Topical Questions 2026-01-12

2026-01-12

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Direct Answer
Peter Prinsley Lab
Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket
Context
The MP is concerned about the lack of affordable housing in villages within his constituency. He mentions that people in his area are worried about this issue.
I am concerned about the villages in my most beautiful constituency of Bury St Edmunds and Stowmarket; there, people tell me that they are increasingly concerned about the lack of affordable housing in rural communities. What steps is the Minister taking to increase the supply of affordable housing for local people in rural villages through reforms to the planning system, and how will those reforms support the rejuvenation and long-term sustainability of our villages?
Our planning changes will support affordable rural housing by giving rural authorities greater flexibility to require affordable housing on smaller sites. Our £39 billion social and affordable homes programme, which opens to bids next month, is available to rural authorities as well.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Direct Answer
James Cleverly Con
Braintree
Context
The MP is concerned about the impact of increased business rates on high street businesses, citing a specific example in Streatham.
So many words, yet no answer. I asked the Secretary of State specifically about a fourfold increase, like the one that the White Lion on Streatham High Road in his constituency faces. We are talking about a 400% increase, even after transitional relief, from £3,000 a year to £12,000 a year. Will he urge the Chancellor to scrap business rates for businesses like the White Lion on Streatham High Road, and other hospitality and leisure businesses on the high street?
I am sure that the right hon. Gentleman knows that the measures put in place during the pandemic were always intended to come to an end; his Government were going to do the same thing. The Chancellor is looking at the impact of revaluation. She is fully aware of the concerns raised by publicans in Streatham and across the country, and is reviewing the situation, and we expect an announcement in due course.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Direct Answer
Mary Kelly Foy Lab
City of Durham
Context
The MP is concerned about stalled major planning applications in the City of Durham, which have resulted in economic and social impacts.
T3. Major planning applications in Durham, such as those for the Milburngate site and Stack in the city centre, have been stalled for years. This has not only left two white elephants in the city centre, but had a significant impact on jobs, the economy and key venues that have been left undeveloped. What steps is the Minister taking to ensure that major developments in the City of Durham and across the country are not subject to long delays?
While I appreciate my hon. Friend’s concern, we have strengthened policies in the draft national planning policy framework, which is currently out for consultation, that will ensure that major residential schemes are built out in reasonable time. I am more than happy to have a conversation with her about how that may impact developments in her constituency.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Direct Answer
Munira Wilson LD
Twickenham
Context
The MP is concerned about the negative financial impact of a local government funding settlement on their constituency, affecting vulnerable residents.
T2. The Secretary of State will be aware that the so-called fair funding settlement will leave my council of Richmond upon Thames some £29 million worse off over the next three years. It will leave our most vulnerable residents, including children with complex needs and elderly people, facing cuts in critical services, even if the council raises council tax by 5%. Will he extend the transitional period?
I have heard what the hon. Member has said, and will take it as a contribution to the consultation that we are having. She mentions the needs of children; she will have heard me say to colleagues that we have to change the way that we work on this issue. I will happily work with her to ensure that we cut the costs and get better outcomes for our kids.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Luke Evans Con
Hinckley and Bosworth
Context
There are conflicting plans in Leicestershire for local government reorganisation, with no agreement on any of them.
The Government insist on forcing through local government reorganisation when there is no agreement in Leicestershire. There are three different plans ahead. One thing that Leicestershire does agree on is no expansion of Leicester city. Will the Minister put that to the test and have a referendum on it, so that the people of Leicestershire can show the Government just how much they do not want the city expansion?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his input on the reorganisation. As I mentioned moments ago, we have set out the process that we will undertake. We will consult fully and judge each proposal against the criteria that we have set out.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the specific request for a referendum on the city expansion in Leicester.
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Liz Twist Lab
Blaydon and Consett
Context
The recovery grant guarantee is a mechanism to protect the most deprived authorities.
The recovery grant guarantee is a vital mechanism that protects the most deprived authorities. Will the Department commit to increasing the guarantee to match the national average core spending power increase, so that the areas that need funding most are fairly protected?
I thank my hon. Friend for her comments on the fair funding review and the recovery grant, which was needed due to the significant damage done to council finances by 14 years of Tory misrule. I have already met scores of colleagues to discuss council funding, and I will meet scores more over the next couple of days. I look forward to talking with my hon. Friend about the proposal she mentions.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a clear commitment to increasing the guarantee as requested.
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Ayoub Khan Ind
Birmingham Perry Barr
Context
Residents of Birmingham have marked the first anniversary of bin strikes, costing over £15 million on agency staff.
Birmingham residents have just marked the first anniversary of the bin strikes. We have spent more than £15 million on agency staff. Will the Minister personally intervene to help broker a deal between the trade unions and Birmingham city council?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for raising the needs of Birmingham residents. They should come first, and everybody deserves a good bin service. We want all parties to come to the table and deal with this as swiftly as humanly possible.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide commitment to personally intervene.
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Jonathan Brash Lab
Hartlepool
Context
Some southern local authorities are bundling vulnerable people into taxis in the middle of the night and dumping them in Hartlepool.
In purporting to discharge their homelessness duties, some southern local authorities are bundling vulnerable people into taxis in the middle of the night and dumping them in Hartlepool because our housing is cheaper. They are acting in a vile way. I welcome the fact that the Minister has written to me and set out her belief that we need to ban this poor practice. Does she agree that we need to ban it outright?
I would like to give personal thanks to my hon. Friend for his comments on this issue. In the homelessness strategy, we noted that this problem is extraordinarily challenging and important, and I want to take action on it. I thank him for the work that he has done on behalf of Hartlepool residents. We will continue to work together to sort this problem out.
Assessment & feedback
Did not explicitly confirm support for banning such practices.
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Alicia Kearns Con
Rutland and Stamford
Context
The council in Rutland did not consult residents properly on the local government reform proposals.
Rutland’s council could have submitted its own proposals for local government reform, but it has left our fate in the hands of others. The council submitted a proposal to join North Leicestershire, but this is in opposition to the wishes of residents. The council knows that, and purposely did not ask residents what we wanted. Stamford residents want to join Rutland; Rutlanders want to join Stamford. Will the Minister meet me to make sure that all residents are consulted on the Rutland and Stamford model, which the council has taken off the table?
I congratulate the hon. Lady for laying out to the House what sounds like a complicated situation for her constituents. We will take what she says under advisement, as part of the process. I am always happy to make myself available to meet Members of this House.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to specifically meeting the MP to address the issue.
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Elsie Blundell Lab
Heywood and Middleton North
Context
Many local authorities are spending less than 1% of their household support fund on essential items like furniture, affecting survivors of domestic abuse.
With many local authorities spending less than 1% of their household support fund on furniture, many domestic abuse survivors are being placed in social housing without access to essential furniture or white goods. What assurances can the Minister give this winter to residents in Heywood and Middleton North who, although grateful for the fresh start that social housing can offer, are living—often with children—in properties that feel bare, cold and not like home?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising that really important issue. One of the reasons why I and the Safeguarding Minister, my hon. Friend the Member for Birmingham Yardley (Jess Phillips), worked closely together on both the homelessness strategy and the violence against women and girls strategy was to ensure that that area of policy joined up—16% of homelessness is caused by domestic abuse. That is why we will not stop until those families leaving refuge have a decent place to be—including the furniture they need—to make a house a home.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific assurances for this winter.
Response accuracy
Q11 Partial Answer
Josh Babarinde LD
Eastbourne
Context
Individuals in East Sussex are finding it difficult to secure accommodation despite the severe weather emergency protocol having ended.
The severe weather emergency protocol has ended in East Sussex. Today, five individuals who were provided with accommodation under it came into my constituency office, not knowing where to turn. We have amazing local charities doing great work, but will the Minister offer advice to those folks who have come into the office in desperate need of support to get out of the situation they are in?
I thank the hon. Member so much for raising that case on the Floor of the House in the way he did. It shows all the different reasons why people can find themselves without a roof over their head. The local authority should be in the lead in supporting them, but if he wants to contact me with further details, I will ensure that the local authority has the support it needs.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific advice or direct support.
Response accuracy
Q12 Partial Answer
Lee Barron Lab
Corby and East Northamptonshire
Context
There is a £20 million investment in the 'pride of Corby' project, but it's crucial that local communities determine how to spend the funds.
I am proud to have secured a £20 million investment in the “pride of Corby” project—that is £2 million a year every year for the next 10 years—but it is crucial that local communities determine how and where the investment is spent. Does my hon. Friend agree that the money must be spent on exactly what the community actually wants, with residents properly consulted and local people as the decision makers?
My hon. Friend is completely right. We are clear that communities must be in the driving seat. That is why we have asked for neighbourhood boards to be set up, to determine the priorities that the investment goes into. The one requirement we have of local areas is that there is a bigger conversation with residents about what they want and need.
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm full support without conditions.
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
Ayoub Khan Ind
Birmingham Perry Barr
Context
Residents of Birmingham have marked the first anniversary of bin strikes, costing over £15 million on agency staff.
Birmingham residents have just marked the first anniversary of the bin strikes. We have spent more than £15 million on agency staff. Will the Minister personally intervene to help broker a deal between the trade unions and Birmingham city council?
I thank the hon. Gentleman for raising this issue, which is clearly very important in his constituency. We know that these disputes are difficult and can be distressing for local residents. We want to support both sides to find a resolution as quickly as possible.
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to personal intervention.
Response accuracy
Q14 Partial Answer
Ellie Chowns Green
North Herefordshire
Context
The hon. Member is concerned about the environmental impact of building construction and operation.
When will the Government take steps to address embodied carbon in buildings?
The hon. Lady can look forward to the future buildings standards being brought into force later this year.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific details on addressing embodied carbon beyond mentioning future standards.
Response accuracy
Q15 Direct Answer
Chris Vince Lab/Co-op
Harlow
Context
The MP has received increased casework from residents suffering from damp and mould in their homes. The issue is exacerbated by a new law aimed at improving social housing conditions.
Across the winter months, I have received an increased amount of casework from residents of Harlow who are suffering from damp and mould in their houses. They deserve quicker repairs and higher standards from landlords. Of course, Awaab’s law is to be welcomed, but will the Secretary of State confirm what enforcement measures will be used to ensure that landlords adhere to the legislation?
Landlords will face the full force of the law if they fail to comply with regulations that have now come into force thanks to Awaab’s law. We expect social housing to get a lot better than tenants have seen over recent decades.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q16 Evasion / No Answer
Graham Stuart Con
Beverley and Holderness
Context
The local government settlement has reduced the budget for East Riding of Yorkshire council by £27 million over three years, leading to potential service cuts and higher council tax.
The local government settlement strips £27 million from East Riding of Yorkshire council. I learned today that there will be an additional £21 million cost over the next three years from the minimum wage and the jobs tax. Does the Minister really think it is acceptable that local residents should have sky-high council tax rises and falling quality of services?
The hon. Gentleman and I were both in this House for the entire period of austerity, which landed at the door of town halls more than almost anywhere else, so if he wants to look for someone to blame for the parlous state of council finances, I would recommend a mirror.
Assessment & feedback
Redirected criticism back to the questioner and blamed austerity policies.
Blame Shifting
Response accuracy
Q17 Direct Answer
Leigh Ingham Lab
Stafford
Context
Some buildings in Stafford are left vacant and deteriorating, causing concerns about property hoarding and urban decay.
Several prominent buildings in Stafford have been left vacant for long periods, with landlords allowing sites to fall into disrepair with no intention of bringing them up to standard. Labour-led Stafford borough council is trying to act proactively to tackle these eyesores, but what advice and support can the Government offer to good councils that are seeking to address property hoarding and to unlock sites for regeneration?
We are clear that we want to boost the power of communities to revive their places. This is why we are rolling out high street rental auctions, stronger and more streamlined compulsory purchase powers, the community right to buy, and Pride in Place, and we will work with any council that wants to take back control of its place and revive its communities.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Iqbal Mohamed Ind
Dewsbury and Batley
Context
The Dewsbury main cemetery is approaching full capacity, with only two remaining plots for Muslim burials. The issue has been known about for several years but remains urgent.
The main cemetery in Dewsbury is approaching capacity following the increase in burials since the covid pandemic. The local authority has been aware of this issue for several years. However, there remains significant uncertainty and concerns are becoming increasingly urgent. The issue is of particular cultural and religious significance, with only two burial plots remaining for Muslim burials. What steps will the Secretary of State take to support local authorities in addressing burial capacity shortages in Kirklees?
We are conscious of the pressure in parts of the country around cemeteries and burials, and we understand the urgency. I ask the hon. Member to write to me with the specifics of the issue in his patch, and we will respond in due course.
Assessment & feedback
Directed the questioner to follow up through a written communication.
Written Communication
Response accuracy
Q19 Partial Answer
Rachael Maskell Lab/Co-op
York Central
Context
The local housing allowance covers less than half the cost of private rents in York, highlighting affordability issues.
The local housing allowance covers just over half of private rents for social tenants in York, as private rents are so extortionate, so will the Government review the broad rental market area, which does not work for our area? It has not been reviewed properly since 2008.
I am working closely with my Department for Work and Pensions colleagues, and we know that there are many problems with affordability in the private rented sector. Ministers have mentioned some of the actions we are taking today, but we will be working with the DWP to do more.
Assessment & feedback
Acknowledged issues but did not provide a specific timeline for review.
Response accuracy
Q20 Direct Answer
Helen Morgan LD
North Shropshire
Context
Shropshire council has faced budget cuts and an increase in demand for social care, raising concerns about its future financial stability.
Shropshire council had its funding cut in the local government finance settlement, despite needing exceptional financial support this year and a surge in demand for social care in the years to come that cannot be managed down by the council. Will the Minister meet me to discuss how to put Shropshire on a stable financial footing?
I have already met the hon. Lady and I would be very happy to meet her again.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q21 Direct Answer
Catherine Atkinson Lab
Derby North
Context
New residential areas are being developed without adequate transportation, causing issues for residents and future development.
Hundreds of new homes are being built at the Friar Gate goods yard, originally a 19th-century rail depot. This development is near the city centre, but other housing that was built further out under the Conservatives went up with inadequate transport infrastructure and little thought for public transport. What is being done to ensure that new homes have the transport infrastructure that they need?
I am more than happy to sit down with my hon. Friend and discuss the matter in more detail.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy
Q22 Partial Answer
Jess Brown-Fuller LD
Chichester
Context
Residents of a new housing development were suddenly faced with significant price increases for road maintenance services.
Constituents on a new build estate in Chichester were ordered without warning to pay an extra £180 a month on top of the £212 that they were already paying. When the Government bring forward their planned legislation, will they stamp out these enormous price hikes and will they hold road management companies to account?
As I have said, we are intending to switch on the relevant provisions in the Leasehold and Freehold Reform Act 2024 that provide consumers with protections. I would encourage the hon. Lady to submit her views to the consultation, and I am more than happy to pick this up with her outside the Chamber.
Assessment & feedback
Directed the questioner towards submitting views through a consultation process.
Consultation Process
Response accuracy
Q23 Partial Answer
Anneliese Midgley Lab
Knowsley
Context
There is a need to ensure that local authorities in the most deprived areas receive adequate funding support.
Will the Minister consider enabling all local authorities in the most deprived areas to have an above-average increase in core spending power in each year of the local government multi-year settlement, including in Liverpool city region?
I am proud to say that this settlement reconnects council funding with deprivation, and I have already explained the detail of that to the House. We will continue working towards that goal.
Assessment & feedback
Acknowledged concerns but did not provide specific commitments for above-average increases.
Response accuracy
Q24 Direct Answer
Context
Shropshire council has faced budget cuts and an increase in demand for social care, raising concerns about its future financial stability.
Shropshire council had its funding cut in the local government finance settlement, despite needing exceptional financial support this year and a surge in demand for social care in the years to come that cannot be managed down by the council. Will the Minister meet me to discuss how to put Shropshire on a stable financial footing?
I have already met the hon. Lady and I would be very happy to meet her again.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy