Topical Questions 2023-02-20

2023-02-20

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Dan Jarvis Lab
Barnsley North
In the levelling up White Paper the Government rightly confirmed that they would match European Union structural fund receipts for Cornwall. They could do the same for South Yorkshire, Tees Valley, County Durham and Lincolnshire, but so far have not. Will they?
I think we may be arguing from slightly different premises, because it depends how one defines the replacement for EU structural funds. I am more than happy to take the hon. Gentleman through the figures and point out the ways in which the funding we have supplied through the funds at our disposal match European commitments.
Assessment & feedback
Does not commit to matching EU structural fund receipts for specified areas
Arguing From Slightly Different Premises Referring To Figures And Ways Funding Matches
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
One issue recently discussed at the Stoke-on-Trent summit at 10 Downing Street, led by my right hon. Friend, was setting free Homes England and Stoke-on-Trent City Council on their fantastic, UK-leading strategy for the regeneration of industrial cities. Will he update the House on how his mission to set free Homes England is going to date?
Stoke-on-Trent and all the six towns are enjoying a renaissance under this Government in a way that they did not under the last Labour Government. We are ensuring that investment is going into Burslem, Tunstall, Stoke and Hanley in a way that did not occur under that Labour Government. Homes England is at the heart of that investment, providing new homes and cultural investment and ensuring that people who voted Conservative at the last general election recognise that they made the right decision.
Assessment & feedback
Discussion about renaissance in Stoke-on-Trent instead of answering how mission to set free Homes England is going
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Lisa Nandy Lab
Wigan
I wish the Secretary of State good luck with that. Last week, he told ITV News that, “nobody will get in the way of making sure we get money to those who are vulnerable and who deserve it”. Was he referring to the Chancellor or the Chief Secretary to the Treasury?
Keir Starmer.
Assessment & feedback
Replying with Keir Starmer instead of clarifying about Chancellor or Chief Secretary
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Lisa Nandy Lab
Wigan
Seriously, the Secretary of State no longer has the power to sign off on a park bench. There are now reports of significant underspends in his Department that are about to be clawed back by the Treasury. Can he guarantee to the towns crying out for investment in town centres, high streets and affordable housing that the full allocation of the towns fund, the future high streets fund and the affordable homes programme will be spent? If he cannot, will he tell us who is to blame—him, or the Chancellor?
My apologies to you, Mr Speaker, and to the right hon. and learned Member for Holborn and St Pancras (Keir Starmer)—the “human roadblock”, as he was once memorably described by my right hon. Friend the Member for Uxbridge and South Ruislip (Boris Johnson). Returning to the issue, it is absolutely the case that this Department is responsible for the disbursement, successfully, of funds to the frontline, helping to transform communities that were overlooked and undervalued by the last Government. No one is going to get in the way of this Department spending the money we need on the communities that need it. The only thing I would say is that there is not a single spending commitment that the hon. Lady has been able to make because of the shadow Chancellor. Labour—
Assessment & feedback
Blaming Keir Starmer and Labour instead of guaranteeing fund allocation
Blaming Keir Starmer Criticising Labour
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Greg Smith Con
Mid Buckinghamshire
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Whole communities have been up in arms after perverse decisions by the Planning Inspectorate, most recently on a site between Askett and Meadle and another between Twyford and Poundon. What steps is my right hon. Friend taking to reform the Planning Inspectorate to stop it walking all over local wishes?
The new national planning policy framework ensures that the Planning Inspectorate will work with, not against, local communities. The Planning Inspectorate also has a wonderful new chief executive officer—an official from my Department who helped to deliver the homes for Ukraine programme and understands what communities need and want.
Assessment & feedback
Does not specify concrete steps towards reform but refers to policy framework changes
Referring To New Chief Executive Officer
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
With around 1,000 jobs and 17,000 placements at stake in Northern Ireland, the shared prosperity fund is too little, too late for those organisations that are currently availing themselves of European social fund support. Can the Minister ensure that, at the very least, decisions on funding will be taken before the end of March to allow successful bids to continue without interruption?
We will do everything we can to expedite that funding to Northern Ireland.
Assessment & feedback
No commitment to specific date or guarantee of full allocation by end of March
Promising To Expedite Without Concrete Dates
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Mark Pritchard Con
The Wrekin
Solar is an important part of the UK's energy mix, and, as the Secretary of State will know, the sun always shines in Shropshire. Does he agree that solar farms, which are often of huge scale, need to be in the right place, not the wrong place? So often, a lot of good agricultural land is lost.
Shropshire, home to the “blue remembered hills” of A. E. Housman, is one of our most beautiful counties. It is vital, even as we pursue renewable energy across the United Kingdom, that we recognise that our environment is just as much about natural beauty as it is about striving towards net zero.
Assessment & feedback
Discussing Shropshire's beauty instead of solar farm placement
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Judith Cummins Lab
Bradford South
According to the Government's own reports, the Prime Minister's Richmondshire local authority is the 67th least deprived local authority in the country, while Bradford is the 21st most deprived. Was levelling up at the heart of the Government's decision to approve roughly £20 million of funding for Richmondshire and no funding for my constituency of Bradford South?
That money went towards ensuring that service families get the accommodation and support they deserve. If Labour wants to be taken seriously as a patriotic party, it should stop talking down our armed forces and ensure that they receive the money they deserve.
Assessment & feedback
Attacking Labour instead of addressing levelling up funding disparity
Attacking Labour
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Context
The four counties of Devon, Cornwall, Dorset and Somerset secured £152 million from the levelling-up fund. These areas form the new powerhouse region called the Great South West.
Devon, Cornwall, Dorset and Somerset secured £152 million from the levelling-up fund last month. The four counties make up the region's new powerhouse, the great south west, of which I chair the all-party parliamentary group. Will my right hon. Friend meet me to discuss the fantastic opportunities that lie ahead for the great south west?
I absolutely will, and I will make sure that the Under-Secretary of State for Levelling Up, my hon. Friend the Member for Bishop Auckland (Dehenna Davison), is with me as well.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Emma Lewell Lab
South Shields
Context
Legislation allows sewage to flow into seas and limits funds for local authorities to prevent pollution from coastal landfill sites. One such site is located in South Shields.
Not only have the Government legislated to allow sewage on to our beaches and into our sea, but they are now limiting funds for local authorities to stop historic coastal landfill sites polluting our coast. One of those sites is in gorgeous South Shields. When can we expect the Government to do something about it?
I agree that it is beautiful, and I will have the chance to visit soon. The additional money that we are making available for the devolution deal for the north-east should help.
Assessment & feedback
Details on specific action or timeline for addressing pollution from landfill sites in South Shields was not provided.
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Gagan Mohindra Con
South West Hertfordshire
Context
There have been multiple frivolous housing development applications in South West Hertfordshire, including one that would increase Tring's population by 30%.
There have been multiple frivolous applications in my beautiful South West Hertfordshire constituency, including in my hometown of Tring, where such applications would increase the population by 30%. What advice can the Secretary of State give me on how best to engage with his Department on these issues so that my constituents' voices are heard clearly?
I know that the new Minister of State for housing and planning, my hon. Friend the Member for Redditch (Rachel Maclean), will be meeting him shortly.
Assessment & feedback
Specific advice or guidance on engaging with the Department was not provided.
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Context
Around one in ten owners relinquishing animals to Dogs Trust cite housing issues as the reason.
Around one in 10 owners relinquishing animals to the Dogs Trust cites housing issues as the reason. Can the Minister confirm that planned measures to protect pet ownership in the renters' reform Bill will be maintained to prevent further pets from being given up unnecessarily?
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
Fisherman's Green has been identified by the local council as a potential housing development site, but many locals oppose it.
Fisherman's Green has been identified by the local council as a potential housing development site in Eastbourne. Local people do not support that, and I support them. Can my right hon. Friend confirm that the council, which owns the land and has put the site into the strategy, can take Fisherman's Green out of the strategy without sanction?
My hon. Friend is absolutely spot on. I have been taking a close interest in the activities of Eastbourne Borough Council. The decision to develop Fisherman's Green is the council's alone.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details on legal implications or sanctions if removed were not provided.
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Mary Glindon Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend
Context
The north-east's authorities are working with the Government to secure a strong devolution deal.
Will the Secretary of State join me in congratulating the leaders and elected Mayor of the north-east's authorities on their work with the Government to secure a strong devolution deal? As his work concludes with Greater Manchester and the West Midlands, can he confirm that he will move quickly to work with those north-east authorities to convey “trailblazer” status and powers, as agreed in the deal?
I could not agree more that the north-east is on the up. Newcastle and Sunderland are doing well in footballing terms, but even better in political terms.
Assessment & feedback
Specific confirmation about moving quickly to work with north-east authorities was not provided.
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Context
Antisocial behaviour is causing misery for Aaron Bell's constituents, as evidenced by survey responses.
Antisocial behaviour is causing misery for my constituents, as I can tell from responses to my survey. Does the Secretary of State therefore welcome the stronger action that we have seen from Staffordshire police since its new local policing model was introduced last June? In the last month, that action has included a closure notice in Knutton, working with Asda to stop boy racers in the Wolstanton car park, and a section 34 order in Chesterton. It is a big issue, but we are moving in the right direction.
Staffordshire's police and crime commissioner is certainly moving in the right direction, as is Staffordshire police, supported ably by my hon. Friend and others such as my hon. Friend the Member for Burton (Kate Kniveton). Boy racers and others who cause misery for their neighbours need to be dealt with effectively.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Florence Eshalomi Lab Co-op
Vauxhall and Camberwell Green
Context
Private renters are facing difficulties securing accommodation due to a shortage of available properties.
Many constituents are contacting me about the rental market; I am sure it is the same across the country. The shortage of available properties is making it hard for private renters who are seeking accommodation. One constituent emailed to say that she had been told to keep requests to a minimum if she wanted to have a chance of getting a property. What will the Secretary of State do about the frankly disgraceful emails that tenants are receiving from letting agents?
There are challenges in the private rented sector and with housing supply everywhere. I would say two things: first, we need to work together to unlock additional supply.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions regarding emails from letting agents were not addressed.
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The Help to Buy scheme has assisted many young constituents in securing homeownership, yet its scheduled end poses concerns.
I am concerned about the upcoming cessation of the Help to Buy scheme. It has helped my young constituents get onto the housing ladder. Can you assure me that the Chancellor is being urged to extend this vital programme?
We will secure an extension to the Help to Buy scheme. The newly appointed Minister of State, Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities is already working on this matter to benefit constituents.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not confirm a specific timeline or funding amount for extending the scheme.
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Hilary Benn Lab
Leeds South
Context
The government is reviewing how to assist buildings with cladding below 11 metres, especially when EWS1 certificates are required despite safety concerns.
Does the Government's commitment extend to helping blocks under 11 metres that need EWS1 certification even if no immediate danger has been identified?
I will look into specifics of individual cases. Conversations with lenders have shown a reduction in EWS1 form demands, but I am willing to investigate further where they are still required.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not commit to taking specific action beyond looking into the issue.
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Context
Warwickshire County Council's on-street parking policy may hinder electric vehicle (EV) chargers' effective use.
On-street parking rules in Warwickshire allow internal combustion engine vehicles to park all day near EV chargers. Does the Secretary of State agree this is problematic?
I will examine the issue closely, as it seems to hinder effective EV adoption. My hon. Friend identifies an anomaly in the system.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not commit to taking specific action beyond looking into the issue.
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Context
Halton Borough Council is set to lose £25 million over three years, raising concerns about the government's levelling-up agenda.
How can taking away £25 million from Halton Borough Council be considered part of the levelling-up programme? When will there be a fair funding review?
The spending review secured significant increases in local government spending. Authorities such as Mike Amesbury's have received necessary funding to deliver services.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not directly address the specific loss of £25 million or promise a fair funding review.
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
The MP is concerned about the need for sufficient healthcare capacity when building new homes, similar to providing primary school places.
Does the Secretary of State agree that we should also provide extra general practice capacity alongside new home developments? What plans does he have to address this?
Our infrastructure levy in the Levelling-up and Regeneration Bill is designed to provide necessary healthcare facilities alongside housing. I look forward to working with my hon. Friend on this issue.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not commit to specific plans or measures for addressing GP capacity issues.
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Context
The MP questions the fairness of levelling-up funding distribution, specifically mentioning his constituency compared to others.
Can the Secretary of State explain why my constituency received less levelling-up investment than the Prime Minister's, despite higher need?
Money has gone to the Prime Minister's constituency for service families' support. The hon. Gentleman acknowledges it is a good thing that UK Government distributes money in this way.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer shifted focus from funding allocation criteria to broader policy statements and criticisms of opposition views.
Changing Subject Criticising Opponent
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Richard Foord Lib Dem
Honiton and Sidmouth
Context
The latest round of levelling-up funding failed to provide investment in the MP's part of Devon, despite proposals from East Devon District Council.
What does the Secretary of State say about towns that feel taken for granted and neglected by this Government's levelling-up efforts?
I suggest voting Conservative, given effective advocacy from local MPs like my hon. Friend for East Devon in working with central Government.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer shifted focus to political party choice rather than addressing concerns about levelling-up funding allocation.
Changing Subject Political Advice
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Meg Hillier Lab Co-op
Hackney South and Shoreditch
Context
A majority of people in the MP's constituency rent privately or socially, with many facing overcrowding and limited options.
What is the Secretary of State doing to deliver properly affordable social rented housing for those who are overcrowded and have no prospects?
The Mayor of London has clear responsibilities in this area, despite criticism. Effective action by the Mayor is required for funding delivery.
Assessment & feedback
The answerer shifted focus to local government responsibility rather than addressing national policy commitments.
Changing Subject Shifting Blame
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Daisy Cooper Lib Dem
St Albans
Context
Some of the Homes for Ukraine six-month placements are nearing their end, with Ukrainian nationals facing difficulties in securing private rented accommodation due to lack of credit history. The local council is considering rematching families but fears that some refugees may become homeless.
Some of the Homes for Ukraine six-month placements are now starting to come to an end, and some Ukrainian nationals in my constituency cannot get into private rented accommodation because they have no credit history. The local council is ready to look at rematching families, but if that does not work out, some of those Ukrainian refugees will have no choice but to present as homeless. Will the Secretary of State look at this issue, and look at the suggestion of a guarantor system backed by the Government?
That is actually a very fair and constructive point. Making sure that there are not just banking facilities, but the kinds of guarantees that the hon. Lady asks for, is something we have been looking at in the past. I will ask the Under-Secretary of State for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, my hon. Friend the Member for Kensington (Felicity Buchan), to talk to the hon. Lady and to St Albans council in order to make sure that the generosity of her constituents is not undermined by the activity of the financial sector.
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask for a guarantor system backed by the Government was not directly addressed with concrete commitments or timelines.
Looking At In The Past Will Talk To
Response accuracy