Topical Questions 2025-06-02

2025-06-02

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
David Simmonds Con
Ruislip, Northwood and Pinner
Context
Hillingdon council hosts the most asylum seekers per capita in the country with a funding shortfall of £5 million annually.
On Friday in my constituency I met the leader of Hillingdon council, which hosts 3,000 asylum seekers in Home Office accommodation—the most per capita of any local authority in the country. He told me that the council faces a £5 million per annum funding shortfall, which is more than its entire budget for libraries and culture on supporting asylum seekers. What plans does the Home Secretary have to ensure that local authorities are reimbursed in full for the role they play in supporting asylum seekers in this country?
The hon. Member raises an important point, and we did inherit an unacceptable asylum backlog, including huge and unacceptable bills for asylum accommodation. We have already brought the bills for asylum accommodation down, saving hundreds of millions of pounds, with hundreds of millions of pounds more to be saved over the course of this year. That is a result of the action we are taking to clear the backlog that the previous Government left us with, and as part of that we are working with the Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government on how to co-ordinate support for local councils.
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide specific plans or assurances about full reimbursement for Hillingdon council
Working With The Ministry Of Housing, Communities And Local Government
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Peter Lamb Lab
Crawley
Context
The Tinsley House and Brook House immigration removal centres in Crawley have faced a scandal.
Crawley is home to the Tinsley House and Brook House immigration removal centres, and their associated scandal. What consideration is being given to the Home Affairs Committee’s inquiry into immigration detention, including ending the use of such centres for indefinite detention?
Immigration centres are not used for indefinite detention. We can only keep anyone in detention in an immigration centre if there is a reasonable prospect of their removal. If there is not, they have to be released.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the Home Affairs Committee's inquiry or mention ending the use of centres for indefinite detention
Immigration Centres Are Not Used For Indefinite Detention
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Chris Philp Con
Croydon South
Context
Small boat crossings have increased to unprecedented levels under the current government.
On the Home Secretary’s watch, this year so far has been the worst in history for illegal immigrants crossing the channel. The Government’s laughable claim to “smash the gangs” lies in tatters—they are not smashing gangs; they are smashing records. What consideration is being given to suspending the 12-year fishing deal with France until they take action against smuggling gangs?
Let me remind the shadow Home Secretary that when he was Immigration Minister he said: “I will continue to push my French counterparts to look hard at interceptions at sea.” Five years of Conservative government later, the French Government had not agreed to any changes at all. This Government have reached a new agreement with France, and we are now pressing for that to be operationalised as swiftly as possible.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address suspending fishing deal but criticized previous government's record on cooperation with France
Five Years Of Conservative Government Later, The French Government Had Not Agreed To Any Changes At All
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Jake Richards Lab
Rother Valley
Context
Unaccompanied children arriving in the country are placed in inappropriate and unsafe accommodations.
At the Home Affairs Committee, we have heard worrying evidence about unaccompanied children arriving in this country and being placed in wholly unsuitable accommodation, including staying in rooms with adult males, which presents safeguarding risks. Clearly, there are issues about the age assessment process at the border and the responsibility of the contractors who organise the accommodation. Will the Minister tell the House what steps the Government are taking to ensure children in this country are safe?
When people arrive and claim to be children, there are tests at the border to check whether we think they are children. If they are accepted as children, they are put into local authority care, so they should not be in asylum accommodation at all. If they are seen to be adults and end up in asylum accommodation, they can always make an appeal to the local authority that they are in and undergo what is known as a Merton age assessment test, which will decide on their age once and for all.
Assessment & feedback
Did not address the issue of inappropriate accommodations or safeguarding risks directly
When People Arrive And Claim To Be Children, There Are Tests At The Border
Response accuracy
Q5 Direct Answer
Chi Onwurah Lab
Newcastle upon Tyne Central and West
Context
Residents in Newcastle reported concerns about nuisance vehicles such as illegal e-bikes, off-road bikes, and speeding cars. The chief constable of Northumbria noted the force has already tripled impoundments over recent years.
Residents in Westerhope told me how nuisance vehicles are making their lives miserable, and I have had similar complaints from residents in Slatyford and Newbiggin. Given that police forces are already working hard but need more enforcement powers, will the Minister set out how her new proposals under the Crime and Policing Bill will improve this situation?
I welcome what my hon. Friend has said; this is a problem up and down the land. At the moment, police forces are doing their best, but the Crime and Policing Bill will allow them to seize vehicles that are being used in an antisocial way, without having to give any warnings, and then to destroy them. That is the way forward, but I pay tribute to the work that is already ongoing with police forces.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Wendy Morton Con
Aldridge-Brownhills
Context
The Home Secretary has not been able to put a cap on illegal immigration, leading to record numbers of boat crossings.
Since taking office almost a year ago, the Home Secretary has failed to put a cap on illegal immigration or deterrence in place. This weekend’s record number of boat crossings shows that her plan is clearly not working. What can she say to constituents about how she plans to take control of our borders?
Given that the right hon. Member was a member of the previous Government, her question might be rather more plausible if she apologised for the 100-fold increase in small boat crossings under her Government’s watch and for the quadrupling of net migration as a result of the policies that she supported in government.
Assessment & feedback
The Home Secretary redirected criticism to the previous government instead of addressing specific issues related to illegal immigration.
Redirecting Blame
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Amanda Hack Lab
North West Leicestershire
Context
The ban on disposable vapes came into effect this week, raising concerns about the importation of counterfeit and banned products.
In light of the new ban on disposable vapes, what measures are being taken to prevent counterfeit and banned vapes from entering the country through ports such as East Midlands airport?
While Border Force does not routinely disclose information of a port-specific nature, in the calendar year of 2024 it seized approximately 300,000 e-cigarettes and vapes at the UK border. Border Force has a robust approach to seizures based on intelligence received from its partners.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister did not provide specific details about measures being taken at East Midlands Airport.
Non-Specific Response
Response accuracy
Q8 Partial Answer
Julie Minns Lab
Carlisle
Context
There is concern that Deliveroo riders are subcontracting to unregistered and potentially illegal workers.
In my constituency, there are concerns about Deliveroo riders subcontracting to unregistered and possibly illegally working individuals. What steps are being taken to ensure all Deliveroo riders are registered and compliant?
There is an amendment to the Border Security, Asylum and Immigration Bill that extends the requirement to check illegal working to the gig economy, the zero-hours economy and all those areas that have non-traditional employer-employee relationships. I look forward to being able to operationalise that when the Bill becomes law.
Assessment & feedback
The Minister provided future plans but did not address immediate concerns.
Future Planning
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Lee Pitcher Lab
Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme
Context
The Doncaster East neighbourhood policing team has seized stolen off-road bikes using drones and high-visibility patrols, improving community safety.
In light of the success in tackling antisocial behaviour with drones and patrols, can the Minister provide an update on the progress of the neighbourhood policing guarantee and when named police officers will be present in Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme?
I welcome the work that South Yorkshire police has been doing and the Doncaster East neighbourhood policing team going after the offroad bikes, which cause havoc and are a total nightmare in the community. They are getting additional neighbourhood police as part of the neighbourhood policing guarantee, and we will give them stronger powers to keep the streets safe.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Direct Answer
Karen Bradley Con
Staffordshire Moorlands
Context
Karen Bradley has tabled an amendment to the Crime and Policing Bill, proposing to extend the definition of exploitation in the Modern Slavery Act to include orphanage trafficking. This issue affects about 5 million children worldwide.
Can I draw the Home Secretary’s attention to the amendment I have tabled to the Crime and Policing Bill, which would extend the definition of exploitation in the Modern Slavery Act to include orphanage trafficking? It is a horrific crime that affects about 100,000 children across the world, and it is something we need to recognise in our legislation.
The Chair of the Select Committee raises a very important point. I know that she has a strong interest in this issue that goes back many years, and has taken strong action herself on modern slavery. We will look at the amendment she has tabled, and are happy to discuss it with her further.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11 Direct Answer
Claire Hazelgrove Lab
Filton and Bradley Stoke
Context
A stabbing incident involving a 15-year-old boy occurred in Cribbs Causeway, resulting in charges against three 16-year-old boys. This has raised concerns about the number of young people involved in serious violence.
Last week, my whole community was shocked and appalled to hear about the stabbing of a 15-year-old boy in Cribbs Causeway. Thankfully, he is stable, and I know we will all be thinking of him and his family at this time. Three 16-year-old boys have been charged. Could the Minister please set out what steps the Government are taking to tackle knife crime, including among young people who could have much brighter futures?
I convey all thoughts to the family of the victim in this awful stabbing case, and all of those affected across the community. My hon. Friend is right to raise the deep concerns that exist about the number of young people getting drawn into serious violence—we are seeing this across the board. That is why the Young Futures prevention programme is so important, and why we need to work to prevent this by strengthening the law on child criminal exploitation.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Sarah Pochin Reform
Runcorn and Helsby
Context
There is a removal van outside an illegal immigrant hotel in Sarah Pochin's constituency, raising concerns about the status and housing arrangements of these individuals.
As I speak, there is a removal van outside the illegal immigrant hotel in my constituency—let us hope they are moving them out, not moving more in. Can the Secretary of State assure my constituents that these illegal immigrants are not being dispersed in the community, being housed in houses in multiple occupation owned by private landlords, and will she advise me on where they will be housed?
Anyone who is in a hotel is someone who has claimed asylum, and whose asylum claim is pending. They are not necessarily illegal immigrants at all, and the hon. Lady should make that position clear.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Direct Answer
Jayne Kirkham Lab/Co-op
Truro and Falmouth
Context
Dr Mohammed Mohsen was offered a position at Royal Cornwall hospital but has been unable to travel due to ongoing conflict and travel restrictions in Gaza.
Last year, Dr Mohammed Mohsen was offered a position in the acute medicine department at Royal Cornwall hospital in my constituency. He was due to start that role last year, but due to the ongoing conflict and travel restrictions in Gaza, he has been unable to travel to the UK. Would the Minister meet me to consider his case, as he requires urgent assistance?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising this matter, and I am very happy to meet her. The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office is working to ensure that those who need to leave Gaza, and are able and eligible to do so, are supported in that. I am very happy to look at this matter with my hon. Friend.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14 Direct Answer
Harpreet Uppal Lab
Huddersfield
Context
Local organizations involved in addressing violence against women and girls are hindered by short-term funding, leading to a need for multi-year contracts.
At a recent roundtable on violence against women and girls hosted by the Mayor of West Yorkshire, we heard from local organisations that do outstanding work but are hampered by short-term funding, as well as from a brave survivor who shared her experiences. They specifically asked for the Government to commit to strategic investment. Will the Minister review contracts with the sector so they are multi-year and take a long-term view of service delivery and preventive work?
My hon. Friend makes an important point that short-term funding massively hampers the sector. The vast majority of violence against women and girls funding comes from local authorities and, in fact, other Departments, but I will absolutely commit to looking at how the Home Office manages its contracts to ensure sustainability.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy