Topical Questions 2025-11-24

2025-11-24

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Rachel Hopkins Lab
Luton South and South Bedfordshire
Context
The fair funding review is under scrutiny for its impact on councils that have historically had lower council tax levels. Luton has faced significant service cuts due to previous funding formulas not considering deprivation adequately.
Luton has seen local services decimated, due to years of Conservative decisions which stripped consideration of deprivation and need from the funding formula. Under a fairer funding system, Luton is set to gain. What can we expect to see from the formula in places like Luton, which suffered so badly under the Conservative Government?
Under our new approach to funding, in places like Luton, which were starved of the resources that they needed for far too long, and for which we can evidence significant levels of deprivation, councils can expect to see the resources that they need in order to help people properly.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
Gideon Amos LD
Taunton and Wellington
Context
The Planning and Infrastructure Bill has been criticized for centralizing decision-making processes. This raises concerns about democratic representation at the local level.
The Planning and Infrastructure Bill takes smaller decisions away from councillors. Last week’s direction, announced in a ministerial statement, will take big decisions involving over 150 homes, such as the decision on Oldway Road in Wellington, out of the hands of local councillors. Do the Government no longer trust local people to shape communities and deliver the housing that we need?
I say gently to the hon. Gentleman that I think he misrepresents the proposal that has been announced. It is not an automatic removal for all planning applications relating to more than 150 homes; it is simply a referral process, which applies in other situations already, that allows the Secretary of State to call in individual applications.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
Context
BUUK is an innovative multi-utility provider that aims to streamline the construction of essential utility assets, potentially reducing bureaucracy in new housing developments.
I recently met representatives of BUUK, a multi-utility infrastructure provider that constructs and operates essential utility assets, and can provide all utilities as a one-stop shop. In view of the Department’s progress on new towns, and the need to rapidly scale up house building, what consideration has the Department given to using innovative delivery models, such as BUUK’s site-wide deployment of utility infrastructure, and thus reducing bureaucracy, streamlining delivery, improving accountability and allowing house builders to get on with building?
I thank my hon. Friend for that question. The Government obviously recognise the importance of ensuring that new housing development is supported by appropriate infrastructure. On the individual company that he references, I will ask my officials to reach out to it directly to discuss its delivery model and find out a bit more about its potential advantages.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Direct Answer
Martin Vickers Con
Brigg and Immingham
Context
The Planning Inspectorate overturned a decision by North East Lincolnshire council for a development of 200 houses in New Waltham, raising concerns about public confidence in the process.
The Planning Inspectorate recently overturned a decision by North East Lincolnshire council for a development of 200 houses in New Waltham in my constituency. The objections centred on highway capacity. In his report, the inspector acknowledged that the nearby roundabout was over capacity, but said that an increase from 100% to 107% capacity would make very little difference. Clearly, local residents disagree. Would the Minister acknowledge that public confidence in the process is being undermined by these decisions?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for that question. Again, he will appreciate that, due to the quasi-judicial nature of the planning system, I cannot comment on individual applications. I am aware of the concerns that have been raised by Members from across the House about holding directions, issued in particular by National Highways. He may be aware of the reforms that we are making to the statutory consultation system as a whole, which are now out to consultation.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Michelle Welsh Lab
Sherwood Forest
Context
New housing developments often face challenges in providing appropriate infrastructure such as GP surgeries, schools and shops.
In my constituency of Sherwood Forest, we have new housing developments, including in Edwinstowe and Rainworth. Does the Minister agree that when these sites are developed, local authorities and housing companies should ensure appropriate infrastructure is put in place, whether that is GP surgeries, schools or shops, because in the past this has not happened, including in Hucknall?
I thank my hon. Friend for that question, and she is absolutely right. Local development plans should address infrastructure needs and opportunities. When preparing a local plan, local planning authorities are under a duty to bring forward infrastructure funding statements. However, we realise that there is more to be done to ensure that we get the right infrastructure built in the right time as a development proceeds.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Andrew George LD
St Ives
Context
Cornwall has almost trebled its housing stock in the last 60 years but faces worsening housing problems despite this growth. The government is imposing housing targets on local authorities.
Why has the Government imposed housing targets on local authorities, and what will they do to ensure that Cornwall's local authority has the power to deliver homes needed for its residents rather than developers' interests?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his question, which is topical as I recently met officials from Cornwall council and Members, including hon. Friends, advocating for new homes in Cornwall, especially social and affordable ones. There is ongoing work, including conversations with Homes England, to better support Cornwall in bringing forward the homes it needs.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not commit to specific actions or timelines for ensuring that Cornwall's local authority has the power to deliver necessary housing.
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Edward Morello LD
West Dorset
I recently met the Water Minister to discuss the Independent Water Commission’s recommendation for pre-pipe solutions to prevent sewage overflows. Will the Minister meet me and Cabinet colleagues to make rainwater harvesting mandatory on all new home builds and major developments?
If memory serves, I answered another question from the hon. Gentleman on precisely this topic. He knows that we are out to consultation on the matter. If he wants to write to me in the first instance with further details about the type of changes he is seeking, I would be more than happy to respond.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not commit to a meeting or immediate action but suggested that Edward Morello should provide detailed information through correspondence.
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Blake Stephenson Con
Mid Bedfordshire
The Government want to improve standards in public life. At a recent council meeting, the leader of Milton Keynes council swore and was abusive following a 16-year-old resident's speech. Does the Secretary of State agree that this behavior is unacceptable?
We recently put forward our response on improving standards. We are looking for an opportunity to take that forward, for the reasons the hon. Gentleman mentions.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not explicitly agree with Blake Stephenson’s assessment but acknowledged the need to improve standards in public life.
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Sarah Pochin Reform
Runcorn and Helsby
Will the Minister confirm what oversight the Department has of the central Government grant given to Halton borough council and Merseyflow for the two bridges in Runcorn, considering a significant portion has gone unspent in recent years? What steps are being taken to ensure transparent use of any unspent funds?
I am afraid that the hon. Lady will have to write to me and outline which fund precisely she is talking about. I am more than happy to get back to her if she does that.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide any specific details on oversight or steps taken, instead requesting detailed information through correspondence.
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Perran Moon Lab
Camborne and Redruth
Context
Cornwall missed out on Pride in Place funding due to the 'trusting your neighbour' indicator being misinterpreted as a marker of affluence rather than deprivation.
The whole of Cornwall, one of the most deprived regions in northern Europe, missed out on Pride in Place funding. Can the Minister confirm that Cornwall will not be disadvantaged because of that in the next tranche of Pride in Place funding?
My hon. Friend is always a champion for Cornwall. To confirm, there were two things that drove the allocation: indices of multiple deprivation and our community needs index. For places that did not receive Pride in Place funding, within our strategy there is a whole suite of tools and levers that communities can grip in order to drive the change that they want to see. I hope we will see that in Cornwall.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly confirm whether Cornwall would be disadvantaged or how it will receive fair consideration for future funding tranches.
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Rishi Sunak Con
Richmond and Northallerton
Context
The Great Ayton allotments group received funding from the community ownership fund last year, but delays in a related planning application are threatening that funding.
The Great Ayton allotments group received funding from the community ownership fund last year. As the deadline for disbursing the funds approaches, delays in a related planning application are threatening that funding. I thank Department officials for trying to resolve the issue, and I ask Ministers to support that flexibility, because the project means a great deal to the community of Great Ayton.
I thank the right hon. Member for raising the important work that has been done in his constituency. We will continue to work with that group, because we want to ensure that all communities have the ability to grip assets and drive the change that they want to see.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address support for flexibility or resolving delays.
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Baggy Shanker Lab/Co-op
Derby South
Context
For years, Derby residents have felt the full force of Tory austerity, with many services at breaking point.
For years, Derby residents have felt the full force of Tory austerity, with many services at breaking point. Does the Minister agree that Derby deserves better, and what can the Government do to ensure that the fair funding review delivers for communities such as Derby?
Councils up and down the country deserve better, especially in great cities like Derby—and with my hon. Friend as their MP, his community will not want for a brilliant champion.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide any specific actions or commitments related to the fair funding review.
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Jeremy Hunt Con
Godalming and Ash
Context
Councils such as Waverley should be charging the community infrastructure levy to private householders who do a straightforward extension on their house.
I thank the Minister for Housing and Planning for his constructive meeting last week on the community infrastructure levy. Could he tell the House whether Liberal Democrat-controlled councils such as mine in Waverley should be charging the community infrastructure levy to private householders who do a straightforward extension on their house?
As this is topicals, I do not want to repeat the extensive conversation that the right hon. Member and I have had. He knows that we are making good-faith efforts to resolve the issue and to bring some redress forward for his resident freeholders.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a direct answer on whether councils can charge the levy.
As This Is Topicals, I Do Not Want To Repeat...
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Danny Beales Lab
Uxbridge and South Ruislip
Context
Hillingdon council has applied for exceptional financial support due to years of underfunding under the previous Government and local financial mismanagement.
Hillingdon council has applied for exceptional financial support due to years of underfunding under the previous Government and local financial mismanagement. Will the Minister assure me that, as part of our updated funding criteria, councils such as Hillingdon will get more of the funding that they need, and that there will also be improved accountability and management requirements on local councils?
I am considering the issues that Hillingdon is facing, which are really serious and important, and I will be in touch with my hon. Friend soon so that we can discuss them extensively.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide assurance regarding additional funding or improved accountability requirements.
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Connor Naismith Lab
Crewe and Nantwich
Context
Cheshire East council area has pockets of severe deprivation, centred largely around my constituency. Under the previous Government, local government funding allocations never really took account of those deprivations.
Cheshire East council area has pockets of severe deprivation, centred largely around my constituency. Under the previous Government, local government funding allocations never really took account of those deprivations. Will the Minister meet me to discuss how we can rebalance funding towards the deprived areas in my constituency that have been left behind for too long?
I will happily meet my hon. Friend—great railway towns like Crewe ought to be invested in. He will have heard from previous answers today that the new measure of deprivation uses fine-grain data, so we can identify those pockets of deprivation, like in Crewe and Nantwich. I look forward to talking with him at length on this subject.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to meeting or discuss specific rebalancing actions.
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Ian Roome LD
North Devon
Context
In rural areas like my constituency, private renting is very expensive and is unaffordable to many.
In rural areas like my constituency, private renting is very expensive and is unaffordable to many. What is the Minister doing to ensure that more housing is available at social rent rather than market rent, which people can simply not afford?
We are ensuring, through the new £39 billion social and affordable homes programme, for example, that the types of homes that need extra grant funding have that flexibility—that will include rural housing.
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify actions or commitments beyond referencing existing programmes.
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Wendy Morton Con
Aldridge-Brownhills
Context
What is grey belt, and can the Minister tell us what assessment he has made of the risk it poses to the integrity of the green belt in areas such as mine?
What is grey belt, and can the Minister tell us what assessment he has made of the risk it poses to the integrity of the green belt in areas such as mine?
The right hon. Lady continues to ask me what grey belt is; Google is her friend in this instance. I continue to refer her to the planning practice guidance that covers exactly what it means.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide any specific clarification or assessment on the impact of grey belt.
The Right Hon. Lady Continues To Ask Me...
Response accuracy