Unduly Lenient Sentence Scheme 2023-12-07
2023-12-07
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
MP is concerned about the effectiveness and impact of unduly lenient sentence reviews.
What assessment has been made of the effectiveness of the Unduly Lenient Sentence scheme? In 2022, my office received 819 requests to review unduly lenient sentences. Of those, 139 were referred to the Court of Appeal, and the sentence was increased in 68% of cases.
In 2022, my office received 819 requests to review unduly lenient sentences. Of those, 139 were referred to the Court of Appeal, and the sentence was increased in 68% of cases.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A serving Royal Navy sailor was attacked and the offenders received small fines, prompting concern about deterrent effect.
What steps will the Government take to review the unduly lenient sentence scheme to cover cases such as that? I welcome much of the work being done. As the Solicitor General will be aware, a serving Royal Navy sailor was the subject of a violent attack in Torquay when he attempted to stop a group of yobs stamping a bird to death, but the unduly lenient community sentences and small fines handed down did not reflect the gravity of the offence or provide any deterrent.
I am very grateful to my hon. Friend for his question. I know he has had a long-standing interest in this subject since even before he was a Member of the House, and I am grateful to him for holding the Government to account. He knows that the ULS scheme—the unduly lenient sentence scheme—is reserved for the most serious matters. It is right to say that we keep the scheme under review.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Imminent changes or concrete steps to address specific cases were not promised.
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
MP writes regularly about too lenient or severe sentences, advocating for a balance in the scheme.
Could the Solicitor General make it clearer what the scheme is about and spread the message more broadly? I regularly write to him to say that a sentence has been too lenient. I recently wrote to him about Bernie Ecclestone, who I thought should have been severely punished for his behaviour. I have also sometimes written to the Solicitor General and his predecessors about too severe sentences, often involving women who have not conducted any violent crime but get long sentences. Can we have a balance, please?
Well, it is a Thursday, and I think we have heard a call for a Backbench Business debate or, indeed, for an Adjournment debate, and I would warmly welcome that. There have been such debates on the unduly lenient sentence scheme. It is not a mystery—there are further details online—but I would seriously welcome a further debate to air these matters, because they are important.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The question about clearer communication and balance was not directly addressed; instead, he suggested debates as an alternative approach.
Suggesting Debates
Response accuracy