Topical Questions 2025-12-09

2025-12-09

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Meg Hillier Lab/Co-op
Hackney South and Shoreditch
Context
The OBR has faced criticism recently, with the publication of budget documents ahead of time being a notable issue.
Would the Chief Secretary or the Chancellor like to remind people about the role of the fiscal risks and sustainability report, which does look longer term at the economy, and the importance that this has in planning?
I have huge respect for the Office for Budget Responsibility, and I reappointed Richard Hughes for a second term earlier this year. We deeply regret the publication of the Budget document ahead of the Budget. Richard Hughes has apologised for that and has resigned, but I thanked him for his leadership of the OBR. My hon. Friend is right to point to the longer-term risks that the OBR also points out.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Edward Morello LD
West Dorset
Context
Rural areas face higher costs for delivering public services compared to urban areas.
Will the Treasury commit to reviewing the funding formula, so that local government, integrated care boards, fire services and all our vital community services get the funding that rural communities deserve?
The Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government recently published “English indices of deprivation 2025”, which included the supplementary report on how deprivation manifests in rural areas. I can assure the hon. Gentleman that the Government will further consider those assessments of deprivation, as well as other inputs, when deciding funding models for local areas.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Dave Robertson Lab
Lichfield
Context
Constituents are concerned about the fairness of energy bill reductions.
What steps will the Chancellor take with Cabinet colleagues to ensure that reductions in energy bills are reflected in standing charges, not just in unit prices?
Energy bills are too high. The Conservatives left Britain dependent on the rollercoaster of gas prices, and left families paying almost £2 billion on bills for their failed energy efficiency scheme, the energy company obligation. We are scrapping ECO and taking some of the expensive levies off bills. My hon. Friend makes an important point about standing charges. He will know that Ofgem continues to consider low standing charge tariffs for exactly the reason that he raises.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Wendy Chamberlain LD
North East Fife
Context
There is concern about the adequacy of in-person banking services, particularly in rural areas.
When will the Government agree to have the Financial Conduct Authority review the criteria for access to banking services?
I am afraid that I must disagree with the hon. Lady when she says that 350 is a meaningless number, but of course we understand the importance of in-person banking for rural communities. The location of banking hubs is determined independently by Link, and the criteria are a matter for the FCA, but I regularly meet MPs to discuss the adequacy and the application of those rules.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Gill German Lab
Clwyd North
Context
The second rise in the national minimum wage has impacted workers, particularly younger ones.
What assessment has been made of the impact of the national minimum wage rise on younger workers?
About 300,000 young workers are expected to benefit from the national minimum wage increases in April 2026. The Low Pay Commission was given a remit to develop its preferred path and pace for the equalisation of the 18-to-20 national minimum wage and the national living wage.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6 Partial Answer
Alison Bennett LD
Mid Sussex
Context
The family farm tax has faced opposition from various political parties.
Will the Minister at least revisit the forestalling clause, which would help older farmers in Mid Sussex and across the country to avoid the consequences of backdating the legislation?
At the Budget, we came forward with a revision to the policy to support people whose spouses have already passed away, and we made the allowance transferable between the spouses. That change will reduce the number of farms affected by the agricultural property relief changes from about 500—as was estimated at the previous Budget—to 375.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7 Partial Answer
Alison Hume Lab
Scarborough and Whitby
Context
Alexander Dennis is a British manufacturer of electric buses.
Will the Minister confirm that this Government are backing British-built buses over Chinese imports, and can he confirm that the changes to public procurement processes will be implemented in time for taxpayers’ money to be spent on buying British buses?
We have a proud history of manufacturing in this country, including in my hon. Friend’s constituency, and we will capitalise on that history as we drive our future growth. The UK is a leader in bus manufacturing, and the Government are committed to supporting the sector, including through the Department for Transport’s UK bus manufacturing expert panel.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Nick Smith Lab
Blaenau Gwent and Rhymney
Context
The MP references the Minister's announcement at the Budget regarding pension schemes for mining communities.
Will he provide an update on plans for changing the surplus sharing arrangements for both the mineworkers’ pension scheme and the British Coal staff superannuation scheme?
My hon. Friend has been a powerful campaigner for those surpluses to be shared with the members of those pension schemes. He knows that we made an announcement at the Budget to ensure that the British Coal staff superannuation scheme surplus is shared with its members, and I know that the trustees are bringing forward their proposals on the sharing of future surpluses.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Partial Answer
Alan Mak Con
Havant
Context
The MP questions the Chancellor's support for entrepreneurs given recent cuts to venture capital trust tax relief.
How can the Chancellor claim to support our entrepreneurs when she is cutting off the funding that they rely on?
I hosted an event last night for entrepreneurs. Speaking at it were the chief executives of Quantexa and Motorway, both of whom welcomed the changes that we made to support entrepreneurs at the Budget, particularly the changes we made around enterprise management incentives, the enterprise investment scheme, VCT, and the three-year stamp duty holiday for companies choosing to list here in Britain. We are backing entrepreneurs in Britain, and they are backing our changes.
Assessment & feedback
Cutting venture capital trusts tax relief
Welcomed Changes At Budget
Response accuracy