Topical Questions 2025-07-07
2025-07-07
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Eastleigh police station was closed in 2019 after 76 years of service. In 2023, the Hampshire police and crime commissioner promised that a new station would be opening within 12 months.
Eastleigh police station was closed in 2019 after 95 years of service. In 2023, the Hampshire police and crime commissioner promised that a new station would be opening within 12 months, but we still do not have one. Does the Secretary of State agree that my constituents deserve a new police station?
As the hon. Member will know, decisions about where police stations are located are for the local force, the chief constable and the police and crime commissioner. She will welcome the news that Hampshire is getting 65 additional neighbourhood police officers, who will be out on the beat this year as a result of the Government’s neighbourhood policing guarantee.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether Eastleigh constituents deserve a new police station
Shifts To Broader Context Of Additional Officers
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
New neighbourhood policing teams have made a difference in restoring safety to Huddersfield town centre. The area faces persistent challenges including violent and knife crime.
In Huddersfield, new neighbourhood policing teams are making a difference in restoring safety to our town centres, with 12 additional officers for the team. I welcome the 6.8% funding uplift received by West Yorkshire police this year, but given the persistent challenges that town centres face—including violent and knife crime, which we have seen in Huddersfield—will the Secretary of State update the House on how the Government will continue to support neighbourhood policing and ensure that forces such as West Yorkshire have the long-term resources they need to keep communities safe?
My hon. Friend is right that we need the additional neighbourhood policing in West Yorkshire. I welcome the 12 additional officers in her constituency, the 100 additional neighbourhood police officers across West Yorkshire and, of course, the additional police officers in Pontefract and Castleford town centres. We have made it clear to police forces across the country that the focus this summer needs to be on tackling town centre crime.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address long-term resources for neighbourhood policing
Shifts To Additional Officers And Summer Focus
Response accuracy
Q3
Evasion / No Answer
▸
Context
The Home Secretary is facing criticism for the high number of illegal immigrants crossing the channel. There are calls for a policy to immediately remove every single illegal immigrant.
It is now clear that the Home Secretary has lost control of our borders. So far, 2025 has been the worst year in history when it comes to illegal immigrants crossing the channel. Her claim to be smashing the gangs is clearly laughable. The French are having almost no effect, despite spending hundreds of millions of pounds, and the press report that not much will change in the negotiations this week. Returns of small boat arrivals are down, representing only 5% of overall arrivals, so will—
The shadow Home Secretary seems to have forgotten that in the short period for which he was immigration Minister, net migration near-trebled and the number of small boats went up tenfold. Not only that, but the funding for France that he has referred to was agreed by his Government when he was at the Home Office. If he really wanted to see serious action against small boats, why did he vote against counter-terror powers for smuggler gangs, against clamping down on illegal working in the gig economy, and against stronger action to stop those dangerous crossings?
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether a removals deterrent is needed
Deflects By Pointing Out Past Failures Of Shadow Home Secretary
Response accuracy
Q4
Evasion / No Answer
▸
Context
The so-called “Police Anti-Racism Commitment” is controversial due to its stance on treating people differently to engineer equality of policing outcomes.
Is the Home Secretary aware of the so-called ‘Police Anti-Racism Commitment’, which is itself flagrantly racist? It says that the racial equity commitment means
‘not…treating everyone ‘the same’ or being ‘colour blind’. It says that the police should treat people differently in order to artificially engineer equality of policing outcomes. Does she agree that that is itself flagrantly racist? The police should treat everyone the same. Will she call on the National Police Chiefs’ Council to cancel the commitment? If it will not, will she legislate to give herself the powers?
‘not…treating everyone ‘the same’ or being ‘colour blind’. It says that the police should treat people differently in order to artificially engineer equality of policing outcomes. Does she agree that that is itself flagrantly racist? The police should treat everyone the same. Will she call on the National Police Chiefs’ Council to cancel the commitment? If it will not, will she legislate to give herself the powers?
As the shadow Home Secretary knows, the police’s oath makes it clear that they have to police without fear or favour, and that is what they do right across the country. It is a shame that he will not support the police in the difficult job that they do, just as the Conservatives voted against cracking down on off-road bikes, against new spiking and stalking laws, and against respect orders. They are against supporting our police.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether to cancel racial equity commitment or legislate
Deflects By Pointing Out Past Failures Of Conservatives
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Alcaline Transport was fined £10,000 after reporting that a clandestine migrant was found in one of its vehicles. There are calls for improvements to the penalization process.
Alcaline Transport in my constituency was fined £10,000 after it reported that a clandestine migrant was found in one of its vehicles. When will improvements to the clandestine entrant civil penalty scheme be fully implemented, so that hauliers who report issues responsibly are supported, not penalised?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising this issue. While the clandestine entrant penalty scheme has to be rigorously enforced in order to be effective, it also provides a very fair process of appeal for hauliers against penalties that are not justified by the facts of a case. I am sure that my hon. Friend will assist the company in his constituency through that appeal process.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address full implementation timeline of improvements to penalty scheme
Shifts To Fair Appeal Process
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Labour police and crime commissioners argue that the money allocated by the Chancellor at the spending review is insufficient to deliver the Government’s policing priorities.
Does the Home Secretary agree with Labour police and crime commissioners that the money allocated by the Chancellor at the spending review is insufficient to deliver the Government’s policing priorities?
We have provided an additional £200 million for neighbourhood policing as part of more than £1 billion of additional funding for police forces across the country. That is how we are putting an additional 3,000 neighbourhood police officers and police community support officers on our streets this year, after the decimation of neighbourhood policing under the Conservatives.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address sufficiency for delivering priorities
Shifts To Additional Funding And Officers
Response accuracy
Q7
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The town of Prudhoe was recently shocked by Islamophobic graffiti found on a building, prompting concerns about hate crime and community safety.
Recently, the town of Prudhoe was shocked when Islamophobic graffiti was found on a building. Such graffiti has no place in Prudhoe, my constituency, Northumberland or this country. Can the Home Secretary assure me that upholding the safety and security of everyone in rural communities, no matter where they are from or what their background, is of the utmost importance to this Government?
My hon. Friend is right. That sort of graffiti and serious hate crime divides communities and needs to be taken seriously by police across the country. It is one of the reasons we are strengthening the law to give the police stronger powers to prevent intimidating protests around not just synagogues but mosques.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Hertfordshire’s policing budget faces a £7 million shortfall, and the recent spending review did not provide direct funding from the Home Office to address this issue.
My thoughts are with the family of Jayesh Pitrola. Hertfordshire’s policing budget already faces a £7 million shortfall, and the recent spending review contained no direct funding from the Home Office to address that. Will the Home Secretary reassure my constituents, as well as our police and crime commissioner Jonathan Ash-Edwards, that Hertfordshire will benefit from more police officers without further local tax rises being required?
As the Home Secretary just pointed out, we have provided an additional £200 million this year to support new neighbourhood police officers and PCSOs for all our communities. I am very happy to meet the hon. Gentleman if he would like to discuss policing further, but this Government are committed to making sure that the police have the resources they need.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The nationally recognized BRAVE programme supported adult survivors of domestic abuse in Berkshire, but it was left unviable after the funding was cut by 25%.
The nationally recognised BRAVE—Building Resilience and Valuing Emotions—programme supported adult survivors of domestic abuse in Berkshire, but after our Conservative police and crime commissioner cut its funding by 25%, the scheme was left unviable. Does the Minister share my deep disappointment about this cut?
Yes, I do. I thank my hon. Friend for highlighting the important work that BRAVE has done in Berkshire. Grassroots organisations are at the heart of work to support domestic abuse victims and the communities they live in. Tackling domestic abuse is at the heart of the Government’s mission and, I should hope, the mission of every police and crime commissioner.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP raises concerns about the ability to deport foreign criminals, including paedophiles, due to constraints under the European Convention on Human Rights.
To what extent does the Minister agree that reform of the European convention on human rights, which can block us from deporting some foreign criminals, including paedophiles, should be a priority for the Government?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right that it should be for Parliament and the Government to decide who has a right to remain in our country. As set out in our immigration White Paper, we intend to clarify these issues and the application of article 8 rights in the UK.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11
Direct Answer
▸
Context
A company paid a large sum to its blackmailer in response to a ransomware attack. The Home Office recently closed a consultation on legislative proposals to counter ransomware.
I associate myself with the Home Secretary’s comments about 7/7. I remember that day too well, and we supported the Government then, too. In more recent times, there have been a number of major cyber-attacks, ransomware attacks and associated blackmail of major companies. It has come to my attention that one such company paid a very large sum to its blackmailer recently. Will she update the House on the progress of the Government’s actions to ensure that blackmailers of this sort do not succeed in future?
I am grateful to the right hon. Gentleman for raising this matter, and will happily meet him to discuss it. The Home Office recently closed a consultation on a world-leading package of legislative proposals to counter ransomware. A public response will be published shortly.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The chair of the Met Police Federation, Rick Prior, and the chair of the West Midlands Police Federation, Rich Cooke, have been removed by the unelected chief executive of the Police Federation after speaking up for their officers.
The chair of the Met Police Federation, Rick Prior, and the chair of the West Midlands Police Federation, Rich Cooke, have both been removed by the unelected chief executive of the Police Federation after speaking up for the officers they were elected to represent. Is the Home Secretary as concerned as I am that the only staff association that police officers are legally allowed to join is no longer fit for purpose?
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for raising this issue; I know he has experience as a police officer. I regularly meet the Police Federation and its officers and chief executive. I will raise his concerns directly with them.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister admits that the situation in the channel is deteriorating, leading to a high number of people in asylum accommodation in Alison Griffiths' constituency.
How does the Home Secretary propose to reduce the number of people in asylum accommodation in Bognor Regis and Littlehampton, given that even the Prime Minister admits that the situation in the channel is deteriorating?
By speeding up the asylum process, so that people are not trapped in asylum hotels by huge backlogs, and by increasing decision making by 116%, following the 70% fall that we saw in the three months before the last election, we will get the system moving again.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Over the past 14 years, police forces have faced significant cuts to personnel and resources. The west midlands still has 540 fewer officers compared to 2010.
Over the past 14 years, police forces have faced significant cuts to personnel and resources. While many areas are returning to 2010 staffing levels, the west midlands still has 540 fewer officers. I support the efforts of the police and crime commissioner, Simon Foster. How can we address the funding gap caused by an outdated national formula that has disadvantaged my Dudley constituents?
My hon. Friend is a passionate advocate for policing in her constituency. I hope she will welcome the increase for the west midlands of over 300 neighbourhood police officers and PCSOs. It comes at a time when we are putting 3,000 more neighbourhood police on the beat. We are also bringing in: new laws on off-road bikes and town centre crime; a ban on machetes, zombie knives and ninja swords; domestic abuse experts in 999 control rooms; and new protections against terrorism for venues. That is action across the board to keep our communities safe.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy