Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Local businesses in economically deprived areas are struggling with an overabundance of gambling shops. The 'aim to permit' legislation prevents councils from restricting these establishments, despite public support for reform.
Economically deprived high streets and poorer high streets are flooded with gambling shops. The “aim to permit” legislation prevents councils from saying no. My summer campaign on gambling reform has received loads of support, including from Gordon Brown, who says that if we tax the gambling industry, we will get £3 billion for our economy. Will the Prime Minister join campaigners and help me to end “aim to permit”, so that constituents such as his and mine can thrive?
I thank my hon. Friend for her question. It is important that local authorities are given additional tools and powers to ensure vibrant high streets. We are looking at introducing cumulative impact assessments, like those already in place for alcohol licensing, and we will give councils stronger powers over the location and numbers of gambling outlets to help create safe, thriving high streets.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Looking At
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Deputy Prime Minister admitted to underpaying taxes, leading to calls for her resignation. Government borrowing costs have risen significantly.
I know the whole House will want to send our condolences to the family of our former colleague, David Warburton.
I also welcome the fact that the Deputy Prime Minister has referred herself to the ethics adviser. She has admitted that she underpaid tax, so why is she still in office? There is not just a crisis at the very top of the Prime Minister’s Cabinet; there is a crisis brewing for the whole country. When was the last time that the cost of Government borrowing was so high?
I also welcome the fact that the Deputy Prime Minister has referred herself to the ethics adviser. She has admitted that she underpaid tax, so why is she still in office? There is not just a crisis at the very top of the Prime Minister’s Cabinet; there is a crisis brewing for the whole country. When was the last time that the cost of Government borrowing was so high?
I join the Leader of the Opposition in her comments about Mr Warburton. I think the whole House would unite on such an issue.
In relation to the Deputy Prime Minister, she has explained her personal circumstances in detail. She has gone over and above in setting out the details, including yesterday afternoon asking a court to lift a confidentiality order in relation to her own son. I know from speaking at length to the Deputy Prime Minister just how difficult that decision was for her and her family, but she did it to ensure that all information is in the public domain. She has now referred herself to the independent adviser. That is the right thing to do.
On the question of borrowing costs, they have risen across the world, as the Leader of the Opposition well knows. We are driving them down by getting debt down. That is hardwired into our fiscal rules; those fiscal rules are non-negotiable.
In relation to the Deputy Prime Minister, she has explained her personal circumstances in detail. She has gone over and above in setting out the details, including yesterday afternoon asking a court to lift a confidentiality order in relation to her own son. I know from speaking at length to the Deputy Prime Minister just how difficult that decision was for her and her family, but she did it to ensure that all information is in the public domain. She has now referred herself to the independent adviser. That is the right thing to do.
On the question of borrowing costs, they have risen across the world, as the Leader of the Opposition well knows. We are driving them down by getting debt down. That is hardwired into our fiscal rules; those fiscal rules are non-negotiable.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Global Context
Non-Negotiable Fiscal Rules
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Deputy Prime Minister admitted to underpaying taxes, leading to calls for her resignation. Government borrowing costs have risen significantly.
I am not sure we would have heard all that sympathy if it had been a Conservative Deputy Prime Minister who was being attacked. I remember when the Prime Minister said that tax evasion was a criminal offence and
“should be treated as all other fraud”.
If he had a backbone, he would sack her.
But let us get back to the issue of borrowing. The Prime Minister did not answer the question about why it is so high. The Conservatives left him the fastest-growing economy in the G7. Under him, the cost of our borrowing is now higher than it is in Greece. Why does the Prime Minister think that is?
“should be treated as all other fraud”.
If he had a backbone, he would sack her.
But let us get back to the issue of borrowing. The Prime Minister did not answer the question about why it is so high. The Conservatives left him the fastest-growing economy in the G7. Under him, the cost of our borrowing is now higher than it is in Greece. Why does the Prime Minister think that is?
If it had been the Conservatives, there would not have been the accountability, which is now in place, because they spent years and years avoiding it. The right hon. Lady’s claims about the economy on their watch are about as credible as her place at Stanford University. [Interruption.] She leaves out of her account, because she wants to talk down the country, that we have the highest growth in the G7. I look forward to her getting up and welcoming that. We have had five interest rate cuts in a row, and, of course, £120 billion of investment in the first year of a Labour Government. That is a record.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Accountability
Global Economic Context
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The question stems from criticism of the Prime Minister's changing policy agendas and his handling of the UK economy, which has led to rising costs for citizens.
This is desperate stuff from the Prime Minister. This week, he had another reset. This morning, the Prime Minister scrapped his five missions. After scrapping his three foundations, his six first steps for change and his seven pillars for growth, the truth is that this man has got no clue—zero clue. But this is serious. The Prime Minister’s incompetence is hurting real people. They are losing their jobs and the cost of everything is going up, from energy bills to the weekly shop. This is a crisis made in Downing Street. Is it not the truth that he is too weak to change course, and too arrogant to admit he got things wrong?
I do not know what social media sites the right hon. Lady has been on this morning, but I think the chair of the Tory party said that this Government are the “firefighters”. Well, in a sense we are, because we are putting out the fires that the Conservatives created. They were the arsonists—the biggest fall in living standards on record, blowing up the finances. We have spent the first year putting out their fires—quite right too—but now we are delivering on the cost of living: funded childcare worth £7,500 for working families, free breakfast clubs and opening new school-based nurseries. That is what we are fighting for: the best start for every child in this country.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not directly address his incompetence or inability to change course; instead he criticized the previous government's policies and actions.
Criticizing The Opposition
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Mayor of the West Midlands, Richard Parker, is delivering growth and jobs by backing SMEs such as Booghe Toys in Birmingham Erdington constituency. The questioner seeks confirmation from the Prime Minister that boosting ambitious small and medium-sized businesses across the UK remains a key priority.
The Mayor of the West Midlands, Richard Parker, is delivering growth and jobs by backing SMEs such as Booghe Toys in my constituency, which has just doubled in size. Will the Prime Minister join me in praising this success and confirm that boosting ambitious small and medium-sized businesses across the UK remains a key priority of his Government?
May I recognise and congratulate the businesses in my hon. Friend’s constituency? We have published our small business plan, which was very well received. It includes new rules; cracking down on late payments, which has long been asked for; a £3 billion boost to more business loans; and fairer business rate systems to support small businesses. That is why it was so warmly received.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not directly confirm the continued priority but instead highlighted recent initiatives in his answer.
Acknowledging Achievements
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Liberal Democrats disagree with the Conservative party's intentions regarding withdrawal from the European Convention on Human Rights. The questioner seeks a categorical ruling out of such actions by the Prime Minister.
Here is an issue on which I hope the Prime Minister will agree with me. The European convention on human rights is a British creation that protects all our basic rights and freedoms: the rights of children, disabled people, survivors of domestic abuse, victims of horrific crimes—everyone. It protects care home residents from abuse and families from being spied on by councils, but the leader of the Conservative party and the leader of Reform want to join Russia and Vladimir Putin by withdrawing from the convention. The Liberal Democrats disagree, and so do the majority of the British people. Will the Prime Minister categorially rule out withdrawing from the ECHR, suspending it or watering down our rights in any way?
We will not withdraw from the European convention on human rights. We do need to make sure that both the convention and other instruments are fit for the circumstances we face at the moment, and therefore of course we have been, as we have made clear, looking at the interpretation of some of those provisions. It would be a profound mistake to pull out of these instruments, because the first thing that would follow is that every other country in the world that adheres to these instruments would pull out of all their agreements with this country. That would be catastrophic for actually dealing with the problem.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not provide a categorical ruling but emphasized the potential consequences of withdrawal or watering down rights.
Highlighting Potential Negative Outcomes
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Global Sumud flotilla, including British citizens, set sail for Gaza to break the blockade and deliver aid. A British boat, Madleen, faced threats and crew detentions in June.
This week, the Global Sumud flotilla, which includes British citizens, set sail for Gaza to break the illegal blockade and deliver much-needed aid. In June, a British boat, the Madleen, was threatened and its crew detained, but we took no action. Can the Prime Minister say what has been learned from this, and what steps are being taken to protect the British citizens on this flotilla?
My hon. Friend raises a really important issue in relation to the horrifying situation in Gaza. The Israeli Government are preventing urgently needed aid from getting in, which is why we are now seeing a man-made famine, and that should cause us all to pause and reflect. We are working with other countries to get aid in by any practical means, but land routes are the only viable and sustainable means of getting aid into Gaza on the scale that is required. Israel must lift the restrictions to allow aid agencies to deliver the life-saving supplies that are so desperately needed.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The PM did not address lessons learned or steps taken specifically for British citizens' safety.
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Online Safety Act aims to protect children from harmful online content.
Prime Minister, last year, my online safety forum of children and young people from every secondary school and college in Darlington found that 71% of our year 10s and 12s had been contacted by a stranger online, a shocking failure that our Online Safety Act will hopefully prevent going forward. Will he join me in calling on the hon. Member for Clacton (Nigel Farage), and all opposed to this vital Act, to pick a side? Are they with us, parents and child protectors, or are they with the predators harming our children online?
Of course, the hon. Member for Clacton (Nigel Farage) is not here to represent his constituency in the House that he was elected to. No, he has flown to America to badmouth and talk down our country. It is worse than that, Mr Speaker: if you can believe it, he has gone there to lobby the Americans to impose sanctions on this country that will harm working people. You cannot get more unpatriotic than that. The Online Safety Act 2023 protects children from material on suicide, self-harm and online predators. Reform says it would scrap it. When its leader was asked, “Well, what would you replace it with?”, his answer was: ‘There needs to be a tech answer. I don’t know what that is’. You cannot run a country on ‘don’t know’ answers.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The PM did not explicitly join in calling out opponents of the Act but criticized the opposition's stance.
Response accuracy
Q9
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Admiral Lord West, a former Labour Security Minister and head of the Royal Navy, wrote in national press denouncing the decision to hand over ownership of Chagos archipelago. He stated it is not 'absolutely vital for our defence and intelligence'.
When Admiral Lord West writes in the national press denouncing what he calls the ‘disgraceful decision to hand over ownership of the Chagos archipelago’, adding that he does ‘not accept that the move is “absolutely vital for our defence and intelligence”, as the Prime Minister claims’, should we rely on his professional judgment or not?
I have the misfortune to disagree with him.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10
Evasion / No Answer
▸
Context
The Green Party leader recently made comments about withdrawing from NATO, unfunded spending, and blocking planning proposals. The Prime Minister has previously stated that ‘Climate action is at the heart of this government’s mission for the protection and prosperity of Britain and the world.’
While the Conservative party deludes itself with the myth of endless fossil fuels, extracting more oil and gas from the declining North Sea basin will do nothing to protect energy security or jobs. The Prime Minister himself has stated: ‘Climate action is at the heart of this government’s mission for the protection and prosperity of Britain and the world.’ With a decision looming on the Rosebank oil field, will the Prime Minister prove that his words mean something, and finally put an end to this climate-wrecking project?
I did notice that the Leader of the Opposition went to Scotland, I think, this week to announce that if she ever became Prime Minister, which is extremely unlikely, she would pull down £50 billion of investment in renewables in Scotland. This is good, secure jobs of the future—absolutely reckless behaviour. The Opposition have not learned anything. The Greens have a new leader—unfortunately for the hon. Lady—and we can now see what they really stand for: withdrawal from NATO at a moment like this; totally unfunded spending that would blow up the economy; and blocking all planning proposals.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address the question about ending the Rosebank oil field project.
Redirecting To Comments Made By Opposition Party
Attacking Green Party Leader
Response accuracy
Q11
Evasion / No Answer
▸
Context
A comedy writer was arrested from a flight by five armed officers, prompting concerns about the prioritization of free expression in public sector institutions.
Like many, I was deeply concerned that a police force deemed it necessary to take five armed officers to arrest a comedy writer from a flight. Some may have found Mr Linehan’s comments offensive, but that is not the point. If we do not support speech that we do not like, we do not support free speech. Will the Prime Minister commit to reviewing our speech laws to ensure that legitimate free expression is protected and will he condemn the culture within the public sector that prioritises this dangerous and perverse nonsense?
I thank the hon. Member for raising this important issue.
▸
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not commit to reviewing speech laws or condemning a police culture that prioritizes restricting free speech.
Acknowledging The Importance Of The Issue Without Taking Specific Action
Response accuracy
Q12
Direct Answer
▸
Context
In a week focused on securing the Type 26 warship programme for Clydeside, Glasgow and Govan, there has been silence from the SNP regarding this major economic opportunity.
Is he as perplexed as I am at the radio silence from the SNP and the contempt that the SNP continues to show for the defence sector? Does he agree that it is a contempt for jobs and growth and an 18-year-long contempt for Scotland?
I am perplexed that the First Minister has not welcomed the deal. It is a massive deal for Scotland—it is 15 years of shipbuilding. I would have expected the First Minister to hold a press conference to celebrate what we have done with this deal. Those 15 years of shipbuilding are extremely important to the Clyde and many industries, and they are a reflection of the professionalism and dedication that workers in Scotland have shown over many years.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The Prime Minister is asked about promoting national pride by ensuring that flags representing different parts of the United Kingdom are displayed alongside the Union Jack on government buildings.
Will the Prime Minister take steps to ensure that across every part of our kingdom, alongside the crosses of St George in England, St Patrick in Ireland, St Andrew in Scotland and the red dragon in Wales, our flag is flown on every Government and public building—hospitals, schools, police stations and railway stations—for every Briton deserves the chance to see a forest of flagpoles and the flutter of the Union Jack?
I share the right hon. Gentleman’s pride in our country’s flag. It represents our history, our heritage and our values. That is why we display it. I was the Labour leader who put the Union Jack on the membership card for the Labour party, and I was very proud to do so. It belongs to all of us.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Steps to ensure flag displays
It Belongs To All Of Us
Response accuracy