Topical Questions 2024-12-19
2024-12-19
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Ofwat announced water bill increases, affecting customers negatively. Previous government's lack of action led to increased costs for fixing sewerage infrastructure.
If he will make a statement on his departmental responsibilities. Recent investigations have shown that a lack of investment in drainage infrastructure has contributed to significant flooding in Uxbridge and South Ruislip. How will water companies including Thames Water be held to account where their lack of investment blights communities through repeated flooding?
The Government recognise the importance and need for a robust drainage system but acknowledge that previous governments failed to ensure adequate investment. Water companies have a duty to ensure effective draining of surface water and provision of sewers.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not address how specific water companies will be held accountable or provide concrete steps for improvement.
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A farmer took his own life fearing becoming a financial burden on family due to inheritance tax changes. The impact of the policy is being questioned by the farming community.
I wish a merry Christmas to everyone in the House, and also to everyone in our farming, food, hospitality and water sectors. But not everyone will be able to celebrate Christmas. In recent weeks, a farmer took himself off to a remote part of his farm and killed himself. The message he left his family is that he did this because he feared becoming a financial burden to his family because of changes to inheritance tax. This is the human cost of the figures that the Secretary of State provides so casually. What does the Secretary of State say to that grieving family?
I extend my heartfelt sympathies but it is irresponsible to weaponise personal tragedy. The Government are investing in mental health services and claimants will pay nothing following the changes to agricultural property relief.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer criticizes the questioner rather than addressing the human cost of inheritance tax changes.
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The previous question raised concerns about the human cost of inheritance tax changes, with a specific mention of a tragic suicide in the farming community.
How heartless and how extraordinary that the Secretary of State is more discomfited by being presented with the facts of the consequences of his policy than the reality of what this policy ensures. I was a Minister for seven and a half years, and I have never seen a policy have the consequences that this one has. Will he collect data on a monthly basis of suicides from farmers, farming families, landowners and family businesses, so that we, the House and the outside community can understand the human costs of this tax policy before it comes into force?
Mental health services are a responsibility of the national health service. The former Health Secretary is not in a position to lecture about public services, and they failed farmers on many fronts including funding and trade deals with Australia.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer criticizes the opposition party rather than addressing the request for data collection.
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Farmers in northern parishes of Southport constituency have requested an internal drainage board (IDB) to manage flooding risks. The necessary statutory instrument is pending.
I recently met farmers in the northern parishes of my constituency, and they told me about the urgent need for improved water management to protect farmland. They want to establish an internal drainage board for flood management, but they cannot take action to set it up until the necessary statutory instrument is in place. Given the importance of establishing an IDB in my area, will the Minister commit to working with me and stakeholders to reduce flood risks, and will she outline when the statutory instrument for an IDB in my area might be put before the House?
I would be delighted to work with my hon. Friend on this important issue. The Association of Drainage Authorities is part of the flood resilience taskforce, and the statutory instrument will be laid as parliamentary time allows.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The answer does not provide a specific timeline or commitment for the statutory instrument.
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A farmer in Horsham constituency struggles to see much profit annually, making regular farming barely investable. The risk of losing a significant portion of the farm to inheritance tax is a major concern.
A farmer in my constituency tells me that even in a good year he is lucky to see much beyond £20,000 in profit. With margins as wafer thin as that, regular farming barely qualifies as investable at all. The risk of losing a huge slice of that farm to inheritance tax at random intervals would not only go to putting this generation out of business, but go a long way towards ensuring that they can never be replaced. Does the Minister agree that this measure—
The point that farmers need to get a better return from their business is well made, and that is exactly what this Government will be addressing.
▸
Assessment & feedback
No specific measures or commitments are provided in response to the farmer's concerns.
Response accuracy
Q6
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The constituency has long felt the impacts of flooding, especially after storms. A flooding report has been produced to address these issues.
Merry Christmas to you, Mr Speaker, and to your team and to colleagues across the House. My constituents have long felt the impacts of flooding, and many residents have been isolated in rural areas after a storm. I have recently produced a flooding report. Will the Minister meet me to discuss it, so that I can support the work of the Department?
There is a very easy and short answer to that: I would be delighted to meet my hon. Friend.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Santa swims have been cancelled in North Cornwall due to raw sewage dumping. Water companies receive money from bill payers but distribute it to shareholders instead.
Does the Secretary of State agree that the best gift he could give my constituents this Christmas would be a total ban on water bill rises until South West Water bosses finally end this scandal?
The hon. Gentleman is right to point to the scandalous situation that the previous Government left our waterways in, with record levels of pollution and raw sewage filthying our rivers, lakes and seas. I have appointed Sir Jon Cunliffe to lead a commission to review governance and regulation so that we can stop it ever happening again.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific ask about banning water bill rises
Changed Subject
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government announced a £5 billion agriculture budget, the largest ever for sustainable farming.
In that context, what more can the Secretary of State do to push for his Department to get that money out the door in a way that the previous Government did not?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. It was extraordinary, was it not, that the last Government managed not to spend £300 million of the farm budget. We are determined to ensure that we do better.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify actions or timelines for improving spending efficiency
Vague Commitment
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
An incinerator in the constituency regularly breaches air pollution limits, but the Environment Agency does not take action.
Will the Government tell us what they are doing to give the EA teeth?
Incineration permit breaches are a matter for the regulator, the Environment Agency, but we are reviewing energy-from-waste capacity across the country and will be making a statement imminently.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify actions to give the EA more enforcement power
Future Announcement
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Government are expected to promote the purchasing of British-grown and seasonal produce through their public procurement framework.
What action are this Government taking to promote the purchasing of British-grown and seasonal produce through their public procurement framework?
We are absolutely determined to ensure that we see more British produce bought across our public sector. We will come to the House with our plans in due course.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific actions or timelines for promoting procurement of British produce
Future Announcement
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Sir Jon Cunliffe has been appointed to lead a commission reviewing water governance and regulation.
It would be helpful if the Secretary of State encouraged Sir Jon to engage with parliamentarians across the House. The necessary changes that he has outlined will take time, however. The truth of the matter is that if those who currently have responsibility were to change their culture and focus on outcomes for customers, rather than their own internal processes, we might see earlier improvements.
There will be an opportunity for Members to engage with Sir Jon Cunliffe's commission in January, and I am sure that the right hon. Member's Committee will want to do precisely that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify timeline or actions beyond parliamentary engagement
Future Announcement
Response accuracy
Q12
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Alde and Ore Estuary Trust is campaigning for refurbishment of flood defences.
I recently met the Alde and Ore Estuary Trust, which has long been campaigning and fundraising to refurbish and secure flood defences on the Alde and Ore estuary. Will the Minister meet me to discuss the trust's projects and the barriers to progress?
Each time I come here for questions, I promise that I will not arrange to meet as many Members, and each time I fail. I would of course be happy to meet my hon. Friend.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust's Allerton project in Loddington is an example of sustainable food production.
Last year I visited the Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust's Allerton project in Loddington. May I commend the contribution that it can make to defining sustainable intensification of agricultural food production? Perhaps it would be a suitable place for a DEFRA ministerial away day early in the new year, to help with the use strategy.
I thank the right hon. Gentleman for his suggestion. I am a great admirer of the Allerton project and have been meaning to visit it for a long time.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm attending an away day, only expressed admiration and interest in visiting
Future Intention
Response accuracy