Health Service Spending 2025-10-21
2025-10-21
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP is concerned about wasteful spending within the NHS and the impact of previous government policies.
What steps his Department is taking to tackle wasteful spending in the health service, considering the example of PFI deals which did huge damage to NHS budgets by saddling trusts with £80 billion in debts despite receiving only £13 billion in assets?
As well as the record investment that we put into the NHS, we are ensuring that we get a better bang for the taxpayer’s buck. Under the Conservatives, for example, the NHS was paying £3 billion to recruitment firms for agency shifts. We have cut agency spending by a third and are abolishing it altogether, with the savings reinvested in staff pay and treatment for patients. That is just one example of how our reform agenda is good for patients and for taxpayers.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address ruling out private finance for new NHS clinics but mentioned learning from previous government's failures.
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlighted an issue where cancer patients from Kirkby Stephen, who need chemotherapy in Carlisle, must travel on the day or before their treatment to get blood tests done at a hospital.
Is it not wasteful and inconvenient for cancer patients needing chemotherapy in Carlisle but living in rural areas like Kirkby Stephen to have to travel on the same day or the day before just to get bloods taken, due to local hospitals no longer funding these services through GP surgeries?
As he often does, the hon. Gentleman highlights in his own very rural constituency some of the fundamental problems at the heart of our NHS. That is why we are reforming it, ensuring that we move hospital services from hospitals into the community and developing neighbourhood health services. We are also looking at the financial flows in the system that lead to these sorts of perverse incentives and funding arrangements, which do damage to his constituents, as they do to many others and to rural and coastal communities.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly address the specific travel inconvenience but acknowledged issues with financial flows and community-based services.
Response accuracy