Topical Questions 2024-02-19
2024-02-19
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP notes that the Defence Secretary has engaged in multiple international meetings. He specifically references visits to the United States, Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Cyprus, and Brussels.
If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities. This year I visited the United States—the White House and Capitol Hill—to lobby on behalf of Ukraine; Saudi Arabia and Egypt, given the crisis in the middle east; HMS Diamond, to thank the ship's crew; and our sovereign base at Akrotiri, to thank the Typhoon pilots. Cyprus itself was also visited. Last week I was in Brussels for the NATO meeting and in Munich for the security conference.
Alongside the NATO meeting, there was the Ukraine defence contact group—a group of 52 countries, all of which support Ukraine. The big concern is ensuring that Ukraine has the things it needs now and planning to ensure it can sustain the fight and push back against the enemy in 2024. That is why I have announced £200 million for drones and a 15-nation coalition for MPI—the multinational procurement initiative. Australia was welcomed to the international fund for Ukraine with its commitment of 50 million Australian dollars, making the fund worth £900 million.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP follows up on the previous question regarding NATO meetings, focusing specifically on progress in supporting Ukraine.
Will my right hon. Friend update the House on progress made at the NATO Defence Ministers meeting, particularly with regard to support for Ukraine?
Alongside the NATO meeting, there was the Ukraine defence contact group—a group of 52 countries supporting Ukraine. The concern is ensuring that Ukraine has what it needs now and planning for sustaining the fight against the enemy in 2024. £200 million for drones has been announced, alongside a 15-nation coalition for MPI—the multinational procurement initiative. Australia was welcomed to the international fund for Ukraine with its commitment of 50 million Australian dollars, making the fund worth £900 million.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP discusses the dire situation for Palestinians, particularly regarding hostages in Gaza and the need for an immediate ceasefire.
The agonies of the Palestinian people are extreme. We all want the fighting to stop now, for hostages to be returned now, for aid to be ramped up now, and a ceasefire that lasts permanently. What is the Defence Secretary doing to help his Israeli counterpart accept that their threatened offensive against Rafah just cannot happen?
I agree about the seriousness of the situation. I visited Israel before the new year and had those conversations directly. We believe it is in Israel's interest, Gaza's interest, and the world's interest to see an immediate cessation followed by a permanent ceasefire. We are doing everything we can to persuade the Israelis of this necessity and putting pressure on Hamas. We are also helping by ensuring plans for what happens in the north of the country and southern Lebanon.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlights the number of veterans in his constituency and asks about steps being taken to provide better support.
Carshalton and Wallington is home to more than 1,700 veterans who have provided, and continue to provide, amazing service to our great nation. What steps are we taking as a Government to provide better support for veterans in our country?
Since 2011, the armed forces covenant and its consequentials have been the absolute lynchpin of public commitment to those who have served. The Ministry of Defence is responsible for several services for veterans. The Veterans Welfare Service supports around 50,000 veterans every year, and the Office for Veterans' Affairs co-ordinates across Government to advance support for veterans and their families.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP raises concerns about the rising number of veterans claiming welfare benefits, expressing doubt over whether this trend should be celebrated or seen as a problem.
The number of veterans claiming welfare benefits is rising steadily, and more than 52,000 are now in receipt of universal credit. Does the Minister find that a cause for celebration or concern?
I am a veteran, and I talk to veterans all the time. Since 2011, we have materially improved the lived experience of our veteran community and their families. We will continue to do so—of that, he can be absolutely sure.
▸
Assessment & feedback
specific concern over rising welfare benefits claims among veterans
We Are Committed To
Response accuracy
Q6
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP questions whether the community benefit criteria for UK defence contracts apply equally to overseas companies.
When defence contracts are awarded, a 10% to 20% weighting is given to social value, which is the benefit that the contract would have for the local and wider community. Does that community benefit apply entirely for the UK, or are overseas companies and their communities considered equally?
That is a very good question. The distinction is between the Cabinet Office social value rules, which are applied across Government and are irrespective, and the rules that the Ministry of Defence applies to our procurement. When the new medium helicopter comes out, we will be clear about incentivising a strong commitment to the UK industrial base.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP references the MOD's recent publication of findings from an inquiry into a fatal Scimitar vehicle accident on Salisbury Plain and asks whether a full formal government response is necessary.
The MOD recently published the findings of the inquiry into the fatal accident involving a Scimitar fighting vehicle on Salisbury plain, in which a young soldier tragically lost his life. One of my constituents was a witness to the accident, which has inevitably had a profound impact on him. The Government have said that they do not plan to make a formal response to the inquiry report, but they have accepted all 52 recommendations. Does the Minister not think that the report requires a full and formal response from the Government, with a detailed action plan for adopting the 52 recommendations?
Very simply, I read that report and accepted all its findings. We do not usually take it further, but I will certainly be happy to take a look at the case she has raised.
▸
Assessment & feedback
necessity of formal government response
We Are Committed
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlights remarks from the Chief of the General Staff about recruitment challenges and suggests that Capita's performance is poor.
On the subject of recruitment and retention, on 7 November the Chief of the General Staff, Patrick Sanders—arguably the best general of his generation—told the Defence Committee: “We are taking 400 soldiers out of the field army to put them alongside recruiters, because—guess what?—it takes a soldier to recruit a soldier.” Never was a truer word spoken. So when are we finally going to sack Capita?
I thank my right hon. Friend for his question—I knew he would get Capita in there somewhere. He is familiar with the Engage to Recruit programme, which is currently underway and having some success in getting soldiers to recruit soldiers. We are now seeing extremely promising recruiting figures, including in January—the best figures for six years.
▸
Assessment & feedback
termination of Capita contract
Working With Partners
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Israel has been criticized for ignoring international appeals regarding its military actions in Gaza and Rafah, raising concerns about the ethical implications of arms sales.
So far, Israel has ignored international appeals to not indiscriminately attack civilians and not take steps that are basically razing Gaza to the ground. It now looks as though it is going to ignore international opinion about entering Rafah, so has the time not now come for us to consider not selling to Israel arms that can be used in those totally unacceptable ways?
Arms deals and export licences are dealt with in the normal way, but not many arms sales take place to Israel. Last year, it was just £42 million for mostly protective equipment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The question about stopping arms sales due to unacceptable actions was not directly addressed.
Not Many Arms Sales Take Place
£42 Million Last Year
Response accuracy
Q10
Direct Answer
▸
Context
There was a diesel contamination incident in the water supply of the Trenchard Lines camp near Upavon. Families have been on temporary water supplies since.
Late last year, diesel got into the water supply at the Trenchard Lines camp near Upavon in my constituency. I commend the resilience of the families who live there, and also of the MOD, which acted very quickly to ensure that there was a temporary supply of water. Those families are still living on that temporary supply, so can the Minister assure me that attention is being given to sorting out this problem and ensuring a permanent supply of clean water?
I am very grateful to my hon. Friend for raising this matter—he is a champion of the defence community in his constituency, and I thank him for his early engagement on it. The local authority regulator has confirmed that the water quality at Trenchard Lines is acceptable, and it is now safe for personnel working and living there to use the mains supply.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There was a serious attack on a commercial vessel in the Gulf of Aden, raising concerns about ongoing threats to merchant shipping.
Today we have seen news of another serious attack by the Houthis on a commercial vessel in the gulf of Aden. Do Ministers think that more Royal Navy ships will need to be deployed to the region, given the ongoing threat to merchant shipping?
We will always look at what is happening in the Red sea based on the reality on the ground. There is now input from a conglomeration of EU countries joining Prosperity Guardian.
▸
Assessment & feedback
No direct confirmation or denial about additional ship deployment was provided.
Based On The Reality On The Ground
Response accuracy
Q12
Direct Answer
▸
Context
There was a previous statement that HMS Albion and HMS Bulwark would not be scrapped or mothballed, but recent information suggests this may have changed.
In the debate on the Red sea on 24 January, I asked for confirmation that HMS Albion and HMS Bulwark would not only not be scrapped, but would not be mothballed. However, a journalist was subsequently told by the Ministry of Defence that nothing had changed, so are those ships going to be mothballed or not?
My right hon. Friend can rest easy: I have been down to visit HMS Albion since those questions, and I can confirm that one of those ships will always be being made ready to sail.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Suicide rates among veterans under the age of 24 are significantly higher than in the civilian population, but these individuals are less likely to access mental health services.
Suicide rates among veterans under the age of 24 are two to four times higher than in the civilian population, but figures show that this group is less likely to be in touch with mental health services. How will the Minister ensure that young veterans can access the support they need?
I am grateful to the hon. Lady for her question—she has been consistent in her inquiry into this matter. She will be reassured to know that across the service community, the rate of suicide is lower than we would expect in the civilian population. There is a subset of young men within the serving population for whom there is an excess, and we are looking very closely at that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific measures to ensure access to mental health support were not detailed.
We Are Looking Very Closely At That
Response accuracy
Q14
Direct Answer
▸
Context
There was a reported pause in MOD capital spending, which raised concerns about its impact on the armed forces recruitment programme and Army centralised training scheme.
The whole House would like to see a larger Army, Navy and Air Force—there is unanimity on that point. Central to that must be not only the armed forces recruitment programme, but the Army centralised training scheme. Will my right hon. Friend confirm that the pause in capital spending by the MOD, which was announced last week in the press, will not affect those two schemes, and that they will continue in as full-blooded a way as they are at the moment?
My hon. Friend will be pleased to know that there is no pause. The approvals are flowing.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
HMS Queen Elizabeth and HMS Prince of Wales entered service significantly late with costs far exceeding initial estimates. There are concerns about their effectiveness.
The Royal Navy carriers HMS Queen Elizabeth and HMS Prince of Wales entered service six and seven years late respectively, with their cost rocketing to over £8,000 million—more than 20 times that of Scotland's ferries—while being plagued with problems and a lack of aircraft. What assurances can we have that these hugely expensive carriers will provide the defence capability for which they were designed?
The whole House recognises the irony of an SNP Member talking about ships being delivered late. The whole House will want to welcome the extraordinary work done by those on HMS Prince of Wales who got the ship ready to leave not at 30 days' readiness, which is what they were ranked for, but in eight days.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The question about effectiveness and capability was entirely sidestepped.
Irony Of An Snp Member
Extraordinary Work Done
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There is a historical context where the British Army was a significant trainer of young men and women in the country.
Does the Secretary of State remember that the British Army used to be the biggest trainer of young men and women in the country and that we produced so many skilled people? When can he take us back to those balmy days?
Since 2014, we have been training 60,000 Ukrainian troops, proving that we know how to get troops trained. We still train extraordinary numbers.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The question about the scale of youth training was not directly addressed; instead, a different training program was highlighted.
Training 60,000 Ukrainian Troops
Response accuracy