Topical Questions 2025-06-30

2025-06-30

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Al Pinkerton LD
Surrey Heath
Context
Following last week's NATO summit in The Hague, where member nations agreed to increase defence spending targets and capability pledges.
I am grateful to the Secretary of State for his response. Now that the Prime Minister has made a cast-iron commitment to meet NATO’s 5% defence spending target, will the Secretary of State make a similarly welcome commitment to cross-party talks to establish a credible and durable path towards meeting that goal ahead of NATO’s 2029 capability review?
I welcome the Liberal Democrats’ support for the commitment we have made at NATO; the Leader of the Opposition was unable to offer that support at Prime Minister’s questions last week. If the hon. Gentleman has ideas about how we should fund that commitment in the next Parliament, I would be perfectly happy to hear them.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to cross-party talks but welcomed support and offered to hear ideas on funding commitments
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Mark Ferguson Lab
Gateshead Central and Whickham
Context
Recent progress in forces housing initiatives has been made, but concerns exist about the Opposition's reprivatisation plan which could undermine current deals.
Does the Minister agree that the Opposition’s half-baked reprivatisation plan would be a huge threat to those in the armed forces and their families?
That is a really valid point. The trouble is that the plan risks the deal we had with Annington. It would outsource all the housing, and take control away from the Government, the Ministry of Defence and the military families who would be living in that housing. Our housing strategy will come in after the summer, and it will be well thought through and delivered.
Assessment & feedback
Did not directly acknowledge threat but highlighted risks associated with reprivatisation plan
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Michelle Welsh Lab
Sherwood Forest
Context
ITP Aero supports over 700 jobs in Hucknall, essential for defence and national security. Concerns about future contracts being completed overseas.
What are this Government doing to ensure that work done under future contracts is completed in the UK, by UK workers?
I thank my hon. Friend for highlighting the vital role of ITP Aero on some of our most important defence platforms, not least Typhoon and the A400M. The strategic defence review makes it clear that we will back British-based businesses where possible, and ITP Aero is already helping to show that defence is an engine for growth in her community.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit explicitly but highlighted government commitment to supporting British businesses through strategic defence review.
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Tristan Osborne Lab
Chatham and Aylesford
Context
Launch of XV Excalibur autonomous submarine vehicle in south England. Inquiry into future investments in autonomous vehicles, unmanned submarines and gliders.
What other investments are being made under the strategic defence review in autonomous vehicles, unmanned submarine technologies, and glider technologies?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising that. Excalibur will be an incredible autonomous asset. The strategic defence review sets out that crewed, uncrewed and autonomous systems will be standard across our armed forces, and at the heart of the review is investment in the people who will be manufacturing and standing behind those systems. That is why, when the defence investment plan comes out later this year, there will be more opportunities for small and medium-sized enterprises, primes and businesses right across the country to invest in our uncrewed and autonomous future in a hybrid military.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific details but highlighted broad commitment under strategic defence review.
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Chris Bloore Lab
Redditch
Context
NATO summit concluded with increased commitments for future defense and deterrence. Question regarding the importance of closer collaboration within NATO.
With the changing nature of the threats we face, does the Secretary of State agree that working even more closely with our NATO allies is crucial to keeping the UK secure at home and stronger abroad?
I do indeed. NATO is bigger, stronger and more lethal than ever before. It is our guarantee that we will never fight alone. That is why the leading contribution that Britain makes to NATO deterrence and defence is a big part of keeping us safe for the future.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Chris Coghlan LD
Dorking and Horley
Context
Concern about the potential impact of President Trump's actions on US military intelligence support for Ukraine, affecting UK support as well.
Do the Government know if the US Government are still providing technical military intelligence support, such as electronic or imagery intelligence for Ukraine? If that were cut off by President Trump, would the Americans effectively restrict our British military technical intelligence support to Ukraine?
The hon. Member will understand that we cannot talk about sharing military intelligence on the Floor of the House, but as he and I have an interest in this, I would be happy to have a conversation with him.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm or deny whether UK support is contingent upon US support; instead suggested off-the-record discussion.
Offered Private Meeting
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Gareth Snell Lab/Co-op
Stoke-on-Trent Central
Context
Concern about the effectiveness of the military covenant in providing adequate support to veterans, especially in urban areas like Stoke-on-Trent.
The North Staffordshire Tri Service and Veterans Support Centre does a wonderful job supporting veterans across Stoke-on-Trent, but all too often, it finds that the military covenant is not working for them. In Stoke-on-Trent in particular, it seems to be failing. What action are this Government taking to ensure that the covenant is worth the paper it is printed on in cities like mine?
I highlight that the Prime Minister has made an announcement about broadening responsibility for the covenant, and the duty of care that it will deliver, from three Government Departments to 14. It will now be for other Departments to ensure that the duty is adhered to across all local councils.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide concrete actions beyond broadening responsibility; focused on departmental accountability.
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Ben Goldsborough Lab
South Norfolk
Context
Concern about the unique challenges faced by veterans living in rural communities, such as South Norfolk.
Some 3,537 of my constituents in South Norfolk are veterans. Being a veteran in a rural community is very different from being one in an urban community. What action are the Government taking to ensure that my veterans have the support they need?
As I have mentioned several times today, the Valour programme will accommodate that. It will not be a service that is a blueprint for everyone, but we will take the geographical differences into account and ensure that it is fit for purpose so that our veterans are given the deal that they deserve.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide concrete actions; focused on general statements about Valour programme.
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Graham Leadbitter SNP
Moray West, Nairn and Strathspey
Context
Concern about a perceived change in the UK's stance on its independent nuclear deterrent following recent announcements.
The strategic defence review, published this month, clearly states: “The foundation of the UK’s approach to deterrence remains a minimum, credible, independent UK nuclear deterrent, assigned to the defence of NATO… The UK’s nuclear weapons are operationally independent.” Somehow, in the last 29 days, the UK Government have decided that they no longer see their Trident nuclear missiles as a minimum credible deterrent. Why was that major change in policy not announced in the SDR?
The Government have made it very clear that our support for our independent nuclear deterrent is solid and is not changing. We are investing in new submarines, we are investing in the base in Faslane, we are investing in new nuclear reactors in Derby, and we are backing the people who keep our country safe with that guarantor of our security, the nuclear deterrent.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address perceived change; focused on current investments and assurances.
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Ben Obese-Jecty Con
Huntingdon
Context
Concern about the stranded F-35B on a runway in India and its potential security risks.
Since 14 June, an F-35B from the Prince of Wales carrier strike group has been stranded on the runway at the Thiruvananthapuram civilian airport in India. What steps are the Government taking to recover the plane, how much longer will that take, and how will the Government ensure the security of protected technologies on the jet while it is in the hangar and out of view?
We continue to work with our Indian friends who provided first-class support when the F-35B was unable to return to the Prince of Wales when on a flight mission, and I am certain that the security of the jet is in good hands because Royal Air Force crew are with it at all times.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific timeline or recovery details; focused on current cooperation and security measures.
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Joe Morris Lab
Hexham
Context
Concern about the fate of missing Ukrainian children in occupied territories or Russia and their need for support.
Given that as many as 35,000 Ukrainian children are still missing and are probably being held in occupied territory or in Russia, will the Minister assure us that the Government are not only taking action to help injured soldiers in Ukraine back on to the frontline, but doing all that they can to support the reunion of Ukrainian children with their families?
We are proud to be investing in Operation Renovator, our contribution to helping injured Ukrainian soldiers to recover and return to the fight to guarantee the safety of their nation, and we will continue to support that operation and our Ukrainian friends for as long as it takes.
Assessment & feedback
Focused on efforts for injured soldiers; did not address children's reunification specifically.
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
John Glen Con
Salisbury
Context
Concern about difficulties in recruiting young men to join the Army, especially in traditional communities.
Infantry regiments cite difficulty in recruiting in their traditional communities and recruitment grounds. Further to the exchange between the Secretary of State and the hon. Member for Epsom and Ewell (Helen Maguire), may I ask what more can be done to encourage, specifically, young British men to join the Army?
Last year 165,000 young people tried to join the British Army. We hired 9,500 of them, but 84% left because the process was too long. We have a superb “attract feature”, but we need to be better at converting, and we are making progress in that regard, although there is more to be done. I am happy to meet the right hon. Gentleman if he has any ideas that might support that.
Assessment & feedback
Focused on process improvements rather than new initiatives; suggested meeting for ideas.
Offered Private Meeting
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Peter Prinsley Lab
Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket
Context
Concern about the development of an integrated air and missile defense system for the UK, especially in light of Germany's preparations.
Sadly, we have all seen the devastation caused by modern missiles. Germany is preparing to receive the Arrow 3 missile defence system, ordered just two years ago, which can intercept intercontinental missiles at 2,500 km. What plans have the Government to equip this country similarly?
One of the recommendations in the strategic defence review was that we develop an integrated air and missile defence system in this country. We must take our homeland security more seriously than we have in the past, and that is exactly what we will do.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific plans or timeline; referenced strategic review recommendation.
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Josh Babarinde LD
Eastbourne
Context
Request for a tribute and condolences after the death of Eastbourne's last surviving war veteran, Eric Deach.
During our last session of Defence questions, I asked the Secretary of State to join me in wishing a happy forthcoming birthday to Eastbourne’s last surviving war veteran, Eric Deach, who was shortly to turn 100. Unfortunately, tomorrow I shall be a pallbearer at his funeral; he did not make it. Will the Secretary of State join me in paying tribute and sending condolences?
[No response provided]
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide any form of acknowledgment or response to the request.
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Calvin Bailey Lab
Leyton and Wanstead
Context
Mr Bailey highlighted the role of cadets in Armed Forces Day celebrations and recognised local air cadet squadrons. He sought to understand the government's approach towards increasing cadet force sizes.
Cadets are a wonderful source of social mobility in our country, and played a key role in last weekend’s Armed Forces Day celebrations. I want to recognise my brilliant local air cadets: 12F Walthamstow and Leyton squadron, and 241 Wanstead and Woodford squadron. Will the Minister set out the Government’s approach to increasing the size of cadet forces in communities like mine so that everyone can benefit from the opportunities that cadets have to offer?
I thank my hon. Friend for all his support for cadet forces and the armed forces. It would be remiss of me not to say that cadet forces provide an excellent social mobility platform for young children across the country by giving them hope, priorities and principles, and pushing them to be determined. This Government have committed to raising the cadet force by 30%, and to giving more children across the country better opportunities.
Assessment & feedback
The response did not provide specific plans or timelines for increasing cadet forces in communities like Mr Bailey’s, despite being asked about them.
Response accuracy