Topical Questions 2024-12-02
2024-12-02
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent has been waiting for social housing after applying for over 80 properties.
I recently heard from a constituent with three young children who has applied for over 80 properties, but is still waiting for social housing. What steps will my right hon. Friend take to speed up the planning process specifically for social housing?
My hon. Friend is right to draw attention to the need for more social housing. We have committed to delivering the biggest increase in social and affordable house building in a generation, and I have proposed changes to the national planning policy framework to support that. We have also announced additional funding for the affordable homes programme.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address speeding up the planning process but mentioned broader housing commitments.
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent is concerned about the safety implications of a Chinese Embassy project.
At whose request did the Secretary of State call in the planning application for the Chinese super-embassy?
We welcome the hon. Gentleman to his place. Despite him being on the Opposition Benches, we seem to have a lot in common: we both came to Parliament in the 2015 intake, represent constituencies in the north and think the Tories deserved to lose the last general election. We take planning decisions in the normal way.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Entirely avoided answering the question about who requested intervention on the application.
Dismissive
Personal
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP is concerned about national security risks posed by the Chinese Embassy project.
I used to have ginger hair as well! May I give the right hon. Lady the answer to my question? It was the Foreign Secretary. In opposition, the now Home Secretary warned that the Chinese Government are “attempting to influence Parliament”, and trying “to interfere in our democracy and undermine our security.”—[Official Report, 11 September 2023; Vol. 737, c. 667.] Those risks are all heightened by this development. Are this Government so desperate to counteract the disastrous Budget and their own growth-wrecking trade union Bill that they are now willing to override national security, national interests and the sensible concerns of their Home Secretary by kowtowing to the Chinese Government?
We have got record investment into the UK through our international business summit. I am proud of our Employment Rights Bill, which is pro-worker and pro-employer. It will reward good employers and put money back into the high street. This Government take national security very seriously and will continue to do so.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Entirely avoided addressing the specific concerns about national security and focused on other matters.
Personal
Broad Statements
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The English Devolution Bill is being considered, which may affect Cornwall's representation.
Given that the mayoral council and leaders' councils are being contemplated as part of the English devolution Bill, what steps is the Deputy Prime Minister taking to ensure that Cornwall's voice is heard in Westminster, after being subsumed for far too long?
It was a pleasure to meet my hon. Friend and colleagues to talk about devolution in Cornwall. He will know that we have agreed to a non-mayoral devolution deal for Cornwall as a first step. We recognise the distinct culture, history and identity of the Cornish people. This important step will allow us to unlock deeper devolution in Cornwall and, in time, we hope it will allow Cornwall to take its seat at the Council of the Nations and Regions.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address the voice being heard in Westminster but discussed broader steps towards devolution for Cornwall.
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent's high-rise building is being remediated, but the materials are allowed to remain.
My constituent, Dom, purchased a high-rise building that, it now transpires, does not meet building regulations on combustible materials used in the early 2000s. His building is being remediated, but the materials are being allowed to remain, locking in the risk for the long term and sending insurance premiums sky high. Why are the Government not investigating historic non-compliance? What is being done to protect homeowners from unfair losses and sky-high insurance premiums?
We are clear that dangerous buildings need to be remediated. That is why the best thing that any building owner can do is get into a scheme today to unlock the funding and meet those duties they have as building owners. When they do that and when they are approved for the grant, they would have an inspection at that point, so I am surprised to hear that dangerous defects would be locked in, as the hon. Lady says, but I am interested in having a conversation with her to understand that further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address why historic non-compliance investigations are not happening but mentioned remediation schemes and inspections.
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A block of flats built by the public sector 60 years ago has a major structural fault.
A block of 50 flats in my constituency was built by the public sector 60 years ago and has now been found to have a major structural fault that will cost over £1 million to fix. The flat owners are also shared freeholders of the block and cannot afford the cost of the repair or to sell their flats. As it is an unusual situation, will the Minister meet me and the resident owners to consider a way forward before the situation gets critical?
Yes, of course. The issue of cladding defects is exceptionally important and, indeed, the subject of a debate later today, but so are non-cladding defects and protecting leaseholders from their impacts.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly agree to meet but acknowledged the seriousness of structural faults.
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP is concerned about the fairness of housing targets in South West Hertfordshire.
Given that the Government are already doing another relaunch, would the Secretary of State reconsider the fairness of housing targets, whereby poor delivery by Labour in London is awarded with lower targets to the detriment of areas such as South West Hertfordshire?
Perhaps the hon. Gentleman did not hear my previous response. The proposed new standard method, which we consulted on, significantly boosts expectations across our city regions. In mayoral combined authority areas, it would see targets grow by more than 30%, matching the ambition of our local leaders.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address reconsideration but discussed new target methods and ambitions.
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government are consulting on the future of pan-regional partnerships such as Great South-West.
The Government are consulting on the future of pan-regional partnerships such as our own Great South-West, which covers Cornwall, Devon, Somerset and Dorset. Businesses I speak to value the ability of our regions to speak with one voice on economic issues to Government and to investors, which are important for our region. Would the Minister meet me and businesses to discuss the future of PRPs?
I thank my hon. Friend for taking the time to meet me to talk about devolution and growth in that region. We are absolutely committed to ensuring that growth is felt in every part of the country, and that requires partnership from central Government, local government and the business community. I would be more than happy to meet him to talk about how we can do that going forward.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly agree to meet but expressed willingness to discuss future plans.
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
British nationals who vote in UK elections are told their MP cannot represent them as they have no overseas constituencies.
In July, British nationals were able to vote for Members of Parliament but now too many are being told the MP of their last address cannot represent them due to rules about representing only constituents. Can we get a letter out to all MPs providing clarity on this issue?
The hon. Member will be aware that the Electoral Commission has published a report on the general election, and we will consider its findings and will come back in due course on this matter and others.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Providing clarity to MPs about overseas voters' representation status
Will Consider
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The housing market in York is overheated due to a high number of short-term holiday lets, which affects the local community.
There are 2,193 short-term holiday lets in York driving up house prices. I have a private Member's Bill on this issue. Will the Minister work with me as I co-produce the Bill to address excessive concentrations of short-term lets and second homes?
My hon. Friend and I have discussed this matter many times. She is well aware of the Government's approach to tackling excessive concentrations of short-term lets and second homes. I am of course more than happy to discuss the issue with her again in the future.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to work on the Bill
Discuss The Issue
Response accuracy
Q11
Direct Answer
▸
Context
There is a collective agreement among MPs that first past the post voting system damages trust in politics, supported by public opinion.
Most parties agree that first past the post is damaging trust in politics. Does the Secretary of State agree with a national commission for electoral reform as recommended by an all-party parliamentary group?
No.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Medway council has suffered a significant cut in direct support grants due to austerity policies.
After 14 years of local government cuts, Medway council faced a 91% cut in direct support grants and financial difficulties. Will the Minister meet with me and Medway council colleagues and finance officers to discuss available support after 14 years of Conservative austerity?
We are working constructively with Medway council as part of our framework to support councils in the most difficulty. This Government are clear that the process will be collaborative and supportive and, on that basis, we are more than happy to meet to discuss it further.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Concrete meeting agreement
More Than Happy To Meet
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Councils are frustrated by the high levels of undeveloped planning consents.
Many councils, especially in south-east England, are frustrated with undeveloped consents. Will the Secretary of State consider allowing a 10-year housing supply number that includes undeveloped consents to ensure timely development?
We took steps, in the proposed reforms to the consultation on the national planning policy framework, to encourage build-out—not least through encouraging mixed-use development. However, we are reflecting on what more can be done to encourage that and to ensure that sites are built out in a timely manner.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Concrete decision on including undeveloped consents
Reflecting On
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent was housed in a hotel that failed to meet her complex needs, feeling unsafe and threatened.
My vulnerable pregnant constituent was housed in inappropriate accommodation after leaving hospital. She felt safer sleeping rough due to threats and drug use around her room. Will the Minister update on work to end shifting homeless constituents to inadequate housing?
I am very sorry to hear about the experience of my hon. Friend's constituent. I refer to my previous comments; I am very happy to meet and engage with her on her work to tackle homelessness and rough sleeping.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific update on efforts
Very Sorry
Happy To Meet
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Wiltshire has an opportunity to join other areas with an elected mayoral authority.
If Wiltshire embraces the chance to become part of a combined authority like Dorset and Somerset, will there be local elections all-out in Wiltshire next spring?
I thank the right hon. Gentleman for his question on devolution. We are absolutely ready to talk to any areas that are keen to take on devolution, particularly a mayoral combined authority. Any decisions on whether elections do or do not take place will be part of future consideration.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific decision on local elections
Part Of Future Consideration
Response accuracy
Q16
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The National Audit Office report shows that most buildings affected by cladding have not been identified.
I welcome the Secretary of State's announcement on deadlines. However, a majority of buildings affected by cladding are still unidentified after seven years. Will the Minister deliver a more joined-up approach to identify and remediate those properties as soon as possible?
I thank the Chair of the Select Committee for that question. It will probably not surprise her to hear that the first question I asked when I became Minister with responsibility for building safety was, “How many buildings need remediating?” I do not think that it will surprise her or colleagues to hear how astonished I was to find out that between 4,000 and 7,000 buildings were unidentified after seven years—which shows the previous Government's intent. We are going to identify them, work out what their risks are and get them remediated.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The government has committed to consulting on ending new freehold estates.
I welcome the Government's commitments, in response to my written parliamentary questions, to a consultation on ending fleecehold. However, my constituents just want to know when that will take place.
As I set out in response to a previous question, we will consult on how to end the prevalence of new fleecehold estates, and we will, in the short term, ensure that residents on existing estates have the protections they need against unfair management charges.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific consultation timeline
Will Consult
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government's Mayoral Council is redistributing power to local communities. The Mayor of the east midlands, Claire Ward, received £5 million for youth trailblazer regions.
I am delighted that the Government's Mayoral Council is handing back powers to local communities. We are already seeing the impact of that. Claire Ward, the Mayor of the east Midlands, attended the first meeting in October. She is leading the way: the East Midlands is one of the youth trailblazer regions granted £5 million of government funding to help young people into work or training. What work are ministers doing to give those who contribute to our country a say in how it is governed?
The forthcoming English devolution White Paper will set out clearly our top-to-bottom redistribution of power, and how we include and engage people at a local level to ensure that they can actively participate in the development of their areas.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There is growing concern among constituents that planning decisions are being swept aside due to the Government's new planning reforms.
There is growing concern among constituents that planning decisions are being swept aside because of the government's new planning reforms. What assurance can the Minister give that there will be meaningful engagement between constituents and their local planning authority, and that decisions will be respected?
As I have said, the best way to shape development in any given area is to have an up-to-date local plan in place. Where such plans are not in place, local authorities leave themselves open to the presumption in favour of sustainable development, and to development via appeal, so I encourage the hon. Gentleman to ensure that his local authority has an up-to-date plan in place. That is the best way for residents to have control.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Encouraging Local Authorities
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The cost of West Sussex county council's Oracle upgrade has risen from £2.6 million to £28 million in five years.
In five years, the cost of west sussex county council's Oracle upgrade has risen from £2.6 million to £28 million. Is that the kind of contract mismanagement that the office for local government can look into?
We are currently in the process of reviewing oversight, accountability, and checks and balances to make sure that they are in place and fit for purpose, and that the early warning system works. More detail on that will follow in the English devolution White Paper before Christmas.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Labour's housing targets need reform to account for land availability around protected landscapes.
Labour's housing targets desperately need reform to take into account land availability around protected landscapes. The government have said that the answer is the costly planning appeals system. Does the Minister think that is a good use of taxpayers' money?
Local plans have to go through examination for a determination of whether they are sound. Hard constraints, such as the type that the hon. Gentleman has just mentioned, will be taken into account when those plans are tested, even under the new framework.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Local Planning
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A combination of factors has meant that many section 106 affordable homes stand empty.
The government's commitment to build more affordable homes is both welcome and urgent. However, we also need to ensure that registered providers are willing and able to take on section 106 affordable homes when they are built. In recent years, a combination of factors has meant that too many homes stand empty. Will my hon. Friend say what steps can be taken to tackle the section 106 standing stock scandal?
We recognise that this is a growing problem across the country that is having a severe impact on affordable housing supply. My hon. Friend will not have to wait long to find out what the government propose to do to bear down on this problem.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Under Review
Response accuracy
Q23
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Proposed planning reforms mean that towns such as Tring will see up to 40% more housing built on the green belt.
The proposed planning reforms mean that towns such as tring will see up to 40% more housing built on the green belt. What assurances can the Minister give that sacrificing that countryside will not have a negative impact on the community, and that we will have infrastructure before the occupation of homes and truly affordable homes for people in the local community?
We want to put in place a planning system that is geared towards meeting housing need in full. That is a clear difference between us and the Conservative party. In bringing forward its local plan and looking at development, every local area should look first at densification—that is, what it can do on brownfield land. It should only have to review green-belt land if it cannot meet the needs in that way or via cross-boundary strategic planning.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Densification
Response accuracy
Q24
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The local council has proposed the closure of the Prince of Wales theatre in Cannock.
Last week, my local council announced the proposed closure of the much-loved prince of wales theatre in cannock. Despite the council's financial pressures, local people do not want that theatre to become collateral damage. Will the Minister meet me to see what could be done to explore community ownership and give our theatre the bright future that thousands of my constituents want to see?
As my hon. Friend knows, I am very keen on community ownership, and I am sad to hear about the situation in his community. I would definitely steer him towards the “asset of community value” process in the immediate term, and of course, I would be very happy to meet him and campaigners on this issue.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q25
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Non-qualifying leaseholder status can make it almost impossible to acquire a mortgage for properties.
Non-qualifying leaseholder status gets slapped on a property in perpetuity long after the required safety works are completed. That status means that it is almost impossible to acquire a mortgage—solicitors advise very strongly that purchasers steer clear of such properties, which are very often flats—and the status is inherited by successive owners in perpetuity. Has the Minister considered what this status does for the housing crisis?
I completely understand the challenge. Drawing a line between qualifying and non-qualifying leaseholders—between people who own a property and therefore suffer from things that have been beyond their control, and landlords that are businesses and therefore have multiple assets—will always be a difficult job. At the edge, where the boundary between qualifying and non-qualifying becomes blurred, there are some difficult cases. As a new government, we are committed to working with people to understand better how we can go forward on that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Challenging
Response accuracy
Q26
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Peter Swallow questioned the government's use of high street rental auctions to address empty shops.
Will the Minister commit to working with local authorities to use new powers to run high street rental auctions, so that we can end the affront of empty shops this Christmas?
Yes. High street rental auctions were launched as part of the Levelling-up and Regeneration Act 2023, which are intended to bring vacant properties back into use.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not provide specifics on how local authorities will work with the government or any commitments beyond acknowledging the existence of the auctions.
Under Review
Part Of A Broader Policy
Response accuracy
Q27
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Mike Martin raised concerns about cross-boundary infrastructure burdens resulting from housing developments.
I represent Tunbridge Wells, and just over the boundary in Wealden district, a large housing development is proposed. Wealden will get the houses, but the infrastructure burden will fall particularly on my constituents who live in Tunbridge Wells. Will the Secretary of State update me on the reforms to the NPPF? What is being done about this problem of cross-boundary infrastructure?
In the NPPF, we set out the clear direction of travel towards the universal coverage of strategic planning across the whole of England. We had an Adjournment debate on that just last week. We are determined to put in place the mechanisms that will allow effective cross-boundary co-operation to ensure that the right infrastructure and housing growth takes place.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer did not provide specific details about current reforms or concrete steps being taken to address cross-boundary infrastructure issues.
Under Review
Determined To Put In Place Mechanisms
Response accuracy