Topical Questions 2023-05-16
2023-05-16
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
May I welcome my right hon. and learned Friend the Justice Secretary to his rightful place? In welcoming the measures designed to protect children in the Government's Online Safety Bill, will my right hon. and learned Friend outline what further action his Department is taking in relation to the criminal justice system to improve prosecution rates for serious offences involving minors, particularly in relation to sex offenders who target young people online?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to raise this point. The Government have invested significantly in new capabilities for law enforcement, including our specially trained network of undercover online officers, to arrest offenders committing online child sexual abuse. Co-ordinated National Crime Agency and policing activity against those offenders is currently resulting in over 800 arrests per month, and we have also delivered a further £4.5 million for organisations supporting victims and survivors of child sexual abuse.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
I am delighted to welcome the Secretary of State to his place for the second day running. I have been reading his speeches with interest. He once said the Conservatives should “do away with the argument that…we are somehow soft on crime.”—[Official Report, 2 July 2018; Vol. 644, c. 90.] Is it not “soft” to tell judges that they cannot lock up dangerous criminals?
Let us just get a few things absolutely clear. We believe in criminals spending longer in custody. It is strange that when there was the opportunity to vote for rapists and serious violent criminals to spend two thirds of their sentence in custody, the hon. Gentleman voted against that. Indeed, I happen to remember, from when I was at the Bar, that his party did exactly the same in the Criminal Justice Act 2003. Whereas previously, people serving sentences over four years would serve two thirds of their sentence in custody, they cut it to half: soft on crime, soft on the causes of crime.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The questioner's statement about judges' inability to lock up dangerous criminals was not directly addressed.
He Redirected The Conversation To A Previous Vote By The Opposition.
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
I am wondering whether the Secretary of State's handover was a little rushed, because his predecessor wrote to judges and told them not to lock up dangerous criminals, because the Government have run out of prison places. That sounds soft to me, because it tells criminals they can get away with crime. Will he withdraw the letter and tell judges to lock up criminals who deserve to be behind bars?
Well, criminals do deserve to be behind bars, which is why I am proud of the fact that when it comes to rape, which is an appalling crime that robs innocence and destroys lives, we have ensured that criminals convicted of that offence get prison sentences a third longer than they did in 2010. I am pleased to be able to record that the numbers convicted of that appalling offence, in the last 12 months for which figures are available, are 10% higher than under the Labour Government.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The questioner's request for withdrawal of a letter and instructions to judges was not addressed directly.
He Shifted Focus To Sentencing Lengths For Rape.
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Sharlotte-Sky, a six-year-old girl from Norton Green, tragically lost her life due to the perpetrator refusing consent to blood samples being tested until the last minute.
I have raised before in the House the case of Sharlotte-Sky, a six-year-old girl who tragically lost her life in Norton Green when her killer was driving his vehicle while speeding and on his phone, and with drink and drugs in his system. It took Sharlotte's mother, Claire, over a year to get her justice because the perpetrator refused to give consent to his blood samples being tested until the very last minute. Will my right hon. and learned Friend support my campaign for Sharlotte's law, which would reform section 7A of the Road Traffic Act 1988 to take away the need for consent when death has occurred because of a motor vehicle?
I express my sincere condolences and deep sorrow to the family of my hon. Friend's young constituent. As he knows, the provisions in the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022 fulfilled our long-standing commitment to increase the maximum penalty from 14 years to life imprisonment for the offence of causing death by dangerous driving. The Department for Transport is considering the publication of a call for evidence on motoring offences. While work is continuing as to its precise scope and timing, it is expected to include aspects of drink and drug driving and the failure to stop and report, with the opportunity to raise other matters. I encourage my hon. Friend to write to me and the Secretary of State for Transport, and I would be happy to discuss these matters further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific ask about Sharlotte's law was not addressed directly.
He Redirected Attention To Ongoing Work On Motoring Offences.
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Former Prime Minister John Major recently stated that many short sentences are pointless and a non-custodial sentence would be more effective.
I welcome the Justice Secretary to his place. Does his agree with the former Prime Minister John Major, who recently said that “many short sentences are pointless and that a non-custodial sentence would be more effective and, perhaps, more fair”?
It is absolutely right that the judiciary, who I respect enormously, do justice on the facts before them. If they feel they can do justice and provide a remedy for the crime that has been committed against society through an unpaid work order, some sort of community disposal or a suspended sentence order, that is a matter for them. The volume of unpaid work orders has gone up, and we are very keen to ensure that the rehabilitation or the unpaid work takes place as close as possible to the community that has been offended against, so that if there has been criminal damage or shoplifting, individuals should pay back their debt to the very society that they betrayed. That is what we would invite courts, in the exercise of their independent discretion, to do.
▸
Assessment & feedback
He Focused On Unpaid Work Orders And Community Disposals Without Directly Addressing John Major'S Statement.
Response accuracy
Q6
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The probate process has a significant backlog, affecting many families awaiting decisions on inheritance.
How many probate cases are awaiting a decision for seven weeks or more, and what is the Minister doing to speed up the decision-making process?
The number of probate cases awaiting a decision for seven weeks or more is roughly 9,135, which represents about 15% of the backlog. The Minister has recruited 100 additional staff members to help clear complex cases.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The number of theft and burglary cases awaiting completion in Crown courts has increased significantly over the past two years.
According to figures from the Ministry of Justice, the number of theft and burglary cases prosecuted in a Crown court by West Mercia police that have been awaiting completion for one to two years increased more than threefold between the first quarter of 2020 and the first quarter of 2022. Can the Minister provide more up-to-date data on those backlogs, and tell us what steps he is taking to ensure that the victims of such crimes in North Shropshire see justice within a reasonable timescale?
The outstanding caseload is continuing to diminish as we increase the number of judges, with 1,000 more judges this year and next. Court capacity has been increased without a cap on sitting days, and there are now 24 Nightingale courts.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific up-to-date data was not provided
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Employing former prisoners can help reduce reoffending rates and fill labour shortages.
What plans does my right hon. Friend have to use prisoners to help to fill labour shortages, and what assessment has he made of the extent to which that may drive down reoffending rates and help to improve the employability of prison leavers?
Getting offenders and ex-offenders into work has a material impact on reducing reoffending rates. My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State explained that there is an opportunity to maximise this due to the tightness of the labour market.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific plans were not outlined
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The House of Lords Constitution Committee warned about the appropriateness of lower courts having power to depart from EU case law.
Does the Secretary of State agree with the assessment of the House of Lords Constitution Committee, which has warned that it is not appropriate for courts other than the Supreme Court and the Scottish High Court of Justiciary to have power to depart from the interpretations of EU case law, and that allowing lower courts to reinterpret EU case law risks causing significant legal uncertainty?
These are sensitive constitutional issues. I should be happy to write to the hon. Gentleman.
▸
Assessment & feedback
No substantive response was provided
Will Write
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A GCSE project highlighted the importance of employment in reducing reoffending rates.
Given that we know employment can help to reduce reoffending, what progress is being made on helping offenders and ex-offenders into work?
My right hon. Friend the Member for East Hampshire has talked about this a little. It is very important for people within jails to be given the chance to connect with opportunities outside.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific progress details were not provided
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Sex Matters petition seeks to clarify the Equality Act 2010.
What preparations are being made to clarify and strengthen all protected characteristics, and to ensure that freedom of speech is protected as well?
The review would be led by the Government Equalities Office. On transgender prisoners, my approach is that transgender women can only be held on the main women's estate if risk-assessed to be safe.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific preparations were not outlined
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Shops in Ipswich are suffering from repeated theft, leading to closures.
Does the Lord Chancellor agree that the criminal justice system needs to be far harder on those who are repeatedly caught shoplifting? It is debilitating for a town centre, and we should not let cultural sensitivities get in the way.
My hon. Friend is right. Crime is crime, and cultural sensitivities should play no part in the police's enthusiasm for cracking down on it. 20,000 additional police officers have been recruited to fulfil the Government's manifesto commitment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures not addressed
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question arises from concerns about the law's impact and whether it accurately captures culpable individuals.
I welcome the Secretary of State to his place. Does he have plans to undertake an assessment of the functioning of the law on joint enterprise?
The hon. Gentleman will be aware that the Court of Appeal considered carefully the scope of the law of joint enterprise to ensure it catches only people who are truly culpable. There are currently no plans to reform the law, but I would consider any sensitive matter he wishes to raise.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific assessment plan was not provided
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q14
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Prison officers were recognized during the coronation parade, raising their profile as a career choice.
Will my right hon. and learned Friend join me in congratulating prison officers on their recognition during the coronation parade? I note HMP Aylesbury is recruiting.
My hon. Friend is an excellent recruiting sergeant for HMP Aylesbury. Prison officers are remarkable people who do a difficult job, and through a £100 million scheme, every prison officer has body-worn video to ensure accountability.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There is public concern about the distinction between people fleeing persecution and those arriving illegally.
Will the Secretary of State ensure discussions with Cabinet colleagues highlight that there is a massive distinction between refugees fleeing persecution and those who leave countries without oppression to arrive here illegally?
This country shows its humane, decent and fair nature through welcoming 500,000 people fleeing persecution since 2015. However, ensuring this humane instinct is not undermined requires fairness in treating those who traffic people or arrive illegally.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific policy to distinguish public perception was not provided
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q16
Direct Answer
▸
Context
There is a need to support veterans who enter the criminal justice system.
Can the Minister say what the Department is doing to support armed forces veterans in the criminal justice system?
The Department ensures that those who leave custody have a guaranteed 12 weeks of accommodation and are supported to rebuild relationships, find employment, address mental health or drug issues. This includes pilot schemes ensuring support for armed service personnel.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Concerns about the temporary release failure of known criminal Dean Woods from Her Majesty's Prison Sudbury.
Since last year, has the Department done anything to make sure that Mr Woods is returned not to a category D prison but to a category B prison and ensure European cooperation?
I offer to meet the hon. Gentleman to talk through that detailed case.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions were not provided
Offer Meeting
Response accuracy