freedom and nation's survival?
I do join my hon. Friend in paying tribute to the parents of these children and many others. I also wish to take the opportunity to say that, while events in the middle east have been dominating the headlines, we and our allies are steadfast in our resolve to support Ukraine for as long as it takes for it to achieve victory.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner criticises the Prime Minister's welcome for Elon Musk, noting that advertisers are now fleeing Musk's platform after his latest outburst.
A few weeks ago, the world cringed at the Prime Minister's fawning welcome for Elon Musk. This week, advertisers are fleeing Musk's platform after his latest vile outburst. What exactly did the Prime Minister think he might learn from an unelected, super-rich individual who had taken over a once successful organisation and plunged it into a death spiral?
It is striking that the hon. Member for Cambridge—of all places!—does not understand the importance of technology sectors and companies to the growth of our economy. It illustrates everything that is wrong with Labour's approach to our economy. What the rest of the world saw was the UK playing a lead in defining the regulations and approach to a technology that will transform how we live.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly answer what PM expected to gain from meeting Elon Musk, instead criticized Labour's economic stance
Response accuracy
Q26
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner refers to Red Wednesday, a day commemorating millions persecuted worldwide for their faith.
Today is Red Wednesday when we remember millions of Christians and others worldwide who are persecuted for their faith. Does the Prime Minister agree that the best way that we can honour Red Wednesday today is to commit to quickly implementing the good words of the new International Development White Paper, which was published yesterday?
I thank my hon. Friend for her continuing dedication as my special envoy on this vital issue. Marking this event annually is just one of the recommendations in the Bishop of Truro's report. We have taken forward all 22 recommendations in a way that we believe is making a real change for those persecuted for their religion or belief.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address whether PM agrees on quick implementation of International Development White Paper
Response accuracy