Topical Questions 2026-02-10
2026-02-10
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Secretary of State has shown leadership in restoring momentum on net zero. The Climate Change Act 2008 provides milestones for delivery.
I welcome the Secretary of State's leadership in restoring momentum on net zero. Will he outline how the Government's energy and climate strategies will be underpinned by clear delivery plans, milestones and transparent reporting to Parliament?
My hon. Friend speaks with great eloquence on these issues. As she knows, that is the great thing about the Climate Change Act 2008, which was passed with the support of all parties. David Cameron—my nemesis—was a great supporter of that plan. The Act gives us the milestones that my hon. Friend talks about. On top of that, we have our clean power action plan.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not provide specific details on delivery plans and transparent reporting to Parliament as requested.
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Secretary of State signed a secret energy deal with China, which has not been published. Intelligence services have raised concerns about China's potential to disrupt the UK's energy system.
Last year, the Secretary of State signed a secret energy deal with China, which he has refused to publish. This is simply unheard of. We have heard repeatedly from intelligence services that China might seek to disrupt our energy system, so it is crucial that the public get to see what he has signed us up to. Will the Secretary of State commit to publishing the full text of his secret energy deal with China, and if not, will he tell the House what it is that he is trying to hide?
May I give the right hon. Lady a piece of advice? Wacky conspiracy theories that she gets on the internet are no substitute for a proper policy.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not address the specific request to publish or explain the reasons for non-publication of the energy deal.
Wacky Conspiracy Theories That She Gets On The Internet Are No Substitute For A Proper Policy.
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Secretary of State has claimed that bills are falling, not rising. The public does not believe these claims.
That is frankly another patronising non-answer from the Secretary of State. I am not sure whether he got the memo, but his party is fed up with the sexist boys club. What is crucial is that the public have lost faith in the Labour party. This is a serious moment. Does he accept that when he stands at the Dispatch Box and tells the public that by his calculation their bills are falling, not rising, they simply do not believe him? Does he also accept that when he does not set out what any of his plans—such as doubling the carbon tax or clean power 2030—will do to bills, he makes a mockery of his party's pretence that it cares about the cost of living? Does he not reflect on all this—the £300 nonsense pledge, the Great British Energy fig leaf—and realise that when it comes to loss of trust, he is not their salvation but their problem?
We will take no lectures from the right hon. Lady on the cost of living crisis, because her Government presided over the worst cost of living crisis in generations. Let me tell her what we are doing: £150 off bills; the warm home discount extended; the warm homes plan. We have done more in 18 months to cut bills for people than they did in 14 years.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not address public skepticism or concerns about future plans' impact on bills as requested.
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
ExxonMobil has closed the Mossmorran ethylene plant despite paying out $17 billion in shareholder dividends. Scottish workers are concerned about corporate greed.
ExxonMobil has just closed the Mossmorran ethylene plant. ExxonMobil also paid out $17 billion in shareholder dividends. Scottish workers are being betrayed for corporate greed. Does the Secretary of State agree that we need Government ownership in vital industries, because private capital will always just look after shareholders' interests and not those of workers, communities and national prosperity?
My hon. Friend does a good job of standing up for workers in his constituency and, following the statement that I made in the House before Christmas, he will know very well the views of the Government on this closure. I was pleased to attend the local taskforce recently with my hon. Friend the Member for Cowdenbeath and Kirkcaldy (Melanie Ward). Along with the investment that the Government are making in Grangemouth and the guarantee of an interview for workers from Mossmorran at Grangemouth, our focus is on supporting the workers and the local community.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not explicitly acknowledge agreement on government ownership but focused on support measures.
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Trump's national security report suggested using gas for geopolitical power. The Hamburg declaration strengthened energy cooperation with European neighbours.
Trump's national security report made it clear that he wanted to use America's gas to project geopolitical power. We must not replace Putin's gas with a reliance on Trump's gas. That is why signing the Hamburg declaration was a step in the right direction, strengthening energy co-operation with our European neighbours. We need to go further, and we should host the next North sea summit, demonstrating UK leadership. Has the Secretary of State managed to get the Treasury to see sense and agree to hosting the next summit?
Not yet, but the hon. Lady makes a really important point, which is that energy security from home-grown clean energy is important here, but that we should also work with our European allies.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not confirm whether the Treasury has agreed to host the next summit as requested.
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The final coalmine in north Wales has closed, raising concerns about safety of coal tips. The Welsh Government is considering a request to include coal tip extraction in the Government's coal licence ban legislation.
My constituency is home to Bersham colliery, the final coalmine to close in the whole of north Wales. Coal tip safety is paramount to Welsh communities, but there is a concern about companies extracting coal from our 2,590 tips for commercial gain. With the Senedd elections less than three months away, if the Welsh Government were to request that coal tip extraction be included in the Government's coal licence ban legislation, would the Minister consider amending the Coal Industry Act 1994 to extend the Mining Remediation Authority's remit to cover those powers and associated responsibilities in the future—
My hon. Friend was at a Westminster Hall debate on this issue a few months ago, and what I said then remains the Government's position: we work closely with the Welsh Government on this issue. We are content with the Welsh Government's position that this area is already regulated and sufficient, but we obviously keep these things under review.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not commit to amending the Coal Industry Act as requested.
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Green GEN Cymru was granted an Ofgem licence shortly after the current Government took office.
Green GEN Cymru was granted an Ofgem licence within days of this Government coming to power. Is the Secretary of State confident in the process that took place, and can he confirm how far it had reached under the previous Government?
Again, we have had a meeting to discuss that issue. I will not get into Ofgem's decisions, but any planning applications or further processes will be dealt with by the Government and by Ofgem in the usual manner.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answerer did not express confidence in the process or detail its progress under the previous government as requested.
Response accuracy
Q8
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The scout group in Bo'ness has installed 40 solar panels, reducing bills and supporting young people with funding. The local energy project is an example of community capacity.
I am delighted by the publication of the local power plan. What steps will the Government take to increase accessibility and community capacity for delivering these plans? Will you join me on a visit to Bo'ness scouts?
My hon. Friend makes an important point. I congratulate the scout group. The Minister for Energy promises that he will visit, and that is now on the record in Hansard.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The environmental impact assessment shows emissions equivalent to 70% of the UK's annual total, but the developer claims this is not significant.
How will climate and environmental impacts be weighted in decisions like these, especially when developers claim they are insignificant?
The hon. Lady will not be disappointed because, as she said in her question, I will not comment on the application. However, we set out clearly in response to the Finch ruling how scope 3 emissions will be taken into account.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specifics of Rosebank's environmental impact
Will Not Comment On The Application
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The 2025 EU-UK summit set ambitions for the UK to join the single electricity market.
Does the Minister agree that close and easier energy interconnection between the EU and the UK is a key strategic component of our continent's energy security, reducing costs for businesses and customers?
At the recent North sea summit, we committed to a joint ambition of 100 GW of offshore renewable projects with our European neighbours, including through co-ordinated energy infrastructure planning.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Strategic agreement without explicit commitment to interconnection
Committed To Renewables But Not Direct Answer On Interconnection
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent's energy bills have doubled over four years, making it unsustainable for him to continue running his hotel.
What will the Secretary of State do to help people like my constituent who are struggling with high energy costs?
This has happened because of the fossil fuel crisis presided over by the previous Government. All I can say to the hon. Gentleman is that we are doing absolutely everything we can to help his constituents and others.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific measures for high energy costs
Previous Government'S Responsibility
Working On It
Response accuracy
Q12
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The nuclear regulatory taskforce recommended reforms to protect nature while providing skilled jobs and energy security.
Does the Secretary of State agree that we need to reform how we protect nature for new nuclear projects, as recommended by the nuclear regulatory taskforce?
We want to improve regulations and processes for new nuclear projects while continuing to protect the environment. We will present a full Government response, and an implementation plan, by the end of this month.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Direct Answer
▸
Context
A National Trust village cottage was sold as it could not meet minimum energy efficiency standards due to high costs.
What will the Minister do to help landlords such as the National Trust resolve this problem?
We are working closely with heritage organisations to tackle precisely that problem. The hon. Lady will see in the warm homes plan that there is specific advise about retrofitting historic buildings.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Morwind received funding for a major offshore wind hub feasibility study at Portland, which could create green jobs.
Will the Minister work with Morwind and me to deliver the hub at pace? Will he come to Portland to meet key players?
It sounds really exciting, and one of us will visit.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specifics of delivering the hub at pace
Sounds Exciting But No Commitment On Timeline
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The proposed Rosebank oil field could break international law and support companies accused of illegal settlements.
What steps is your Department taking to ensure that all UK oil and gas projects respect international law?
Of course, all projects that are consented and licensed have to follow the law, and the North Sea Transition Authority as a regulator makes that happen. I will not comment on projects that are currently going through the consenting process.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific Rosebank compliance issues
Projects Under Review
Not Commenting Specifically
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Around 75% of privately rented homes in Blackpool have damp or mould, and the Chancellor announced £30 million in the warm homes plan.
When will Blackpool receive its share of this money? When will the plan get under way?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. What is really important is not just the funding we are providing but the regulation we are introducing in the warm homes plan—promised by the last Government but never delivered—so that people who are privately renting get the decent, warm, comfortable homes they deserve.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific timeline for funds and implementation
Emphasising Regulation Rather Than Funding
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Concerns have been raised about the potential for thermal runaway in batteries used on prime agricultural land, with worries that heavy metals could vaporize at high temperatures.
I must raise a very important issue with the Secretary of State: there is concern about thermal runaway in batteries, especially those on prime agricultural land. Heavy metals vaporise at 900° and thermal runaway burns at over 1,000°. What research and assessment has been done on the evaporation of these heavy metals, which would poison agricultural land?
The right hon. Gentleman raises an important point. All the evidence points to the fact that the fire risk from batteries is less than in residential homes, but we take safety incredibly seriously. I recently convened a roundtable of those involved to look at what more we might do in the regulatory space, and DEFRA is looking at environmental regulations on batteries.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific research or assessment on heavy metals evaporation due to thermal runaway
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Imerys was successful in auction round 7, raising questions about how local communities can benefit from Cornwall's renewable energy potential.
I welcome the news this morning of Imerys's success in auction round 7. What steps is the Minister taking as part of the local power plan to ensure that local communities share the spoils of Cornwall's great renewable energy potential?
If my hon. Friend stays tuned, he will be hearing all about it in an hour's time.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide any specific steps or information on ensuring local community benefits from renewable energy projects
Will Discuss This Later
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Residents in rural Cheshire are anxious about a proposed development consent order for the Peak Cluster project, which is being consulted on.
Many of my constituents are anxious about the consultation process and the environmental impact of the Peak Cluster project in rural Cheshire. Will the Secretary of State commit to meeting me and local representatives to ensure that community concerns are properly addressed before the development consent order is submitted?
As I have said repeatedly, any projects that are going through the planning system have to demonstrate community engagement and that they have engaged genuinely with that feedback. That is part of the process, and projects of any kind are assessed against that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to meeting local representatives specifically
Projects Must Demonstrate Community Engagement
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There is ongoing work on carbon capture, usage, and storage as well as hydrogen projects within the Humber region.
What progress is being made on carbon capture, usage and storage and hydrogen projects in the Humber?
Given that it is topical questions, I might struggle to say all the progress that is being made, but the Government have committed in our energy strategy and in decisions made by the Chancellor to fund hydrogen and carbon capture, to ensure that those are important parts of our energy mix.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific details on the progress of projects
Too Broad A Question
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Rendesco, a renewable energy business in the constituency, received a £2 million grant from UKRI but is facing delays due to unresponsive communication.
Rendesco is a brilliant renewable energy business in my constituency. Just before Christmas, it was awarded a £2 million grant from UK Research and Innovation, but since then the phone has not been working at UKRI's end. Can Ministers have a word to see whether this money can be unlocked, to ensure that Rendesco's product can be brought to market and that jobs are not lost?
Yes, if the hon. Member gives us the details.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to unlocking the funding directly
Needs More Details
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Sunnyside Academy received funding from Great British Energy to install new solar panels, helping the school reduce its energy bills.
Working with Councillor David Branson, I have been pushing to get more support for our local schools to cut their bills. I am really pleased that Great British Energy funded new solar panels for Sunnyside academy in Coulby Newham last year. Will Ministers meet me to see whether we can get more support so that more of our local schools to cut their bills?
I congratulate Sunnyside academy. This Government and GB Energy are delivering a policy opposed by the Conservative party.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to meeting or discussing additional support for schools
Opposition'S Stance
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A new emissions trading scheme has been imposed, affecting domestic shipping and potentially increasing costs for consumers in Northern Ireland.
Last week the Government pushed through the imposition of the emissions trading scheme on domestic shipping. That will have a huge impact on Northern Ireland, because so many goods are brought into Northern Ireland from GB, or sent there, on ferries. What assessment has the Minister made of the impact this will have on consumer prices and manufacturing costs in Northern Ireland? Does he recognise that Northern Ireland will face heavy costs because of this net zero policy?
The right hon. Member and I debated this at length in the Delegated Legislation Committee last week. On the impact of this measure on Northern Ireland, I am sure he will be pleased to welcome the fact that we are providing a 50% reduction on the carbon tax associated with the extension to domestic maritime for journeys to Northern Ireland.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a full assessment of impacts beyond mentioning the reduction in carbon tax
Debated Already
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A local sweetshop, Teddy Grays in Dudley, is celebrating 200 years of business but faces challenges with rising energy bills.
This year Teddy Grays in Dudley celebrates 200 years in business, with five generations of the same family keeping that local sweetshop and mainstay in Dudley. However, as with many small businesses, energy bills are a constant threat to its success. What steps is my right hon. Friend taking to ensure that Teddy Grays can enjoy another 200 years of sweet success, and will he meet me to discuss this further?
That was an extremely sweet question, and I would be happy to meet my hon. Friend to discuss the issue further and outline many of the initiatives that the Government are taking to support small businesses.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific steps or details on initiatives for Teddy Grays
Wants To Meet
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The GMB's Scotland Secretary criticized the government for taxing and regulating the oil and gas sector out of business.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. “Our Governments seem stricken, almost delusional, in the face of onrushing disaster,” and we are seeing arguably the most destructive industrial calamity in our nation's history. Those are the words of the GMB's Scotland Secretary about the Government's determination to tax and regulate the oil and gas sector out of business. Does the Minister agree with the words of his union friend?
I recently had a useful meeting in Aberdeen, in which the GMB participated, about building up the future of the North sea. What I never hear from Conservative Members is any support for industries that will invest in the North sea in the future, and in the tens of thousands of jobs that will go with it.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the question about agreement with GMB's criticism
Attacking Opposition
Response accuracy
Q26
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There is a former coal-fired power station site at Ratcliffe-on-Soar on the edge of the M1 that has decommissioning potential for clean energy generation. The site represents a significant opportunity for sustainable development and economic growth.
As the Secretary of State knows, there is a fantastic site on the edge of the M1 at Ratcliffe-on-Soar—the last of the coal-fired power station sites to be decommissioned—which will make a superb site for clean energy generation. Will he commit to meeting me and Claire Ward, Mayor of the East Midlands, to discuss it further?
I visited Ratcliffe-on-Soar for the closure ceremony. It was a good example of a just transition done well, and an historic moment of consensus, delivering the phase-out of coal across our country. I am happy to meet my hon. Friend. I recently met the mayor to talk about the future of that site, which has huge potential.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to a specific meeting was not confirmed beyond an expression of willingness and no additional details were provided.
Response accuracy
Q27
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Consumers in Northern Ireland are facing the imposition of a carbon tax on domestic shipping through the emissions trading scheme, while consumers in Scotland who depend on ferries for supplies have obtained an exemption.
Returning to the imminent imposition of the emissions trading scheme on domestic shipping, why will consumers in Northern Ireland face the imposition of a carbon tax, whereas consumers in Scotland who equally depend on ferries for their supplies are obtaining an exemption? Where is the parity?
The Government were pleased to provide an exemption for the islands around Scotland for a number of reasons, but particularly because of the small populations on those islands and the non-competitive nature of the ferry services.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address why Northern Ireland does not have a similar exemption, only provided an explanation for Scotland's exemption.
Response accuracy