Topical Questions 2023-07-10

2023-07-10

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Context
The Leslie Sports Foundation in Shelley Community football club received £318,456 from the community ownership fund.
Following the wonderful news that the Leslie Sports Foundation has been awarded £318,456 from the community ownership fund, will Minister visit the foundation to view its existing facilities and discuss its exciting plans for the newly funded one?
I congratulate my hon. Friend on being a brilliant advocate for that project. I have no doubt that the work of the Leslie Sports Foundation will make a huge difference to the lives of people in his constituency. The Minister for Levelling Up, my hon. Friend the Member for Bishop Auckland (Dehenna Davison), would be delighted to visit.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Matthew Pennycook Lab
Greenwich and Woolwich
Context
The Conservatives promised to ban section 21 no-fault evictions over four years ago. The Renters (Reform) Bill was published in May this year.
Given the desperate situation that many renters are currently facing, and the urgent need to provide them with greater security and better rights, why have the Government not lifted a finger to progress that legislation in the weeks since it was published?
I share the hon. Gentleman's desire to do more to help people in the private rented sector but, as he will have heard, we wanted to make sure that we had a fit-for-purpose impact assessment so that the House could reflect on the changes that we are making and the benefits they will bring.
Assessment & feedback
Did not explain why no progress has been made since publishing the Bill.
Impact Assessment
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
The Department needs to assess cash retention practices and possible measures to prevent them, which cause issues for subcontractors.
What assessment has the Department made of the use of cash retentions in the construction industry and of possible measures that could prevent the practice?
My hon. Friend will know that that policy area is led by the Department for Business and Trade. Nevertheless, it is important that we work closely with a wide range of stakeholders and businesses to achieve a consensus. It can sometimes be challenging, but we are clear that any solution must be a sustainable one that works for the industry and its clients, addressing the need for surety and fair payment.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific measures or assessment results.
Stakeholder Consultation
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Christian Wakeford Lab
Bury South
Context
The Renters (Reform) Bill was introduced to Parliament over 50 days ago with no set date for Second Reading despite ample parliamentary time.
Why do the Government not care about renters?
The Bill, as you know, Mr Speaker, is beautifully formed, but the impact assessment that goes with it needs to be read in the round to see what a great piece of legislation it is. One thing that would enable us to bring forward legislation is if the Labour party were to end its pointless opposition to our Illegal Migration Bill.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address why no date has been set for Second Reading, instead criticized Labour's opposition to another bill.
Opposition Criticism
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Richard Fuller Con
North Bedfordshire
Context
The transfer of home equity loan administration from Target to Lenvi has faced issues with unanswered emails and phone calls.
What is going on with the administration?
I have been having daily meetings with Homes England and the service provider. It is the case that there have been some issues with the transfer, as my hon. Friend highlights. I want anyone listening to this to know that they can contact either their local MP or the service line, and we will resolve it. I have insisted that additional call centre staff are available and extended working hours.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Context
Over the last 50 years, housing has become over 13 times more expensive with tenants spending up to half their income on rent. Only one in three people born this year will own a home before they are 50 if current trends continue.
When will the Government grow a backbone, stand up to those MPs and build the houses we need to avoid catastrophe?
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman but, as was pointed out earlier in these questions, the area of the country where housing numbers are worst, where planning permissions are being built out most slowly and where the fewest planning permissions are granted overall has been London, under a Labour Mayor.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to building houses but criticized the Labour Mayor in London for poor housing performance.
Opposition Criticism
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
The revenue support grant mechanism is believed to be unfair, with rural authorities like Dorset receiving little if any compared to urban areas.
What is he doing to restore that balance and fairness for rural areas?
My hon. Friend has absolutely made this case on multiple occasions, both to my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State and to myself. He is a champion for West Dorset and for rural communities in general. We will continue to work with local MPs who are concerned about this.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific actions or timeline for addressing the imbalance.
Working With Mps
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Jon Trickett Lab
Normanton and Hemsworth
Context
2,000 families were evicted in May due to no fault of their own. The Secretary of State met with private landlords' associations.
While the Government drag their heels on section 21, thousands of families are being evicted through no fault of their own by rapacious landlords—let's be honest about it—with 2,000 families in May alone this year. That is not acceptable. Meanwhile, the Secretary of State has been having cosy meetings with private landlords' associations, which gives the impression he is on the side of the landlords and not the renters. Will he at least say now that the Bill will come back in September?
I am very grateful to the hon. Gentleman. In fact, I am on the side of a healthy private rented sector. The overwhelming majority of landlords do a brilliant job and I want to pay tribute to the National Residential Landlords Associations and Ben Beadle for their effective work in this area.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not confirm that the Bill would come back in September
Changing The Subject
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Bob Blackman Con
Harrow East
Context
The Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Bill received Royal Assent and will become law on 29 August.
Now that my private Member's Bill, the Supported Housing (Regulatory Oversight) Bill, has received Royal Assent, when will my hon. Friend start the consultations required to enact it, so that we can kick out rogue landlords?
I congratulate my hon. Friend on his excellent private Member's Bill, which the Government were happy to support as it tackles a very real problem. The Bill will become law on 29 August; we will start the consultation as soon as is practicable thereafter.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Simon Lightwood Lab Co-op
Wakefield and Rothwell
Context
Tyrrell Court in Wakefield has introduced a new service charge of £125 annually on top of existing fees.
Last week at business questions I raised the case of Tyrrell Court in Wakefield, where the social landlord, Wakefield and District Housing, has added a new service charge for communal lighting on top of the charge for window cleaning and communal cleaning, despite people having been tenants for 20 years without ever being charged that fee before. It adds up to £125 extra per year. Is the Secretary of State as concerned as I am that landlords are introducing these charges when people can afford them least?
It does indeed sound a concerning case, and we will follow up.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not provide specific details on addressing the issue
Minimal Commitment
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
New homeowners are often obliged to sign up to contracts they cannot leave, leading to inflated fees and poor services.
Property management companies are undoubtedly holding back home ownership. New homeowners are often obliged to sign up to contracts that they cannot leave. That leaves them stuck with inflated fees, and very often with poor services. I am sure the Minister agrees that management companies need their activities curbed; they need legislation imposed on them so that we can get back to a fairer system of housing.
I agree entirely. I thank my hon. Friend for the excellent debate that he brought to Westminster Hall, in which we discussed these issues in detail. We will legislate, when parliamentary time allows.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide a specific timeline or legislative details
Minimal Commitment
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
The Secretary of State previously stated his aim to abolish the feudal leasehold system.
The Secretary of State said that he had the noble aim of abolishing the feudal leasehold system. Could he update the House on his progress on the abolishment of that feudal system?
It will be in the King's Speech, God willing.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not provide a specific timeline or details on abolishing the feudal leasehold system
Minimal Commitment
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
The A38 is a major route on the Devon and Cornwall peninsula that requires substantial work between Carkeel and Trerulefoot.
The A38 is the main route to the largest city on the Devon and Cornwall peninsula. This nationally significant route needs substantial work between Carkeel and Trerulefoot in my constituency. What work is the Department doing with the Department for Transport to make that a reality?
My hon. Friend highlights the importance of nationally significant infrastructure programmes all across the country. It is vital that we speed up those projects and make sure that they deliver for local people more quickly. My hon. Friend is a champion for the A38; I know that she will be talking to the Department for Transport, and I am happy to do so as well.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not provide specific details on the actions being taken to improve the A38 between Carkeel and Trerulefoot
Changing The Subject
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
The Scottish Government are facing vetoes from the UK government on policies and legislation passed by the Scottish Parliament.
The Secretary of State says that the Scottish Government are not using the powers that they have, but it is his Government who keep vetoing Scottish Government policies and legislation that has been passed by the Scottish Parliament. Does that not just show that the Conservatives never wanted devolution in the first place and can now barely contain their glee at getting to roll back the powers of devolution?
No, it was the Scottish National party that did not want devolution; it wants independence. It is in the name, isn't it? They are nationalists and they want to break up the United Kingdom; we extend devolution within England and we support it in Scotland.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not address the question about whether Conservatives wanted devolution from the outset
Attacking Opposition
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Saqib Bhatti Con
Meriden and Solihull East
Context
Solihull Council is using the Government's brownfield land release fund to regenerate the Kingshurst village centre.
Thanks to the Government's brownfield land release fund, Solihull Council is getting on with the job of regenerating Kingshurst village centre, including by building new environmentally friendly houses. With that in mind, will the Secretary of State accept my invitation to see at first hand the progress of the regeneration of Kingshurst village centre, and see how it can be supported further by a successful levelling-up fund round 3 application?
Once again, my hon. Friend makes a brilliant case on behalf of the residents of Solihull borough.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not accept or decline the invitation to visit Kingshurst village centre
Changing The Subject
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
Fife Council received £14 million from the levelling-up fund for connectivity projects related to the reopening of the Levenmouth rail link.
Fife Council is currently working on the details of the levelling-up fund, which gave us some of our own money back under the last round. Most of that money—over £14 million—is for connectivity projects related to the very welcome reopening of the Levenmouth rail link. Since the bid was put together, it has become clear that by far the most important connectivity project associated with that reopening is the construction of a pedestrian footbridge to maintain the ancient public right of way at Doubledykes crossing in the middle of my constituency. If it becomes clear that the project has support from the community, will the Secretary of State allow Fife Council to reallocate the funding—
I will investigate the matter. It is important that public access is maintained. I do sympathise with the hon. Gentleman: given that there are now no Labour Back Benchers left to ask questions, he has to take the Opposition responsibilities on his shoulders.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not commit to reallocate funds for the footbridge project
Minimal Commitment
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
East Berkshire seeks its fair share of levelling-up funds after meeting the Levelling Up Minister to discuss community projects in Bracknell.
May I thank the Levelling Up Minister for her time when we met to discuss community projects in Bracknell? East Berkshire would also welcome its fair share of levelling-up love, so could she please advise on the how and when for the next tranche of funding?
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for outlining the concerns of local residents, showing why levelling up is also needed in parts of the country like Bracknell. We will imminently announce full details of levelling-up round 3, and I will provide him with those details when we have them.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner asked for specific how and when of distribution, but the answer was vague on these specifics.
Imminently Announce Full Details
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Jim Shannon DUP
Strangford
Context
The Windsor framework does not resolve all issues related to the Northern Ireland protocol, which impacts the relationship between Northern Ireland and the UK.
To strengthen the Union, and with the Windsor framework not able to answer all the difficulties due to the Northern Ireland protocol, what recent discussions have taken place with Cabinet colleagues on pressing the EU for a common-sense approach and on making the necessary adjustments to keep Northern Ireland a functional and integral part of the UK, which is the will of the people?
The hon. Gentleman is absolutely right that it is the clearly expressed will of Northern Ireland's people to be embedded in the United Kingdom, and we need to make sure that the EU takes a constructive approach, following on from the publication of the Windsor framework. My right hon. Friends the Foreign Secretary and the Northern Ireland Secretary are taking that forward.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner asked for details on specific discussions but received broad statements about ongoing efforts without specifics.
Need To Make Sure Taking That Forward
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Context
Eastbourne received £20 million in the first round of levelling-up funds and has plans to apply again.
Eastbourne secured £20 million in round 1 of the Government's levelling-up fund, part of which is set to transform a disused dairy and downland farm into a world-class visitor centre. Will previously successful constituencies, such as mine, be eligible to apply for the forthcoming round 3? We have big plans for the seafront.
My hon. Friend continues to be a fantastic champion for Eastbourne. We will be announcing full details of levelling-up round 3 in due course, but we are taking on concerns, from those who have previously received funding and from those who have not, to make sure that we get this third round absolutely right.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner asked about eligibility criteria for previous recipients applying again, which was not directly addressed.
Taking On Concerns Get This Third Round Absolutely Right
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Context
Playgrounds are important community assets that help with child development and provide free entertainment during cost of living pressures.
Playgrounds are often a godsend for stressed parents. They are great for kids' development, and they are free entertainment during all these cost of living pressures. Will my right hon. Friend consider earmarking a fund so that parish councils and community groups can bid to improve areas that are in a poor state or that lack the inclusive equipment we all want to see?
My hon. Friend is a brilliant champion for better provision of playgrounds and stronger support for families and young people. The community ownership fund is available for some of the purposes she mentions, but I look forward to working with her to do more in this area.
Assessment & feedback
The questioner asked specifically about earmarking a new fund, which was not directly addressed; instead, an existing fund was mentioned.
Community Ownership Fund Working With Her To Do More
Response accuracy