Topical Questions 2025-11-04
2025-11-04
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Janet Daby asked about the financial support provided to local councils to help families struggling with homelessness and temporary accommodation.
Will the Chancellor consider increasing finance to local councils so that they can better support constituents and improve their wellbeing and security?
At the spending review, we enabled better investment in temporary accommodation stock and strengthened local authorities’ financial position. Those changes will support local authorities to increase the supply of good-quality temporary accommodation and drive down day-to-day spend on such accommodation.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Edward Morello inquired about the funding model and whether it would include rurality as a metric to support rural areas better.
Will those choices come at the expense of rural communities such as West Dorset, or will she commit to reviewing the funding model to ensure that rurality is a funding metric?
At the spending review, we set out record investment into farming and rural communities right across this country. That is only possible because of the choices that we have made on taxation and balancing the public finances.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Andy MacNae inquired about the progress made with implementing changes to the Green Book that might enable better investment in small northern towns.
Will the Chancellor please update the House on progress made with the implementation of the Green Book review and change, as a result, might better enable investment in small northern towns such as those that make up Rossendale and Darwen?
I thank my hon. Friend for his question and campaigning work on this. At the spending review, I announced changes to the Green Book, particularly our work on place-based business cases, looking at how spending can cumulatively benefit an area.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The automotive sector reps met with Justin Madders to discuss changes in the employee car ownership scheme, which will increase taxes on working people. This raises concerns about unintended consequences for the car sector.
I refer the House to my membership of Unite. I met Unite reps in the automotive sector yesterday, including from the Vauxhall plant in Ellesmere Port, who raised with me their concerns about changes to the employee car ownership scheme in the automotive sector. This will mean an increase in taxes on working people and lead to unintended consequences for the car sector. Also, it will not raise the money that the Treasury believes it will, so will the Minister meet me and the interested parties to discuss this further?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising this issue. The Government are fully committed to doing all they can to supporting the UK car industry to grow, invest and provide employment in constituencies such as his and in other important sites across the country. Specifically on the employee car ownership scheme, we should be clear that private use of a company car is a valuable benefit to an employee but it is also right that company car tax is paid on it, ensuring fairness with other taxpayers who pay tax on cars provided by their employers. That said, I would be happy to meet my hon. Friend and the interested parties to discuss this further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
During the general election campaign, the Chancellor promised that her forthcoming Budget would not raise taxes on working people.
The Chancellor justified at the Dispatch Box what a working person is. Will she reiterate at the Dispatch Box now what she said to the British public during the general election campaign, which is that her forthcoming Budget will not raise taxes on working people?
We will set out all our Budget measures at the Budget.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
British businesses face a toxic storm of crushing tariffs from America and mountains of paperwork due to Brexit.
British businesses face a toxic storm of crushing tariffs from America and mountains of paperwork from Europe. I welcome the Prime Minister’s recognition that we need to do something about the latter because in my constituency, because of Brexit, businesses now have to deal with 27 different VAT regimes rather than one. Can the Chancellor update us on what she is doing to be a red against the red tape and solve that problem?
The work that my right hon. Friends the Chancellor and the Prime Minister have been doing with Europe is all about taking down trade barriers where they get in the way of our national interest and economic growth. That is our priority, as well as cutting bureaucracy for businesses here in the UK.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Chancellor previously announced on September 29th that every primary school in England will receive a library by the end of this Parliament.
Will the Chancellor update the House on how and when schools can apply for libraries for primaries funding, which she announced on 29 September?
We have made a commitment that every single primary school in England will have a library by the end of this Parliament. The Department for Education will set out the process in due course, but any primary school without a library can rest assured that it will have one soon.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A loophole in small business rates relief allows wealthy second homeowners to avoid paying taxes.
Will the Chancellor consider in her Budget closing the loophole in small business rates relief that allows wealthy second homeowners to have their homes on the rental market for 72 nights a year and therefore avoid paying any tax whatsoever? My constituents working the minimum wage are having to subsidise them. That is not fair, is it?
We will set out the changes that we will make to business rates at the Budget.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government's pride in place programme aims to help communities feel proud of their areas. The Isle of Wight did not receive any of this funding, despite facing challenges.
The Government’s pride in place programme presents a welcome opportunity for communities across the country to once again feel proud of where they live, especially after years of austerity and neglect under successive Conservative Governments. However, the Isle of Wight received none of that funding, which feels like an oversight, given the challenges our island faces, not least with cross-Solent transport. Will the Chancellor assure me that she is doing everything possible to ensure that islanders are not left behind and that they, too, can benefit from this programme and feel pride in our island once again?
The pride in place funding is going towards 250 communities across the country to ensure that local people are in control of investing in their local areas. I note my hon. Friend’s comments about the community that he represents. Of course, the Government’s wider agenda about driving growth, increasing people’s wages and ensuring that people are better off is central to improving the lives of his constituents and those right across the UK.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Since the Chancellor's speech, the FTSE 100 has dropped by over £22 billion.
Since the Chancellor delivered her speech this morning, the FTSE 100 has dropped by over £22 billion—the real £22 billion rather than the fantasy £22 billion black hole. What can the Chancellor say right now to steady the markets so that all our constituents’ pensions are protected?
What this Government have done to steady the markets is to kick the Conservatives out of office and leave them in opposition for years to come.
▸
Assessment & feedback
stabilizing the market
Political Commentary
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Chancellor is being asked to congratulate Rolls-Royce on a recent deal with Türkiye.
I welcome our Government’s recent Typhoon deal with Türkiye, which will see the brilliant team at Rolls-Royce in Filton play a key role in engine production and maintenance. Will the Chancellor join me in congratulating them, our local small and medium-sized enterprises and others, and set out how integral she sees defence as an engine for growth?
My hon. Friend is a solid defender of businesses and working people in her constituency. The defence industrial strategy is about supporting British industry as we—and other countries around the world—up what we spend on defence. We want British businesses and British workers to benefit from that investment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Treasury analysis exists that breaks down contributions by ethnicity, but it is not published. The questioner asks for a commitment to publish similar data broken down by nationality.
Through freedom of information requests, Restore Britain has uncovered unpublished Treasury analysis breaking down contributions by ethnicity. Evidently the data exists, so will the Chancellor commit to going further by publishing the same analysis by nationality, so that we can see which groups are paying their way, and, more importantly, which groups are not?
Mr Speaker, I am considering how to respond to that question. I will simply leave it at saying that everyone must pay their fair share of tax. That is something that the Labour party are committed to in government.
▸
Assessment & feedback
publishing data by nationality
Vagueness
Political Commentary
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner is campaigning for the Eden Portland project in his constituency, which would rejuvenate Portland and create jobs.
On a more constructive note, for the past year I have been campaigning hard for Eden Portland to open in my constituency. If opened, it would be a world-class attraction, rejuvenating Portland, attracting investment, creating well-paid jobs and promoting our coast. The project is a success story waiting to happen, so will the Chancellor of the Exchequer continue to work with me, Dorset council and the team at Eden Portland to deliver that exciting project as soon as possible?
I thank my hon. Friend again for raising the opportunities in Portland. As he knows, we are working closely with Dorset council, the project and him to bring that to fruition.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The questioner agrees with the Chancellor that public R&D is a key lever for economic growth, but notes it will not significantly increase over the spending review period.
The Chancellor knows that I agree with her that the use of public research and development is one of the most effective levers for economic growth, but it will not significantly increase over the entire five-year spending review period. If the Government are serious about economic growth, they must find a way to increase public research and development. Does she agree?
We are increasing spending on research and development in real terms and in every year of this Parliament, for exactly the reasons that the hon. Gentleman mentions. But we are doing more than that: we are supporting start-up and scale-up businesses through our pensions reform, through the British Business Bank and through UK Export Finance. We are absolutely determined to ensure that the money that goes into R&D in this country turns into great businesses that stay in this country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Chancellor is being asked to meet with the questioner and consider how catapults can support economic growth.
Will the Chancellor join me in congratulating the great work of Red Hat, a catapult based in Hyndburn that has supported the safeguarding of over 300 jobs and the development of 46 new products? Will she meet me to consider the role of catapults in supporting economic growth in places such as Hyndburn?
I thank my hon. Friend again for raising the opportunities in Portland. As he knows, we are working closely with Dorset council, the project and him to bring that to fruition.
▸
Assessment & feedback
meeting request
Repetition
Vagueness
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
Unspecified
Not provided in text
▸
Context
The question is related to the previous discussion about funding, but specifics are not given.
Unspecified
I note my hon. Friend’s comments about the community that he represents. Of course, the Government’s wider agenda about driving growth, increasing people’s wages and ensuring that people are better off is central to improving the lives of his constituents and those right across the UK.
▸
Assessment & feedback
specific funding concerns
Vagueness
Political Commentary
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Chancellor mentioned difficult decisions for everyone except the ultra-rich. Billionaire wealth has increased while living standards have fallen.
With billionaire wealth soaring while living standards fall, does she agree it is time to tax extreme wealth fairly to tackle cost of living crisis and invest in public services?
As the hon. Gentleman knows, that is not what I said in my speech this morning. In last year’s Budget we got rid of the non-dom tax status, introduced VAT and business rates on private schools, increased capital gains tax, taxed private jets, and eliminated carried interest—more than the Green party has ever done to reduce inequality.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not directly address the question of taxing extreme wealth to tackle cost of living crisis or invest in public services.
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Concerns over proposed changes to agricultural property relief affecting rural growth opportunities and community viability.
Could my hon. Friend confirm what assessment has been made about the impact of proposed changes to agricultural property relief on growth opportunities in rural areas and the viability of rural communities?
As I said earlier, the proposals made by CenTax and others would result in twice as many farms paying more tax as are planned under Government’s proposals. We think our proposals are right and fair.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The assessment requested was not provided, only comparison to other proposals.
Comparison
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Asylum accommodation costs in Northern Ireland quadrupling from £100 million to £400 million, total UK cost £15.3 billion over next decade.
With asylum accommodation costs quadrupling, should the Chancellor look at where waste lies rather than hiking taxes again?
I absolutely agree with the hon. Lady that we should reduce the cost of asylum accommodation. Indeed, our commitment to close all asylum hotels in this Parliament is important.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Chancellor did not address wasteful spending or tax hikes directly.
Commitment
Response accuracy