Legal Migration 2024-02-26

2024-02-26

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Context
MP seeks information on steps being taken to reduce legal migration.
What steps he is taking to reduce levels of legal migration?
On 4 December, the Government announced a package of new measures to further reduce net migration, including but not limited to stopping overseas care workers bringing family dependants, increasing the salary threshold for skilled worker visas to £38,700 and raising the minimum income requirement for family visas in stages to £38,700. The changes are being introduced gradually from early 2024 and are not retrospective.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
MP welcomes measures to reduce immigration abuses but asks for a review of occupations critical for food security.
I welcome the measures taken to reduce abuses of the immigration system, but I also recognise the need to exempt critical occupations where we have a specific shortage from the new minimum salary. Given the vital and growing importance of food security across the country, will my hon. Friend commit to a review of those occupations which are none the less critical for our food sector and our rural and coastal communities?
There is no stronger advocate for the fishing industry in this House than my hon. Friend. He will appreciate that we have received that return from the MAC. We will look very carefully at its recommendations, but my hon. Friend knows that as a Government we have been consistently flexible in responding to the needs of the fishing sector. I would argue that there is more we can do to promote domestic employment, but let me take this matter away and consider his representations.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to review occupations critical for food security not explicitly stated
Will Look Carefully At Recommendations Take The Matter Away
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Context
MP raises constituents' concerns about legal migration reduction.
A key issue often raised by my constituents is the desire to see a dramatic reduction in legal migration. Bearing in mind that the Opposition appear to have no plan in that regard, can my hon. Friend reassure me that he will look at new ways to stop this migration, that he will make sure that everybody has the right to work in this country and that we will not decrease wages by bringing in cheap labour from abroad?
My hon. Friend is very supportive of the holistic approach that the Government are taking on this issue. The measures that we have announced and are taking forward will reduce the inflows by 300,000. It is important to consider this against the back to work plan that the Department for Work and Pensions is delivering to encourage more people to take on these roles domestically. She should be absolutely certain that we as a Government will deliver on these measures and will continue to keep them under review to see whether we can go further.
Assessment & feedback
Specifics of new ways to stop migration not provided, focus on domestic employment
Holistic Approach Keep Measures Under Review
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Zarah Sultana Your Party
Coventry South
Context
A constituent's skilled work visa was mistakenly withdrawn by the Home Office, leading to loss of right to work and financial hardship.
To cut a long story short, a constituent's skilled work visa application was mistakenly withdrawn by the Home Office. The error has resulted in him no longer having the right to work in the UK, forcing him and his wife to leave their jobs. His wife is five months pregnant and, although they pay their NHS surcharge, the Home Office error means that they are again getting healthcare bills. The situation is increasingly desperate, so I ask the Minister to meet me to look into this case and ensure that this Home Office error does not do any more harm than it already has for this young couple.
The hon. Lady will appreciate that I do not have the specifics of the case to hand, but if she kindly shares them with me, I will look into the case as a matter of urgency.
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to meet and discuss specific case lacking clarity
Do Not Have Specifics Look Into It
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Context
MP requests a meeting to discuss challenges faced by asylum seekers.
I hope the Minister will take this opportunity to recognise that the right to claim asylum is allowed under international law and that, therefore, there is no such thing as an illegal asylum seeker. On that basis, perhaps he can tell us whether he or any Minister has met people with lived experience of the system and whether he will meet the people at the Maryhill Integration Network in Glasgow North to discuss these issues.
The hon. Member will recognise that, in an answer to one of his hon. Friends, I said that I would be willing to meet him and his Glasgow colleagues to discuss some of the challenges. I have made an undertaking to him that that meeting will happen, and I will make sure that it happens at the earliest possible opportunity.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Stephen Kinnock Lab
Aberafan Maesteg
Context
MP lists Home Office failures and questions the reason for not meeting with the independent inspector of borders.
Since our last Home Office questions, the list of Government failures on immigration has continued to grow relentlessly: 30,000 asylum seekers stuck in limbo, unable to be processed due to the Prime Minister's legislative fiasco; 250 visas awarded to a care home that does not actually exist; net migration trebled; and criminals free to fly into our country undetected on private jets. Having just sacked the independent inspector of borders and immigration, is the Home Secretary sitting on 15 different reports by the inspector because he is checking for typos, or is it because he is utterly terrified of what those reports will tell us about this Government's shambolic and failing immigration system?
Let me answer that point very directly: having given proper consideration to those reports, we will be responding to them. As I said in the House last week, we will do so very soon. The shadow Minister mentioned the Government trying to dodge scrutiny. When it comes to the general aviation report, for example, it was our officials who asked the inspector to take it forward. Far from dodging scrutiny, we have invited it in that area.
Assessment & feedback
Direct response on reports lacking clarity, suggests inviting scrutiny but no concrete action mentioned
Proper Consideration Responding Soon Invited Scrutiny
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Context
Reunite Families UK highlighted the disproportionate impact of Tory changes to visa income thresholds, particularly affecting women.
People who come here to work, study and live make a significant impact on Scotland's economy and society. Reunite Families UK has highlighted the disproportionate impact that Tory changes to visa income thresholds will have on women. I have asked the Minister this before, and I have yet to have an answer: when will he publish the full equality impact assessment on this damaging policy?
We will publish the equality impact assessment associated with the policy in due course. The hon. Lady will appreciate that the Government's position is clear that the current levels of net migration are not sustainable.
Assessment & feedback
Publication date and specifics of the impact assessment
The Government'S Position Is Clear
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
Glasgow branch of the Association of Ukrainians in Great Britain held a demonstration and service to mark two years since the escalation of Russian aggression in Ukraine. The Government's recent changes to the Ukraine scheme caused uncertainty and distress.
I spent a lot of time this weekend with members of the Glasgow branch of the Association of Ukrainians in Great Britain, which put on a major demonstration and a service in Glasgow cathedral at the weekend to mark two years since the escalation of Russian aggression in Ukraine. The Government's changes to the Ukraine scheme came with very little notice and caused a great deal of uncertainty and distress in that community. Will the Minister tell me whether, for example, a wife whose husband has been injured fighting on the frontline against Putin's war machine will be able to sponsor her husband to come here under these restricted rules?
There will continue to be an out-of-country route through the Homes for Ukraine scheme to facilitate people being able to come here from Ukraine. Ukrainian nationals who would have qualified under the Ukraine family scheme will still be able to apply under Homes for Ukraine.
Assessment & feedback
Specific eligibility criteria and sponsorship rules
There Will Continue To Be An Out-Of-Country Route
Response accuracy