Topical Questions 2025-05-01

2025-05-01

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Harriet Cross Con
Gordon and Buchan
Context
Since the Government announced the family farm tax in the Budget, CBI Economics has surveyed over 4,000 businesses and farms across the country. The survey found that 49% have cancelled or deferred investment, and 34% have reduced or paused it.
Many rural businesses rely on farms for their trade. Since the Government announced the family farm tax in the Budget, CBI Economics has spoken to over 4,000 businesses and farms across the country—49% said that they have either cancelled or deferred investment, and 34% said that they have reduced or paused it altogether. How can the Government say that they are supporting local businesses, and what will the Department do to support farms and rural businesses that are suffering because of the Government’s policies?
I feel that is a question for either the Treasury or the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, but the hon. Lady made it well. Agriculture features prominently in trade and business, and I will ensure that she gets the right opportunity to put questions about taxation to the Chancellor.
Assessment & feedback
The answer avoids addressing the specific request for action from the Department of Business and Trade to support affected businesses.
Redirects Question To Other Departments
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Ben Obese-Jecty Con
Huntingdon
Context
The hon. Member's constituency has experienced severe postal service delays, particularly affecting rural areas and businesses.
Across my constituency in recent weeks we have experienced severe delays to post in those areas served by the Huntingdon delivery office. That follows a recent restructuring of the workforce and changes to delivery routes. Rural communities and businesses, in particular, have been impacted, with missed hospital appointments and several businesses telling me that it is affecting their ability to receive and therefore pay invoices. Will the Minister urgently investigate those ongoing and worsening delays in Huntingdon, and write to me with the outcome of his findings?
I had to wait 50 minutes for a question, Mr Speaker, but this is an important one and I share the hon. Member’s concerns. We regularly meet Ofcom to discuss the performance of Royal Mail, and I will certainly write to him about the discussions we have in respect of his constituency.
Assessment & feedback
The answer acknowledges the concern but does not promise an urgent investigation as requested.
Acknowledges Concerns Without Committing To Specific Action
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
James Wild Con
North West Norfolk
Context
The hon. Member asks for transparency regarding the financial support given to British Steel by taxpayers.
Will the Secretary of State be straightforward with the House today about how much taxpayers’ money has been spent so far on British Steel?
The amount of working capital provided to British Steel to date stands at £94 million, which is considerably less than if we had given a large amount of money to Jingye, or if we had had to deal with the complete loss of the entire British Steel site and business.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Nick Timothy Con
West Suffolk
Context
According to reports, issues around visas have been resolved as part of the free trade agreement negotiations with India.
According to reports in The Guardian, Government sources have said that issues around visas have been resolved as part of the Government’s free trade agreement negotiations with India. Will the Secretary of State rule out visa liberalisation as part of those negotiations?
We should always be careful about what we read in some newspapers. [Laughter.] The hon. Gentleman knows that we cannot give a running commentary on trade negotiations, but the UK-India talks have been fruitful this week. I am optimistic and excited for the future of what is a key relationship bilaterally and for the signal it can send to the rest of the world.
Assessment & feedback
The answer avoids giving a direct ruling on visa liberalisation and instead refers to the general progress of negotiations.
Refuses To Comment On Ongoing Negotiations
Response accuracy