Stewart McDonald
MP for Glasgow South
SNP
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
Does the Prime Minister agree that now is the time for this project to be paused and reviewed by the Government on national security grounds?
Context
China's largest wind turbine manufacturer, Ming Yang Smart Energy, is planning to build a facility in Scotland. There are concerns about China's involvement in UK critical national energy infrastructure.
Rishi Sunak
China has different values from ours, and we take firm steps to protect ourselves. The National Security and Investment Act 2021 was passed to screen transactions for protection, and it has been used to block Chinese investment in sensitive areas.
Assessment
null
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Last year, the Prime Minister and other senior Ministers were given the conclusions of a Government audit of research programmes at UK universities with links to the Chinese state. Despite the report's warnings, no action has been taken. Why is this?
Context
A Government audit flagged hundreds of UK university research programmes as high risk for misuse by the Chinese Communist Party. The Prime Minister and other Ministers were given these findings last year.
Rishi Sunak
We will continue to take a robust approach towards China, rooted in our national interest. The National Security Act 2023 includes measures such as a foreign influence registration scheme. We will continue to take all necessary powers to protect the country.
Assessment
The specific ask about confirming knowledge of the report and explaining lack of action was not directly addressed.
Under Review
Proactive Approach
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Of course the sadism of Hamas can only be condemned, and there is no question of Israel's right to defence and security, but international law is very clear that acting against international law in response to terrorism is unjustified. In all the packages announced by the Prime Minister for humanitarian aid and military support, how will the Government ensure adherence to international law?
Context
Concerned about the impact of military actions against international law, specifically regarding Israel's right to self-defence and security.
Rishi Sunak
The assets moved into the region are for surveillance to prevent escalation and arms transfer, not combat. They provide contingency support for humanitarian assistance as required.
Assessment
Specific commitments on adherence to international law beyond surveillance operations
Changed Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Despite the catalogue of crimes committed by the Wagner Group across Africa and the middle east and in Ukraine, there is no permanent Cabinet Office official to co-ordinate government efforts against it. Will the Prime Minister appoint one and fund evidence collection for future justice?
Context
The Wagner Group, a Russian private military company, is accused of numerous human rights violations in Ukraine and other regions.
Rishi Sunak (Prime Minister)
We have designated both the Wagner Group and its leader under our sanctions regime, support mechanisms holding individuals accountable for violations of international law, but I reassure that we are working closely with partners to counter malign use by Russia. No mention of appointing an official or funding evidence collection.
Assessment
Appointment of a permanent Cabinet Office official and funding for evidence collection were not addressed
Talking About Sanctions And Support Mechanisms
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The MP warned of 'Ukraine fatigue' amidst rising prices and other financial pressures. He questioned if the Prime Minister's leadership was undermining support for Ukraine, asking her to commit to continued economic, military, and political support for Ukraine.
Context
The MP expressed concern about public fatigue and the potential impact on support for Ukraine amid economic challenges.
Elizabeth Truss
The PM committed to ensuring military support equals that provided in previous years. She stated that Ukraine can win with continued backing, but did not provide specifics or commitments beyond this.
Assessment
While affirming the commitment to military support, the PM avoided detailed commitments on economic and political support for Ukraine.
Acknowledged Military Support Without Details
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Staff at two hospitality venues in Glasgow, Blue Dog and AdLib, have had no furlough payments since the summer of last year. Although I have raised this with HMRC directly, the situation still has not moved forward. If I send the Prime Minister the details, will he knock heads together; help the staff, whose bills are going unpaid and debts are rising; and get the cash that they are entitled to into their accounts?
Context
Staff at Blue Dog and AdLib in Glasgow have had no furlough payments since the summer of last year.
Boris Johnson
I am very happy to look at it.
Assessment
Specific commitment to address the issue was not given
Promising To Look At It
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Even before the pandemic began it was clear that the UK has one of the most manifestly inadequate systems of statutory sick pay in the world: we are second from the bottom in European terms, and it continues to shun millions of workers who are low earners, work in the gig economy or are self-employed. As we come back from the crisis in economic terms and make the workplace better, will the Prime Minister agree to work with those of us in the Opposition who want to see a system that is fit for the 21st century that can meet people's needs?
Context
Prior to the pandemic, it was clear that statutory sick pay in the UK is inadequate.
The Prime Minister (Boris Johnson)
Yes, of course, statutory sick pay is an important part of the way we tackle the problems of self-isolation and all the issues faced by people facing coronavirus, but people also receive additional funds. Anybody looking impartially at what we are doing to support the people of this country throughout this epidemic will concede that the UK has done more than virtually any other country on earth to look after the people of this country, whether through the furloughing scheme, the bounce-back loans or anything else.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
What is he doing to turn the 'slow yes' on weapon delivery for Ukraine into a quick one? Does this not make a case for a comprehensive defence agreement between Britain and the EU?
Context
Frustration has been expressed about the slow pace of delivering weapons support for Ukraine from European countries, including Germany and the UK.
Leo Docherty
No, it does not, but we continue to work very energetically and closely with our friends across Europe, including at the recently convened French summit, to ensure that the heft and military capability of all Ukraine's allies are brought to bear in increasing Ukraine's fighting edge.
Session: Ukraine
View All Questions -->
The results of economic modelling from the Rhodium Group, the RAND Corporation and Bloomberg indicate severe consequences for global GDP due to either an economic blockade by China on Taiwan or a full-scale invasion. Has the Government conducted its own economic modelling for both scenarios? If so, will it publish these findings?
Context
Recent reports from various economic analysis firms have indicated significant potential impacts on global GDP if there is an economic blockade by China on Taiwan or a full-scale invasion. This has raised concerns about the preparedness and policy response in the UK.
Anne-Marie Trevelyan
The hon. Gentleman highlights the importance of understanding and planning for such economic coercion. This is an area of policy that sits within my portfolio in the FCDO. Across Government, we currently have a lot of focus on thinking about how we can build resilience in UK interests and support partners.
Session: China Diplomatic Relationship
View All Questions -->
What recent assessment has been made of the strength of the UK's diplomatic relationship with China? The Government must assess this in light of various economic and geopolitical pressures.
Context
The question arises from ongoing concerns about the UK's approach towards a strategic partner that also presents challenges. This includes balancing trade, security interests, and human rights issues.
Anne-Marie Trevelyan
The Government set out their approach to China in the integrated review refresh last year. We must continue to engage with China to work towards open, constructive and stable relations to manage disagreements, defend our freedoms and co-operate where our interests align. The Foreign Secretary spoke with China's Foreign Minister Wang Yi on 5 December in pursuit of those objectives.
Session: China Diplomatic Relationship
View All Questions -->
What are the Government doing to ensure that US support for Ukraine remains steadfast despite the ongoing political situation in the US?
Context
McDonald asked about the government's efforts to ensure US support for Ukraine remains steadfast despite political situations in the US, following President Zelensky's meeting at the White House and the Foreign Secretary's visit to Capitol Hill.
Leo Docherty
We are leading by example.
Session: NATO Support for Ukraine
View All Questions -->
It is obvious that in order to cement a sense of economic resilience Scotland requires a population growth strategy, but the devolution settlement, unfit as it is, will not come anywhere near that, and the Government continue to set their face against it. Can the Secretary of State explain why?
Context
Devolution settlement not fit for purpose regarding economic resilience.
Alister Jack
If the Scottish Government want more people to settle in Scotland—and immigration is at a record high—they need to build more housing, have lower taxes and better public services, and make Scotland more attractive to people.
Session: Devolution in Scotland
View All Questions -->
What assessment he has made of the state of devolution in Scotland?
Context
Assessment requested on current state and effectiveness.
Alister Jack
With devolved powers, the Scottish Government can tailor policy in areas such as health, education and justice, as well as in tax and welfare through additional powers in the Scotland Act 2016. The UK Government are working with local government and local partners to deliver on their needs and wishes. That is real devolution in action.
Session: Devolution in Scotland
View All Questions -->
How is the Secretary of State working here in London but also with partners to suffocate that capability as quickly as possible?
Context
The question stems from concerns about Iran's role in supplying Russia with drone technology used against Ukraine, particularly affecting Kyiv.
James Cleverly
The hon. Gentleman makes a very important point. When we first received credible reports of Iranian support to Russia in its drone attacks on Ukraine we investigated them and subsequently sanctioned entities and individuals involved in that. We are aware of the report he mentioned, and that will of course form part of our thinking on what other action we should take. It is important to remember that the action we have taken thus far is not the limit of our work, and we will continue to choke off the financial supply both to Russia itself and those seeking to arm it in that brutal war against the Ukrainian people.
Session: War in Ukraine
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions has he had with his Ukrainian counterpart on the war in Ukraine?
Context
The question arises from discussions between UK and Ukrainian officials on support for Ukraine during the ongoing conflict.
James Cleverly
I had the pleasure of meeting the Ukrainian Foreign Minister Dmytro Kuleba in Kyiv last week. I reassured him that the UK support for Ukraine and its territorial integrity is unwavering. The Ukrainian Government and people can count on our continued support both in their work on the battlefield and diplomatically, and, through the Ukraine recovery conference, our support in the rebuilding of their country once this war is over.
Session: War in Ukraine
View All Questions -->
My constituent Brian Murray has been campaigning for compensation following years of chronic health conditions caused by an infected blood transfusion. When will the Government enact all of the recommendations regarding compensation from the second report by Sir Brian Langstaff?
Context
Brian Murray lost his wife Roberta due to chronic health conditions after an infected blood transfusion, and he wants to know when the Government will enact all recommendations from Sir Brian Langstaff's second report regarding compensation.
Maria Caulfield
We take this issue seriously, and we have made interim payments to those infected. The Minister for the Cabinet Office came to the Dispatch Box in April when Brian Langstaff's review was published, and we are working night and day to respond to those recommendations and get that plan out as soon as possible.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Given the growing abuse of unpaid work trials, will you meet me to discuss what new legislation might look like?
Context
Unpaid work trials are being increasingly used despite Government guidance discouraging their use.
Guy Opperman
If he writes to me with the details of his argument, I will certainly consider it.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
AerCap is the largest provider of commercial aircraft in the world and, after the imposition of sanctions, it required a number of leased aircraft in Russia to be returned. That has not happened; instead, those aircraft have been re-registered in Russia, and continue to fly and operate. I know that there is a court case on the issue of loss with the insurance industry, but do the Government consider that to be an example of sanctions evasion?
Context
AerCap is the largest provider of commercial aircraft, and some leased aircraft in Russia have not been returned as required after sanctions were imposed.
James Cleverly
It is very difficult for me to come to an assessment based just on the points made in the hon. Gentleman's question. I am more than happy to look at the matter in more detail, if he will write to me about it or catch me privately. As I say, with regard to the legal action, he will understand that the Government cannot comment while that is ongoing.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I thank Mr Speaker. The Ministry of Defence has worked co-operatively on Ukraine despite any reshuffles. With winter approaching and intensified Russian attacks in south and eastern Ukraine, I ask to ensure that UK training for Ukrainian forces keeps pace with these developments and helps them through the winter.
Context
The situation in south and eastern Ukraine has worsened, with Russian Defence Minister Shoigu ordering an intensification of attacks. Winter approaches, raising concerns about the effectiveness of current support for Ukrainian armed forces.
Ben Wallace
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his constructive manner. We are learning as we go on the training, starting with a pledge to train 10,000 Ukrainian soldiers which may end up being 20,000 or more based on need. Our guided multiple launch rocket system is now active in Ukraine, delivering similar munitions that have had significant effects on Russian war capabilities. The key is to ensure Ukraine can withstand the summer and be prepared for winter.
Session: Ukrainian Resistance to Russian Aggression
View All Questions -->
I want to return to the issue that the shadow Secretary of State raised—not the individual allegations or even the “Panorama” programme, but the wider issue of the unanswerable case for democratic oversight of special forces. When will the Department devise proposals, bring them to the House, and allow us to debate and legislate on that issue? Surely that does not require anything at all from the courts.
Context
The shadow Secretary of State raised concerns about the need for democratic oversight of special forces.
Ben Wallace
Indeed it does not, and the hon. Gentleman is perfectly at liberty to table a motion and have a debate in this House. The key is making sure that democratically elected Ministers in this House have oversight of our special forces, and we are also bound by law in the same way that anyone else is.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I am grateful for that answer, but as other hon. Members have said, including on the Conservative Benches, a successful strategic concept surely does not include the UK Government cutting the armed forces by 10,000 and reducing the Army to its size in the war of the Spanish succession in 1701. Will the Minister, along with his colleagues in the Ministry of Defence, revisit the arbitrary cutting in size of the Army by 10,000? Would that not show NATO allies that he was serious about conventional defence forces in the UK and send the right message ahead of Armed Forces Day later this month?
Context
The question addresses concerns over the UK's decision to cut its armed forces by 10,000 and reduce the Army to pre-18th century levels.
James Heappey
Opposition spokespeople are in the habit of starting the clock on pledges for defence spending increases the day after the UK makes an enormous increase in defence spending. The UK led the alliance in deciding to increase spending in the face of increased insecurity in the Euro-Atlantic. NATO's strategic concept does not specify exactly what each nation must have; the strategic concept is what NATO as an alliance wants to do.
Session: NATO Effectiveness
View All Questions -->
Before I get into my question, as this will be our last Defence questions before Armed Forces Day, may I thank those in the armed forces for all their service, particularly over the past couple of years during the pandemic? On the strategic concept, there are three areas that we believe the Government must push for NATO to strengthen: the state levers of conventional defence power; societal resilience across the alliance, particularly in conjunction with the European Union's strategic compass; and the international rules-based system that keeps us safe, including among alliance members themselves. Can the Minister outline, as he tries to garner that consensus, what he thinks a successful strategic concept looks like?
Context
The question follows a discussion on the upcoming NATO strategic concept, focusing on areas such as conventional defence power and societal resilience.
James Heappey
It is one of those wonderful moments when we are in vigorous agreement. We would share the view that the state levers of hard power and the societal levers of resilience are hugely important, that NATO must stand for something and that its members must subscribe to a rules-based international system.
Session: NATO Effectiveness
View All Questions -->
Will the Minister enlighten the House as to what discussions are taking place in NATO specifically with a focus on helping the country to rebuild? The war will come to an end eventually and our friendship must continue the day after.
Context
The questioner raises the issue of NATO focusing on bolstering its own defences and supporting Ukraine militarily, with a need for international cooperation in post-war reconstruction.
James Heappey
The discussions in NATO focus on Euro-Atlantic security implications of the conflict, but wider geopolitical and economic plans may be discussed outside of NATO within other groupings such as the G7, EU, etc.
Session: Russian Aggression Support for NATO Allies
View All Questions -->
On behalf of the Scottish National party, may I welcome the letter from Speaker Stefanchuk to this House? My last exchange with the Secretary of State was in relation to the NATO strategic concept. When I asked about the Government's stance on it?
Context
The questioner seeks information regarding the Government's stance on the NATO strategic concept, previously discussed with a Secretary of State who is not present.
James Heappey
The hon. Gentleman will have to accept my apologies, but so important is the NATO strategic concept that it is something that the Secretary of State works on with his team immediately around him. He will need to write to the hon. Gentleman with the detail he asks for.
Session: Russian Aggression Support for NATO Allies
View All Questions -->
I am grateful for that answer. I may be jumping the gun slightly—I suspect the Secretary of State might come to this in his statement after questions—but one thing we were asked about a lot there was the new grouping between Ukraine, Poland and the United Kingdom. The detail on that is not quite out there just yet. Will he update the House on exactly what the new grouping hopes to achieve? Can he give an assurance that it will complement the work of other allies, rather than overlapping it?
Context
There were discussions about the new grouping between Ukraine, Poland and the United Kingdom during Stewart McDonald's visit to Ukraine.
Ben Wallace
We are working through those details right now and, as soon as I can, I will update the hon. Gentleman and the House. It is incredibly important we recognise that Ukraine borders a number of major NATO countries that will feel the direct consequence of an invasion. It is also important that President Putin's view of many of those countries, which he himself has written down in previous essays, could continue should he be successful in Ukraine. It is therefore really important that the UK plays a strong role in reassurance not only of NATO countries, but of other friends such as Sweden and Finland.
Session: Ukraine Territorial Integrity
View All Questions -->
On behalf of the Scottish National party, I welcome Speaker Pelosi and the American delegation to the Chamber. I also congratulate Team GB and yes, in particular, that fantastic curling team that so many of us have been enjoying in recent days. As the Defence Secretary knows, we have supported the Government's actions in helping Ukraine to defend itself against its neighbouring aggressor. Indeed, the Government's actions in giving military support are an act against war. However, during my visit to the Ukrainian capital a couple of weeks ago, I heard concerns at Government and parliamentary level about them still missing some support that I understand they had discussed with his Department. Will he assure us that those discussions are ongoing or give us an update?
Context
During his visit to the Ukrainian capital, Stewart McDonald heard concerns about missing support that Ukraine had discussed with the UK's Department of Defence.
Ben Wallace
I am grateful to the hon. Gentleman. On his comments about the winter Olympics, I have one of only two English curling rinks at Barton Grange in my constituency. I look forward to a Scots abroad event. We are open to all sorts of suggestions. I speak regularly to my defence counterpart in Ukraine, and it is incredibly important that, should we get through this with a diplomatic solution, we continue to help support Ukraine's resilience both in capacity building and training and in nation building to ensure that it is a strong and secure state.
Session: Ukraine Territorial Integrity
View All Questions -->
What assessment has been made regarding Lukashenko's statement on potential involvement in any future Russian-Ukrainian conflict?
Context
Lukashenko has stated Belarus will not remain neutral if there is a furthering of the conflict between Russia and Ukraine.
Vicky Ford
Russia is uniquely placed to exert pressure on Belarus to end repression. We want a reformed Belarus with good relations but insist that violence, harassment and arbitrary detention must stop.
Session: Belarus
View All Questions -->
But that was exactly what it was. Let us not muddy the words here: Paris was deceived, was it not? Are common challenges not better faced when liberal democracies trust each other and understand each other's mutual interests? Whether it is on the rise of authoritarianism or on issues of climate change, terrorism or migration, we must be aligned with our Euro-Atlantic allies first. Has the fallout from AUKUS not taught us all that we need to pursue a comprehensive defence and security treaty with the European Union? Can the Minister tell us why France was excluded right from the start?
Context
The fallout from the AUKUS agreement has raised concerns about trust among liberal democracies. The MP is questioning the exclusion of France in major defence initiatives.
Jeremy Quin
We have a number of close relationships, including through the Five Eyes, that we pursue on a global basis. We have an extremely close relationship with France, with whom we are doing so much around the world and with whom we enjoy extremely close relationships on equipment and support, as well as actively in the field. The bedrock of our relationships inside western Europe is of course NATO, which I am sure the hon. Gentleman would agree with. That is absolutely vital, and it is the cornerstone of our defence. It is an area in which we work closely with our European allies, including France.
Session: Defence Exports
View All Questions -->
Thank you, Mr Speaker. It is good to see you back from “Coronation Street” in such fine form, and to see the defence team still in its place. When the Government presented the integrated review to the House, we were told that this Indo-Pacific tilt would not undermine interests in the Euro-Atlantic area. Can the Minister tell the House exactly how engaging in secret diplomacy against the mutual security and against the trust interests with one of our closest European allies helps our interests in the Euro-Atlantic area?
Context
The MP inquired about the impact of the secret diplomacy with Australia.
Jeremy Quin
I think that that would be an accidental misunderstanding of the situation on the part of the hon. Gentleman. The reality is that a close friend and a close ally decided that they had a different strategic need and wanted to do something differently, and approached us.
Session: Defence Exports
View All Questions -->
Will our Government look at bringing an in-house employment network like Canada's spousal employment network in-house? The current situation leaves it to the third sector despite their efforts.
Context
Helping the spouses of service personnel find good-quality work is largely left to third-sector organisations, while Canada has a successful in-house model.
Ben Wallace
We are working on a families' strategy and his suggestion is exactly an area we are focusing on. We need to reinvigorate such organisations whether through the state or a blend of non-governmental organisations, charities, volunteers, and the state.
Session: Forces Families
View All Questions -->
Will the Secretary of State increase the childcare subsidy available to personnel and their families? The current subsidy is £2,000 but families are spending much more on childcare costs.
Context
Families of service personnel often face significant childcare costs, sometimes three times the amount provided by the Government.
Ben Wallace
We are increasing spending on wraparound childcare to over £165 million a year for families with children up to 11 years old, reflecting that most service personnel do not have a nine-to-five job and it will help them considerably. In fact, where we have run the pilots this has been incredibly popular.
Session: Forces Families
View All Questions -->
Refugee organisations say that 30 million new displacements last year were caused by floods, storms, and wildfires, triggered three times more displacements than violent conflicts did, and the number of those internally displaced worldwide hit record levels. Yet this Government have chosen to slash foreign aid to some of the world's most vulnerable to climate-based threats, making a complete mockery of the United Kingdom's leadership role ahead of COP26. So what assessment has the Ministry of Defence made of the cuts to foreign aid?
Context
The question addresses the worsening impacts of climate change on global poverty, economic stability, and security. It also mentions that acts of nature caused 30 million new displacements last year, more than conflicts.
Jeremy Quin
Climate change worsens poverty and economic stability, and poses a significant risk to global security. In our climate change and sustainability strategic approach, which I launched in March, we have laid out the extensive steps that we are taking to mitigate climate change and to address its implications.
Session: Climate Security
View All Questions -->
There is a lack of joined-up Government thinking on that. If the Government were serious about the impact that climate change is having on the threat picture, the foreign aid budget would not be getting cut and greater attention would be paid to the high north and the Arctic. What does the Ministry of Defence specifically want to get out of COP26?
Context
The defence Command Paper is seen as lacking in joined-up Government thinking on the impacts of climate change. The foreign aid budget has been cut, suggesting a lack of seriousness about the threat picture.
Jeremy Quin
COP26 is an entire-Government piece of work, and we are working with all nations around the Earth to get a whole load of deliverables out of COP26. Our commitment in terms of defence to meeting and addressing the needs of climate change was recognised on President Biden's Earth Day earlier this year, where the US Defence Secretary referred to the UK as having “raised the bar” in terms of Defence's work in this country on climate change.
Session: Climate Security
View All Questions -->
We know that hostile foreign actors are spending more money and following more sophisticated methods than ever before when it comes to sowing disinformation, including here in the UK. The latest data from both Facebook and Twitter tells us that in particular Iran and Russia are giving the United Kingdom and politics in the UK a lot of attention. Will the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster arrange a briefing for Members of Parliament and political parties, on appropriate terms, with the security services, so that we can all better understand the threat and ensure the integrity of our political discourse and democracy?
Context
Foreign actors like Iran and Russia are increasingly engaging in disinformation campaigns, particularly in the UK. This has raised concerns about the integrity of political discourse and democracy.
Michael Gove
The hon. Gentleman raises an important point; when it comes to many foreign defence and security questions, his is a sane and sensible voice. He is absolutely right that all political parties should be made aware of some of the potential attempts to subvert our democracy. Therefore I look forward to working with my colleagues to make sure that the material that we can share is shared and that everyone is aware of what we need to do to defend our democracy.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
When the integrated review is published tomorrow, will it contain something—anything at all—to reverse the trend on satisfaction given everything the armed forces have done during the pandemic?
Context
The integrated review is expected to address issues of personnel satisfaction, particularly concerning pay freezes.
Johnny Mercer
Let me be clear: this will be the first strategic review to have a specific address to our people. They are our finest asset. They are rewarded not only financially but through the choice of career on offer to them. I encourage the hon. Gentleman to read that when it comes out and I am more than happy to have a conversation with him after that.
Session: Armed Forces Personnel
View All Questions -->
Why does only four in ten serving personnel think that the pay they receive reflects the work they do?
Context
Four in ten serving personnel do not believe their pay reflects the work they do, indicating significant dissatisfaction.
Johnny Mercer
The crushing irony of our people who work in Scotland having to pay more in tax and therefore take home less pay and the hon. Gentleman raising this point is not lost on those who serve. Pay is a one of a number of factors that people speak about when the armed forces continuous attitude survey comes through. It is by no means the primary factor. We are constantly reviewing it and I am comfortable that we offer a world-class package to our people.
Session: Armed Forces Personnel
View All Questions -->
Will he match that for all UK personnel working here and abroad to help fight the pandemic in the upcoming Budget—yes or no?
Context
The MP questions about a £500 thank you payment for NHS and social care workers and asks if MOD will match it.
James Heappey
I will, of course, have a look at what that might mean if, in return, the hon. Gentleman will consider taxing the armed forces less than the Scottish Government currently do.
Session: Covid-19 Regional Support
View All Questions -->
What plans does the Minister have to recognise the extraordinary effort and work of those in the armed forces working on the pandemic alongside such brilliant NHS staff?
Context
The MP expresses gratitude towards the armed forces in Scotland and questions about future recognition.
James Heappey
The priority is to get on with the job at hand. However, there will be an eye on recognising their contribution when all this is done.
Session: Covid-19 Regional Support
View All Questions -->
Someone's put 50p in them today, Mr Speaker, haven't they just? Let me ask the Secretary of State this. I have asked him time and again, and he usually just shouts back to me whatever is in his folder; let's try answering the question. Of the spending announced for Scotland, at what point—he has only a few days of the year left—will the Government finally meet the promise they made six years ago of 12,500 personnel stationed permanently in Scotland? It is currently below 10,000. In all the projects he listed, he did not mention the promise of the frigate factory.
Context
The promise made six years ago for 12,500 personnel stationed permanently in Scotland is currently below 10,000. Stewart McDonald asked when this promise will be met.
Ben Wallace
I laughed because, having examined the proposals, the frigate factory would have included the closing of Govan and the investment in Scotstoun. I am not sure, but I remember distinctly that Govan was originally a very proud Labour seat, obviously then represented by the First Minister of Scotland.
Session: Integrated Review Treasury Discussions
View All Questions -->
Surely the review is meant to tell us what the threat is and then the Government respond with the spending, rather than the spending coming before the review is published. All that being said, I suppose we are where we are. I am grateful for one thing that the Secretary of State has done: he has finally listened to our policy of a multi-year defence agreement. May I ask him to go one step further? In other countries where those are used, they involve all political parties. Will he pledge to do so?
Context
The review should inform spending, not the other way around. Stewart McDonald asked if Ben Wallace would pledge to involve all political parties in a multi-year defence agreement.
Ben Wallace
What would be good is a welcome from the Scottish National party that £1.76 billion will be spent with Scottish business, at least, year on year. That is something that the Union manages to deliver for Scotland through the United Kingdom armed forces.
Session: Integrated Review Treasury Discussions
View All Questions -->
Support to the W93 programme in this budget cycle is critical, as stated by the Secretary of State. Given press reports and his Department's alarm over a possible Democratic victory impacting US support for this programme, does he agree with Tom McTague's assessment that Britain's strategy itself may be an existential challenge?
Context
The question stems from a letter sent by the Secretary of State to members of Congress in April stating that support for the W93 program is critical. Concerns have been raised about potential funding issues following an election outcome.
Ben Wallace
The hon. Gentleman misunderstands; the UK will maintain a £41 billion defence budget, one of Europe's largest. The nuclear deterrent and submarines are not under threat despite any single-year funding settlement. Steps will be taken to address financial challenges but this does not mean an end to our strategic goals or commitments.
Session: Strategic Defence Review Timescale
View All Questions -->
Can he tell us what the consequences of the postponement are for the future nuclear warheads system and, in particular, the W93?
Context
The MP expressed concerns about the postponement of a multi-year spending settlement and its impact on future nuclear warhead systems.
Ben Wallace
As I said to the right hon. Member for Wentworth and Dearne (John Healey), the first thing is to wait until we have worked through the consequences of the one-year spending announcement by the Treasury... I, or indeed the Prime Minister, will then be happy to come and update the House about what that means for the integrated review and the consequences that follow.
Session: Strategic Defence Review Timescale
View All Questions -->
Government promised 12,500 troops but never hit 10,000; also missed delivering frigate factory. Why does Secretary of State not answer question? Let us move to multi-year defence agreements: will we see progress when integrated review published next month?
Context
The SNP criticises defence promises not met in Scotland, mentioning Denmark's approach of multi-year agreements as a model.
Ben Wallace
We are having multi-year integrated review that sets course for next few years. SNP always resorts to saving regiments rather than discussing threats to Scotland; Treasury has talked about four-year spending settlement in next comprehensive spending review, so it is based on multiple years.
Session: Armed Forces Capability Future Security Threats
View All Questions -->
I echo comments about armed forces and current crisis. We know all about over-ambition and under-delivery when it comes to MoD: six years ago we were promised a frigate factory but promise broken; 12,500 regular troops in Scotland promised but number never hit 10,000. Is it time for multi-year defence agreements to prevent £13 billion equipment-plan black hole?
Context
The Scottish National Party criticises the UK government for failing to meet promises on defence infrastructure in Scotland, referencing a promised frigate factory that was not delivered.
Ben Wallace
Of course he may have missed Type 31 frigate and Type 26 ships being made in Scotland; Faslane base recently basing P-8s in Kinloss. There will be more investment and units placed in Scotland, because we believe UK is best union for security of all citizens. We do not believe in separation or borders between our countries. We are stronger when together.
Session: Armed Forces Capability Future Security Threats
View All Questions -->
Can he assure the House that the Scotland Office will be engaging fully with the upcoming integrated defence review, and will he agree to meet me to discuss some of the issues that are important to him and to the rest of Scotland?
Context
The MP seeks assurance that the Scotland Office will engage in the upcoming integrated defence review and requests a meeting to discuss issues important to his constituency.
Douglas Ross
I would be delighted to meet the hon. Gentleman, and we can continue that discussion about the great investment by the UK Government into Scotland, and into Moray. Last week, we welcomed the first of nine P-8A aircraft, the “Pride of Moray”, which touched down at Kinloss.
Session: Maritime Security
View All Questions -->
What discussions has he had with the Secretary of State for Defence on maritime security off the coast of Scotland?
Context
The MP is concerned about maritime security, particularly in the high north of Scotland due to historical breaches.
Douglas Ross
The Scottish Secretary and I regularly meet the Secretary of State for Defence to discuss a range of issues of importance to Scotland, including maritime security.
Session: Maritime Security
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Living Standards
01 February 2024
Responding: Bim Afolami
Main Concerns
['I am concerned about low living standards in the UK, which are well below those of western European counterparts. Economic insecurities such as inflation and energy prices, social factors like recovery from the pandemic, and global issues including climate change and immigration contribute to this problem. Brexit has exacerbated these challenges. Additionally, there is a stark need to reimagine public services due to heightened expectations post-pandemic.']
Specific Asks
['The government should consider new ideas beyond tax cuts to tackle living standards issues. We need investment in modernising public services and addressing income inequality, health inequalities, and the impact of global factors such as climate change and immigration.']
Unpaid Work Trials
29 March 2023
Responding: Kevin Hollinrake
Main Concerns
['I am concerned about the practice of unpaid work trials, which contributes to £3 billion in missing wages across the UK. These trials often involve applicants working for hours without payment and sometimes even for jobs that do not exist, exploiting them during busy periods such as Christmas trading. The study by Middlesex University and the Trust for London shows that this practice is widespread and morally fraudulent.']
Specific Asks
['I urge the Government to amend the National Minimum Wage Act 1998 to outlaw unpaid work trials, ensuring fair pay and preventing exploitation of job seekers.']
Afghan Special Forces Relocation Review
14 October 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Code of Conduct and Modernisation Committee
25 July 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Called the Leader of the House to move the first motion on code of conduct and guide to the rules, corrected a small error in paragraph 2(a) of chapter 4 of the guide to the rules. Also introduced ame...
Russia
08 May 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Taiwan Strait
25 March 2024
Adjournment Debate
Led by this MP
The debate began by Stewart McDonald congratulating Taiwan’s new President-elect Lai Ching-te, acknowledging the democratic leadership of outgoing President Tsai Ing-wen. He highlighted China's aggres...
Cyber-security and UK Democracy
25 March 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Ukraine
28 February 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Israel and Palestine
08 January 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Breaking Down Barriers to Opportunity
08 November 2023
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Education is key to unlocking opportunities for the next generation. The Conservative Government has invested heavily in childcare, schools, and technical education over the past decade. Despite inher...
War in Ukraine
24 October 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Situation in Russia
26 June 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
7
PMQs Asked
39
Ministerial Questions Asked
52
House of Commons Debates Involved
2
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
0
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1457 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
+91% above average
This MP:
7
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
+191% above average
This MP:
39
Average:
13.4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
-20% below average
This MP:
2
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+970% above average
This MP:
52
Average:
4.9
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-100% below average
This MP:
0.0
Average:
69.2
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Stewart McDonald's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.