PMQs 2023-10-18

2023-10-18

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Chris Law SNP
Dundee Central
Context
The Rafah border crossing from Gaza into Egypt has been hit by Israeli airstrikes, causing terror and preventing people from escaping. A councillor's family members have been affected.
May I associate myself with the concerns about last night's bombing of a hospital in Gaza? The Rafah border crossing is critical for humanitarian aid and escape but is closed due to airstrikes. Can you give your personal assurance that every step is being taken to open this crossing?
The thoughts of everyone in the House will be with those affected. We are doing everything possible to ensure British nationals' safety, including engaging in dialogue about opening the Rafah crossing.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific steps or assurance for opening the Rafah crossing as requested.
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Context
Recent hate crimes against British Jews have increased, and the House welcomes actions to fight this.
British Jews have faced vile abuse recently. While welcoming all actions taken by the government to combat hate crime, can you consider urgently revoking visas of foreign nationals who commit such acts?
We agree with fighting hate crime. Additional £3 million has been provided to support the Community Security Trust, and we work with police to ensure that hate crime is met by law. We have power under existing immigration rules to cancel a person's presence if it is not conducive to public good.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Hundreds killed at a Baptist hospital in Gaza. The Foreign Secretary said the UK will work with allies to find out what happened.
Can you tell us when you might be able to update the House on progress regarding the investigation into last night's bombing of Al-Ahli Hospital?
The situation is under analysis by our intelligence services. We are working closely with allies and will continue efforts to get humanitarian aid into the region. More information is not available at this point.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a specific timeline for an update on progress.
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Families of British hostages held by Hamas in Israel are mourning. The attack is a shock and Hamas is responsible.
Israel has the right to defend itself, but if Hamas had concern for human life, they would release the hostages immediately. Is it clear that they should do so?
Hamas is responsible for this conflict and distress among families affected is unimaginable. The Prime Minister will meet some of the families offering support, working with partners to secure their freedom.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address whether Hamas should release the hostages immediately as asked.
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Charities report a humanitarian crisis with hospitals barely functioning, children fleeing homes, and civilians terrified due to lack of basic necessities like fuel.
Yesterday I met charities reporting a severe humanitarian crisis in Gaza: children are fleeing their homes; hospitals struggle to function. Medicines, food, fuel, and water must be provided immediately to prevent a catastrophic situation for innocent Palestinians.
An acute humanitarian crisis is unfolding, necessitating immediate response. The UK has provided £10 million in humanitarian aid and is working with local partners to move aid and relief teams to Egypt's el-Arish airfield. We will continue efforts to ensure aid reaches those in need as quickly as possible.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Direct Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
There has been an increase in hate crimes against Jews and Muslims since Hamas's terrorist attack, including attacks on Jewish businesses and mosques needing increased security.
Since Hamas's attack, there has been a rise in antisemitism and Islamophobia: Jewish businesses attacked; mosques need more protection. Every Member of this House must work to ensure British Jews and Muslims can live free from fear and discrimination.
We will continue funding the Community Security Trust and protective security grants for mosques. We remain in dialogue with police to arrest those who commit hate crimes or incite violence, ensuring these actions face full legal consequences.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7 Direct Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The vision of a two-state solution seems distant, with Hamas trying to destroy this peaceful future.
Despite challenges, maintaining hope for peace is crucial. The Prime Minister should work to sideline voices of division and despair to maintain the possibility of a political path to peace.
We are committed to making progress towards peaceful coexistence between Palestinians and Israelis. We emphasise this commitment in all conversations with regional leaders, striving for a future filled with dignity, security, and prosperity.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The enemies of peace would like division, and the House must speak with one voice in condemning terror while supporting Israel's right to self-defence.
During this crisis, the House must condemn terrorism, support Israel's right to defend itself, protect human life, and maintain humanitarian access in Gaza under international law.
We stand united in condemning Hamas for their terrorist attack and supporting Israel's right to self-defence. We urge Israeli forces to avoid harming civilians while recognising Hamas's cruel actions.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Context
The Prime Minister announced £12 billion for east-west high-speed rail lines between Manchester and Liverpool, focusing on great northern towns as well as cities.
I commend the PM's work to find a peaceful settlement in the Middle East. The decision to provide £12 billion for east-west high-speed rail lines is welcome. Will he ensure Warrington benefits fully from this upgrade?
We will invest £12 billion in better connecting Manchester and Liverpool for Northern Powerhouse Rail as previously planned. This includes high-speed lines which would provide better rail connections for northern towns like Warrington.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Stephen Flynn SNP
Aberdeen South
Context
Recent attacks in Gaza have caused significant civilian casualties, prompting calls for a ceasefire. The questioner wants to ensure safe passage for aid and refugees.
We all continue to condemn the terrorist attack on Israel and support the defeat of Hamas while protecting civilians. Given recent shocking images from Gaza, will the Prime Minister join others in calling for an immediate ceasefire?
Israel has a right to defend itself against terrorism, and its forces operate within international law. We urge Israel to take precautions to avoid harming civilians.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask for a ceasefire was not directly addressed.
Urging Israel To Be Cautious
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Stephen Flynn SNP
Aberdeen South
Context
The ongoing conflict in Gaza has displaced many people, prompting discussions about a refugee resettlement scheme similar to those for Syrian and Afghan nationals.
Given the displacement of civilians due to the conflict, will the Government consider creating a refugee resettlement scheme akin to previous ones for Syrian and Ukrainian nationals?
We support Palestinian refugees through UN funding, providing aid annually. We are working with allies to deliver humanitarian assistance in Gaza.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask for a resettlement scheme was not directly addressed.
Supporting Refugee Funding
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Context
Reports of Israeli attacks on hospitals in Gaza have led to increased Jew hate on social media, raising concerns about the accuracy of such reports.
Following inaccurate reporting by British media, will the Prime Minister emphasize that information from Hamas must be scrutinized carefully due to its implications for Jewish communities?
We should not rush to judgment and must treat information from Hamas with scrutiny, as we do with Russia.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
The proposal for an east-west council to strengthen the UK Union, focusing on trade and opportunities presented by leaving the EU.
Building links across the four nations of the UK can strengthen the union. Will the Prime Minister agree with a proposal for an east-west council to discuss and collaborate on trade?
There is merit in exploring a new east-west council to further strengthen the Union, and I look forward to discussing it with colleagues.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask for agreement on the proposal was not directly addressed.
Exploring Merit
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Martin Vickers Con
Brigg and Immingham
Context
Funding reallocated from HS2 to support regional transport projects in northern Lincolnshire, including the A15 dual carriageway and resurfacing of the A180.
Following funding reallocation from HS2, will the Prime Minister consider boosting local economy through improved access to Humber freeport by dualling the A15 between Lincoln and A180?
The North East Lincolnshire will benefit from a new £2.5 billion fund to support local transport connections, including possibly some of those mentioned.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask for the A15 dual carriageway was not directly addressed.
Supporting Funding Through A New Scheme
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Janet Daby Lab
Lewisham East
Context
The government has proposed cutting state spending by £200 billion and freezing NHS budgets, which Labour opposes.
Government Members have said the way to fix the economic crisis that they have caused is to cut state spending by £200 billion and to freeze NHS budgets. When will the Prime Minister stand up to the extremists in his party and condemn those ideas?
Weeks after I became Prime Minister, we announced a significant increase of almost £14 billion for the NHS and social care. We followed that up with the first long-term workforce plan in the NHS's history, to ensure that we train the doctors and nurses we need for the future. That demonstrates our commitment to the NHS.
Assessment & feedback
Cutting state spending by £200 billion and freezing NHS budgets
Committed To Increasing Nhs Funding
Response accuracy
Q16 Direct Answer
Desmond Swayne Con
New Forest West
Context
The question relates to the governance and spending of aid funds in Gaza.
Aid poured into Gaza in 2005 when Israel withdrew. Enlightened governance could have made a success of it. It is Hamas that has turned it into hell, is it not?
I know that this is a subject on which my right hon. Friend speaks with authority, and I thank him for his previous work in the area. With regard to our aid funding, as the Foreign Secretary will outline later, we have very stringent governance in place to make sure that it is spent on the humanitarian needs that we want to address. I also agree with him that there is one person and one person alone that is responsible for the atrocities that we are seeing, and that is Hamas.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Richard Foord Lib Dem
Honiton and Sidmouth
Context
A wing of Seaton Hospital is earmarked for demolition by NHS Property Services, which has introduced a policy demanding £300,000 rent.
On behalf of the Liberal Democrats, may I associate myself and my party with all the comments about the protection of innocent civilians today wherever they may be? A whole wing of Seaton Hospital in Devon is earmarked for demolition under this Government. The proposal to demolish this wing is an insult to the communities that raised millions of pounds to help fund the upkeep of services at that hospital. The space was given to NHS Property Services, but, thanks to the charging policy introduced by the Conservatives, that company is demanding £300,000 in rent. Will the Prime Minister let NHS Property Services hand over the space to health charities and community interest groups so that we can stop a wrecking ball going through Seaton Hospital?
As the hon. Gentleman knows, decisions about hospital infrastructure are a matter for the NHS. I am told that Devon Integrated Care Board is working together with NHS Property Services and local community healthcare providers to establish a future sustainable use for the currently vacant space.
Assessment & feedback
Handing over the wing of Seaton Hospital to health charities and community interest groups
Decisions About Hospital Infrastructure Are A Matter For The Nhs
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Context
The Penistone Line is in need of an upgrade to improve transport links.
I would like to thank the Prime Minister for his commitment to improve transport links in the north. However, to ensure that a complete strategic approach to rail links is achieved across the region, it should include the much-needed upgrade to the Penistone line running from Huddersfield, through my constituency, to Sheffield—an upgrade that my hon. Friends the Members for Colne Valley (Jason McCartney) and for Penistone and Stocksbridge (Miriam Cates), who are sat with me, would also like to see delivered. With that in mind, will my right hon. Friend commit to including the Penistone line in the Network North plans?
My hon. Friend is a fantastic campaigner for the Penistone line rail upgrade. I know that my right hon. Friend the Transport Secretary is conducting a corridor development study given the new commitments to services on the Sheffield to Leeds and Sheffield to Hull lines, and, as part of that exercise, will consider enhancing the service on the Huddersfield to Penistone and Sheffield line, and I know that my hon. Friend will discuss this further when he meets the rail Minister.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to including the Penistone Line upgrade in Network North plans
Conducting A Corridor Development Study
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Karin Smyth Lab
Bristol South
Context
Around a third of children in Bristol South live in poverty, many from working households. A Conservative candidate made foul-mouthed comments about families struggling to make ends meet.
In Bristol South, around a third of children live in poverty, most of them in working households. It is about the same as in Tamworth, where the Conservative candidate for tomorrow's election made foul-mouthed comments about families struggling to make ends meet. This is the Prime Minister's Conservative party. Will he condemn that candidate's comments?
I am proud of our record supporting people with the cost of living. Thanks to the actions that we have taken, we have paid half of the typical family's energy bill last winter, frozen fuel duty and boosted the national living wage to record levels, and 8 million people across this country are now receiving direct cost of living payments worth £900.
Assessment & feedback
Condemning a candidate's comments regarding poverty-stricken families
Record Supporting People With The Cost Of Living
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Context
Approximately 15% of breast cancers are lobular, harder to detect and treat.
Mr Speaker, you may notice that many ladies in the Chamber today are wearing pink for breast cancer awareness, but roughly 15% of those with breast cancer are diagnosed with lobular cancer, a little known strain that is harder to detect, has worse outcomes and has no dedicated treatment. I am working with Dr Susan Michaelis at the lobular moonshot project to campaign for a dedicated research stream for lobular cancer. Will the Prime Minister meet with us to discuss this and how the Government can help us to save more lives from breast cancer?
I thank my hon. Friend for all her work in this area. Early diagnosis of cancer is key and the NHS “Help Us, Help You” campaign is seeking to address the barriers deterring patients from accessing diagnosis and treatment. Thanks to treatments and faster detection, survival rates for breast cancer are now increasing. Last year, more than 1 million scans were carried out, preventing an estimated 1,300 deaths from breast cancer.
Assessment & feedback
Meeting to discuss a dedicated research stream for lobular cancer
Campaign Seeking To Address Barriers Deterring Patients
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
Concerned about the impact of military actions against international law, specifically regarding Israel's right to self-defence and security.
Of course the sadism of Hamas can only be condemned, and there is no question of Israel's right to defence and security, but international law is very clear that acting against international law in response to terrorism is unjustified. In all the packages announced by the Prime Minister for humanitarian aid and military support, how will the Government ensure adherence to international law?
The assets moved into the region are for surveillance to prevent escalation and arms transfer, not combat. They provide contingency support for humanitarian assistance as required.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitments on adherence to international law beyond surveillance operations
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Context
Outraged by the murder of a local resident by an asylum seeker, demanding action on illegal migration.
A Hartlepudlian was murdered by an asylum seeker. People are afraid and angry. My office is besieged by asylum seekers weekly. My staff are intimidated. Most are illegal migrants who should be expelled. The families affected deserve action. Will the Prime Minister take action, ensure enforcement, and expel those with no right to be here?
The Government is doing everything possible to tackle illegal migration, removing those with no right to be here. We have excellent relationships for returning people to many countries and will continue using every avenue at our disposal.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions or timelines for enforcement and expulsion
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Context
Concerned about the humanitarian crisis caused by Hamas's attacks and Israeli military responses, citing UN and Médecins Sans Frontières statements.
Events in Israel and Gaza are horrifying. Condemning Hamas's terrorism is right, but should also be condemned for any war crimes committed by the IDF. The siege of Gaza and withholding water from its people is described as collective punishment—a war crime under the Geneva convention. Why support such actions?
Israel has a right to defend itself against Hamas, who embed themselves inside civilian populations. The hon. Gentleman should acknowledge that Hamas puts innocent civilians in harm's way.
Assessment & feedback
Specific violations of international law by Israel's military operations
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Context
Concerned about the Israeli reaction leading to potential war crimes and urging the Prime Minister to ensure adherence to international law.
My right hon. Friend is right to reassure British Jews after the October 7th atrocity. He will travel to the region, seeing shock and trauma accompanied by rage. The danger is that Israel's reaction amounts to a war crime—a mistake. I urge him to ensure restraint on behalf of all.
We will always urge Israel to take practical precautions to avoid harming civilians and act within international law, recognising the complexity on the ground. Hamas embeds itself in civilian populations.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions or statements urging restraint from Israel's military operations
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Context
Concerned about missing medical records of a constituent, including crucial blood tests from Christmas Island. The Ministry admits withholding at least 150 files.
The Prime Minister is pleased that nuclear veterans are receiving promised medals but John's full medical records remain incomplete. His blood tests are missing, as are countless others'. Will he review withheld documents in national archives and hold a public inquiry into why these omissions occurred?
The new nuclear test medal is being received. Health records requests are part of ongoing litigation, but individuals can request their medical data via subject access requests and complaints process.
Assessment & feedback
Specific review or public inquiry into withheld medical records
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q26 Partial Answer
Simon Hoare Con
North Dorset
Context
Concerns over a potential humanitarian crisis due to the situation in the Middle East, with Egypt's role being crucial.
We appear to be on a downward spiral in the middle east, which inevitably will lead to a humanitarian crisis. The role of Egypt will be fantastically important. What can we in the wider international community do to work with the Egyptians to ensure that refugees coming on to Egyptian soil are legitimate refugees who pose no threat to the Egyptian state and are not terrorists in disguise?
My hon. Friend raises an excellent point regarding the Egyptians' concerns about that border, but we have prioritised speaking with President Sisi and are in continued dialogue with our Egyptian partners to see what we can do to provide reassurances and get humanitarian aid to the region. We are working with local partners, including the Egyptian Red Crescent, and the UN on the ground.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitments or actions taken by UK in collaboration with Egypt were not explicitly detailed
Response accuracy
Q27 Partial Answer
Context
Industrial dispute at the Ministry of Defence site in Beith, impacting critical supply lines to Ukraine.
The industrial dispute at the Defence Equipment and Support, Ministry of Defence site at Beith in my constituency is dragging on, as workers engage in strike action for parity and fairness in the workplace. These workers are critical to ensuring that necessary supplies to Ukraine are uninterrupted, but all attempts by the workers to resolve this dispute have proved to be unsuccessful in the face of management intransigence. Will the Prime Minister personally and urgently use his influence to ensure that a meaningful offer is made to these workers, so that the matter can be resolved, further strike action can be averted, and supplies to Ukraine can continue without disruption?
I thank the hon. Member for highlighting the critical role played by non-craft support operatives at Defence Munitions. Different rates of pay for workers with different skills and qualifications are entirely normal practice in both the public and the private sector. This year, as part of DE&S pay 2023, a generous pay award was delivered which significantly improved the base pay of workers engaged in the dispute. I am told that officials continue to be open to talks on a constructive basis with the GMB to resolve the situation.
Assessment & feedback
Personal intervention by Prime Minister not explicitly committed to
Response accuracy