Israel and Palestine 2023-10-24

2023-10-24

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Context
The MP inquires about actions taken by his department in response to the Gaza and Israel conflict.
What steps are being taken with international partners in the Middle East in response to the situation in Gaza and Israel?
Since Hamas's brutal terror attacks on 7 October, my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister and I have visited the region and have spoken and met extensively with counterparts totalling almost 20 countries, as part of our extensive diplomatic efforts to prevent escalation, to sustain the prospect of regional peace and to secure the free movement home of British nationals in Gaza and the release of hostages.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Context
The MP raises concerns about reports of payments made by the Palestinian Authority to families of dead and captured Hamas terrorists.
Will my right hon. Friend condemn these payments to rapists, torturers and murderers? Will he use his good offices to ensure that no British aid money has gone towards this filthy practice?
I can reassure my hon. Friend that we always ensure that UK aid money is protected from misappropriation. I can confirm to him and the House that no British aid money goes directly to the Palestinian Authority. We have raised this issue with the Palestinian Authority and highlighted our belief that it is not conducive to good relations and a future two-state solution.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
Desmond Swayne Con
New Forest West
Context
The MP inquires about the current status and feasibility of a two-state solution amid Israeli settlement expansion.
What are the prospects for a two-state solution given the pace of Israeli settlements on the West Bank?
The Government's long-standing position is that we oppose settlement expansion, for the reasons I have highlighted extensively in the conversations that I have had with the Israeli Government and the leadership of countries in the region. Despite the terrible circumstances we are experiencing, there is a renewed desire for a meaningful resolution that means that the terrible images that we saw on 7 October will never be repeated.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Marsha de Cordova Lab
Battersea
Context
The MP highlights concerns from constituents about the humanitarian situation in Gaza and asks for clarity on Israel's actions under international law.
With over 1,700 children killed in Gaza and a severe humanitarian crisis unfolding, will the Foreign Secretary provide clarity on when it is legal for Israel to cut off water, fuel, food and electricity?
There is always much debate in this House about the interpretation of international humanitarian law. I have raised directly with my Israeli counterparts the need, in whatever actions they take to secure their protection, defend Israeli citizens and secure the release of hostages, for them to act in accordance with international law. I have received assurances from the Israeli President to that effect.
Assessment & feedback
Specific legal conditions under which Israel's actions are considered lawful were not provided.
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Context
The MP questions the effectiveness of Israeli precautions to avoid civilian casualties, with over 4,650 Palestinians killed.
Beyond repeating promises about protecting civilians, what meaningful action is being taken by the Foreign Secretary's Department to ensure that innocent Palestinians are kept safe?
I am on record mourning the Palestinian lives that have been lost in this conflict, just as we mourn, and I mourn, the loss of Israeli lives in this terrible situation. I can assure the hon. Gentleman that the UK Government take the loss of life, from whichever community, incredibly seriously.
Assessment & feedback
No specific actions were detailed beyond acknowledging the seriousness of civilian casualties.
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Context
The MP expresses support for Israel's right to defend itself and seeks information on efforts to secure the release of hostages.
What steps is my right hon. Friend taking to support Israel in securing the release of over 200 captives, including British citizens?
My hon. Friend reminds the House that the Government remain focused on the protection of British nationals in Israel, the West Bank and, of course, Gaza. It would be inappropriate for me to go into detail, but I can assure him and the House that we speak with all parties who we believe could have influence on those holding hostages: Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad and others.
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps taken were not detailed; instead, a general commitment was given.
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
The MP calls for the UK to prioritize expanding the Abraham Accords as a means of fostering peace.
Will the Foreign Secretary commit to expanding the Abraham accords, which could bring strategic partners to the table and offer a future peace between Israel and Palestine?
I have said regularly how much I value the Abraham accords. The improving of relationships between Israel and the Arab nations in its near neighbourhood is an extremely positive step. There is a realistic belief that part of the aim of the attack of 7 October was to derail future normalisation and negotiations.
Assessment & feedback
No specific commitment to expanding the Abraham Accords was provided.
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Sarah Champion Lab
Rotherham
Context
Constituents are concerned about the welfare of internally displaced Palestinians in Gaza. Since October 7th, nearly 600,000 individuals have been sheltering in UN facilities, with staff killed and installations damaged.
I am inundated with emails from constituents terrified for the future of internally displaced Palestinians in Gaza. With nearly 600,000 people sheltering in UN facilities since October 7th, and many staff and installations affected, when the ground invasion starts, where will these people go? Who will host them, administer them, and provide support?
All conversations with Israel, Egypt, and intermediaries have focused on preserving human life. We completely support Israel's right to self-defence against Hamas's brutal actions, including the retrieval of video evidence showing atrocities committed by Hamas.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about long-term objectives was not addressed.
Supporting Israel'S Right To Defend Itself
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Imran Hussain Lab
Bradford East
Context
Indiscriminate airstrikes and a siege have resulted in thousands of deaths among innocent Palestinians, including over 1000 children. The situation is described as a humanitarian catastrophe.
Since last week, indiscriminate strikes and sieges continue to kill thousands of innocent Palestinians. How many more must be killed before the government condemns the brutality and bloodshed in Gaza?
We support Israel's right to defend itself against rocket attacks, even if it means civilian deaths. We have grieved for Palestinian lives but must not forget Hamas's actions, including targeting Jews.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about condemning violence was avoided by focusing on Israel's right to self-defence.
Defending Israel'S Actions Mentioning Hamas Attacks
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
Hamas has been taking hostages, and there are British citizens among them. One suggestion is to appoint a prime ministerial envoy for hostage negotiations.
With state-sponsored terrorism involving hostage-taking, should the government appoint a special envoy with diplomatic immunity to negotiate the release of British hostages in Gaza?
The suggestion is noted as important. Our diplomats are often best placed for negotiations, but the proposal will be taken seriously.
Assessment & feedback
No commitment was made to appoint a special envoy.
Noting Importance Mentioning Current Diplomatic Efforts
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Rachel Hopkins Lab
Luton South and South Bedfordshire
Context
Emails from constituents express concern over the humanitarian situation, urging support for UN agencies like UNRWA to provide long-term resources and ensure fuel access.
How can international partners be involved in providing long-term resources to UNRWA and ensuring fuel supply into Gaza, as Labour suggests?
The Prime Minister and Development Minister have extensive talks on humanitarian aid. An additional £30 million was announced, making Britain one of the most generous contributors.
Assessment & feedback
No mention of working with international partners for long-term resources or fuel supply.
Mentioning Current Discussions Announcing New Aid
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
David Lammy Lab
Tottenham
Context
The urgency of quiet diplomacy is highlighted, referencing George Mitchell's quote about the need for timely success. Reports suggest possible hostage release discussions have stalled.
With reports of potential hostage releases stalling, can you update on progress to secure the release of all 200 hostages held by Hamas?
The Prime Minister and other leaders remain focused on bilateral conversations with regional leaders to secure hostage releases.
Assessment & feedback
No specific timeline or concrete actions were provided.
Mentioning Ongoing Focus Noting Diplomatic Efforts
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
David Lammy Lab
Tottenham
Context
The situation in Gaza is causing significant distress. The question addresses the need for Israel to adhere to international laws during military operations.
Does the Foreign Secretary agree that Israel must follow the laws of war by taking every possible step to protect civilians, ensuring aid is rapid and safe, lifting blocks on essential supplies like water and medicines, and preventing permanent displacement? Does he also agree this is necessary for long-term peace?
The preservation of civilian life remains a priority, and we discuss with Israel regularly to ensure they abide by international law. The goal is to prevent this from becoming a regional conflict through professionalism and restraint.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly confirm agreement on all points about protecting civilians and upholding laws of war
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Brendan O'Hara SNP
Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
Context
There are concerns about potential breaches of international humanitarian law by Israel in its response to Hamas attacks.
Has the Secretary of State seen or been made aware of any evidence that Israel has breached international humanitarian law in its actions since 7 October?
It is not my role to assess the interpretation of events. However, we are trying to ensure that Israel abides by international law in its actions for legitimate self-defence.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly answer whether there has been any evidence found or seen regarding breaches of humanitarian laws
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Brendan O'Hara SNP
Argyll, Bute and South Lochaber
Context
There are concerns that UK may be overlooking or ignoring evidence of breaches of international humanitarian laws by Israel.
If it is not the Foreign Secretary's responsibility to assess, who does this? Is he unaware of forced displacements and cuts to essential supplies, or is he saying these facts do not apply under international law?
The hon. Gentleman's interpretation of the situation does not necessarily reflect my view; I do not agree that the UK Government has decided international humanitarian law does not apply.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address who is responsible for assessment or whether breaches have been acknowledged
Undermining Questioner'S Definition Of Events
Response accuracy