Railways Reform 2023-04-20

2023-04-20

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The MP inquired about recent steps taken by the government to reform railways.
What recent steps has he taken to reform the railways?
In February this year I set out our commitment to reforming the railways. Last month I was pleased to be able to visit Derby and announce its success in being named as the location of the headquarters of Great British Railways. We will publish our response to the rail reform legislation consultation before the summer recess. Meanwhile, we are continuing to deliver rail reform, including the roll-out of pay-as-you-go technology across the network, simplifying industry processes and developing the long-term strategy for rail.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment Without Specifics
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
Concerns have been raised about the Handsacre link being scrapped due to recent efforts to find savings on HS2.
Will he confirm that the Handsacre link will indeed go ahead?
My hon. Friend never misses an opportunity to raise her constituents' concerns about HS2, both with me and with the Rail Minister, thus doing the job that she was elected to do extremely well. Our priority is to deliver the opening stage of HS2 on schedule and to ensure that high-speed services from Old Oak Common to Birmingham Curzon Street begin between 2029 and 2033, but I have made it clear that phase 1 construction works north of Birmingham from Delta Junction to Fradley—including works at Handsacre—will continue to progress.
Assessment & feedback
Personal Praise Commitment Without Specifics
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
The Scottish Government has announced the scrapping of peak fare rail travel for six months from October.
Does he welcome a measure that will aid hard-pressed families during this cost of living crisis?
This Government strongly support devolution, and not just to Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, but through what we are doing with combined authorities across England, because we think that having decisions taken more locally is a good thing for the country. The Scottish Government have an enormous number of powers and they should use them widely.
Assessment & feedback
Welcoming or opposing peak fare scrapping in Scotland
Changing Subject To Devolution
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Tan Dhesi Lab
Slough
Context
A leaked report reveals the Government's intentions to cut Network Rail funding, risking railway reliability.
Why are Ministers so passionately committed to making our railways less reliable and ever more expensive?
That was an extraordinary question, containing not a single fact. The Government have provided a record £44.1 billion settlement for Network Rail in control period 7—in English, that is between April 2024 to March 2029. Compared with the previous control period, that is a 4% increase in real terms when compared on a like-for-like basis, and an above-inflation settlement during a highly challenging fiscal environment.
Assessment & feedback
Reasons for cutting railway funding and impact on reliability
Dismissing Question As Factless
Response accuracy