PMQs 2025-04-30

2025-04-30

TAGS
Response quality

Questions & Answers

Q1 Partial Answer
Kemi Badenoch Con
North West Essex
Context
The MP refers to the Under-Secretary of State for the Home Department's admission of a cover-up regarding child rape gang scandals. She asks for clarification and accountability.
On Monday, the Prime Minister’s safeguarding Minister—the Under-Secretary of State for the Home Department—admitted on the Floor of the House that there was a cover-up of the child rape gang scandal. Does the Prime Minister think we should expose this cover-up?
This is obviously a serious issue. I oversaw the first grooming gang prosecution, which was in Rochdale, more than a decade ago. There is a contrast here, because when the Leader of the Opposition was Minister for children and Minister for Women and Equalities, she never raised this issue in the House in three years. The shadow Home Secretary held 352 external meetings during 20 months. How many were on this issue? Not one. Of course, the Conservatives failed to implement a single recommendation from the independent inquiry into child sexual abuse. My position is absolutely clear: where there is evidence, the police should investigate and there should be appropriate prosecutions. That is route No. 1. Route No. 2 is that we should implement existing recommendations, which did expose what went wrong.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not directly address whether a cover-up occurred or commit to exposing it.
Redirecting Blaming Previous Government
Response accuracy
Q2 Partial Answer
Kemi Badenoch Con
North West Essex
Context
Following up on the Prime Minister’s earlier statement, Mrs. Badenoch asks about the status of local inquiries promised by the government and expresses concern that these are not sufficient.
In the last year of the Conservative Government, we had a gangs taskforce that found 500 perpetrators, protecting thousands of victims. We launched the inquiry that the Prime Minister is talking about, but more still needs to be done. It is now four months since I asked him for a full national inquiry. Instead, he promised five local inquiries. There will be one in Oldham. Will he now name where the other four will be?
We are providing for local inquiries—[Interruption.] Conservative Members have got so much to say now; why did they not implement a single recommendation in the 14 years they had in office? There are recommendations already in place about the change that needs to be made. They sat on a shelf under the last Government; we are acting on them. We are providing for local inquiries, and we are investing more in delivering truth than the last Government ever did.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not name specific locations for additional local inquiries.
Blaming Previous Government
Response accuracy
Q3 Partial Answer
Kemi Badenoch Con
North West Essex
Context
Continuing the discussion on local inquiries, Mrs. Badenoch questions why the Prime Minister cannot name specific locations for additional inquiries.
The Prime Minister cannot name a single place because nothing is happening. He stood at the Dispatch Box and promised five local inquiries. On the last day of term, he had his Minister come out to water down the promise that they would provide funding. That is not good enough. At least 50 towns are affected by rape gangs—places like Peterborough, Derby, Birmingham, Nottingham, Leicester, Rotherham, Rochdale and Preston. Is he dragging his heels on this because he does not want Labour cover-ups exposed?
We are providing for local inquiries, and we are investing more in delivering truth than the last Government ever did.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not address why specific locations were not named or why there was a delay.
Blaming Previous Government
Response accuracy
Q4 Partial Answer
Kemi Badenoch Con
North West Essex
Context
The MP emphasizes that victims want a full national inquiry rather than local inquiries, citing support from various individuals and regions.
The right hon. and learned Gentleman is not the Director of Public Prosecutions any more—he is the Prime Minister. People want to know what he is going to do now, not have him talk about what he did years ago. We are asking for a full national inquiry. Andy Burnham wants a national inquiry, and he is not Conservative; he is Labour. Harriet Harman wants one. The hon. Member for Rotherham (Sarah Champion) wants one. All the victims I have met want a full national inquiry. The Prime Minister keeps talking about local inquiries, yet they have not got going, and they have not got going because local authorities do not want to investigate themselves.
We have had a national inquiry, and we have had recommendations. [Interruption.] Look, hundreds of recommendations have been made in relation to this issue. It is a serious issue. I strongly believe that we should implement the recommendations that have already been made, and that is what we are doing.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not commit to initiating a new national inquiry.
Sticking To Existing Policies
Response accuracy
Q5 Partial Answer
Kemi Badenoch Con
North West Essex
Context
The MP highlights instances of ongoing issues in various localities, suggesting that the government is failing to address these effectively.
The Prime Minister says we should listen to victims. The victims want a national inquiry. We have not had a national inquiry. We had the child sex abuse inquiry, which the Conservatives launched. There is still more to be done; it did not cover the scandal in detail. In Manchester, just last year, authorities were still covering up abuse, and the local inquiry chair there has quit. Bradford council, which covers an area with some of the worst abuses, refuses any inquiry, local or national. Whether we are talking about the streets of Birmingham or the town hall of Bradford, it is chaos and cover ups with Labour councils.
Labour Members have been listening to victims for decades and working with them in relation to what they want, which is local inquiries, and we have set those local inquiries up. My record, where I thought something had gone wrong, is of going after it and putting it right.
Assessment & feedback
The Prime Minister did not commit to new actions beyond existing measures.
Deflecting Blaming Previous Government
Response accuracy
Q6 Direct Answer
Nadia Whittome Lab
Nottingham East
Context
New data shows that in March last year, 64% of children were in poverty in the Hyson Green and Arboretum ward in Nottingham East, which is the highest proportion in the east Midlands. This situation highlights the previous Conservative government's record on child poverty.
In light of new data showing that 64% of children were in poverty in the Hyson Green and Arboretum ward in my constituency last March, I urge you to confirm that this Labour Government will do everything possible to eliminate child poverty. Will they not rule out abolishing the two-child benefit limit as part of their taskforce's efforts?
My hon. Friend highlights the disgraceful record of the previous Government who saw an additional 900,000 children fall into poverty during their term. Labour's commitment is to reduce child poverty significantly and we are exploring all available levers including revisiting the two-child benefit limit.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q7 Direct Answer
Ed Davey Lib Dem
Kingston and Surbiton
Context
Fiona Laskaris's autistic adult son Christopher was exploited and murdered by a convicted criminal. When Fiona attempted to get a mental capacity assessment for her son, she faced dismissal from authorities, suggesting that family concerns about a loved one’s mental capacity should be more formally considered.
I have raised the tragic case of Fiona Laskaris whose autistic adult son Christopher was horrifically exploited and murdered by a convicted criminal. When Fiona sought a mental capacity assessment for her son, she faced dismissive responses. I propose changing the law to ensure families' concerns about their loved one’s mental capacity are properly considered. Will the Prime Minister personally support this change?
I express my gratitude for the right hon. Gentleman raising this tragic case, and I believe that thoughts of everyone in the House are with Christopher’s family and friends affected by his loss. We will certainly investigate further what actions can be taken to prevent similar tragedies from happening again.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q8 Direct Answer
Context
Cornwall has vast natural resources for onshore and offshore wind, geothermal, and tidal power. There are opportunities for clean energy investments to enhance local economic development and job creation.
I congratulate Truro City football club on their remarkable journey from homelessness to league champions in one season. Cornwall's abundant renewable energy sources offer significant opportunities for investment and growth. Confirm that the recent solar panel installation at Falmouth community hospital is just the beginning of further investments planned by GB Energy in Cornwall.
I extend my congratulations to Truro City football club for their impressive achievement. Clean energy investments are an integral part of our clean power plan, and this project at Falmouth community hospital is indeed just the start. We aim to further empower 200 schools and many NHS sites across the country with GB Energy’s solar projects, generating significant savings and contributing positively to local communities.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q9 Direct Answer
Josh Simons Lab
Makerfield
Context
The MP noted that his constituents in Orrell have faced a lack of local health provision but highlighted an upcoming partnership with Wigan Athletic and Wigan Warriors to establish a centre for women's sports excellence.
For years, my constituents in Orrell have suffered from a lack of local health provision, but next month that will begin to change, thanks to a new partnership that I have built with our local NHS, Wigan Athletic and Wigan Warriors at a centre for excellence in women’s sport. This will be a shining example of shifting healthcare from hospitals into communities. Can I urge the Prime Minister to continue with our plan for change and to ignore the hon. Member for Clacton (Nigel Farage), who for decades has pushed to dismantle our NHS so that my constituents would have to pay to see their doctor?
I see the hon. Member for Clacton (Nigel Farage) complaining, but what did he say? His words were,
“we’re going to have to move to an insurance-based system of healthcare”
and:
“If you can afford it, you pay”
—not under our watch. While he is busy taking Liz Truss’s advice and fawning over Putin, we are driving down waiting lists, with 3 million extra appointments delivered and waiting lists slashed in the most deprived areas. That is six times that the waiting lists have come down, including during the winter period. We are rebuilding our NHS, rebuilding our country’s future and delivering for working people.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q10 Direct Answer
Liz Jarvis Lib Dem
Eastleigh
Context
The MP highlighted a recent water supply incident in Eastleigh, including outages and sewage dumping into the River Itchen. She mentioned that constituents are facing significant increases in water bills.
Just before Christmas, thousands of my constituents were left without water after yet another incident involving Southern Water—the latest in a long series of issues, including outages and sewage dumping in our precious chalk stream, the River Itchen. Yet this month, my constituents face water bill hikes of 47%. Does the Prime Minister understand why my constituents are so angry about that, and what reassurances can he give them that Southern Water and Ofwat will be held to account?
I thank the hon. Member for raising this, and the Conservatives should apologise to her constituents for allowing record sewage into our waterways. Our water Act will clean up our rivers, lakes and seas. Under new powers that came into effect last week, in fact, water bosses can now face years in jail for concealing sewage spills. We have banned the payment of bonuses and introduced new powers, and of course we are delivering a major review through our water commission. I reassure the hon. Member that we will not hesitate to take further steps.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q11 Direct Answer
Sam Carling Lab
North West Cambridgeshire
Context
The MP highlighted the need for local police to have time and resources to tackle crime in their areas, especially shoplifting and antisocial behaviour.
Listening to residents in North West Cambridgeshire on the doorstep and at local coffee mornings, there is a clear message: people want local police to have the time and resources to get to know crime in their areas and to tackle it at the root. I know our Labour mayoral candidate is committed to that if she is elected tomorrow. Could the Prime Minister update residents across Cambridgeshire and Peterborough on how our plan for change is tackling crime and antisocial behaviour and boosting police ranks by 13,000 officers, who will be visible in all local communities?
The Conservatives decimated neighbourhood policing, and crimes like shoplifting and antisocial behaviour ran rife. I can tell my hon. Friend what we are doing through the plan for change: extra police officers, extra police community support officers, more special constables, and—on top of that—a named officer for every community, and more teams out in our town centres on Friday and Saturday nights. That is what you get with a Labour mayor working with a Labour Government to deliver change for Cambridgeshire and Peterborough.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12 Direct Answer
Josh Babarinde Lib Dem
Eastbourne
Context
The MP highlighted a case where a war veteran, Staff Sergeant Pauline Cole, saw her pension credit reduced due to military compensation being considered income by the Government.
Eastbourne war veteran Staff Sergeant Pauline Cole sustained injuries while serving our country. She was awarded military compensation, but because military compensation is currently considered income by this Government, her pension credit has been cut from £77 a week to just £11 a week. We have met the relevant Minister to try to address this to no avail. With the 80th anniversary of VE Day just next week, will the Prime Minister meet Pauline, who is in the Gallery, and I to address this injustice and ensure that no veteran is penalised for serving our country?
I thank the hon. Member for raising this important issue with us. We will always stand up for those who served our country, and I pay tribute to Pauline for her service. I will ensure that she gets the appropriate meeting that she wants and needs to discuss her specific case.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13 Direct Answer
Julie Minns Lab
Carlisle
Context
The MP highlighted the introduction of free breakfast clubs across various schools in Carlisle, funded by the Labour Government.
This week, thanks to this Labour Government, hundreds of free breakfast clubs have opened across our country. Will the Prime Minister join me in sending good wishes to the staff and pupils at Castle Carrock, Yewdale, Longtown, Inglewood, Brook Street, Blackford, Hallbankgate and Bishop Harvey Goodwin schools in my constituency, which are among the first to benefit from this important scheme? Will he confirm that this is just the start of Labour’s plan for change to deliver for working parents?
Let me pay tribute to all the staff in her constituency working in the breakfast clubs, which of course deliver free breakfasts and 30 minutes of free childcare, saving working parents £450 a year. We have opened the first 750 across the country, and there will be many more to come. We of course also are saving parents £50 a year by making school uniforms cheaper—something the Leader of the Opposition ordered all her troops to vote against.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14 Direct Answer
Paul Kohler Lib Dem
Wimbledon
Context
The MP raised concerns about the increasing prevalence of loud music and videos without headphones on public transport, citing planned cuts to British Transport Police as exacerbating the issue.
Q12. The playing of music and loud videos without headphones on public transport is becoming increasingly common. The various byelaws outlawing such antisocial behaviour are clearly not working, and the planned cuts to the British Transport Police are bound to make matters worse. Will the Prime Minister back the Lib Dem plan to introduce effective enforcement and a publicity campaign to persuade people to plug in their headphones? You never know, Mr Speaker; after that, we could perhaps encourage the uncivil minority to take their feet off the seats.
The hon. Gentleman raises an important question about antisocial behaviour. [Interruption.] The Conservatives are laughing about it; that really sums up what they did in the past 14 years. He knows that there are already strict rules in place to prevent antisocial behaviour, including fines of up to £1,000. We are focused on tackling antisocial behaviour. It is not low-level; it affects people, their communities, their sense of safety and what they can do with their own lives. That is why an additional £1.2 billion has been set aside for policing—13,000 new neighbourhood police officers, new respect orders and a named officer in every community. We take this seriously; the Conservatives laugh about it.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15 Partial Answer
Bell Ribeiro-Addy Lab
Clapham and Brixton Hill
Context
The question references the rise in rents in Clapham and Brixton Hill, where rents have increased by 10% over the past year while wages have not risen at a comparable rate. Metro mayors are calling for rent control to address this issue.
Rents in my constituency are becoming exceedingly unaffordable. The most recent Office for National Statistics data estimates that the average rent has risen by 10% in the past year, while the average wage has not risen at the same rate. Several metro mayors are calling for the power to control rents in their region in order to tackle the issue. The steps taken in the Renters’ Rights Bill to cap rents at the market rate are positive, but as it is landlords who set the market rate, renters in my constituency fear that those steps will not be enough to protect them from rising rents. What steps are the Government taking to bring down rental prices?
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to raise this important issue. Communities across the country face the consequences of the Conservatives’ utter failure to build enough homes. Our Renters’ Rights Bill improves the system for 11 million private renters, blocking demands for multiple months of rent in advance, and finally abolishing no-fault evictions—something that the Conservatives said over and over again they would do, but, as usual, never got around to doing. That work is backed up by major planning reforms, our new homes accelerator and £600 million to deliver 300,000 homes in London, as part of the 1.5 million homes that we will build across the country, which are desperately needed.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q16 Partial Answer
Context
The question relates to a proposal for a new urgent treatment centre and out-patients facility in Warrington, which has over 200,000 residents but no such facilities. The proposal aims to reduce A&E waiting times and deliver 100,000 appointments per year.
I welcome the Government’s action to fix our NHS and deliver 2 million more appointments, which my constituents are already benefiting from. Together with Warrington and Halton NHS trust, I recently submitted a ready-to-go proposal for a new urgent treatment centre and out-patients facility in Warrington, which has over 200,000 residents but no urgent treatment centre. The proposal would reduce A&E waiting times and deliver 100,000 appointments every year. Will the Prime Minister or the Health Secretary agree to meet me and local health partners to discuss that transformational project?
I am happy to ensure that my hon. Friend meets the Health Secretary. We have got waiting lists down for six months in a row now, delivering 3 million extra appointments. The Further Faster 20 programme is doubling the rate at which waiting lists are falling, including in her trust. Of course, earlier this week we froze prescription charges at under £10. A lot has been done and there is a lot more to do, but our plan for change is working to get the NHS back on its feet.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q17 Partial Answer
Deirdre Costigan Lab
Ealing Southall
Context
The question highlights the Prime Minister's announcement of tough action against fly-tippers, including up to five years in prison for commercial offenders.
After 14 years of a Conservative Government who let fly-tipping increase to record levels across the country, my constituents in Ealing Southall will welcome the Prime Minister’s announcement today that fly-tippers will now face tough action, new technology for enforcement and up to five years in prison. Will the Prime Minister set out what other steps he is taking to help councils to tackle fly-tipping and the difference that will make to communities like Ealing Southall?
Under the last Government, we saw 1 million incidents of fly-tipping. Under Conservative councils, we see enforcement down and fly-tipping up: look at Tory-led Northumberland, where instances of fly-tipping are up 76%. We are introducing tough powers to seize and crush the vehicles of commercial fly-tippers, who now face up to five years in prison for operating illegally. That is a Labour Government clearing up the mess left by the Conservatives.
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18 Partial Answer
Sammy Wilson DUP
East Antrim
Context
Spain experienced blackouts, highlighting concerns about the impact of net-zero policies on job losses in Scotland's oil industry and rising energy costs affecting businesses and consumers. A former leader of the Prime Minister’s party has acknowledged issues with the current approach.
The blackouts in Spain have caused chaos. Many Back Benchers in the Prime Minister’s own party are concerned about thousands of jobs being lost in Scotland's oil industry due to high energy costs making businesses uncompetitive and consumers facing fuel poverty. Does the Prime Minister acknowledge that his net-zero policy is causing harm? Will he accept advice from someone within his own party, given his reluctance to listen to opposition members?
When asking questions at PMQs, it is important to look beyond headlines. Tony Blair advised more carbon capture investment, which we have done; AI usage, which we support by investing heavily in AI jobs of the future; and domestic targets for business certainty. These actions align with what Tony Blair suggested. We must not politicise the challenges faced by countries like Spain during difficult times.
Assessment & feedback
The PM avoided directly acknowledging harm caused by net-zero policies or accepting internal criticism
Weaponising Difficult Position
Response accuracy
Q19 Direct Answer
Alex Ballinger Lab
Halesowen
Context
The government has secured British Steel, supporting defence manufacturers like Somers Forge and B.B. Price in Halesowen and Cradley Heath that rely on this steel for military equipment production.
Welcoming the Government’s decision to secure British Steel, at a time when European security is critical, will the Prime Minister commit to making manufacturing investment in the Black Country a national priority to live up to our industrial heritage and create high-quality defence jobs needed?
I pay tribute to my hon. and gallant Friend for his service to his country. Our national security and economic security are interconnected; defence spending is increasing, with the highest sustained increase since the cold war period. We have launched a new hub giving up to 12,000 small firms better access to defence contracts. This supports job creation in the Black Country and across the UK.
Assessment & feedback
null
Response accuracy