Topical Questions 2023-01-12

2023-01-12

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Cat Smith Lab
Lancaster and Wyre
Context
A constituent, after returning from maternity leave, moved to a new farm but was denied the young farmer's financial support payment. The MP requested clarification and a meeting with the Farming Minister.
I was contacted by a young farmer in my constituency who, after returning from maternity leave, moved to a new farm and created a new business. She was denied her young farmer's financial support payment by the basic payment scheme because the Rural Payments Agency deemed it to be a continuation of her old business. The BPS rules have no business continuation guidance. Why are the new business questionnaires needed when the RPA determines that a new farm is not a new business? Will the Secretary of State ask the Farming Minister to meet me and my constituent to discuss this case?
It would be helpful if the hon. Lady wrote directly to the Farming Minister, who I know is happy to meet her to go through the case. It sounds like quite a complicated, technical situation, so it may take a little time to get a full answer from the RPA.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not commit to asking the Farming Minister for a meeting but suggested writing directly instead.
Suggesting Alternative Action
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Context
The MP inquired about the importance of trade with Brazil, including its export market potential for UK farmers and its potential as a source of imported food.
The Secretary of State has mentioned Brazil a few times today, and we know that she recently visited Brazil for the inauguration of President Lula. While acknowledging her brief time there, does she agree that Brazil represents a huge export market for our farmers and our food sector, as well as being a potential source of food that we currently import from elsewhere?
Brazil already produces a significant amount of foods that are not produced in this country, so we welcome any imports. My hon. Friend highlights the importance of trade and how we can export to Brazil. In any potential future trade agreement with Mercosur, of which Brazil is a member, we would want to make sure that we uphold our standards on food safety, animal welfare and environmental protection.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Wera Hobhouse Lib Dem
Bath
Context
There were more than 775,000 sewage spills in England and Wales between 2020 and 2021. The MP raised concerns about the removal of important indicators for river health by the government.
Between 2020 and 2021, there were more than 775,000 sewage spills in England and Wales. The Government have muddied the waters further by scrapping vital indicators of river and stream health, and by omitting water quality from their legally binding environmental targets. The Secretary of State avoided my previous question on this subject, so I ask again: how can our constituents be sure that their water is clean?
We will be publishing our environmental improvement plan, but the hon. Lady will be aware of the action already taken by the Under-Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, my hon. Friend the Member for Taunton Deane (Rebecca Pow). As we have highlighted to the House today, thanks to Conservative Government monitoring is now widely available, so that we can tackle that, and we never had it before. That is why we are trying to resolve the issues and I know that the hon. Lady will want us to achieve that as quickly as possible.
Assessment & feedback
The Secretary of State did not provide a specific answer on how constituents can be sure about water cleanliness, but referred to future plans and current actions by another Minister.
Referencing Other Actions
Response accuracy
Q4 Direct Answer
Context
The MP raised the issue of clear labelling for consumers who want or do not want to buy halal or kosher meat.
Some people particularly want to buy halal and kosher meat, and some people particularly want to avoid doing so. Is it not time to properly label all these products appropriately, so that consumers, whether they want to buy this or do not want to buy it, can make an informed decision?
The Government have committed to consult on mandatory labelling reforms this year. We want to make it easier for consumers to purchase products aligned with their values. As part of the consultation, we will seek views on labelling products that conform with religious requirements, such as those that are halal and kosher.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Wendy Chamberlain Lib Dem
North East Fife
Context
The MP met the Agricultural Industries Confederation Scotland and heard concerns about rising fertiliser costs due to high gas prices.
Earlier this week, I met the Agricultural Industries Confederation Scotland and it echoed what I am hearing in North East Fife about the impact of gas prices on the cost of fertiliser. What assessment has the Minister undertaken of the impact of fertiliser costs on farming and what is he doing to prevent farmers from being forced to roll back agricultural production as a result of it?
I am chairing the fertiliser taskforce within DEFRA that is looking at these challenges. We recognise the huge pressure that fertiliser prices are putting on farmers up and down the country. We will continue to work with our colleagues in the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy to assist in dealing with the challenge we are facing. The good news is that the wholesale price of gas is coming down and some fertiliser prices are reflecting that drop in wholesale gas prices.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide a detailed assessment or specific actions taken but mentioned ongoing work and recent trends in gas and fertiliser prices.
Mentioning Ongoing Work
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Context
The MP raised concerns about local authorities not reviewing their air quality action plans regularly enough, leading to outdated and ineffective plans.
The Government require local authorities to assess local air quality, but they only expect and request air quality action plans to be reviewed every five years. Many of those plans are seriously out of date, so will the Government please get a bit tougher with local authorities to make sure that those plans are up to date and are doing what they are supposed to do?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising that important point, which highlights not only the role of local authorities in air quality, but ensuring that these action plans are reviewed and delivered on time. We have recently updated our local air quality management policy guidance, with a new escalation process for local authorities that do not have an up-to-date plan.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not enforce stricter timelines but mentioned updating guidance and implementing an escalation process.
Mentioning Updated Guidelines
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Helen Morgan Lib Dem
North Shropshire
Context
The MP raised concerns about repeated flooding of the River Severn and the Vyrnwy, which originates upstream in Wales.
The River Severn and the River Vyrnwy are in flood again, and the Minister will know that this is the fourth year in a row we have seen flooding, with record flooding over the past three years. Obviously, that water originates upstream in Wales. Will she update me as to the conversations she has had with her Welsh colleagues about managing the upper Severn catchment?
The hon. Lady raises the important point that the whole catchment is involved in flooding; this is about not just where the flooding occurs at the bottom, but where it comes from. Not long ago, I visited the Vyrnwy reservoir. Apparently, that was the first time a Minister had ever been there. I held a roundtable with the Welsh equivalent of the Environment Agency and all sorts of other bodies, but the Labour Welsh Environment Minister declined to join us.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister focused on her visit and a missed opportunity for collaboration rather than addressing flood management discussions directly.
Changing Subject
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
The MP's constituents were without mains water due to severe weather affecting Southern Water's facilities.
Two days before Christmas, thousands of my constituents were left without any mains water after the big freeze followed by thaw led to a deluge. Does the Minister agree that Southern Water needs to explain and compensate residents this month? Will she thank Winchester scouts for their work in distributing bottled water?
Yes. I also thank my hon. Friend for his work as the local MP; all our local MPs got involved in this, as did DEFRA's emergency team. I met the chief executive officer of South East Water to talk about how it had to put up better water stations and improve its communications—all the things that he is mentioning. Its feet will be held to the fire to get its comms out to everybody to explain what happened and to improve the situation in future.
Assessment & feedback
Specific compensation details not provided
Under Review Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Dan Jarvis Lab
Barnsley North
Context
Untreated sewage was released for over 2.6 million hours in 2021 and customers pay a significant portion on servicing debt.
Untreated sewage was released from storm overflows for more than 2.6 million hours in 2021, with customers paying 20% of their water bills on servicing debt. Does the Minister think that the current system of regulation is fit for purpose?
Yes, the Minister does think that the current regulation is fit for purpose, but many tweaks and improvements are made to ensure that it is working properly. That is why, under the Environment Act 2021, powers were given to Ofwat to alter the licences, so that what it pays out reflects whether it is improving the environment. That will be a critical step forward, as will our strategic policy statement that we gave it to put tackling storm overflows and improving the environment at the top of the agenda.
Assessment & feedback
Specific details on customer financial burdens not provided
Under Review Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Neil Hudson Con
Epping Forest
Context
Highly pathogenic H5N1 avian influenza has been confirmed in the constituency.
H5N1 avian flu has been confirmed in Eden. Will my right hon. Friend join me in thanking frontline workers, including vets? Will farmers be reassured that support and compensation measures are constantly under review?
I join my hon. Friend in paying tribute to those people who are working on avian flu, including the chief vet, who was recognised in the new year's honours list. I can assure my hon. Friend that we continue to talk to, and work with, industry to make sure that farmers can be profitable and confident that their business will succeed next year.
Assessment & feedback
No specific assurances on ongoing review
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Kerry McCarthy Lab
Bristol East
Context
Proposals to restrict plant-based products from using traditional meat and dairy terms.
There are reports that the UK might adopt proposals banning producers of plant-based products from using traditional meat and dairy terms. Does the Minister think the British public is so stupid to think a product called 'oat milk' comes from a cow?
My advice is not to believe everything that we read in the papers.
Assessment & feedback
No specific stance on labelling proposals
Does Not Engage With Question
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
Blackpool's historic piers are deteriorating due to coastal erosion.
Blackpool's historic piers show signs of significant deterioration. Although the Department is providing £12 million for coastal erosion, the measures needed around the piers are not included. Will the Minister meet me to discuss how they can be amended?
Within our budgets, we have the coastal erosion fund, of which my hon. Friend is aware. The pier is a very specific case. Of course, I would be happy to meet him to discuss this.
Assessment & feedback
No commitment on plan amendment
Will Meet
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
Research shows over 1.3 million disposable vapes are thrown away weekly.
Material Focus found that at least 1.3 million disposable vapes are thrown away every week, including precious metals improperly disposed of and litter issues. What is the Secretary of State doing to support clear recycling advice?
I thank the hon. Lady for her question. We had a recent debate on this subject. It is astounding that these disposable vapes are being literally littered. Measures include our extended producer responsibility scheme, which puts the onus on the manufacturer and the seller of the product to deal with their safe disposal.
Assessment & feedback
No specific recycling advice mentioned
Under Review Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
Request to increase hedgerow coverage by 40% by 2040.
What steps is my hon. Friend taking to support the planting of hedgerows to increase hedgerow coverage by 40% by 2040?
Hedgerows are absolutely fantastic, as I saw for myself here in Parliament at the hedgerow showcase of CPRE, the Countryside Charity. As we treble tree planting across this country, I will ensure that we do everything possible to put hedge planting and protection at the forefront of our priorities.
Assessment & feedback
No specific steps mentioned
Under Review Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Context
Concerns about alien plant species entering the UK.
What discussions have Ministers had with colleagues about monitoring and restricting plants brought into the UK from overseas by the public to protect biodiversity and food production?
The hon. Lady raises an important question. It is critical that we have that information for the public at our borders, as well as the targeted information focused on nurseries. We will continue to inform the public that bringing alien species into this country is bad news for nature in the UK.
Assessment & feedback
No specific monitoring measures mentioned
Under Review Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
Two horses died in New Year's fireworks celebrations this year, one incident occurring in Andrew Selous' constituency. The Animal Welfare Act 2006 struggles to enforce regulations against such incidents.
New year's fireworks celebrations caused the deaths of two horses this year—one in my constituency. The Animal Welfare Act 2006 is very difficult to enforce. May I meet the animal welfare Minister to look at this issue? The numbers are astounding. No fireworks display is ever worth the death of a much-loved family pet or animal.
I am conscious of the impact fireworks can have on animals. I will share my hon. Friend's concerns with my noble Friend Lord Benyon, who covers this area, and I expect Lord Benyon will meet with him.
Assessment & feedback
Meeting request was not directly addressed or committed to.
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Jim Shannon DUP
Strangford
Context
Vets in Northern Ireland face difficulties accessing essential veterinary medicines due to the Northern Ireland protocol, impacting both availability and cost.
The Minister will be aware of the Northern Ireland protocol and the difficulties that vets in Northern Ireland are experiencing in accessing medicines. It is important that assistance is given on both availability and cost. Vets are reorientating their supply chains with great difficulty. Can I seek the Minister's help for Northern Ireland vets in respect of medicines access, so that we have the same access to treatment as the rest of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland?
The hon. Gentleman will be aware of the status of what is happening with the Northern Ireland protocol. My noble Friend Lord Benyon leads on borders and veterinarians, so I will bring the hon. Gentleman's question to his attention. It is important that we continue to ensure a peaceful solution to what is happening in Northern Ireland and a restoration of the Northern Ireland Executive and Assembly as quickly as possible.
Assessment & feedback
The issue was not directly addressed, focusing instead on broader political issues regarding the Northern Ireland protocol.
Response accuracy