Topical Questions 2025-11-18
2025-11-18
TAGS
Response quality
Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Members of the British Coal Staff Superannuation Scheme are seeking justice similar to that received by former mineworkers under the mineworkers' pension scheme. Constituents like Ray Sweet, Don Jennings and Andy Callow have benefited from previous government actions but now seek additional support.
Last year, over 1,000 former mineworkers in North Warwickshire and Bedworth benefited from this Government’s historic decision to release the surplus from the mineworkers’ pension scheme. Now, members of the British Coal staff superannuation scheme, such as my constituents Ray Sweet, Don Jennings and Andy Callow, are seeking that same justice. Could the Minister reassure my constituent and others like her that the Government are doing everything they can?
I pay tribute to all those who toiled in our coalmines for a very long time—we owe them a great debt. As the Prime Minister said in the House on 12 November, the Government remain committed to agreeing a way forward with the trustees that will benefit scheme members. We will make an announcement on this issue in due course.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
During the COP, forests in Brazil were deforested despite the Secretary of State lecturing about saving the planet. The UK did not put any money into the forest fund.
At this COP, acres of the Amazon were chopped down so that the Secretary of State can lecture us about saving the planet. Can the Minister justify why his Government did not even put a single penny into the forest fund, which could have at least repaired some of the damage?
I think the shadow Secretary of State has a bit of a cheek talking about anyone’s action on the climate crisis when she has completely reversed her own position on it. The UK’s climate leadership is an incredibly important contribution to the world’s action on the climate crisis. That crisis is not a future threat, but a very present reality. The UK has been a part of the forest initiative; we have supported Brazil and others to make that happen. Of course, coming up to a Budget and with tight fiscal considerations, we want to make sure that every pound of British taxpayers’ money is spent.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Isle of Wight is facing issues with exporting its green energy due to capacity constraints in subsea cables.
As Members all know by now, the Isle of Wight is a great place to live, work and learn, but it is not just getting ourselves across the Solent that is a problem, but exporting our green energy under it. Of the three subsea cables connecting us to the grid, two are at capacity and the third is dedicated to a power station that only runs for a few hours a month. I am grateful to Scottish and Southern Electricity Networks for its engagement so far, but will the Minister meet me, SSEN and the Isle of Wight council so that we can find a way to export our energy and unlock the Isle of Wight’s green future?
This is partly why the upgrade of our grid is so important. My hon. Friend references the particular example of the Isle of Wight, but right across the country we need to build much more transmission infrastructure so that we can get power to communities and businesses that need it most and bring down bills by getting clean power to people. I am happy to speak to him further about the specific case, and I know he is already engaging with the distribution network operator responsible for this case to make things happen.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
More than 3,600 families in Newbury are living in fuel poverty. The warm home discount helps with bills but the constituency needs the full warm homes plan.
More than 3,600 families in my constituency are living in fuel poverty. While I welcome the warm home discount that will help with bills, it is really the warm homes plan that we need to see rolled out. Can the Minister give any assurance to my constituents about when they will be able to see that investment?
The warm homes plan will be funded to £13.2 billion, and we will announce it before the end of the year.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The north-east is a hub for clean energy supply chains but years of under-investment by the Tories have left many North sea ports unable to host modern turbine manufacturing.
The north-east is a vital hub for clean energy supply chains, and my constituents in oil and gas want to be part of that transition, but years of under-investment by the Tories mean that many North sea ports cannot host modern turbine manufacturing. As the Government prepare their plan for the future of the north-east, will the Minister consider infrastructure investment to enable communities and workers in the north-east to better benefit from clean energy jobs?
I recognise what my hon. Friend says about the importance of port infrastructure in the north-east. We made a manifesto commitment to support investment in our ports through the National Wealth Fund, and I would be happy to discuss with her how the north-east in particular could benefit from that.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Small energy-intensive businesses like hair salons in North East Hampshire are struggling due to high energy prices.
In North East Hampshire, small energy-intensive businesses such as hair salons are struggling, because they cannot reduce their consumption. What plans does the Minister have to support those kinds of small businesses?
In response to earlier questions, I outlined the British industrial competitiveness scheme, which we announced in our industrial strategy. That will extend support to a wider range of businesses. We recognise the issues that businesses are facing with high energy prices, primarily as a consequence of the previous Government’s policies not to invest in renewable energy. We are changing that by investing in British home-grown renewable energy.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Peatlands are a critical carbon store, storing more carbon than UK forests. Robbie Moore is concerned about the impact of green energy projects on these important habitats.
Our peatlands are a vital store of carbon, storing 26 times more carbon than UK forests. Would you agree that green energy projects built on peatland must prove they mitigate more carbon than they release through construction and disturbance? Will you commit to refusing any nationally significant infrastructure project failing this test?
While I cannot comment on specific planning decisions, the planning regime considers the importance of peat for biodiversity, water and carbon storage in decisions about renewable infrastructure. Existing protections for peatland habitats and deep peat are included in the national planning policy framework.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to refuse any project failing the test
Cannot Comment On Specific Planning Decisions
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A primary school in Chris Vince's constituency is installing solar panels on its roof, which will reduce energy bills and provide educational opportunities.
I welcome the investment in Roydon Primary School for solar panels. Can you talk about how this will bring down bills and what educational impact it might have?
The school will start to receive money off its bills immediately, which can be reinvested into teaching facilities. Children had lessons on clean energy and learned about sustainability's impact on their school and the planet, offering an important curriculum benefit.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A constituent, Gareth from Pitney, lives in an off-grid home with no affordable heating options other than oil. Transitioning to sustainable heating alternatives would cost him about £20,000.
What steps are you taking to support off-grid homeowners like Gareth to transition to sustainable heating alternatives? What assessment has been made of using renewable liquid heating fuels?
The warm homes plan, launching before the end of the year, will address issues in rural homes. A consultation on alternative heating fuels was also launched today, inviting responses from constituents and others interested.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps for off-grid homeowners
Warm Homes Plan
Consultation
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Development of data centres, industries and housing in west London is hampered by inadequate national grid capacity.
What action will you take to ensure that west London can contribute to the growing UK economy despite current grid limitations?
We are upgrading the national transmission system and investing in it. It is crucial for future power sources and ensuring we can deliver power to demand centres where there are economic growth opportunities.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Reform-led Derbyshire county council has abolished its climate change committee and scrapped its aim to tackle the causes and impact of climate change.
Will you outline steps your Department is taking to ensure local authorities continue addressing climate change effectively and meeting national targets?
Reform-led councils dismissing actions necessary for protecting communities from impacts of climate change is concerning. It’s important that we stay committed and do everything possible to protect communities against devastating floods and other climate impacts.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific steps by the Department
Reform-Led Councils Dismissing Actions
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
ExxonMobil announced plans to close its Fife ethylene plant, affecting many workers who have decades of service. Constituents are concerned about lack of clarity on redundancy packages and support.
Today’s news that ExxonMobil is to close the Fife ethylene plant in Mossmoran is a devastating blow to my constituents. Workers with decades of service will lose their jobs but have no idea of the redundancy package they will receive. Despite months of attempts to engage, ExxonMobil has not been forthcoming about its intentions or what the Government can do to save the plant and jobs. Will the Government do all it can to support a future for the plant and workers?
This is a hugely concerning time for the workers, their families, and the wider community. The Government has been in regular contact with ExxonMobil. My hon. Friend met with the Business Secretary recently and has engaged as much as possible. While issues are deeply concerning, we stand ready to provide support. The Business Secretary will speak to her and others to ensure a robust response for the workforce at this difficult time.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did Not Directly Address Call For Information Sharing
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Reports suggest the UK's decision not to contribute to the tropical forest forever facility is under review. The COP30 conference focuses on ending deforestation.
With just a few days of COP30 left, it is disappointing that UK climate leadership is at risk due to the Government’s decision not to contribute to the tropical forest forever facility. Are reports that this decision is under review accurate? Will the UK play its part in contributing directly to ending deforestation?
We are taking a leading role at COP and fighting for Britain’s interests. We will continue making tackling climate change a priority of this Government. However, the specific decision regarding the tropical forest forever facility was not addressed.
▸
Assessment & feedback
decision on funding tropical forest forever facility
Highlighted General Commitment To Cop And Climate Action
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
National Energy Action polling shows four in ten adults using prepayment meters have found themselves without credit, facing financial distress due to standing charges.
Polling by National Energy Action reveals that many families are unable to maintain energy access due to prepayment meter issues and accruing debt. Does the Minister agree that Ofgem must explore practical reforms to ensure households are not penalised?
My hon. Friend is correct about energy bills placing a burden on constituents. Ofgem has announced proposals requiring suppliers to offer tariffs with lower standing charges from early 2026, but further work needs to be done.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Acknowledged Issues But Highlighted Existing Efforts By Ofgem
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
2,000 acres of farmland have been approved for solar by the Government, creating a significant project. The constituency seeks a land use strategy to ensure community benefits.
Last year, 2,000 acres of farmland were approved for solar projects. With another 2,000 being eyed up next door, when will the Government bring forth a land use strategy and impose minimum compensation for those losing their countryside?
We appreciate engagement with the hon. Lady on these issues. The planning system considers cumulative impacts, but a more strategic approach is needed through the land use framework and the strategic spatial energy plan.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Acknowledged Need For Strategy But Did Not Commit To Timeline
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Energy Minister previously stated that £200 million investment from the national wealth fund brought private investment to Grangemouth. The constituency seeks an anchor industry similar to former oil refineries.
Last month, it was announced that a £200 million investment in Grangemouth has secured private investment through the national wealth fund. Does the Minister agree we need an anchor industry with scale and skills like those of the former oil refinery? When will the Government take a partial stake and make an announcement on Grangemouth’s industrial future?
I pay tribute to my hon. Friend's work with the Government and national wealth fund, securing £200 million investment through 100 projects. Due diligence is ongoing before we can make any announcements.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Acknowledged Progress But Deferred Commitment
Response accuracy
Q17
Partial Answer
▸
Context
ExxonMobil's closure at Mossmorran raises concerns about the impact on the Acorn carbon capture, utilisation and storage project.
What is the Minister’s assessment of the potential impact on the Acorn carbon capture, utilisation and storage project in light of ExxonMobil’s closure at Mossmorran?
We are processing this news and have had conversations to ensure that the wider energy infrastructure does not pose risks. I meet the Acorn company regularly, and we will continue supporting the project.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Acknowledged Concerns But Provided Limited Details
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
XLCC plans to build the UK’s first high-voltage direct current subsea cable manufacturing factory at Hunterston, with headquarters in Lillian Jones' constituency. The project is seen as a major opportunity for Ayrshire.
XLCC’s project to build the UK’s first high-voltage direct current subsea cable manufacturing factory at Hunterston represents a major opportunity for Ayrshire. It is exactly the kind of investment in renewable energy that we need to drive growth, create jobs and strengthen our energy security. What steps is the Minister taking to support firms such as XLCC to delivery these projects?
One reason why we are so keen for the supply chain for the upgrade of our grid to be in the UK is our wish to ensure that there are opportunities for factories in constituencies such as my hon. Friend’s, and I recently met her, along with my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Scotland and XLCC, to discuss those opportunities. XLCC is currently changing its business model but remains committed to being part of the supply chain for cables in the future, and we will continue to do everything we can to support it.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The oil refining industry employs tens of thousands of people and is crucial to energy security. The industry is under pressure.
The oil refining industry employs tens of thousands of people and is crucial to our energy security. It is also a key part of the ministerial brief. The sector is under immense pressure, so can the Minister tell the House when he will meet industry representatives directly?
I have met industry representatives, and when I did so they told me that it was the first time they had met anyone from the Government in 13 years. Many of the issues that are now emerging have been long in the making because of the last Government’s failure to recognise their importance. However, the hon. Gentleman is right to say that refineries are an important part of our energy mix and our economy. We will do all that we can to support them, and I continue to meet their representatives and those of Fuels Industry UK regularly.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Northern Ireland seeks dedicated funding from UK-wide schemes such as the Nature for Climate Fund to support peatland restoration.
Will Northern Ireland receive a dedicated share of UK-wide peatland funding schemes such as those covered by the Nature for Climate Fund?
I shall be more than happy to meet the hon. Member, as I am sure will the Minister for Climate, my hon. Friend the Member for Leeds North West (Katie White), when she returns from COP30.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The specific funding allocation was not addressed
Will Meet To Discuss
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
Andrew Bowie
point of order
▸
Context
A serious news event at the Mossmorran plant has occurred, affecting workers and the wider community. The request is to bring forward a statement on the situation.
Given the very serious news coming out of the Mossmorran plant this morning, might you inform me how it might be possible for the Government to bring forward a statement on the situation today?
A lot of Members obviously have a keen interest in this matter, as it affects their constituencies. I am sure that those on the Treasury Bench have heard the request. I am more than happy to support that request if the Government bring it forward.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Details of bringing forward statement not provided
Response accuracy