Topical Questions 2023-01-10
2023-01-10
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP seeks an update on his department's actions since the last oral questions.
If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities. Since the last oral questions, we have published our rape review progress report and launched a 24/7 support line for victims of rape.
Since the last oral questions, we have published our rape review progress report, which shows that adult rape cases charged and cases received at the Crown court were up by 65% and 91% respectively compared with 2019. We have launched a 24/7 support line for the victims of rape so that we can be there to provide the support they need in their hour of need.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP supports a constituent's campaign on spiking, which has gathered over 1500 testimonies. The issue is concerning as spiking is already a criminal offence.
I have been supportive of my constituent Sharon Gaffka's campaign on spiking. She was spiked twice and has more than 1,500 testimonies of people aged 14 to 64 who have had the same experience. Will my right hon. Friend update me on the discussions he has been having with the Home Office about punishments and prosecutions so that we can stamp this crime out?
I thank my hon. Friend for his consistent campaigning on such an important issue. He will know that spiking is already a criminal offence with a maximum sentence of 10 years' imprisonment. The primary barriers to prosecution that we have identified are suspect identification and the gathering of sufficient evidence. We are taking a range of practical measures to address that, such as reclassifying gamma-hydroxybutyric acid—the so-called date rape drug—from class C to class B, investing in projects such as safer streets and the safety of women at night fund to protect women, and working with the police to produce a forensic strategy to ensure that we have stronger prosecutions and law enforcement in this area.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There were a quarter of a million violent assaults inside prison over the last decade, with over 8,000 weapons found inside prison last year alone.
There were a quarter of a million violent assaults inside prison over the last decade. Last year alone, over 8,000 weapons were found inside prison. Does the Secretary of State accept responsibility for the fact that violence is now rife in our prisons?
I do not accept that categorisation. What I would say is that we have introduced a whole range of measures, from drug testing to X-ray scanners, and we are now seeing enforcement picking up contraband which, frankly, was not being dealt with before. Last year, the hon. Gentleman criticised the funding we are putting into X-ray scanners. I wonder whether he will now withdraw those remarks.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Doesn't accept responsibility directly and instead asks for a withdrawal of previous criticism.
Looking At This
Will Focus On
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Violence, drug abuse, and rising contraband have been issues in prisons since the Conservatives came to power.
I wonder whether drug testing is working, because drug abuse in prisons has shot up by 400% since the Conservatives came to power. Last year, crack cocaine was found being manufactured in cells inside Sudbury prison. Rising violence, rising drug abuse—does the Justice Secretary admit that the Government have lost control of our prisons?
No, and as I announced just a few moments ago we are introducing more scanners so that we detect, pick up and stop the flow of contraband into prison, whether drugs, mobile phones or weapons. We also have a step change in the approach to drug treatment. For example, we have fewer heroin addicts dumped on methadone indefinitely, and more drug recovery wings and more incentivised wings for substance-free living.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Doesn't admit losing control but introduces new measures as a response.
Will Focus On
Response accuracy
Q5
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Residents are concerned about burglaries and want to ensure that those arrested receive appropriate sentences.
Carshalton and Wallington residents are deeply concerned about burglaries. I welcome the Metropolitan police's commitment to attend all burglaries, but will my right hon. Friend outline what his Department is doing to ensure that those who are arrested receive appropriate sentences?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. I can tell him that domestic burglary has actually fallen by half since 2010, and the Metropolitan police's operational tenacity is one element of that. On sentencing, the maximum sentence is 14 years. That is obviously an individual decision for judges, but I can also tell him that since 2010 the average sentence has increased by nine months, from 22.6 months to 31.6 months.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government were supposed to respond by the end of November to the Justice Committee's hard-hitting report but have not done so.
The Government were supposed to respond by the end of November to the Justice Committee's hard-hitting report on IPP—imprisonment for public protection—sentences, yet they still have not done so. Will the Secretary of State tell us exactly what the hold-up is and when we can expect his official response?
This is an important issue, and I am grateful to the Select Committee for raising it. We want the number to come down, but the right way to do that is not to let out offenders who have been deemed dangerous in the past based on legislation passed under the Labour Government that would not apply now. Therefore, we are taking every measure to ensure offenders can pass the threshold and satisfy decision makers that they are safe to be released.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Doesn't address when a response will come but explains approach to reducing IPP numbers.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q7
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Buckinghamshire youth offending service received a rating of good following an inspection by HM inspectorate of probation.
This morning, Buckinghamshire youth offending service received a rating of good following an inspection by HM inspectorate of probation. The inspectors say leadership is strong, that staff are skilled and motivated, and that, crucially, feedback from children themselves is positive. Will my right hon. Friend join me in congratulating Bucks YOS? Does he agree that effective and efficient local youth offending teams are crucial in steering young people away from crime?
I am delighted to hear that result and I totally agree with my hon. Friend on the importance of youth offending teams. They have been a great success since 2010 in reducing the number of under-18s who are locked up. They are fundamental to helping to put young people on a better path and stopping them getting on to the path of incarceration and reoffending.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Women eligible for early release from prison are being denied that opportunity due to a lack of safe move-on accommodation, affecting mothers' ability to re-engage with their children.
Women eligible for early release from prison are being denied that opportunity due to the lack of safe move-on accommodation. Many of those women are mothers and a safe home would allow them to re-engage with their children. Will the Secretary of State please look urgently at investing more money and innovation in developing safe community accommodation like that available through the Hope Street Project, to allow more women across the country to benefit from early release?
We are also locking up fewer women and that is right where it is possible to avoid incarceration. We are investing large amounts of money into an increased accommodation offer. I will absolutely look at the particular project the hon. Lady mentions and am happy to discuss it.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary did not commit to a specific timeline or funding amount for safe move-on accommodation, though he indicated willingness to discuss the issue further.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Robert Brown murdered his partner Joanna Simpson, is due to be released from prison in November after serving only 13 years. The family and friends are terrified for their lives.
Robert Brown murdered his partner Joanna Simpson. He battered her to death before burying her in a pre-dug grave. This dangerous man is due to be released from prison in November after serving only 13 years of his sentence. Will the Lord Chancellor urgently review that decision? The family and friends of Joanna Simpson are terrified for their lives.
I thank my hon. Friend for raising the matter. I pay tribute to her and to the family, who are very much in my thoughts. She will know that we have an extra power, which we introduced in the Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Act 2022; it is quite a confined power, but I will undertake to look at it in this case.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Lord Chancellor did not commit to reviewing the decision without further details or a specific timeline.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q10
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Disabled people and organizations use the Human Rights Act in their fight for humane treatment, including equal health treatments.
Has the Secretary of State considered the effect of his Bill of Rights proposals on disabled people and organisations, who consistently use the Human Rights Act in their fight to ensure that disabled people are treated humanely and equitably, for example by ensuring that they receive the same health treatments that are routinely given to the rest of the population?
The hon. Lady raises a critically important point. Of course there is nothing in our Bill of Rights that would impact on the healthcare that disabled individuals or communities would receive.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Data Protection Act may create unnecessary bureaucratic barriers for policing and the administration of justice.
Has my right hon. Friend liaised with colleagues in Government with regard to amending the Data Protection Act to ease the bureaucratic burden on policing and speed up the administration of justice?
We are determined to reduce any unnecessary bureaucratic barriers that make it harder for our police, and our criminal justice system more broadly, to work as effectively as possible. Although I am not aware of any discussions about the specific issue that my hon. Friend mentions, or about the section 29 exemption for policing under the DPA, I am aware that the Police Federation is doing some work on the issue.
▸
Assessment & feedback
There was no commitment to discuss or amend the Data Protection Act specifically.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Prison Service has lost more than 99,000 years of prison officer experience since 2010.
Figures unearthed by my hon. Friend the Member for Easington (Grahame Morris) show that the Prison Service has lost more than 99,000 years of prison officer experience since 2010. That is startling. Is this absolute failure of Government policy what has caused the current state of chaos and crisis in His Majesty's Prison Service?
I pay tribute to prison officers for the amazing job that they have done—particularly through the pandemic, but also more generally. We often pay tribute to frontline emergency service workers, but prison officers in particular are out of sight, out of mind. That is why it is so important that we followed the recommendations of the pay review body. I can tell the hon. Gentleman that since 2016 the number of full-time prison officers has increased by 3,662.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary did not address whether this was an absolute failure but instead emphasized positive actions taken for prison officers.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Despite IPP sentences being abolished over a decade ago, many are still in custody due to mental health conditions developed in prison.
Despite IPP sentences having been abolished more than 10 years ago, 2,926 IPP prisoners were still in custody as of June 2022, of whom 608 were 10 years over their original tariff. Does my right hon. Friend agree that many of those people are locked in prison as a result of mental health conditions that they have developed while in custody, rather than because of the threat that they pose to the public?
My hon. Friend has raised the issue with me a number of times, and I respect his view. Of course, we have repealed the IPP legislation, but we are dealing retrospectively with the backlog of cases.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Lord Chancellor did not address whether those in custody were due to mental health issues rather than public safety concerns.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Women are victims of violent crime, yet the government has not delivered on promises for a victim's bill or appointed a new Victim's Commissioner.
Too many women and girls are victims of violent crime, yet the Government have still not delivered the long-promised victims Bill. They have also failed to appoint a Victims' Commissioner since last September. Victims need support and the Government are letting them down. Why do the Government not prioritise victims?
I hope I can reassure the hon. Lady: we are funding victims to the tune of quadruple the level under the last Labour Government; we will appoint a new Victims' Commissioner shortly; and the Victims Bill will be coming forward as soon as parliamentary time allows.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Lord Chancellor did not commit to specific timing for the Victim's Bill or the appointment of a new commissioner but stated these would happen 'shortly'.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There are rising numbers of rape prosecutions but still too low, partly due to long court delays.
My last meeting of 2022 was probably the most important, because I met our police chief and police commissioner to discuss rape victims in Essex. The number of prosecutions is rising but it is still far too low, and one of the factors that put women off is the long court delays. As more judges are recruited, will the Government please ensure that they focus on rape cases, so that 2023 can be the year in which women who have been raped know they will have access to justice?
My right hon. Friend is right. In June last year, we announced—this is on top of the measures I have already mentioned—enhanced specialist sexual violence support in three specific Crown court locations where there is a high throughput of rape cases: Leeds, Newcastle and Snaresbrook.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Lord Chancellor did not commit to ensuring new judges focus on rape cases but highlighted measures already taken.
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Conviction rate in rape cases is abysmal with only one in 100 reported rape cases resulting in a charge. Labour wants to improve this.
Under this Government, an abysmal one in 100 reported rape cases results in a charge. The Government say that they want to return to 2016 charging levels, but at this rate we are never going to get there. Labour has been calling for specialist rape courts and legal advocates for victims. When will the Secretary of State finally take the action that is needed to secure justice for as many victims as possible?
I thank the hon. Lady for raising this issue, which comes up at every session of Justice questions. In fact, the conviction rate in rape cases has risen in the last year, from 68% to 69%. The hon. Lady asked about specialist rape courts; I have just mentioned the three specialised fitted courtrooms that we have introduced in the areas with the highest throughput of rape cases to achieve exactly what she is asking for.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific ask about legal advocates and a timeline was not addressed
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A private Member's Bill became the Civil Partnerships, Marriages and Deaths (Registration Etc) Act 2019, obliging the Government to introduce regulations giving coroners powers to investigate stillbirths. The questioner asked for a meeting on this issue three months ago but nothing has happened.
In February, it will be four years since my private Member's Bill became the Civil Partnerships, Marriages and Deaths (Registration Etc) Act 2019, obliging the Government to introduce regulations giving coroners powers to investigate stillbirths. During Justice questions on 18 October, I asked the Minister why nothing had happened, and asked for a meeting to make progress on the issue. Three months on, still nothing has happened. Why not?
My hon. Friend is right—he has raised this matter before—and I shall be happy to sit down with him and find out what the logjam is so that we can move this forward for him.
▸
Assessment & feedback
No specifics on why nothing has happened or when it will happen
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Last year, there were 17,700 cases of drugs being found in prisons, an increase of well over 411% since the Conservatives came to power in 2010. The questioner is questioning who the Secretary of State blames for this failure.
It is simply unacceptable that drug dealers are able to continue to peddle their trade so easily behind bars. Last year, there were 17,700 cases of drugs being found in prisons, an increase of well over 411% since the Conservatives came to power in 2010. Who exactly does the Secretary of State blame for this failure in law and order?
The hon. Gentleman is right to raise the importance of checking and stopping the flow of drugs and other contraband into prisons. He should speak to the shadow Justice Secretary, the hon. Member for Croydon North (Steve Reed), who, when we introduced £100 million of investment in X-ray scanners last year, said that it was a waste of money.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not answer the specific ask and instead criticized another MP
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A woman standing alone quietly praying outside an abortion clinic was arrested. The questioner asks if the Secretary of State is aware of this event.
The Secretary of State will be aware of the existence of public spaces protection orders in some council areas. Is he also aware of a scandalous event that took place in Birmingham just before Christmas? A woman standing alone, quietly and with no protest material, outside an abortion clinic which was closed was arrested by police and asked what she was doing. When she said that she was quietly praying in her head, she was arrested and taken to a cell, and, while being questioned by police, was asked what she was praying about.
I do not know the facts of that case. If the hon. Gentleman would like to write to me, I will make inquiries to the extent that I am able to do so.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm awareness or take responsibility for addressing the issue directly
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Minister was asked to assess racial disparities in joint enterprise prosecutions once the data is available. The questioner wants confirmation on this.
In answer to Question 11, asked by my hon. Friend the Member for Edmonton (Kate Osamor), what the Minister seemed to say was that he was willing to assess the racial disparities in joint enterprise prosecutions once the data was available, which it is not at present but which it will be in the near future. Am I right to draw that conclusion?
What I said was that the issue was complex, and that I would be happy to sit down with the hon. Member for Edmonton to go through the exact details and the exact concerns, rather than addressing such a sensitive issue across the Dispatch Box, so that we could have a meaningful discussion and see whether we could find a way forward to resolve the underlying issues.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm willingness to assess disparities directly
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Five years ago, the Right Rev. James Jones reported on the experience of the Hillsborough families. The questioner is asking when a Hillsborough law will be introduced to change how justice is delivered.
Five years ago, the Right Rev. James Jones reported on the experience of the Hillsborough families. My constituents and I are waiting for the Government to introduce a Hillsborough law that will change the way in which justice is delivered in this country. When will that happen? We are sick of waiting.
With regard to the independent public advocate, I am very sympathetic and I want to make an announcement on that shortly. I reassure the hon. Lady that we have been working hard across Government to get the right answer ready, to be able to provide her with the reassurance that she needs.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm a timeline for introducing a Hillsborough law
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner's constituent has had their historical CSE case postponed three times since they reported abuse in 2019. The clerk of the court said only important cases were being prioritised.
My constituent, a victim of historical child sexual exploitation, has had her case postponed three times since she reported her abuse back in 2019. Each time it is cancelled, she relives the trauma that she experienced, and this has been made worse by the clerk of the court saying that only important cases were being prioritised. What percentage of historical CSE cases are delayed for four years and responded to so insensitively?
This is an acutely sensitive issue and if the hon. Lady wants to write to me about that specific case, I would be happy to look into it. Of course, listing decisions and things like that are made by the judges independently in those particular cases.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide statistics on delays for historical CSE cases
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A man who pleaded guilty to sexual abuse was given permission to go on holiday. The Secretary of State asked the questioner to write to him, but in the response from the Minister, the central point about bail conditions was not addressed.
I have previously raised the case of a man who, after pleading guilty to sexual abuse, was given permission to go abroad on holiday. The Secretary of State asked me to write to him, but in the response from the Minister, the central point of concern about bail conditions was not addressed. Will the Secretary of State or a Minister say whether, in general terms, they think it is appropriate for sex offenders to go on holiday? I do not. Do they?
I would want to put public protection first and foremost, but of course it will all depend on the circumstances of any individual case.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address appropriateness for sex offenders going on holiday generally
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
▸
Context
One magistrate signed off 496 cases in just 3 minutes and 51 seconds, including cases involving children, disabled people, and people experiencing fuel poverty. The questioner asks what steps the Minister will take to ensure proper scrutiny.
Speed is compromising scrutiny in the magistrates court when it comes to the issuing of warrants to fit prepayment meters. In one court, 496 cases were signed off in just 3 minutes and 51 seconds, including cases involving children, disabled people and people experiencing fuel poverty. What steps will the Minister take to ensure that magistrates scrutinise every single application?
I appreciate that this is a sensitive issue for families and people who can be very vulnerable. Obviously the judiciary is independent, but I will raise those concerns with the judiciary to see if I can find out the details, and stress the importance of getting it right and not rushing justice.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific steps or a timeline for proper scrutiny
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question arises from the need to address crimes committed during Russia's invasion of Ukraine, specifically focusing on the advantages of a special international tribunal.
What advantages does the Secretary of State see in convening a special international tribunal to try offences committed in Russia's war on Ukraine, including the crime of aggression?
We are doing a huge amount to support the Ukrainian authorities with domestic trials. We are also one of the large group of leading countries referring the situation in Ukraine to the International Criminal Court, and in a couple of months I will be convening a meeting here with the Dutch Justice Minister and getting countries together to ensure we can avoid any impunity for Putin's illegal and disastrous war.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The advantages or rationale behind establishing a special international tribunal were not directly addressed.
Under Review
Working With Partners
Response accuracy