Cost of Living 2023-06-28

2023-06-28

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The MP is concerned about the impact of rising costs of living in Scotland.
What recent discussions he has had with Cabinet colleagues on the impact of cost of living increases on households in Scotland?
The United Kingdom Government recognise the challenges facing households due to elevated costs of living and have taken action with a support package worth £94 billion UK-wide, or £3,300 per household on average.
Assessment & feedback
Specific discussions with Cabinet colleagues were not detailed
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
Food inflation is over 15%, forcing many households to choose between heating or eating, particularly in Sunderland.
With food inflation well in excess of 15%, people cannot afford basic staples. What advice does the Minister have for households worried about providing food?
The Government continue to provide cost of living support, with average Scottish household receiving £1,850. About £5.2 billion was spent in 2022-23, more than the Scottish Government's entire annual welfare budget.
Assessment & feedback
Specific advice and measures not detailed
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
Interest rates have risen, leading to a potential mortgage crisis affecting disposable income for many householders.
After 13 interest rate hikes, the IFS warns of a 20% fall in disposable income for 1.4 million households. What is his party doing to address this?
The Government remain committed to responsible economic management to bring inflation under control, which will help achieve lower interest rates and mortgage rates.
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures not detailed
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Context
Rent hikes are adding to the cost of living crisis, with Scottish Government extending rent caps and eviction freezes.
What exactly is his Government doing to protect tenants in Scotland and prevent an increase in homelessness?
Tackling inflation is a priority. Benefits have been uprated, including £137.5 billion to pensioners and £67.9 billion on benefits for disabled people and those with health conditions.
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures not detailed
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Context
A recent survey shows one in six adults in Scotland accessed food aid due to cost pressures.
Is the Minister aware of a YouGov survey showing almost one in six adults accessing food aid? What steps are being taken to address this?
The UK Government remain committed to supporting the most vulnerable, evidenced by £137.5 billion to pensioners, £67.9 billion for disabled people and those with health conditions, and benefits uprated by 10.1% since April.
Assessment & feedback
Specific food poverty strategy not detailed
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Vicky Foxcroft Lab
Lewisham North
Context
Child poverty levels fell under the last Labour Government but are now rising.
Under the last Labour Government, child poverty in Scotland fell from 40% to 20%. What steps are being taken to lower it again?
The UK Government are committed to supporting the most vulnerable, evidenced by benefits uprated since April 2023. The Scottish Government's failures are highlighted.
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps not detailed
Attacked Previous Government
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
Balancing costs of £4.2 billion were added to energy bills last year, affecting householders.
£4.2 billion was added to energy bills last year due to balancing costs. What are the Government doing about pumped-storage hydro schemes?
The UK Government have introduced an Energy Price Guarantee saving households £160 from July, bringing total support to £1,500 since October 2022. The premium paid by prepayment meter users is ending.
Assessment & feedback
Specific support for hydro schemes not detailed
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Robbie Moore Con
Keighley and Ilkley
Context
The SNP announced a new election focused on another independence referendum, despite the Prime Minister and government focusing on delivering public services and helping with cost of living.
I know that the Prime Minister and the Government are entirely focused on helping people to deal with those pressures. However, the focus of the SNP Government seems to be elsewhere as they announced that the next election would be entirely focused on yet another independence referendum. Does the Minister agree that this is the wrong priority for Scotland, and that Scotland's two Governments should be working together to improve the delivery of public services and help people with the cost of living?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. Both of Scotland's Governments—the UK Government and the Scottish Government—should be focused on delivering better public services and supporting people with the cost of living, but instead we hear the SNP cheering about another independence referendum. This Government remain focused on delivering for the people of Scotland; I am just sad that the SNP Government in Edinburgh fail to do so.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Ian Murray Lab
Edinburgh South
Context
The Secretary of State promised to arrange a meeting for David Williamson, a Scottish terminal cancer patient. Citizens Advice Scotland showed that the number of Scottish mortgage holders searching for advice on repossession is up by 341%.
Let me also wish the Secretary of State a happy birthday—a significant birthday—for next week. Nearly five months ago, the Secretary of State promised to arrange a meeting for David Williamson, a Scottish terminal cancer patient, but neither his Department nor the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care has been able to do so. I wonder whether that could be sorted out as soon as possible. Millions of people across the country are facing spiralling mortgage rates and rents. Statistics released by Citizens Advice Scotland this week show that the number of Scottish mortgage holders searching for advice on repossession is up by 341%. Does the Minister agree with the insightful advice from the Prime Minister that worried mortgage payers hit by a Tory mortgage premium should just “hold their nerve”?
I can confirm that the Scotland Office did write to the Department for Health and Social Care about the case of David Williamson, and I will undertake to ensure that we pursue that. As for mortgage rates, the Government recognise that this is a very concerning time for homeowners and mortgage holders, but we cannot ignore the fact that interest rates have risen across western economies as a result of the pandemic and the impact of the war in Ukraine. Of course, the Bank of England sets the base rate, which has an effect on mortgage pricing—as the hon. Member will recall, it was the Labour Government who made the Bank independent of Government. As he will also know, last week the Chancellor agreed with mortgage lenders a brand-new mortgage charter, which will hopefully provide some protection and reassurance for mortgage holders.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not address the specific ask to arrange the meeting for David Williamson as soon as possible or directly answer about the Prime Minister's advice.
Under Review Looking At This
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Ian Murray Lab
Edinburgh South
Context
The Secretary of State's list of excuses did not include the fact that the Tories crashed the economy, which has resulted in some of these mortgage interest rates.
The Scotland Office is saying that Scottish mortgage holders should just “hold their nerve”. What the Minister did not include in his list of excuses was the fact that the Tories actually crashed the economy, which has resulted in some of these mortgage interest rates. Is it not incredible that during the worst cost of living crisis in living memory the Prime Minister's entire approach is to tell people to hold their nerve, while the approach of the First Minister in Scotland is to launch proposals for a de facto referendum and a written constitution—something that he himself admits Scottish voters do not want? Scotland has two Governments so out of touch with the priorities of the Scottish people that polling shows that 70% think they are doing little to help with the cost of living. Does the Minister agree that what Scots need and deserve is a UK Labour Government focused solely on delivering the priorities of Scottish voters?
This UK Government are very clear that now is not the time for another independence referendum, but the Labour party so often ends up backing SNP policy after SNP policy in Scotland. As we are approaching the summer holidays, perhaps the right hon. and learned Member for Holborn and St Pancras (Keir Starmer) should take his flip-flops and see whether there is space in the SNP's camper van.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not address the question about a UK Labour Government or how it would help with cost of living.
Change Subject
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
At over 19%, food inflation in the UK is 50% higher than among EU neighbours, with 28% of the UK's food coming from Europe.
I thank the Secretary of State for his kind words about Winnie Ewing and Craig Brown. Let me pay my own personal tribute to Winnie Ewing, who was such an icon for our party and, almost uniquely, served in three Parliaments—our own Madame Écosse. At over 19%, food inflation in the UK is 50% higher than among our EU neighbours, yet both the Government and the Labour party seem to be in complete denial about Brexit's contribution to this cost of eating crisis. With 28% of the UK's food coming from Europe, how will the UK Government prevent a new surge in food prices next winter, when extra post-Brexit checks are introduced at the border?
As the Chancellor has said, food price inflation has been a problem in many parts of Europe. In Germany, Sweden, Portugal and Poland, food price inflation is around 20%, so this is not a UK-only problem. The Government are doing everything they can to deal with Putin's invasion of Ukraine and the aftermath of the pandemic. We have one central focus, which is bringing inflation down. We are ensuring that is this Government's one priority.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not address how UK Government will prevent a new surge in food prices due to Brexit.
Under Review Looking At This
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
The London School of Economics has shown that a third of food inflation in the UK is due to Brexit. With the loss of freedom of movement, European workers are no longer available, leading to £60 million of Scottish fruit and veg rotting in fields.
The London School of Economics has shown that a third of food inflation in the UK is due to Brexit. With the loss of freedom of movement and European workers, Brexit has also caused £60 million of Scottish fruit and veg to rot in the fields, threatening farms and further increasing the cost even of domestic produce. As a Brexiteer, should the Secretary of State not apologise to the Scottish public, including his own constituents, for driving up food prices, and maybe explain why he still supports the proven liar who was one of its main architects?
We do not accept the SNP's analysis. As I have already explained, food inflation is an issue in many parts of Europe. It is a bit rich for an SNP Member to bring up food price inflation and rising costs, especially when leaked papers this morning revealed that SNP Ministers in Edinburgh are discussing raising council tax by up to 22.5%, meaning that some people will end up paying £751 more per year. Under the SNP in Scotland, local government funding has been gutted, forcing councils to slash local services and impose large tax hikes. I will take no lessons from the hon. Member about bringing prices down for households in Scotland.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not address whether he should apologize or explain his support for Brexit architects.
Attack Change Subject
Response accuracy