Topical Questions 2024-01-15
2024-01-15
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Home Secretary is being asked about his department's priorities.
If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities. This year, the Home Office has seen significant progress in various areas such as reducing small boat crossings and arresting people smugglers. The questioner seeks an update on these initiatives.
This year, the Home Office will continue to build on our progress on the public priorities: a 36% fall in small boat crossings last year, 86 arrests of small boat pilots, 246 arrests of people smugglers, the biggest-ever international operation resulting in 136 boat seizures and 45 outboard motors being seized, the illegal migration package announced, more than 2,000 county lines drugs lines smashed and the introduction of the Criminal Justice Bill to give police leaders more powers. We are relentlessly focused on delivering community safety on behalf of the British people.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Police are receiving more than 560 reports of spiking every month, with the Home Office previously stating that it is seen as funny and a joke.
Now that we have the Home Secretary here to answer for himself, can he tell us whether he is aware that the police are receiving more than 560 reports of spiking every month, and in December the Home Office said that the reason the crime is so prevalent is that it is seen as funny and a joke? How can we have any confidence in the Home Secretary to deliver action on spiking when he thinks it is a joke?
I am the Home Secretary who has actually introduced action on this. In my first week in the job, I visited Holborn police station to see the work of the Metropolitan police in tackling violence against women and girls. I made it clear to the Home Office that my priority was the protection of women and girls. I am taking action on this issue, and I am absolutely determined to continue doing so.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures or policies related to spiking incidents were not detailed.
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Home Secretary is questioned about the importance of anti-extremism training within government departments.
I am sure the Home Secretary would agree that anti-extremism training in Departments is extremely important. What more can the Government do to ensure that it is training to tackle extremism, rather than anti-Government and party bias training?
My hon. Friend will have seen recently a pretty extraordinary report on allegations about extremism and the failure to train properly, and what is going on in universities around the United Kingdom. In one recent problematic case, it was said that it is very hard to define what a terrorist is. We know what a terrorist is, the law knows what a terrorist is and this Government know what a terrorist is, and that is exactly why we have just proscribed Hizb ut-Tahrir.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures for ensuring proper anti-extremism training were not addressed.
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Five more lives were tragically lost in the channel this weekend. The Home Secretary is questioned about losing people from the Rwanda list and the asylum backlog.
We welcome the proscription of Hizb ut-Tahrir. Five more lives were tragically lost in the channel this weekend. As criminal gangs profit from those dangerous boat crossings, it shows how vital it is to stop them, but we need the Home Office to have a grip. The Home Secretary gave no answer earlier on the 4,000 people he has lost from the Rwanda list. Can he tell us if he has also lost the 35,000 people he has removed from the asylum backlog? How many of them are still in the country?
I join the right hon. Lady in expressing sadness and condolences for those who lost their lives in the channel. That reinforces the importance of breaking the people-smuggling gangs. The fact is that we are driving down the numbers of people in the backlog: we are processing applications more quickly and ensuring that decisions are made so that those who should not be in this country can be removed either to their own country or a safe third country. That is why the Rwanda Bill is so important, and why we will continue working on these issues.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Exact numbers of people lost from both lists were not provided.
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Returns have dropped 50% since the last Labour Government. The Home Secretary is questioned about his policy's effectiveness.
Returns have dropped 50% since the last Labour Government. The Home Secretary is still not telling us where those missing people are. He appears to have lost thousands of people who may have no right to be in the country, and lost any grip at all. In the ongoing Tory asylum chaos, we have Cabinet Ministers, countless ex-Ministers and the deputy Tory chair all saying that they will oppose the Home Secretary's policy this week—a policy that we know he and the Prime Minister do not even believe in. If the deputy Tory chair this week votes against the Home Secretary's policy, will he be sacked, or is the Prime Minister so weak that he has lost control of asylum, lost control of our borders, and lost control of his own party, too?
Conservative Members of Parliament are absolutely united in our desire to get a grip of this issue. I am not the person who has held up a sign saying, “Refugees welcome”; I am not the person whose colleagues oppose each and every rhetorical flourish. Until the Labour party comes up with a credible plan, I will not take its criticism any more seriously than it deserves.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The question about whether the Deputy Conservative Chair would be sacked was avoided.
Changing The Subject To Criticise Labour
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Foreign nationals committing violent offences and being sent to prison need to be deported at the end of their sentences.
The British people welcome people who come to this country to work and contribute to our economy. But those who abuse our hospitality, commit violent offences and are then sent to prison need to be deported at the end of their sentences. Will my right hon. and learned Friend update the House on how many were deported last year, and what action he will take to ensure that foreign nationals who are violent offenders are automatically deported when they leave prison?
We are clear that foreign criminals should be deported wherever possible, and we will continue to do so, in stark contrast to the calls to stop the deportation of foreign national criminals from the Leader of the Opposition and the Labour party. My hon. Friend will be pleased to know that foreign national offender returns have increased by 19% in the last 12 months.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures for automatic deportation were not detailed.
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Conservative Government is criticised for failing to manage the asylum system effectively, resulting in a backlog and excessive use of hotels.
My constituents often have to wait months to elicit a response for their asylum or Home Office queries. Given the Conservative Government's persistent failure to effectively manage the asylum system, resulting in a backlog of almost 100,000 cases and the excessive use of expensive hotels, does the Home Secretary not feel that now is the time to adopt Labour's comprehensive plan, which would end the use of expensive hotels within 12 months and significantly reduce the backlog?
I think the hon. Gentleman means Labour's non-existent plan. The fact is that last year, we made 112,000 initial decisions; if the hon. Gentleman has specific cases that he wishes to raise with me as the Minister, I am very happy to have a look at those, but the productivity improvements that we saw last year carry through a lot of learning as we now get on and deal with the backlog. A lot of positive work has gone on, and he should recognise that point.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Adoption of Labour's plan was not addressed.
Changing The Subject To Criticise Labour
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Humber-side police force has increased its officer numbers since 2010, with strong leadership from previous chief constable Lee Freeman and current commissioner Jonathan Evison.
Humber-side police now has over 800 more officers than in 2010. Does the Minister agree that top-class leadership is important for this progress? What is he doing to ensure improvements are made to the present leadership training scheme?
I join my hon. Friend in commending Humberside police force on the progress it has made under chief constable Lee Freeman, who is now one of His Majesty's inspectors and can apply what he learned to improve leadership across the country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Improvements to the present leadership training scheme were not addressed
Commending Progress Without Specifics
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government pledged to make changes to the Afghan citizens resettlement scheme pathways 1 and 3 on October 17th.
On October 17th, the Government pledged changes to the Afghan citizens resettlement scheme pathways 1 and 3. When can the House expect an update and a plan?
We are continuing to work collaboratively on the response to Afghanistan and will say more about our efforts as soon as we can.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific update timeline not provided
General Statement Without Specifics
Response accuracy
Q10
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Falmouth received £67,000 from the safer streets fund. The Offences against the Person Act was amended to specifically address spiking.
Falmouth received £67,000 from the safer streets fund. How will these positive changes improve conviction rates in Devon and Cornwall?
We have amended the Offences against the Person Act, and we are investing in rapid drink testing research to address the issue of time between offence and toxicology report.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
UKHospitality estimates that the revision to the salary level for skilled worker visas will result in a loss of most skilled workers.
95% of skilled worker visas gained last year would be lost under new regulations. When will the Government recognise this and adjust the salary level?
We disagree with the interpretation that the revision was insufficient and are focusing on domestic employment support through the back to work plan.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific salary level adjustment not addressed
Disagreement Without Addressing Salary Level Issue
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There is an ongoing conflict between Israel and Hamas.
What steps are being taken to provide advice to police forces regarding support for communities amid the conflict?
We have committed £18 million to the Community Security Trust and £7 million for academic security due to a rise in antisemitism.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Supporting communities during conflict not addressed
Shifts Focus To Antisemitism
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There are recurring weekly demonstrations.
How many times must a demonstration be repeated before organisers become liable for some policing costs?
We recognise the legitimacy of protests and their impact on communities. Repeating them does not strengthen arguments, but we see abuse by others.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Organisers' liability for policing costs not addressed
Discussion About Protesters Without Addressing Cost Issue
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Public Order Act 2023 was passed with an amendment ensuring safe access zones for women using abortion clinics, but a consultation may weaken this.
Will the Home Secretary meet to discuss why the Public Order Act is now under review, and can he meet urgently before the January 22nd deadline?
If the hon. Lady writes on this issue, I will endeavour to find out details of her point.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Urgent meeting and alignment with original House vote not addressed
Request For Written Communication
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Home Secretary recently produced a report on safe and legal routes to comply with section 61 of the Illegal Migration Act 2023. The questioner is concerned about how a specific 16-year-old orphan from an east African country, linked to the UK and seeking asylum, can be helped through these routes.
Last week, the Home Secretary produced a report on safe and legal routes to comply with section 61 of the Illegal Migration Act 2023. It is very long and generous on the existing legal routes, but can he tell me how my 16-year-old orphan from an east African country with links to the UK, who is a genuine asylum seeker, will be helped to come legally and safely to the UK by what the Government have published so far?
My hon. Friend is a very passionate advocate on this issue, and we had a conversation last week about this very point. The fact is that, since 2015, we have welcomed over half a million people through our safe and legal routes. We are introducing the cap precisely because we want to see that generosity extended in the years ahead, but the pressures of illegal migration in particular make that very challenging and difficult.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific details on how a 16-year-old orphan from an east African country can be helped through legal routes were not addressed.
Response accuracy