Questions & Answers
Q1
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP from Newcastle-under-Lyme has been addressing the issue of flatlining wages, in-work poverty, and a struggling economy that affected constituents for 14 years.
For 14 years, my constituents in Newcastle-under-Lyme had to suffer flatlining wages, in-work poverty, and a bust economy that served nobody. Can I urge the Deputy Prime Minister to use the Employment Rights Bill to turn the page on the last 14 years, give our businesses the support they need, and finally restore dignity, prosperity and opportunity to the good people of Newcastle-under-Lyme?
I thank my hon. Friend for his question and welcome him to his place. When this Government took office, we promised the biggest upgrade to workers' rights in a generation—a new deal for working people. We said that we would introduce a Bill within the first 100 days, and we have kept that promise.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address how the Employment Rights Bill will turn the page on the last 14 years or support businesses in Newcastle-under-Lyme
Promised To Introduce A Bill Within The First 100 Days
Response accuracy
Q2
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP from Hertsmere questioned the definition of 'working people' provided by the Labour government.
I join the Deputy Prime Minister in paying tribute to the bravery of Sir Chris Hoy—he truly is an inspiration to us all. I also echo her comments about the train crash in Powys. What is the Deputy Prime Minister's definition of working people?
Let me start by welcoming the right hon. Gentleman to his new place. Today is our first exchange since he pushed for a July general election, and if his own side has not offered him a peerage, I certainly would have. The definition of “working people” is the people who the Tory party have failed for the past 14 years.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide a clear definition of working people but instead criticized Conservative policies and personnel decisions
Criticized Conservative Government'S Performance
Response accuracy
Q3
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP from Hertsmere questioned the Deputy Prime Minister about the definition of 'working people' and whether small business owners fall into this category.
The Deputy Prime Minister stood on a manifesto promising not to raise taxes on working people. It now appears that she cannot even define who working people are, so I will give her another go. There are 5 million small business owners in this country; are they working people?
I do not know how the shadow Deputy Prime Minister can stand there with a straight face when it was the small businesses—the working people of this country—that paid the price of the Conservatives crashing the economy, sending interest rates soaring. I think he needs to learn his own lessons in opposition.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not answer if small business owners are considered 'working people'
Criticized Conservative Government'S Economic Policies
Response accuracy
Q4
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP from Hertsmere questioned the Deputy Prime Minister about raising employer national insurance and whether this affects working people.
I think the whole House will have heard the Deputy Prime Minister disregard 5 million hard-working small business owners. These are the publicans, the shopkeepers, the family running a local café. None of those count as working people to her. Labour gave a clear commitment not to raise national insurance. The independent Institute for Fiscal Studies has given its view on this. It says that raising employer national insurance is “a tax…on working people.” Even the Chancellor said that raising employer national insurance was a “jobs tax” that will “make each new recruit more expensive and increase the costs to business”. So does the Deputy Prime Minister agree with the IFS and her own Chancellor?
I remember what the Conservatives said to business. What was it? “Eff business”, whereas this party held an international investment summit last week, which put about £63 billion into our economy. We are pro-business, pro-worker and getting on with fixing the mess that they left behind.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether she agrees with IFS or her Chancellor
Criticized Conservative Government'S Approach To Business
Response accuracy
Q5
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP from Hertsmere questioned the Deputy Prime Minister about raising employer national insurance and its impact on working people.
I think we can take it from that answer that the Deputy Prime Minister does not agree with the IFS, and I suppose it should not come as a surprise that she does not agree with her Chancellor, but does she agree with this: “Working people will pay…when employers pass on the hike in national insurance”? Those are her words, so does she at least agree with herself?
What I am incredibly proud of is that this week, this Government brought in a new employment Bill that will raise the living standards of 10 million workers. Would the shadow Deputy Prime Minister like to apologise for the hike in taxes—they are at a 70-year high—that he put on working people, the crashing of the economy and the disaster that he left behind?
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address her agreement with previous statement or IFS view
Criticized Conservative Government'S Economic Policies
Response accuracy
Q6
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP from Hertsmere acknowledged the Deputy Prime Minister's policy but raised concerns about tax rises and the impact on working people, then shifted to discuss the Commonwealth summit.
The Deputy Prime Minister mentions her policy. Let us be clear: it is a £5 billion hit to the British economy, and that is her own assessment. Following these answers, there will be millions of working people even more worried about the tax rises coming their way in next week's Budget. However, as this is our last exchange across the Dispatch Box, I would like to turn to somebody I hope we can all agree is a hard-working person—His Majesty the King. Will the Deputy Prime Minister join me in sending him best wishes ahead of the Commonwealth summit in Samoa? In particular, will she confirm that this Government recognise the unique role played by the Commonwealth, and will she commit to deepening that relationship, so that, under His Majesty's leadership, we build upon possibly the greatest legacy of the late Queen?
I will miss our exchanges—the battle of the gingers, the late nights voting—and in that spirit, I will agree with my right hon. Friend. The King does a tremendous job, and so did the late Queen. The Commonwealth is very important, and that is why the King and the Prime Minister are working together at the moment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm commitment to deepening economic ties with the Commonwealth
Acknowledged The Importance Of The Commonwealth
Response accuracy
Q7
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP from Hertsmere questioned the Deputy Prime Minister about deepening economic ties with the Commonwealth and building on the legacy of Queen Elizabeth II.
I thank the right hon. Lady for that answer. Our Commonwealth family is brought together by historical and cultural ties—indeed, much like the pair of us. [Interruption.] I will resist the temptation to replicate that. As we look to the Commonwealth's future, we have the opportunity to deepen our economic relationship. Will she assure the House that the Prime Minister will use the summit to continue the work, begun by the last Government, of building deeper economic ties with our Commonwealth friends and allies?
We talk about economics; the architect of the 2024 Tory general election campaign is doing his victory lap before retiring with the hereditary peers that he fought so hard to protect. He leaves behind a Tory party in utter denial—heads in the sand, refusing to accept their rejection by the British public. Their plan for Britain includes scrapping the minimum wage, cutting maternity pay and tax breaks for the big oil companies. This Labour Government were elected—[Interruption.]
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not provide assurance regarding deepening economic ties with the Commonwealth
Criticized Conservative Government'S Policies And Personnel Decisions
Response accuracy
Q8
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlighted constituents' heart-rending stories of poor end-of-life support.
I have heard many heart-rending stories of constituents who had poor palliative care. Will the Deputy Prime Minister agree to set up a commission for palliative and end-of-life care, so that everyone can access the best support when terminally ill?
I thank my hon. Friend for raising this emotive subject. Discussions have begun on how to improve access to palliative and end-of-life care, and I will ensure that she gets a meeting with the relevant Minister.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to setting up a commission
Response accuracy
Q9
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP noted the NHS is bracing for a winter crisis due to insufficient care workers.
Our NHS is facing a winter crisis because there are thousands of people in hospitals who should be discharged but cannot be due to lack of care workers. Will the Deputy Prime Minister consider an NHS winter taskforce to end this cycle and improve patient discharge?
I thank the hon. Lady for her comments and share her desire to ensure care workers are given respect. Labour will create a national care service and launch its first fair pay agreement for care professionals.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to establishing an NHS winter taskforce
Response accuracy
Q10
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP questioned the impact of increased national insurance contributions on care workers and small businesses.
An increase in employers' national insurance contributions could affect millions of small businesses, including 18,000 small care providers. Will nothing in the Budget make it harder for vulnerable people to access the care they need?
I will not speculate on the Budget, but we recognise the impact of 14 years of Conservative government. We will rebuild Britain and grow our economy to fund public services.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address specific concern about national insurance contributions
Response accuracy
Q11
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The MP raised concerns over job risks at Hitachi Rail due to lack of government action.
Next year marks the 200th anniversary of the Stockton to Darlington railway. Will the Deputy Prime Minister join me and others in ensuring no stone is left unturned as we fight for the future of the Hitachi rail factory?
I welcome my hon. Friend and assure him that we are in close contact with Hitachi on operations to secure a sustainable future. We will support British manufacturing.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q12
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP praised Labour staff for campaigning against Donald Trump.
Will the Deputy Prime Minister join me in applauding Labour staff members who campaigned against Donald Trump?
I am loving this love-in. People often go and campaign on their own time with their own money, happening across all political parties.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q13
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP highlighted a survey showing three quarters of parents with special needs children have had to give up work or cut hours.
Charities like The Yard in Kirkcaldy provide vital support for disabled children and their families. Does the Deputy Prime Minister agree that tackling this intolerable reality is crucial?
I absolutely agree with my hon. Friend and pay tribute to those who work with disabled children. Future funding decisions will need to be taken as part of the upcoming spending review.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q14
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The MP criticised the Labour Government for cuts to pensioners' support, taxing education, and putting pressure on businesses.
Why does this Labour Government have such a problem with aspiration given recent cuts to pensioner support, taxing of education, and £5 billion in additional business pressures?
The hon. Member might not have been here last Parliament when his Government left a black hole of £22 billion, crashed the economy, and saw inflation at 11%, making pensioners worse off.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q15
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Following the Hamas attacks of October 7, a humanitarian crisis has developed with over 42,000 people killed and 11,000 children among them. Aid workers have been killed, families are starving, and people burned alive attached to drips.
I watched in horror as 42,000 people were killed in Gaza, 11,000 of them children. People have been burned alive attached to drips, aid workers have been killed and now families are starving. I asked the Prime Minister last year that the world will not stand by and see the lack of humanitarian assistance. If the Israeli Government will not listen to our Prime Minister's words, what tangible, measurable actions will we take as the UK Government?
The humanitarian situation in northern Gaza is dire. We need an immediate ceasefire, much more aid allowed to flow in and an immediate release of all the hostages. The Government have suspended UK export licences to Israel for items that might be used in the current conflict due to a clear risk they might be used in serious violations of international humanitarian law.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific measurable actions if Israeli government does not heed PM's words were not addressed
Response accuracy
Q16
Partial Answer
▸
Context
There are cases where parents and carers have argued that their fatal actions were lawful punishment. Scotland and Wales already protect children from violence.
Our child protection services have had to deal with a number of cases where parents and carers have argued that their fatal actions were lawful punishment. Will the Deputy Prime Minister bring forward legislation bringing the rest of our country into line with Scotland and Wales, so that all children enjoy unambiguous protection in law against violence?
The hon. Gentleman raises a very important point. I will ensure that the Minister has a meeting with him. The first job of any Government is to protect their citizens and that includes our children.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific legislation or timeline not provided
Response accuracy
Q17
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Government appointed Mariella Frostrup as the new menopause employment ambassador.
Last Friday was International Menopause Day and the Government announced Mariella Frostrup as the new menopause employment ambassador. Hopefully, the Deputy Prime Minister will join me in celebrating that appointment, and confirm that this Government will do all they can to keep menopausal women happy, healthy and wonderful.
Absolutely, and I thank my hon. Friend for her work in this area. This Government will boost protections for women experiencing menopause symptoms at work and I am proud that we have appointed Mariella Frostrup as the new menopause employment ambassador.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q18
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Charlie, an eight-year-old boy with autism, has been out of school for almost a year. There are 1,800 children in Surrey missing school due to lack of appropriate special educational needs provision.
Charlie from my constituency is an eight-year-old boy with an autism diagnosis who has been out of school for almost a year. He is one of 1,800 children in Surrey missing school because of a lack of appropriate special educational needs provision. Will the Government commit to ending this scandal by properly funding special educational needs provision in next week's Budget?
I thank the hon. Member for her very important question. I am sorry to hear about what Charlie and many other children with special educational needs have gone through.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Commitment to proper funding not addressed, only acknowledgment of issue
Response accuracy
Q19
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Recent news includes the death of a pregnant woman and children in the channel. There are ongoing deaths due to human smugglers.
This morning we woke to more tragic news of deaths in the channel, something we are hearing far too often. Just last month, we saw the death of a pregnant woman and children. What are the Government doing to take on the evil smuggling gangs who are trading in human misery?
I thank my hon. Friend and welcome him, and his expertise in the National Crime Agency, to this place. He knows that we inherited an asylum system in chaos.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Specific actions against smuggling gangs not detailed
Response accuracy
Q20
Partial Answer
▸
Context
The decommissioning of RAF Scampton is underway. There are concerns about the runway, spaceport, heritage centre being used for housing.
Will the Government please continue to work closely with me and West Lindsey district council to ensure that RAF Scampton is sold off in a timely fashion at a fair price, so that we secure the future of the runway, the spaceport and the heritage centre?
I thank the right hon. Gentleman, the Father of the House, for his question. My right hon. Friend the Home Secretary is taking urgent action to clear the backlog of cases and reduce the use of asylum accommodation, saving millions for taxpayers.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Sold RAF Scampton without addressing spaceport or heritage centre needs
Response accuracy
Q21
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Hundreds of leaseholders, tenants and shared owners are living in properties with cladding and other defects. People's lives are on hold due to building safety issues.
In my constituency, hundreds of leaseholders, tenants and shared owners are living in properties with cladding and other defects. Around the country, there are thousands. Their lives are on hold. Many are facing bankruptcy and delaying having children, unable to move. We have had another change in ministerial responsibility. Will the Deputy Prime Minister take a personal lead on keeping on top of this issue?
I thank my hon. Friend for her important question. Let me say from the outset that the pace of remediation has been too slow.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Personal lead commitment not clear beyond acknowledgment
Response accuracy
Q22
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Shropshire farmers face significant flooding issues, with recent data indicating only £2.1 million out of £50 million in the farming recovery fund has been distributed.
Shropshire's farmers have been suffering from flooding following 18 months of incredibly wet weather, topped off last Wednesday by a month's worth of rain in 24 hours. They were not eligible for the farming recovery fund, and a freedom of information request found that only £2.1 million of that £50 million has been handed out to farmers. Will the Government consider extending the eligibility of that scheme so that we can keep farmers going when they are deluged by floodwater?
I am really sorry to hear the plight of Shropshire farmers. We inherited the flood defence programme in disrepair, and thanks to 14 years of mismanagement and failure, communities are unprotected and families and businesses are forced to pay the price. We launched a flood defence taskforce to turbocharge the delivery and co-ordination of flood defences, and we are investing £1.5 billion this year to scale up flooding national resilience.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not address whether eligibility criteria for farming recovery fund will be extended
Response accuracy
Q23
Direct Answer
▸
Context
The Employment Rights Bill includes a fair pay agreement for care workers, aiming to improve their working conditions.
The Government have delivered on their manifesto commitment to introduce the Employment Rights Bill. It includes a historic fair pay agreement for care workers, which will benefit all those who care for older and disabled adults such as those in my constituency. Does the Deputy Prime Minister agree that care workers deserve pay and conditions that match the amazing work they do to support our loved ones to have a fulfilling life?
I welcome my hon. Friend to her place. As a biased former care worker, I will always champion carers and the complex quality and professional work that they do. I absolutely agree that care workers deserve the pay and conditions to match their enormous contribution to our community. I am proud to say that we are delivering that fair pay agreement that will give carers the recognition that they deserve, and I will ensure that those carers are able to deliver the best possible care to our loved ones.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q24
Partial Answer
▸
Context
A recent study indicated a significant drop in UK goods exports and imports to the EU since Brexit.
Last month, a widely reported study from Aston Business School showed that UK goods exports to the EU are 27% down, and imports are 32% lower than they would otherwise have been, thanks to the Conservatives' failed Brexit deal. Will the Deputy Prime Minister tell me what steps the Government are taking as part of their reset with the EU to cut Brexit red tape for small businesses, to help our economy get growing again?
I welcome the hon. Member to his place. He is right to advocate for small businesses, which are the backbone of our economy. This Government are turning the page on the relationship with Europe, reinvigorating alliances and forging new partnerships rather than reopening the divisions of the past. We will improve the UK's trade and investment relationship with the EU, tearing down unnecessary barriers to trade.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not specify steps being taken or timeline for reducing red tape
Response accuracy
Q25
Direct Answer
▸
Context
Private renters in the Cities of London and Westminster face issues such as damp, mould, no-fault evictions, and sudden rent hikes.
Some 27,000 people in the Cities of London and Westminster live in the private rented sector. After 14 years of neglect and delay, they face damp and mould in their homes, and risk no-fault evictions and out-of-the-blue rent hikes. Does the Deputy Prime Minister agree that the Renters' Rights Bill currently in Committee will transform the lives of private renters and finally rebalance power between tenants and landlords?
I welcome my hon. Friend to her place. I am incredibly proud of the Renters' Rights Bill that we are pushing through Parliament, because too many renters are being exploited by a minority of unscrupulous landlords, unable to challenge bad practices because they could be evicted at any moment.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Response accuracy
Q26
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Communities in Bedfordshire, including Maulden, have experienced an increase in flooding due to recent housing developments.
Communities across the country, including in Bedfordshire, recently experienced widespread flooding. The village of Maulden in my constituency has experienced an increase in flooding following cumulative housing development. As the Deputy Prime Minister requires communities across the country to build more homes, will she also ensure that those new developments do not increase the flooding risk?
I welcome the hon. Member to his place. We recognise the devastating impact that flooding can have. I know that the flooding Minister visited Bedfordshire in September to meet volunteers and residents. We inherited flood defences in disrepair and behind schedule. We have launched the floods resilience taskforce, and when it comes to the planning reforms needed to deliver the 1.5 million homes this country needs, we will ensure that the right infrastructure is in place and that communities are resilient.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm measures to prevent new developments increasing flood risks
Response accuracy
Q27
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Zoe's Place, a hospice in Liverpool, faces closure threats due to funding issues.
Zoe's Place, in the West Derby area of Liverpool, is a hospice that provides support to sick children and their families. It has been threatened with closure and has to find £5 million by the end of the year. Does the Deputy Prime Minister agree that such hospices need to be on a statutory footing and not reliant on charitable funding?
The hospice situation in this country has faced significant challenges because of the 14 years of devastation under the Conservatives. The Health Secretary has already raised these issues and knows that this is of importance; I will make sure that my hon. Friend gets to meet him.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not confirm support for statutory footing for hospices
Response accuracy
Q28
Partial Answer
▸
Context
Lincolnshire, a key agricultural area, is facing pressure from energy development projects that could impact agriculture.
The Deputy Prime Minister will know that my constituency, and Lincolnshire as a whole, is the breadbasket of Britain, producing 12% of the food consumed across the entire nation, including 30% of the vegetables and 20% of the sugar beet. That is because of the grade 1 and 2 land in Lincolnshire, yet Lincolnshire faces an invasion of giant pylons down the east coast and huge solar developments. Will she meet a delegation of colleagues from Lincolnshire and nearby, including my right hon. Friend the Member for Louth and Horncastle (Victoria Atkins), my hon. Friend the Member for Sleaford and North Hykeham (Dr Johnson) and the Father of the House, my right hon. Friend the Member for Gainsborough (Sir Edward Leigh), so that we can establish that energy security must never be a competitor with food security?
I thank the right hon. Member for his question. He knows that we launched a consultation on the national planning policy framework. We will protect agricultural land, we will ensure that we have renewable energy so we have energy security in this country, and we will get Britain building again.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Did not commit to meeting with delegation to discuss specific issues
Response accuracy