Strength of the Union 2023-01-09
2023-01-09
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP is questioning the current state and future resilience of the United Kingdom.
What assessment he has made of the strength of the Union?
When we work together as one United Kingdom, we are safer, stronger and more prosperous. We are better able to tackle the big problems—from supporting families with the cost of living, to leading the international response to Russia's war in Ukraine and to being a world leader in offering the vaccine to all our citizens. We are taking specific action in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, including putting local voices at the heart of decision making.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A recent poll in Scotland indicated majority support for independence, with concerns over anti-trade union legislation.
Oh—is it still Monday? Six of the last seven polls in Scotland have shown majority support for Scottish independence. What does the Minister think is driving up that support? Is it the ignoring of the majority of pro-independence MSPs? Is it the assault on workers through the anti-trade union legislation coming forward? Or it just 12 long, brutal years of Tory rule, for which Scotland has not voted since the 1950s?
We respect the priorities of the Scottish people, who are focused on improving the NHS, on education, on tackling inflation and on getting a ferry that actually works and takes them to the islands. We will work in co-operation with the Scottish Government. We respect devolution and we want to work with them to implement the people's priorities.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific reasons behind growing support for independence, anti-trade union legislation concerns
We Respect The Priorities Of The Scottish People
We Will Work In Co-Operation
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The previous election saw a pro-independence majority win, and polls indicate that most Scots want to remain in the EU.
If the Government and the Minister, as a proud Scot, respect the wishes of Scottish voters, surely they will respect the votes in the last Scottish parliamentary election, which elected a pro-independence majority in Parliament. Also, an opinion poll last year showed that 72% of Scots want to remain in the EU—what has happened to respecting that wish? If this is a voluntary Union, what is the mechanism for the people of Scotland to demonstrate their consent or otherwise to staying in it?
I am very proud to be a Scots person. The hon. Gentleman mentioned the 2021 Holyrood elections: less than one third of the Scottish electorate voted for the SNP in that election.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Respect for voters' wishes on independence and EU membership
Less Than One Third Of The Scottish Electorate Voted For The Snp
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP questions how proposed legislation can be seen as collaboration when not supported by devolved administrations.
A guid new year tae yin and a', and monie may ye see. The Minister talks about Administrations working together, so how is it working together when the Government propose unpopular and extreme legislation, such as the proposed anti-strike legislation that they have trailed in the media, which no devolved Administration support and which has not been consulted on? How is that strengthening the Union?
This Government work tirelessly with the devolved Administrations. I have been in post for only a few months, and I have had two conversations specifically on Homes for Ukraine with the Scottish and Welsh Administrations. In the first three quarters of last year, there were more than 200 departmental meetings. The Prime Minister, within three weeks of taking office, met the First Ministers in Blackpool. That is the commitment of this Government.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Collaboration on unpopular legislation
This Government Work Tirelessly With The Devolved Administrations
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Concern over proposed anti-strike legislation and whether it will be accepted if devolved administrations reject it.
If the devolved Administrations say no to the proposed anti-strike legislation, the Government will accept that then, will they not?
We have established procedures in place. We are there to discuss.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to accept rejection
We Have Established Procedures In Place
Response accuracy