Topical Questions 2023-09-14

2023-09-14

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Chi Onwurah Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
Context
The question is about the Secretary of State's role in supporting inward investment across the UK.
If she will make a statement on her departmental responsibilities. The Department for Business and Trade supports inward investment into all regions and nations of the UK, including hosting an investment summit showcasing Northern Ireland's opportunities.
As Secretary of State for Business and Trade, my priority is to support inward investment into all regions and nations of the UK. This week, we delivered the investment summit showcasing opportunities in Northern Ireland.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Chi Onwurah Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
Context
A well-known business, Wilko, has entered administration, affecting many high streets including Newcastle city centre.
This weekend I will visit Wilko in Newcastle. Should I explain to staff there that mass redundancies and empty shopfronts are what the Conservatives mean by levelling up? The local community and staff at Wilko are concerned about the impact of administration.
We support businesses like Wilko during such difficult times, discussing best ways forward with unions and helping to find bidders. The Government is providing support to ensure people have somewhere to go.
Assessment & feedback
The answer avoids the specific ask about what mass redundancies mean for 'levelling up'.
Working With Unions Supporting By Finding Bidders
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
The Parliamentary Partnership Assembly was set up under the trade and co-operation agreement with the EU to promote Britain's interests overseas.
Do Ministers agree that delegates should be promoting Britain's interests, not acting against them? The PPA is a parliamentary body independent of Government but values its role in supporting a mature relationship with the EU.
The Government value the work of the Parliamentary Partnership Assembly and support its role. The right hon. Friend is correct that we should look forward, not backwards.
Assessment & feedback
Does not address whether delegates against UK interests should leave PPA explicitly.
Looking Forward
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Jonathan Reynolds Lab Co-op
Stalybridge and Hyde
Context
Wilko's demise highlights concerns about the future of town centre retail, with several bidders saying that town centre retail is no longer a viable business model.
In light of Wilko's situation and bids stating town centre retail is not viable, does the Government believe their policy environment is sufficient for high streets to thrive? The loss of 12,500 jobs due to Wilko affects many families.
The Government are concerned about the impact on families and are supportive. We believe that high streets are reshaping themselves, with rates relief of £13.6 billion over five years.
Assessment & feedback
Does not address whether current policy environment is sufficient explicitly.
High Street Is Reshaping Rates Relief
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Jonathan Reynolds Lab Co-op
Stalybridge and Hyde
Context
Ministers' answers do not match the scale of the problem; 12,500 Wilko workers are at risk. Labour's plans include reforming business rates and tackling late payment.
Based on Ministers' answers today, this Government have simply given up on high streets. The problem demands a response from them. What is their plan?
The hon. Gentleman's point about business rates lacks clarity, as Labour has not specified how to replace £22 billion of lost taxation receipts.
Assessment & feedback
Avoids discussing concrete actions for high streets and criticises Labour instead.
Criticising Labour
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Bob Blackman Con
Harrow East
Context
The Secretary of State and Prime Minister recently visited India for negotiations on a trade deal. A previous promise was made by her predecessor to have the deal in place by Diwali.
With Diwali this year, what confidence does she have that we will have the trade deal with India in place? The visit is an opportunity to negotiate further on the wonderful trade deal with India.
My hon. Friend, it's not about the day but the deal. We are working as much as we can to get a mutually beneficial deal with India.
Assessment & feedback
Does not provide specific confidence level or commitment.
It'S Not About The Day
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
Recent figures show that small businesses in the UK are owed over £32 billion in late payments. EU sets out an SME relief package to tackle this issue.
What is the Minister doing to combat late payments for SMEs? The problem of late payments coupled with rising energy costs and other inflationary pressures make running small businesses impossible.
We launched a payment and cash flow review earlier this year, which is due to report very shortly. We will be ambitious in making sure small businesses get paid more quickly.
Assessment & feedback
Does not provide specific details on immediate actions or measures.
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Luke Evans Con
Hinckley and Bosworth
Context
The local Caterpillar factory celebrated its 70th anniversary, employing 1,300 people.
In August, I was lucky to be invited to the 70th anniversary of Caterpillar being founded in my constituency. It now employs 1,300 people and exports across the world. Will my hon. Friend congratulate Caterpillar on its investment here?
I join my hon. Friend, a great champion of Bosworth, in congratulating Caterpillar on 70 years and 1,300 employees. That is fantastic. I look forward to going along and having a go on the electric diggers.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Judith Cummins Lab
Bradford South
Context
Wilko, a retailer in Bradford South, recently went into administration.
The loss of Wilko is devastating for thousands of workers who will lose their livelihoods. Will the Secretary of State confirm that she will seek answers from Wilko management about why clear warnings were ignored and the business was driven into the ground? She will meet me and the GMB trade union to assure us that those basic failures will not be repeated?
The hon. Member raises an important point. There is certainly, as part of the administration process, an obligation on the administrators to look at the circumstances that led to the demise of that company and report to the Insolvency Service.
Assessment & feedback
Meeting with MP and GMB
Looking At The Circumstances
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Context
The events industry is a significant export opportunity for the UK.
As chair of the all-party parliamentary group for events, can I highlight the huge benefits the sector brings us in promoting trade, exports and inward investment? Will the Department do more to promote the UK worldwide as a great place to bring international events, business meetings and conferences?
My right hon. Friend raises a good point. The events industry is often overlooked, yet it is a great export opportunity. Those are some of the things I am going to raise with the Board of Trade, which is meeting next week.
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions for promotion
Raising At Board Of Trade
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Context
Many small businesses are struggling with the rise in prices caused by import-export costs, which is attributed to Brexit.
Airdrie and Shotts is home to some fantastic local businesses. Recently, I had the pleasure of visiting Christie's bakery and Gin Blossoms. Small businesses across Scotland play a vital role in the local economy but are feeling the brunt of rising prices of raw materials due to import-export costs caused by Brexit. Can the Minister outline how the UK Government will compensate businesses for the damaging losses that Brexit continues to cause?
The hon. Member raises an important point about the cost of living impact on businesses. These are global issues, not domestic issues.
Assessment & feedback
Compensation for Brexit losses
Global Issues
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Context
Sector deals were effective in boosting productivity, innovation, and skills in sectors like aerospace, AI, and offshore wind.
In the period leading up to 2021, sector deals were a very effective means of boosting productivity, innovation and skills. What plans are there to review, revitalise and extend those public-private partnerships?
My hon. Friend raises a good point. Those sectors are critical for the UK economy. While we did have plans around sector deals, I would focus on the Chancellor's five sectors that he thinks will drive growth in the UK.
Assessment & feedback
Specific plans to review and revitalise
Chancellor'S Five Sectors
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
Phoenixing is a practice that puts a burden on legitimate SMEs, as well as the taxpayer.
We know that phoenixing, unpaid-for services rendered, puts a burden on legitimate SMEs but also burdens the taxpayer. Given that the Minister did not accept my amendment to the Economic Crime and Transparency Bill, can he explain what the Government are actually doing to prevent this practice?
I am happy to engage with the hon. Member. I missed the earliest part of his question, but we are providing an awful lot of support for small businesses in various ways.
Assessment & feedback
Current stance on phoenixing practices
Various Ways
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Context
There is interest in updating the public on proposals for a carbon border adjustment mechanism.
May we have an update on our proposals for a carbon border adjustment mechanism?
The Treasury published a consultation in March on a range of measures to mitigate carbon leakage. Potential policies include a carbon adjustment mechanism on managing product standards.
Assessment & feedback
Specific updates on the CBAM
Consultation In March
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Jeff Smith Lab
Manchester Withington
Context
The launch of UK Music's “Manifesto for Music” highlighted the need for musicians' voice in discussions about AI.
Yesterday, I joined my hon. Friend the Member for Cardiff West on the all-party parliamentary group on music for the launch of UK Music's impressive “Manifesto for Music”. The opportunities and risks of AI are a key issue for the industry. Will the Government commit to musicians having a voice and a place at the table for the AI summit in November?
That is certainly something we can look to do. There are many concerns about what will happen to copyright and intellectual property once AI continues to advance in this area.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to representation at the summit
Look To Do
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
The question arises from discussions about trade agreements and partnerships involving the United States.
I notice that the Americans refer to it as the trans-Pacific partnership. Have there been any discussions with the US Administration about them eventually rejoining this partnership?
The hon. Friend is right; it was initially called the TPP, and Canada added 'comprehensive and progressive'. The US has stated that it will not sign free trade agreements like the one we had under consideration. Instead, the Atlantic declaration by the Prime Minister and President Biden serves as a new vehicle for forming a trade partnership. My Department works actively across Government with counterparts in the US to ensure this delivers for the UK.
Assessment & feedback
Discussion of specific plans or commitments about the US rejoining the TPP
Changed Subject To Atlantic Declaration
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Andrew Gwynne Ind
Gorton and Denton
Context
The Halifax, the last bank in Denton town centre, closed recently. This leaves small businesses without access to high street banking.
Many small businesses still rely on high street banks like the Halifax which has just closed its doors in Denton and Reddish constituency. What can be done to ensure they have access?
The hon. Gentleman makes an important point; we urge banks to listen to their customers on keeping doors open. The banking framework relationship with the post office network provides deposit and cash facilities for small businesses, which will ensure sustainability of the post office network.
Assessment & feedback
No specific plan or commitment mentioned to prevent bank closures in town centres
Changed Subject To Banking Framework Relationship
Response accuracy
Q18 Direct Answer
Kerry McCarthy Lab
Bristol East
Context
There was a visit to Harland & Wolff shipyard and concern about the future of UK shipbuilding in light of disappointing auction rounds.
Harland & Wolff in north Devon discussed potential for UK shipbuilding jobs linked to offshore renewables. Given last week's auction round disappointment, what can be said to convince shipbuilders there is a future with service vessels?
I was at Harland & Wolff last night for London International Shipping Week. They are excited about the shipbuilding credit guarantee scheme, providing Government-backed loans of up to £500 million to ensure that shipbuilding continues to thrive in the UK.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Context
There is a discussion about the impact of Brexit, with some finding aspects regrettable or disappointing.
Despite overwhelming evidence to contrary, Ministers claim Brexit benefits. Will the Secretary of State admit any regret over Brexit?
The hon. Gentleman is right; I find one thing regrettable - he continues to discuss this despite the world moving on post-referendum. We have left the EU and won't return under same terms. Focusing on benefits like control over laws, borders, money, and deregulation through smarter regulation programme.
Assessment & feedback
No specific admission of regret or disappointment about Brexit
Changed Subject To Benefits Of Brexit
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Andy McDonald Lab
Middlesbrough and Thornaby East
Context
The UK automotive industry faces challenges with the increase in rules of origin thresholds and cheaper Chinese electric cars entering the market.
With UK automotive transitioning to net zero, what additional measures are being taken to ameliorate impact of cheaper and heavily subsidised Chinese imports?
The transition poses a risk of greater reliance on China for battery manufacturing needed for zero emission vehicles. We work with allies like US and critical minerals strategy to diversify supply chains, ensuring competitiveness and national security.
Assessment & feedback
No specific measures mentioned to address cheaper Chinese imports
Changed Subject To Wider Issues Of Transition
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Jim Shannon DUP
Strangford
Context
Great Britain is the main export market for agricultural goods from Northern Ireland, but the Northern Ireland protocol complicates trade.
Given Great Britain's importance as an export market for agri-trade in Northern Ireland and complications due to NI protocol, what discussions has Secretary of State had with DAERA?
The hon. Gentleman is right; first thing we want to see is restoration of Executive in Northern Ireland. Discussions facilitate business conversations and encourage restoration of Executive for driving changes wanted.
Assessment & feedback
No specific discussions mentioned on agri-trade issues related to NI protocol
Changed Subject To Restoring The Executive
Response accuracy