PMQs 2024-05-15

2024-05-15

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
Residents of Woking's eastern villages are concerned about proposed developments and lack of infrastructure provision. More than 1,000 constituents have expressed worry over the impact on local environment.
Residents across the eastern villages of Woking, in Byfleet, West Byfleet and Pyrford, have seen a large number of proposed developments in recent years. Of particular concern is an area of beautiful fields near West Hall, where more than 1,000 constituents have written back to me in recent weeks, expressing their deep concerns about the lack of provision of local infrastructure and the potential effects on the local environment.
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. Unlike both the Liberal Democrats and Labour, who believe in top-down targets that would decimate the green belt, we believe in local people having a say over their local communities. That is why we are ensuring that we make best use of brownfield land and that we conserve and enhance our precious countryside for generations to come.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify whether the government agrees Labour's proposals would be calamitous but defended their stance on greenbelt development
Changed Subject Entirely Used Hedging Language
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister announced a prisoner release scheme which led to the release of prisoners early, raising concerns about public safety.
Does the Prime Minister think that his decision to let prisoners out 70 days early makes our country more secure?
There are strict eligibility criteria in place, with exclusions based on public safety. No one would be put on the scheme if they were deemed a threat to public safety.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific details about early release such as number of prisoners or crimes committed
Changed Subject Entirely
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
A prison inspection report found that high-risk prisoners were released at short notice without sufficient planning, raising concerns about public safety.
Does the early release of stalkers, domestic abusers and those considered a risk to children sound like the work of someone who is making the country more secure?
As I said, no one should be put on the scheme if they are a threat to the public. Let me be crystal clear: it does not apply to anyone serving a life sentence, anyone convicted of a serious violent offence, anyone convicted of terrorism, or anyone convicted of a sex offence.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific details about high-risk prisoners released early
Changed Subject Entirely
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
The Prime Minister announced a prisoner release scheme, raising concerns about public safety.
Are any of the prisoners he is currently letting out early considered to be high-risk?
The right hon. and learned Gentleman just showed spectacularly why he is just not fit to lead this country into the future.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific details about high-risk prisoners released early, instead attacked Keir Starmer
Changed Subject Entirely Attacked Questioner
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
A prison inspection report found that high-risk prisoners were released at short notice without sufficient planning, raising concerns about public safety.
Does the early release of stalkers, domestic abusers and those considered a risk to children sound like the work of someone who is making the country more secure?
As I said, no one should be put on the scheme if they are a threat to the public. Let me be crystal clear: it does not apply to anyone serving a life sentence, anyone convicted of a serious violent offence, anyone convicted of terrorism, or anyone convicted of a sex offence.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific details about high-risk prisoners released early
Changed Subject Entirely
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Keir Starmer questions the government's early release scheme, citing the Lewes report which shows domestic abusers are being released early.
The Prime Minister is literally letting criminals out early. The only answer to the question that I have asked—whether domestic abusers should be exempt from his early release scheme—from anyone who is serious about security is yes. Does he not think that, rather than confiscating lanyards like some jumped-up milk monitor, he should stop issuing “Get out of jail free” cards to prisoners who are considered to be a risk to children?
Another week with no ideas and absolutely no plans for the country! The Opposition have had 14 years to think about nothing but the future, but all they can do is talk about the past. Statistics have confirmed that we have had the joint fastest growth rate in the G7 this year.
Assessment & feedback
Domestic abusers and early release scheme exemptions
Changed Subject To Economic Growth
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Keir Starmer Lab
Holborn and St Pancras
Context
Residents of Hayley Green's Squirrels estate oppose BRSK's proposal to erect telegraph poles, claiming it violates guidance. James Morris seeks a review of permitted development rights and more power for Ofcom.
While I understand the need to upgrade our broadband infrastructure, it cannot be right that a company called BRSK is proposing to erect telegraph poles at the Squirrels estate in Hayley Green, in my constituency. The residents are 100% opposed to these proposals, which go against the guidance. Does the Prime Minister agree that BRSK should abandon its proposals, that there should be a review of permitted development rights in relation to this type of infrastructure, and that he should give Ofcom more power to investigate breaches?
I thank my hon. Friend for rightly championing the views of his constituents on this important topic. Network operators must follow legal obligations when deploying their networks and Ofcom can, in fact, investigate reports of failure to follow those obligations.
Assessment & feedback
Review of permitted development rights and additional power for Ofcom
Acknowledged Network Operator Obligations But Did Not Commit To Specific Actions
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Context
Prime Minister compared the Scottish independence movement with North Korea, Iran and Russia, which Flynn finds inappropriate.
On Monday, the Prime Minister outlined what he considers to be extremist threats to our society, and in doing so he actively compared North Korea, Iran and Russia with those people in Scotland who believe in independence, so can I ask him to rise, once, to the standards befitting his office, and apologise for those puerile and pathetic remarks?
That is not what I said, but I will say to the hon. Gentleman that his party is indeed a threat to the integrity of the United Kingdom. When the people of Scotland accepted the referendum result in 2014, it was the SNP that didn't.
Assessment & feedback
Apology for comparing Scottish independence supporters with extremist regimes
Criticized The Snp
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Stephen Flynn SNP
Aberdeen South
Context
Flynn questions the Prime Minister's legacy and his handling of Scottish independence.
Let us be clear. What the Prime Minister did was not just equate my colleagues and I to dangerous despots across the world; he proactively compared almost half the Scottish population to a war criminal like Vladimir Putin, and he did so as their Prime Minister, as the man who represents them on the world stage and as the man who on these isles is tasked with defending their liberties and their democracy. We know that his sorry time in office is rapidly coming to a conclusion, but is this really how he wants to be remembered?
As ever, the right hon. Gentleman is distracting from the actual record of what the SNP is doing in Scotland. This obsession with independence means that Scottish schoolchildren are being let down, plummeting down international league tables; the Scottish NHS is the only place in the United Kingdom where funding is actually falling in real terms;
Assessment & feedback
Handling of Scottish independence and how he wants to be remembered
Criticized Snp'S Policies
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Stephen Flynn SNP
Aberdeen South
Context
Starmer questions the government's early release scheme, citing reports that domestic abusers are being released.
Well, I am glad to hear that those on life sentences are not being released early. The Prime Minister may not think that releasing domestic abusers is a problem, but Labour has repeatedly called for domestic abusers to be exempt from the scheme to release prisoners early. His Government have shamefully ignored those calls. Now that we have the evidence that domestic abusers are being released early—the Lewes report—will he finally change course and back Labour's calls?
Another week with no ideas and absolutely no plans for the country! The Opposition have had 14 years to think about nothing but the future, but all they can do is talk about the past.
Assessment & feedback
Exempting domestic abusers from early release scheme
Changed Subject To Economic Performance
Response accuracy
Q11 Direct Answer
Context
Uxbridge College has partnered with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, a significant achievement for further education in Uxbridge.
Will the Prime Minister join me in congratulating Uxbridge College on its pioneering partnership with MIT? This is groundbreaking work that benefits local businesses and students, as well as the wider education sector.
I join my hon. Friend in congratulating Uxbridge College on its collaboration with MIT, which is equipping students with future skills that local businesses need.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Liz Saville-Roberts PC
Dwyfor Meirionnydd
Context
The Welsh Labour Government is pausing the sustainable farming scheme, which affects farmers in Wales negatively.
My party has secured a win for Welsh farmers as Labour halted the sustainable farming scheme. Will the Prime Minister guarantee he will never sign a deal that threatens farmers' interests?
Welsh Conservatives exposed flaws in Labour's proposals, which would have led to job losses and less food security. The Prime Minister criticises Plaid Cymru's support for the Welsh Labour Government.
Assessment & feedback
Guaranteeing protection against harmful deals
Changing Subject Criticising Opposition
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Context
Local NHS services are improving, but some constituents still face long waiting times.
Despite local improvements in the NHS, I have constituents who wait too long for care. Can I urge the Prime Minister to redouble efforts to grow the NHS workforce and reduce waiting times?
We are reducing the overall NHS waiting list by around 200,000 since September last year despite industrial action. Our productivity plan will free up clinicians' time with patients, and we aim to train more doctors and nurses for future requirements.
Assessment & feedback
Specific commitments on workforce growth
Vague Promises
Response accuracy
Q14 Direct Answer
Richard Burgon Lab
Leeds East
Context
Palestinian deaths and British aid worker killings have not influenced the Prime Minister's stance on arms exports to Israel.
After 30,000 Palestinian deaths, the killing of British aid workers, and a possible attack on Rafah, what will finally convince this Prime Minister to end arms sales to Israel?
Unlike the US, we do not directly sell arms to Israel and our position on export licences remains unchanged. Our regime regularly reviews compliance with international law.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Context
The Prime Minister lit the light of liberation at the start of its journey to Normandy for War Graves Week, commemorating sacrifices made during WWII.
Will my right hon. Friend join me in confirming that standing up against tyrants who cause war in Europe is as important today as it was 80 years ago?
The Prime Minister agrees with my right hon. Friend about standing up against authoritarian states. Building our defence in uncertain times is crucial, which is why we increased defence spending.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Wendy Chamberlain Lib Dem
North East Fife
Context
The reopening of the Levenmouth railway contrasts with TSB's decision to close its local bank branch, potentially leading to banking deserts.
TSB is closing a bank branch in Leven, which hinders small businesses and communities. Does the Prime Minister accept that the Government have been too slow on this issue? What else will he do?
We legislate to protect cash access through various channels. Customers can use post offices, ATMs and community initiatives like banking hubs.
Assessment & feedback
Admission of being too slow on the issue
Vague Promises
Response accuracy
Q17 Direct Answer
Alberto Costa Con
South Leicestershire
Context
Colin Pitchfork, a double child rapist and murderer, is having another parole hearing. He exposed himself to over 1000 women and girls.
As the MP for South Leicestershire, I distributed a constituency-wide survey asking my constituents about Parole Board reform. The problem is that the reconsideration mechanism rules allow Mr Pitchfork to ask for a reconsideration of a reconsidered decision limitless times, and it is cost-free to him. Will the Prime Minister arrange a meeting between me and the Justice Secretary to discuss necessary changes to the reconsideration mechanism rules? Will he arrange for me to deliver the findings of the survey to his No. 10 policy team?
I commend my hon. Friend for his tireless campaigning on this case. We are reforming the parole system to add a ministerial check on the release of the most dangerous criminals, and we are changing the law so that life means life. I will arrange for the findings of my hon. Friend's survey to be properly considered, and ensure he meets the Justice Secretary to discuss his proposals further.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Context
Israel's actions in Gaza have resulted in the deaths of thousands of innocent civilians, blocking aid and water supplies.
In Gaza, Israel has attacked hospitals, refugee camps, and killed aid workers. Why does the Prime Minister allow Israel to get away with it unchallenged? And why does he continue to act as a bystander?
We support Israel's right to defend itself against Hamas, but I am deeply concerned about the humanitarian crisis. We are trebling investment and trying to get more aid into Gaza through various means. The hon. Lady can rest assured that we will continue doing everything possible to provide support.
Assessment & feedback
PM did not address why Israel is allowed to act with impunity
We Are Doing Everything We Can
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Context
Students at Coleg Menai need certainty about the future of Wylfa before committing to a career in nuclear.
Last week, I visited Coleg Menai where apprentices from Urenco were present. The students are excited but need certainty about Wylfa's future. Will the PM confirm when Great British Nuclear will decide on whether it will be a gigawatt or small modular reactor site? When can they expect spades in the ground?
Great British Nuclear has reached an agreement to purchase the Wylfa site, but decisions have not yet been made on the final sites. The Energy Secretary is keen to update my hon. Friend as soon as a decision is made.
Assessment & feedback
No specific timelines or mechanisms were given for decision-making or construction start
Decisions Have Not Yet Been Made Keen To Update Her At The Earliest Opportunity
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Context
The Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman's report stated that the Department for Work and Pensions was guilty of maladministration towards women's state pensions in the 1950s.
In March, the Ombudsman's report made it clear that these women suffered significant injustice and are owed compensation. Nearly 279,000 women have died waiting for justice. When will the PM place before this House a mechanism for appropriate redress?
Following the ombudsman's report, we are reviewing findings thoroughly. We are committed to ensuring pensioners have dignity and security through measures like the triple lock.
Assessment & feedback
No timeline or mechanism for addressing injustices was provided
Reviewing Findings Thoroughly Broadly, We Are Committed
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Context
Community pharmacies face financial pressure leading to closures, with 177 pharmacies closing this year.
Community pharmacists play an essential role in reducing urgent care service pressures. Pharmacy First is a good example of Government commitment. However, community pharmacies are under extreme financial pressure and some have closed, including in St Ives. Will the PM do everything to ensure funds directed toward supporting community pharmacies?
About 80% of people live within a 20-minute walk of a pharmacy. We are backing them with Pharmacy First, providing £645 million in extra funding to help deliver NHS services closer to home and reduce waiting lists.
Assessment & feedback
No additional funds specifically for financial pressures were mentioned
We Are Backing Them With Pharmacy First £645M Extra Funding
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Mary Glindon Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne East and Wallsend
Context
Three North Tyneside schools are facing structural issues with RAAC and hundreds of pupils have been relocated due to safety concerns. The cost to fix these issues significantly exceeds the £3.5 million allocated.
Three North Tyneside schools have been identified as having a structural problem—not reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete—and hundreds of pupils are now being taught off site. The costs of putting those schools right significantly outweigh the £3.5 million school condition allocation funding for all of North Tyneside. Will the Prime Minister ensure that the Department for Education applies this policy: if it is alerted to significant issues with a building that cannot be managed with local resources, it will provide additional support on a case-by-case basis?
I thank the hon. Lady for raising the case. As she knows, the Department for Education has provided extensive support and funding to all those schools that have RAAC, which in the end was less than 1% of all schools that could have been affected. More generally, there is the very significant amount we are investing in school rebuilding and maintenance.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to providing additional support on a case-by-case basis when alerted to structural issues.
Provided Extensive Support And Funding Significant Amount We Are Investing
Response accuracy
Q23 Direct Answer
Greg Smith Con
Mid Buckinghamshire
Context
Proposed solar installations in Mid Buckinghamshire would cover thousands of acres of agricultural land, from a 2,100 acre installation called Rosefield to smaller but equally destructive ones near Kimblewick.
The clear message from yesterday's Farm to Fork summit is that food security matters. As we await today's written statement on ground-mounted solar, can my right hon. Friend assure me that proposed solar installations in my constituency, which would cover thousands of acres of agricultural land—from a 2,100 acre installation in the Claydons, called Rosefield, to smaller but equally destructive ones, such as the one proposed for an area near the village of Kimblewick—now have less chance of getting approved?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to raise this. Particularly at a time of increasing geopolitical risk, we must protect this nation's food security and our most valuable agricultural land. We can achieve our solar deployment targets by using brownfield sites and rooftops away from our best farmland.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q24 Partial Answer
Helen Morgan Lib Dem
North Shropshire
Context
The officer in charge of accommodation wrote to families this month stating that requests for non-urgent repairs are not currently affordable, despite the Prime Minister claiming defence is a priority.
I have seen for myself the mouldy and damp accommodation that our military families are sometimes forced to live in, so I was disappointed this week to find out that the officer in charge of accommodation wrote to families this month to say that requests for non-urgent repairs are not currently affordable. The Prime Minister has spent this week claiming that defence is a priority, so when will he prioritise a safe, warm and decent home for the servicemen and women who put their life on the line for us?
We are committed to ensuring that our armed forces personnel and their families have safe and well maintained accommodation. At this point, 96% of service family accommodation meets or exceeds the Government's decent homes standard.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a specific timeline for prioritizing housing improvements.
Committed To Ensuring Safe And Well Maintained Accommodation
Response accuracy
Q25 Partial Answer
Context
The all-party parliamentary group on birth trauma published their first report, called “Listen to Mums: Ending the Postcode Lottery on Perinatal Care,” with over 1,300 testimonials received.
This week, the all-party parliamentary group on birth trauma published our first report, called “Listen to Mums: Ending the Postcode Lottery on Perinatal Care”. This was the first national inquiry by cross-party politicians on the issue. We received more than 1,300 testimonials from the public. I thank the Health Secretary for attending our report launch on Monday. I am delighted that she has agreed to our headline recommendation for a national comprehensive maternity strategy, to be published by NHS England. Will the Prime Minister fully back our report and implement all our recommendations, to ensure that all mothers in this country get the aftercare that they deserve?
I thank my hon. Friend for her incredible campaigning on this issue. When we met and discussed the issue, she presented me personally with a copy of this important report.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to fully backing or implementing all recommendations.
Incredible Campaigning Presented Me Personally With
Response accuracy
Q26 Partial Answer
Nadia Whittome Lab
Nottingham East
Context
Adult rape cases take an average of two years to complete, leading to a high drop-out rate among survivors. Just 2.5% of recorded rapes resulted in charges last year.
When adult rape cases take two years, on average, to complete, it is no wonder that 62% of all rape survivors drop out of the process. Given that just 2.5% of rapes recorded last year resulted in a charge and fewer still will end in conviction, it is no wonder that the Victims' Commissioner, Rape Crisis and others have argued that rape has been effectively decriminalised in this country. Is the Prime Minister not ashamed that, because of his Government's failings, victims and survivors are being put through a living hell in our criminal justice system?
While it is right that the hon. Lady raises this incredibly important topic, I completely disagree with her characterisation of how this Government have treated it.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the question about handling of rape cases or shame over failures.
Disagree With Her Characterisation Right That She Raises
Response accuracy