Wealth Tax Potential Merits 2025-04-08
2025-04-08
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Analysis from disability groups shows that the 'Pathways to Work' Green Paper will negatively impact more than 3 million people, while Oxfam's polling indicates that 77% of the public prefer increased taxes on the wealthiest rather than cuts to benefits for the poorest.
Given the detrimental effects of the 'Pathways to Work' Green Paper and Oxfam’s poll results indicating public preference for increasing taxes on the richest rather than cutting welfare, should we not consider raising funds from those with the broadest shoulders?
As I mentioned earlier, the Government have already implemented changes to make the tax system fairer and ensure that the wealthiest pay their fair share. These reforms include increasing capital gains tax, air passenger duty for private jets, and stamp duty on second or additional homes. We believe these measures address the need for a more equitable distribution of taxes.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Neil Duncan-Jordan's specific ask about introducing a wealth tax was not directly addressed; instead, existing reforms were highlighted as sufficient to ensure fairness in taxation.
Highlighting Existing Reforms
Not Addressing The New Wealth Tax Proposal
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
For over a decade, austerity measures have eroded community support; the global pandemic exacerbated inequality; ongoing cost-of-living crises continue to impoverish ordinary people. Public sentiment now strongly favors an annual wealth tax targeting only the richest individuals rather than cutting benefits for those in need.
Given historical austerity measures, the exacerbation of inequality during the pandemic, and current cost-of-living crises, should we not consider a Government willing to introduce an annual wealth tax on the very wealthiest in society to improve living standards?
If my hon. Friend thinks we are imposing austerity, he has not read the Budget carefully enough. It includes increases in revenue spending across all Departments and capital investment to ensure future building while adhering to fiscal rules. These rules prevent the fiscal irresponsibility seen under previous governments.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Brian Leishman's specific ask about introducing an annual wealth tax was not addressed; instead, current spending increases and adherence to fiscal rules were highlighted as sufficient measures against austerity.
Changing Subject
Highlighting Existing Reforms
Response accuracy