Topical Questions 2025-11-03

2025-11-03

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Lorraine Beavers Lab
Blackpool North and Fleetwood
Context
Service leavers in the constituency are experiencing homelessness and addiction before receiving necessary support.
Across our country, service leavers like Brady, a 29-year-old from my constituency, are experiencing homelessness and addiction before receiving the support they need. I welcome the Government’s work on the renewed armed forces covenant, but does the Minister agree that structured and timely health and welfare checks following discharge would strengthen that promise to veterans like Brady?
We have significant processes in place before exit to ensure a smooth transition, particularly to manage personnel who are wounded, injured or sick, and the Valour initiative should help us take steps to better co-ordinate support for veterans. I can assure my hon. Friend that improving how service personnel leave the services is a key priority for me.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Lee Anderson Reform
Ashfield
I have a really simple question: do this Government consider China a national security threat?
No one word can sum up a country as significant and as complex as China, but our experience tells us that China is certainly an economic threat, as well as an opportunity in many areas.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Vikki Slade LD
Mid Dorset and North Poole
Context
Veteran constituents have experienced long delays in receiving payments under the armed forces compensation scheme.
Several of my veteran constituents have contacted me about very long delays in payments under the armed forces compensation scheme. Mr Butler, who lives near Wareham, has two separate claims—one for hearing loss and another for an arm injury—and has been waiting two years for an outcome. As we look forward to Remembrance Sunday and reflect on the sacrifices made, what steps is the Department taking to ensure that we pay our debts to those who have served us more recently?
I thank the hon. Member for raising the case of her constituent. If she writes to me with the details, I will look into exactly why it has taken that long.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Helen Morgan LD
North Shropshire
Context
There have been reports of rat infestations at RAF Shawbury in the constituency.
I have been campaigning on service family accommodation since shortly after my election, so I welcome the Government’s commitment to improving it over the past few weeks. However, single living accommodation continues to be a considerable concern. There have recently been reports of rat infestations at RAF Shawbury in my constituency. What will the Government do to improve single living accommodation, which is equally as important as service family accommodation?
We will shortly start our single living accommodation review to address exactly those points—the sometimes shocking state of such accommodation and what we can do to support the people who live in it.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Ben Spencer Con
Runnymede and Weybridge
According to media reports, the Secretary of State recently revealed in a speech that the UK had deployed troops to Israel to monitor the ceasefire in Gaza. Could he take this opportunity to update the House on the number and activities of any troops deployed there?
The hon. Gentleman is not correct in saying that the troops are there to monitor the ceasefire. A small handful of British forces personnel have been deployed to the Civil-Military Co-ordination Centre at the request of the US, and it is the US that is leading that work.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Joani Reid Lab
East Kilbride and Strathaven
Context
Babcock is recruiting overseas welders due to a skills shortage.
Recent reports show that Babcock is having to recruit hundreds of overseas welders because of a skills shortage in Scotland. This is the direct result of decades of under-investment in further education and skills in Scotland. Can the Minister outline what the UK Government can do to ensure that my constituents can access the apprenticeships and skills that defence jobs depend on?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. If only we had a Scottish Government who were investing in defence skills rather than one who dither on defence. The Scottish Government did not invest in the welding centre in Glasgow; it required a Labour Government in the UK to step in and invest. We are delivering for defence. The Scottish Government are dithering on defence, and they are letting jobs slip out of their hands as a result.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Lincoln Jopp Con
Spelthorne
Context
In response to the Secretary of State's comment regarding the SNP as a threat, Lincoln Jopp asks about China's standing in national security.
Now that the Secretary of State has warmed up a bit by calling the SNP a threat to our national security, will he have another go and say whether China is a threat to our national security?
I have nothing to add to what I said in response to the hon. Member for Ashfield (Lee Anderson), who asked the same question. What a waste of a question.
Assessment & feedback
Specific statement on China's threat level was avoided by referring to a previous answer.
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Amanda Martin Lab
Portsmouth North
Context
The hon. Member for Portsmouth North welcomes the Government's Op Valour pilot but expresses disappointment that Portsmouth is not part of it, asking for reassurance and support.
I very much welcome the Government’s Op Valour pilot programme and the Minister’s commitment to improving support for our veterans. However, I am disappointed that Portsmouth—home to the Royal Navy and one of the largest veteran communities—is not part of the programme. Can the Minister reassure me that councils like Portsmouth city council will be encouraged and supported to join Op Valour and look after the veterans who live in our city?
I share my hon. Friend’s disappointment. Valour is a £50 million programme that will bring together a network of regional hubs to ensure that there is a physical location where veterans can go to seek help. I urge every region of the UK to get involved.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Sarah Bool Con
South Northamptonshire
Context
The hon. Member highlights an issue raised by EKA Ltd and service personnel regarding the absence of robust spare parts provision for MOD service recovery vehicles, requesting a review and meeting to discuss.
EKA Ltd in my constituency is a supplier to Ministry of Defence service recovery vehicles that have to be deployed with our tanks, but an issue that it and other service personnel have highlighted is the absence of the provision of robust spare parts in the event of a breakdown or damage. The Government are spending millions on these assets but leaving them completely unprotected. Is the MOD reviewing the provision of spares as part of its procurement, and would the Minister meet me and EKA Ltd to discuss the matter further?
I am happy to meet the hon. Lady to discuss this further. The last Government, I am afraid, left not only our weapons stockpiles almost empty, but far too many of our parts stockpiles as well. We are looking at investing in that as part of our defence investment plan, but I am happy to meet her to discuss the matter further.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Partial Answer
Brian Leishman Ind
Alloa and Grangemouth
Context
The hon. Member questions the idea of an industrial strategy based on militarism, citing Tony Benn and Mick McGahey's perspectives.
Two giants of the Labour and anti-nuclear arms movement would have been 100 this year: Tony Benn and Mick McGahey. I never had the pleasure of meeting either, but I think they would have recognised that an industrial strategy based on militarism is flawed. The defence sector is less than 1% of the UK workforce, so militarism is not a UK-wide industry and it serves war, not peace. What happened to choosing welfare over warfare, and to choosing jobs in sectors that will promote real economic growth and actual social benefit?
I have to say that my hon. Friend is wrong on this. Over 400,000 jobs are supported—directly and indirectly—by defence, and almost 70% of the defence investment we make in this country is outside London and the south-east, right across the UK.
Assessment & feedback
Specific statement on militarism's role as an industry was avoided by mentioning job figures.
Response accuracy
Q11 Direct Answer
Helen Maguire LD
Epsom and Ewell
Context
The hon. Member highlights the inconsistency in medical discharge processes across units, asking about steps being taken to improve this.
People’s experiences of medical discharge from the armed forces vary significantly, and too often it fails those who need the support most. What steps is the Minister taking to improve the discharge process, including improving consistency across units?
I thank the hon. Member for raising an important point. Making sure that service personnel who leave under the medical discharge are fully set up for success in their post-service life is fundamental and a huge priority for me.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Dave Robertson Lab
Lichfield
Context
The hon. Member mentions the F-35 Lightning II aircraft helmets from his constituency, asking for reassurance on the cost of introducing new tactical nuclear freefall bombs.
Last week I had the honour and privilege of attending the dedication of the new LGBT+ armed forces community memorial at the National Memorial Arboretum in Alrewas in my constituency, alongside His Majesty the King, proud veterans and members of our armed forces. Will the Minister join me in commending the unveiling of this important memorial, and does she agree that it will serve as a lasting reminder of the injustice and discrimination suffered by LGBT+ service personnel and as a powerful symbol of our commitment to equality and respect for all those who serve?
It was clear to see how much that event meant to the LGBT+ veterans, many of whom had suffered terribly under the ban. Many said to me that they never thought this day would come. I hope that the event itself and the memorial will serve as a lasting reminder of our responsibilities going forward.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Partial Answer
John Cooper Con
Dumfries and Galloway
Context
The hon. Member inquires about the cost implications of introducing new tactical nuclear freefall bombs with F-35A, requesting reassurance.
The F-35 Lightning II aircraft is a cutting-edge system, the helmets for which come from my constituency, but the Public Accounts Committee has the MOD in missile lock over the cost of introducing the new nuclear freefall bombs with the F-35A. Can the Minister give the House some reassurance that the decision to bring in tactical nuclear weapons is not going to cost us a bomb?
Assessment & feedback
Specific statement on costs was avoided by a brief response.
Response accuracy