Topical Questions 2024-10-29

2024-10-29

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Context
The Chancellor is set to present her first Budget.
If she will make a statement on her departmental responsibilities. Tomorrow I will present my first Budget. It will be a Budget that fixes the foundations of our economy and delivers on the promise of change.
Tomorrow I will present my first Budget. It will be a Budget that fixes the foundations of our economy and delivers on the promise of change. It will turn the page on low growth and will be the start of a new chapter towards making Britain better off. It will mean more pounds in people's pockets, an NHS that is there when they need it, and businesses creating wealth and opportunity for all.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Context
The Joseph Rowntree Foundation has stated that the previous Government's decision to freeze local housing allowance rates will push 80,000 private renters on housing benefit into deep poverty during this Parliament.
I commend the Chancellor for recently outlining investment in social housing, but in the interim the Joseph Rowntree Foundation has stated that the previous Government's decision to freeze local housing allowance rates will push 80,000 private renters on housing benefit, including 30,000 children, into deep poverty during this Parliament. Will the Chancellor now consider unfreezing the allowance and relinking it to the actual cost of local rents, so that those families can keep their heads above water?
My hon. Friend makes a really important point, which I think is familiar to all of us in our communities, about the cost of housing outstretching people's incomes. In our manifesto we committed to building 1.5 million new homes, including social housing, which is so important and can give security to people who would otherwise be left in insecure housing in the private rented sector.
Assessment & feedback
Unfreezing local housing allowance rates
Manifesto Commitment
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Jeremy Hunt Con
Godalming and Ash
Context
The Chancellor previously stated that raising employers' national insurance was a jobs tax.
This are indeed our final exchanges in the House, so before tomorrow's fireworks I wish the Chancellor well for the future in her role. There has been a lot of common ground between us. For example, before the election she said that raising employers' national insurance was a jobs tax that would take money out of people's pockets. I very much agree with her on that; does she agree with herself?
The right hon. Gentleman knows better than almost anyone else that there a was £22 billion black hole in the public finances. That will require difficult decisions, but even in those circumstances we will do everything in our power to protect the incomes of ordinary working people, so we are committed to ensuring that no working people will see higher taxes in their payslips after the Budget.
Assessment & feedback
Employers' national insurance tax
Black Hole In Public Finances
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Jeremy Hunt Con
Godalming and Ash
Context
The Chancellor is planning the biggest tax-raising Budget in history. The UK has spent £2.3 billion on loan for Ukraine.
We all know why the Chancellor is inventing this fictitious black hole. Thirty times this year, before the election, she promised not to raise tax, and now she is planning to present the biggest tax-raising Budget in history. More consensually, however, as this is our final exchange, I welcome her announcement last week of a £2.3 billion loan for Ukraine. Does she agree that the strongest signal of resolve that we can send to Putin is a commitment to spending 2.5% of GDP on defence, and does she understand why so many people are worried by the fact that she has yet to do so?
I have always respected the right hon. Gentleman, but I think it is important for us not to deny the seriousness of the situation that we face with the black hole in the public finances. Combined with the lashing out at independent economic institutions, it suggests that he has more in common with Liz Truss and Kwasi Kwarteng than perhaps we thought. I watched my party lurch towards an ideological extreme and deny reality, and we spent years in opposition as a result. The shadow Chancellor risks taking his party down the same path.
Assessment & feedback
Defence spending commitments
Black Hole In Public Finances Lurching Towards Ideological Extreme
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Adam Jogee Lab
Newcastle-under-Lyme
Context
The constituency's beer and pub sector generates £23 million in tax receipts each year.
My constituency's beer and pub sector makes a significant contribution to the economy, both locally and nationally. Our 76 pubs and two breweries generate £23 million in tax receipts each year. Will the Chancellor work with the sector to unlock its growth potential, in Newcastle-under-Lyme and across our country?
I know that Newcastle-under-Lyme and, indeed, the whole county of Staffordshire have a proud brewing tradition, and my hon. Friend will be an excellent champion of breweries in his constituency. Supporting pubs and breweries is very important for me as a Minister. Indeed, on my first day in the Treasury's Darlington economic campus, I visited Durham brewery—it was a work visit—where I heard from the Society of Independent Brewers and associates about the huge contribution that breweries make to British society. Further details will be set out by the Chancellor tomorrow.
Assessment & feedback
Unlocking growth potential for beer and pub sector
Future Budget Announcement
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Tom Morrison Lib Dem
Cheadle
Context
The Chancellor recently announced an extra £550 million for the school rebuilding programme.
The Chancellor recently announced an extra £550 million for the school rebuilding programme. Can she now confirm that all the schools on that programme, including Bramhall high school, are fully funded and will get their repairs soon?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his question. I went to school in the '80s and '90s, and I was taught in portacabins because there was not enough room in my school. I know how important it is that children are taught in proper facilities. We will set out more details of our capital investments at the Budget tomorrow.
Assessment & feedback
Funding for schools in programme
Future Budget Announcement
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Damien Egan Lab
Bristol North East
Context
Local government faces short-term cuts that can often end up costing more in the long run.
I would like to ask a question that comes out of local government. One of the frustrations that I found after 14 years in local government was that short-term cuts can often end up costing more in the long run—an example that always comes to mind is youth services. What does the Chancellor make of the Local Government Association's call for spending on prevention to be routinely considered in both Treasury and departmental spending decisions, and for better tracking of long-term outcomes?
My hon. Friend is right to point out the opportunities for improvement. As the Chancellor set out in her July statement, prevention will be at the heart of this Government's new approach to public service reform. That will be set out in the spending review in the coming months.
Assessment & feedback
Local Government Association's call for prevention spending
Future Spending Review
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Helen Maguire Lib Dem
Epsom and Ewell
Context
Many households are facing homelessness due to rising living expenses.
Many households are facing homelessness due to increasing household costs. What support can the Chancellor provide to them?
Building the homes that our country needs is a top priority for this Government. In our manifesto, we committed to build 1.5 million homes in this Parliament, including social housing, so that people have access to secure and affordable accommodation and that every family have a roof over their heads. We will set out more details on all of this in the Budget tomorrow.
Assessment & feedback
Support for households facing homelessness
Future Budget Announcement
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Paul Foster Lab
South Ribble
Context
Councils face significant pressures due to fragmented, short-term policies of the previous Tory Government.
I was the leader of South Ribble borough council in Lancashire, where we continually struggled to set meaningful budgets. Will Ministers please assure me that the proposals being considered in tomorrow's Budget will see an end to the fragmented annual public sector funding allocations and a reintroduction of meaningful, forward-thinking, multi-year settlements?
The Government recognise significant pressures that all councils are facing. We are looking at consolidating funding streams for local authorities into the local government finance settlement, and we will work towards implementing our commitment to a multi-year financial settlement.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify timeline or concrete details of implementation
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Ben Maguire Lib Dem
North Cornwall
Context
Teachers and parents in North Cornwall revealed the extent of the broken special educational needs system during a SEND summit.
During my SEND summit in Bodmin on Saturday, teachers and parents revealed the shocking extent of our broken special educational needs system. Thousands are struggling to get the support they need. What are Treasury Ministers doing to ensure that local councils and schools are properly resourced to deliver an effective SEND system?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his question. This is an issue that resonates right across the House, with so many of us hearing terrible stories at our surgeries about the lack of support for some of the most vulnerable children in society. We will set out more detail on departmental settlements in the Budget tomorrow.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific measures or funding details
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Sam Carling Lab
North West Cambridgeshire
Context
There are over 50 pubs and breweries in Sam Carling's constituency, supporting more than 1,500 jobs and contributing millions of pounds to the local economy.
Residents in my constituency are still feeling the pinch from Liz Truss's mini-Budget. It is vital that this Government fix the foundations of our economy to deliver proper public services. Can the Chancellor tell me how she will deliver this for the north-east and for people across the country?
I thank my hon. Friend for his question. He is absolutely right to say that pubs make an enormous contribution to our society and economy. The current alcohol duty system supports pubs through draught relief, which ensures eligible products served on draught are charged less duty. The Government are committed to delivering a fairer business rates system for high streets, including hospitality.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to specific actions or funding for the hospitality sector
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Richard Holden Con
Basildon and Billericay
Context
Eighty-two per cent of those who lost their winter fuel payments are below the poverty line or within £55 a week of it.
Eighty-two per cent of those who have seen Labour take away their winter fuel payment are either below the poverty line or within £55 a week of it. How can the Government justify this, when they are not even allowing a freedom of information request from the Financial Times to be responded to?
We are not hiding the figures. If I had had the chance, I would have said that 455,000 pensioners are paying the higher rate of tax and that 39,300 are paying the additional rate.
Assessment & feedback
Did not justify removal or address FOI request issue
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Emma Foody Lab Co-op
Cramlington and Killingworth
Context
Residents are still feeling the impact of Liz Truss's mini-Budget, which had disastrous impacts.
Residents in my constituency are still feeling the pinch from Liz Truss's mini-Budget. It is vital that this Government fix the foundations of our economy to deliver proper public services and a rise in living standards. Can the Chancellor tell me how she will deliver this for the north-east?
My hon. Friend is right to draw attention to the disastrous impacts of the Conservative mini-Budget just over two years ago, which is still having an impact on people's lives as they pay higher mortgage bills. This Government have committed to return sustainability to the economy and to working with business to reform our planning system, our pensions system and our skills system.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify how economic foundations will be fixed
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Saqib Bhatti Con
Meriden and Solihull East
Context
Small business owners are working people, struggling with fuel prices.
Small business owners are some of the hardest-working people that I know. The Labour party struggled to define them over the weekend. Does the Chancellor agree that any rise in fuel duty would be a tax on those hard-working people?
The previous Government factored into their forecasts an increase in fuel duty this year.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address if it is a tax on hard-working people
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Matt Rodda Lab
Reading Central
Context
Pensioners need better returns, while pension savings can help generate economic growth.
Can the Minister update the House on how the Government will help to secure better returns for pensioners while also unlocking opportunities for pension savings to help generate growth?
The Chancellor launched the landmark pensions review in July, which I am leading. It is looking at measures to drive more UK pension investment into the UK economy, boosting growth but also improving pension savers' outcomes.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify measures or timeline for improvements
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Greg Smith Con
Mid Buckinghamshire
Context
Countryside Alliance research shows rural households spend up to £800 a year more on fuel than urban households.
Countryside Alliance research shows that rural households spend up to £800 a year more on fuel than urban households. Will the Chancellor protect rural communities in the Budget tomorrow?
The hon. Gentleman is urging me to comment on the Budget, but he will have to wait until tomorrow.
Assessment & feedback
Changed subject by deferring to budget announcement without specifics
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Context
The UK is now the most unequal country in the G7 bar America, with unfair tax loopholes benefiting wealthy individuals.
This Government have inherited a Britain that is now the most unequal country in the G7 bar America. The UK's 50 richest families own 50% of the country's wealth. What steps will be taken to address this inequality?
My hon. Friend will have to wait for the Budget tomorrow, but he will know that we have committed to closing some loopholes, including VAT on private schools, the non-dom loophole and cracking down on tax avoidance.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify how wealth inequality is being addressed
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Caroline Voaden Lib Dem
South Devon
Context
In South Devon, the average house price is now 14 times the average salary at £425,000. Rural and coastal areas like the South Hams face significant digital and transport connectivity issues.
The hon. Member noted that in South Devon, the average house price is now 14 times the average salary at £425,000. She asked what measures the Chancellor is taking to ensure that rural and coastal areas such as the South Hams will be included in economic growth initiatives.
Our commitment is to build 1.5 million homes, including social housing in rural areas, and to improve digital connectivity with more details on infrastructure investment to be announced in the Budget tomorrow.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify measures for South Devon or mention concrete steps addressing affordability and connectivity issues specifically.
Response accuracy
Q19 Direct Answer
Katrina Murray Lab
Cumbernauld and Kirkintilloch
Context
Young people on zero-hours contracts are particularly vulnerable to problematic debt from 'buy now, pay later' services.
'Buy now, pay later' is attractive to young people who rely on irregular income. The hon. Member asked for assurances that the Chancellor's regulations will protect this group from problematic debt.
Proposed regulations aim to drive high standards of conduct among firms offering 'buy now, pay later' services, ensuring affordability checks and strong consumer protections are in place.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q20 Partial Answer
Ashley Fox Con
Bridgwater
Context
During the last election, Labour promised to cut energy bills by £300. However, there is no clear timeline for this promise.
The hon. Member inquired about the Chancellor's plan to fulfill Labour's previous pledge of cutting energy bills by £300 and requested a specific timescale for implementation.
We are committed to reducing people's energy bills by investing in home-grown energy and better insulating homes, but no specific timescale was provided beyond stating that more detail would come in the Budget.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a clear timeline for cutting energy bills as requested.
Response accuracy
Q21 Partial Answer
Danny Beales Lab
Uxbridge and South Ruislip
Context
A hundred councils in England have requested changes to unlock investment in new council homes, including addressing housing revenue account debt.
The hon. Member questioned if the Chancellor would look specifically at debt allocations and HRA accounting to unlock much-needed investment in new council homes as requested by a hundred councils.
This Government's commitment is to deliver 1.5 million new homes, but no specific mention was made about examining HRA debt allocations as requested.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the request for examination of HRA debt allocations specifically.
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Gregory Campbell DUP
East Londonderry
Context
There is a debate about whether people on low incomes should be exempt from paying income tax.
The hon. Member asked if the Chancellor would consider exempting individuals earning up to £300 per week from paying income tax, particularly those on low incomes or part-time employees.
Details of our tax policy will be set out in the Budget tomorrow; however, we have committed to not increasing taxes for working people on their income or national insurance contributions.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address the request for exemption from income tax for low-income earners.
Response accuracy