Stewart Hosie
MP for Dundee East
SNP
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
Both covid and Brexit are suppressing trade and damaging jobs and the economy and while we hope that, as covid ends, global trade will bounce back, there is no guarantee that that will happen quickly. The Prime Minister could mitigate some of this damage by seeking an extension to the Brexit transitional period. Will he explain to the House why he is being so negligent in not seeking that transitional extension now?
Context
Hosie raises concerns about the economic impact of both COVID-19 and Brexit, suggesting that an extended transitional period could mitigate some damage.
The Prime Minister (Boris Johnson)
As I have said, one of the most remarkable things about this crisis has been the way that the whole country has come together to deal with it. There has been a spirit of unity and sharing that we have not seen for a very long time. I do not think that a lot of people in this country want to see the Brexit argument reopened. They want to see it settled, they want to see it done, and that is what this Government intend to do.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Given the current high inflation, will the Chancellor guarantee halving inflation as promised by the Prime Minister?
Context
OBR forecast inflation to peak at 2.9% but it reached 5%, now 8.7%. Food inflation is 16.5%
Jeremy Hunt
The IMF, OBR and Bank of England predict hitting our target to halve inflation. We will stick to this plan.
Session: Cost of Living
View All Questions -->
In the absence of changing the Bank of England inflation target, what do the Government plan to do about mortgage pain?
Context
Mortgage rates have increased from 2.57% to 6%, causing concern.
Jeremy Hunt
We will look at doing everything we can to help people under pressure but avoid actions that would prolong inflation.
Session: Cost of Living
View All Questions -->
What steps are the Government taking to ensure that investment zones do not suffer from the same problem as enterprise zones and freeports?
Context
The MP questions whether investment zones will suffer from the same problems as enterprise zones and freeports.
John Glen
We will be working closely with the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities to look at each proposal by the end of the year. We will be having that certainty on the tax incentives over those five years and making local authorities an accountable body for the delivery of this.
Session: Investment Zones
View All Questions -->
What additional fiscal support are the Government providing to differentiate these investment zones from enterprise zones?
Context
The MP inquires about the fiscal support offered by investment zones compared to enterprise zones.
John Glen
The key distinction is that we have identified areas that have clusters, often relating to a university, and that have potential in a key sector. The investment zones will be worth £80 million over five years.
Session: Investment Zones
View All Questions -->
A two-year fixed-interest mortgage with a 5% deposit was under 3% last August but is now north of 6%. A similar mortgage with a 25% deposit has also seen its interest rate increase from 1.25% to over 6%. How can it possibly be fair that somebody buying an average-priced house in Scotland worth around £190,000 could face such high interest rates?
Context
Interest rates for two-year fixed-rate mortgages have significantly increased over the past year, impacting average-priced house purchases.
Andrew Griffith
Interest rates are now falling, something the right hon. Gentleman declined to mention. The best thing we can do to help those interest rates is to deliver on the Prime Minister's objective of halving inflation.
Session: Mortgage Rates
View All Questions -->
Before we even get to the issue of support for mortgage holders, what is the Treasury doing to ensure the availability of mortgages, a good range of mortgage products and an end to offers being withdrawn unless there is a very, very good reason to do so?
Context
Last August, there were 75,000 mortgage approvals. By December, this number halved, with reports of mortgage product removals and offer withdrawals.
Andrew Griffith
We have recently renewed the mortgage guarantee scheme which helps the availability of high loan to value ratio mortgages. We are looking very clearly at the mortgage market and at things that we can do to help first-time buyers.
Session: Mortgage Rates
View All Questions -->
Therein lies the problem: this will go to high energy users. The Federation of Small Businesses described the changes as “catastrophic” and the beginning of the end for tens of thousands of small businesses, the British Chambers of Commerce said that an 85% drop in the financial envelope of support will fall short for thousands of UK businesses who are seriously struggling, and UKHospitality criticised the sudden and sharp drop in support, estimating the move would cost that sector £4.5 billion in the next 12 months. Why does the Minister think they were all wrong and he is right?
Context
Concerns expressed about the impact of reduced energy support schemes on small businesses, citing criticisms from various business organisations.
James Cartlidge
As I said to the hon. Member for Airdrie and Shotts (Ms Qaisar), we were clear when we created the scheme to support businesses with their energy bills that it had to be time limited because of the generosity of the support—£18 billion over six months. We were absolutely transparent about that. But we have maintained a universal scheme covering businesses, charities and the public sector. Yes, it is less generous, but it remains significant. As I said, he is welcome to write to me with the specific case he raised.
Session: Economy Impact of Changes in Energy Support Schemes
View All Questions -->
I have a constituent with a number of shops. He has seen his four-weekly energy costs rise from £12,000 last October to £27,000 today. Moving on to lower tariffs, but with the reduced energy support, he will still see that £12,000 every four weeks doubled, to £24,000. What advice would the Minister give to my constituent? How would he find the £140,000 off the bottom line in a business already operating on tight margins?
Context
A constituent's story of a business owner seeing significant increases in quarterly energy costs and the challenge of finding £140,000 to cover future expenses.
James Cartlidge
With great respect to the right hon. Gentleman, he was there when I gave the statement about the new scheme. I was clear with him about the fiscal position overall. He is welcome to write to me on that specific case. Obviously, I cannot comment on the detail of that individual case. What I can say is that we continue to put in place up to £5.5 billion of support with the energy bills discount scheme. That is a significant intervention and it remains a universal scheme with targeted support for the most energy and trade-intensive sectors.
Session: Economy Impact of Changes in Energy Support Schemes
View All Questions -->
Given the intention to review capital requirements, how will the Chancellor ensure the regulatory focus on stability is maintained?
Context
The MP is concerned about the potential weakening of regulatory standards and international confidence in UK's financial system.
John Glen
I heartily agree with its conclusions. Stability is at the core of the regulators' objectives, but also developing frameworks in line with expectations so that we can remain a world-leading global hub for financial services.
Session: Financial Conduct Authority Loyalty Penalties in Insurance Market.
View All Questions -->
Given that many consultations closed very quickly, how can we be convinced that the painful lessons of the financial crash have not been forgotten?
Context
The MP is concerned about the timeline of consultations regarding financial services regulation and fears lessons from the financial crash might be overlooked.
John Glen
For four and a half years, I was the Economic Secretary to the Treasury, and many of those reforms were baked up over a lot of consultation with industry over many months. The Edinburgh reforms represent an incremental advance on those reforms and have high prudential regulatory standards very much at their core.
Session: Financial Conduct Authority Loyalty Penalties in Insurance Market.
View All Questions -->
Half the public thinks there is inadequate regulation of political party spending and only 14% think there is transparency around it. The Paymaster General knows well that there have been concerns about the influence of dark money in the UK electoral system for many years. Why could it be that this Government are planning to suppress the right of ordinary people to vote rather than tackle the real problem of dark money buying influence in the democratic process?
Context
The public is concerned about inadequate regulation of political party spending, with only 14% thinking there is transparency. There are long-standing concerns over the influence of dark money in the UK electoral system.
Michael Ellis
These bold assertions have no basis in evidence or reality and suppress votes. The right hon. Gentleman wants to focus on a lack of regulation regarding voting confidence, while we seek to protect the voting system as outlined in our manifesto commitment.
Session: Voter ID Requirements Turnout and Enfranchisement
View All Questions -->
Some 90% of the public think that polling station voting is safe from fraud and abuse, and they are right to think that. Personation resulted in a single conviction in 2016, 7, and 2019, and zero convictions in 2018. Given up to 3.5 million people may not have suitable ID and the Government's pilots confirmed up to 324,000 people would be denied a vote in a Great Britain election, why are this Government prepared to embark on voter suppression on an industrial scale?
Context
The public largely believes polling station voting is safe from fraud, with only one person convicted of personation over multiple years. Up to 3.5 million people lack suitable ID for new provisions in the Elections Bill, which could disenfranchise up to 324,000 voters.
Michael Ellis
I am surprised by the right hon. Gentleman, because it is not just a question of convictions: attempts to commit crimes are also wrongs. We have to focus on reducing criminality in this area and increasing voter confidence that they will not be subject to personation.
Session: Voter ID Requirements Turnout and Enfranchisement
View All Questions -->
Given the rise in support for independence and decline of Union, is it suspicious that the contract was awarded to Public First without competition?
Context
The question follows a ruling by the High Court that found the Minister acted with apparent bias when awarding contracts to Public First without competitive tender.
Michael Gove
A bottomless Unionist slush fund does not exist. The contract was not awarded by me and I did not act with any actual or apparent bias, as found by Lady Justice O'Farrell.
Session: Union in Scotland Public Opinion Polling
View All Questions -->
How can the Minister justify siphoning off many tens of thousands of pounds from covid recovery work to fund this political research?
Context
The High Court ruled that the Minister for the Cabinet Office acted with apparent bias in awarding contracts to Public First, a company previously advising him, Prime Minister, and Dominic Cummings.
Michael Gove
I did not award the contract. The Scottish Government have received more than £180 million from the UK Government in covid recovery funds, which they have yet to publish accounts on how it is being spent.
Session: Union in Scotland Public Opinion Polling
View All Questions -->
Monitoring is fine, but we need action. Let me raise the issue of another business: ATL Turbine Services, which brings into Scotland for repair turbine parts from around Europe and the world. It has told me that its post-Brexit admin costs are now 10 to 15 times greater than they were last year. It cannot use the Revenue's post-VAT accounting processes. It is encountering significantly more shipping errors, not just costs. Most damningly, it has said that, while the high-level structure has been put in place, the details of how it works in practice are basically non-existent and, where they do exist, have fallen short. Cost increases, administrative burdens, shipping errors, no useful guidance—when will this Government finally take these issues seriously? Would it not be better to admit, finally, that the truth is that, for business, Brexit is not working?
Context
The MP raises specific issues faced by another local company, ATL Turbine Services, including increased post-Brexit admin costs and shipping errors.
Penny Mordaunt
I have been doing a large amount of work with Lord Frost to look at what advice and support there is for businesses and what their needs are. They now need at this stage more bespoke support, and we are standing that up and putting it in place. We will be informing Members of this House about that in short order. As well as mitigating the difficulties that we are having, as a nation, to work through, we want people to maximise the opportunities. The trade deals that I referred to represent £217 billion-worth of business. We want all businesses across the UK to maximise that and we will provide the space for them to do that.
Session: Barriers to Trade Between EU and UK
View All Questions -->
In February, I raised with the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster the issue of Wilde Mode, a company in my constituency, and the increases in shipping costs it has had. In the past week or so, it has confirmed that it is still being quoted about €1,000 to ship in from Poland, when pre Brexit it was effectively zero. What concrete action are the Government going to take to resolve these problems, to end this uncompetitiveness and to mitigate these massive Brexit-driven cost increases?
Context
The MP is concerned about the impact of Brexit on a local company, Wilde Mode, facing significant increases in shipping costs.
Penny Mordaunt
In addition to the work that my noble Friend Lord Frost is leading on, which the right hon. Gentleman will be aware of, and the financial support we have put in place, we are monitoring what businesses are being charged, whether it is through trader support services or through particular aspects of the supply chain. We are monitoring those costs, and that is factored into our work and the work that Lord Frost is taking forward.
Session: Barriers to Trade Between EU and UK
View All Questions -->
Why have the UK Government chosen to mislead the public by omitting their identity in ads?
Context
Further concern over Government advertisements not clearly identifying themselves as such, potentially misleading the public.
Michael Gove
I am happy to put my name and that of the UK Government to all this material. We work in conjunction with devolved Administrations to place content appropriately, including during the covid pandemic. The Scottish Government also advertises in newspapers.
Session: Native Advertising in UK Newspapers Departmental Spending
View All Questions -->
Why have the Government chosen to flout the Advertising Standards Authority (ASA) code by omitting their identity in ads?
Context
Concern over Government advertisements not clearly identifying themselves as such, potentially misleading the public.
Michael Gove
I have been furnished with no evidence of flouting the code. However, if there are complaints, we will investigate them. He also notes that the Scottish Government spends money on advertising in newspapers like The Press and Journal and The Courier.
Session: Native Advertising in UK Newspapers Departmental Spending
View All Questions -->
I am struggling to see the advantages and new opportunities. A firm in my constituency, Wilde Mode Ltd, imports rolls of printed fabric from Poland. The delivery costs have increased from under €40 before Brexit to €2,000 now, making it unsustainable. When will measures to ease these problems be put in place fully and actually start to work?
Context
A firm in Stewart Hosie's constituency, Wilde Mode Ltd, faces significant increases in delivery costs from Poland due to Brexit. Before Brexit, deliveries cost less than €40 but now are quoted at €2,000 for the same service.
Michael Gove
I am grateful to raise the case of the firm in Dundee and will look specifically at Wilde Mode Ltd's challenges, including those faced by the Polish supplier and courier company. I aim to ensure any interruptions in supply from Poland to Dundee are addressed.
Session: Trade UK and EU
View All Questions -->
Measures to ease border problems have been put in place but are they working effectively? When will these measures start making a difference?
Context
60% of companies report difficulties importing/exporting to/from the EU, impacting supply chains.
Michael Gove
Facilitations and easements have been put in place, some before the transition period. More support is being provided, particularly to SMEs, to take advantage of opportunities.
Session: Trade UK and EU
View All Questions -->
That was possibly the worst case of deflection I have ever seen, even from a Tory. The Brexit advice on offer to businesses such as John Ross Jr, which has an exemplary 30-year record in exporting, “has fallen woefully short when it comes to one of the most important commercial issues of our time.” Instead of vague promises about future campaigns, pathetic attempts at deflection and playing rather silly politics, would it not be better to fix the problems at the UK-EU border, where real exports happen, to protect real jobs and businesses?
Context
The Secretary of State was criticised for vague promises about future campaigns instead of fixing border problems.
Elizabeth Truss (Secretary of State for International Trade)
My right hon. Friend the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster is working very hard with the Brexit business taskforce to make sure that disruption is minimised and businesses are given support. It is perfectly reasonable for me to raise the £200 million that has been given to the Scottish Government and how they are spending it, and the hon. Gentleman's silence speaks volumes.
Session: Food and Drink Exports
View All Questions -->
The Secretary of State was copied in to a letter to the Business Secretary from Vicky Leigh-Pearson, the sales director at John Ross Jr, Aberdeen, salmon producers and exporters. It described in excoriating detail the “barrage of useless information” on Brexit, which added no value or clarity for such food and drink exporting businesses. Would it not be better to fix the problems at the UK-EU border, where real exports take place, rather than make vague promises about future promotional campaigns?
Context
Vicky Leigh-Pearson, sales director at John Ross Jr in Aberdeen, described the Brexit advice as a barrage of useless information.
Elizabeth Truss (Secretary of State for International Trade)
I observe that the hon. Gentleman did not support a deal, so effectively he wanted no deal for the people of the United Kingdom. I think it is a bit rich of him to raise issues when no deal would have been very, very tricky for the exporters he is talking about. Given that £200 million was given to the Scottish Government to prepare to minimise disruption, I suggest he takes up the issue with Nicola Sturgeon to see how that money has been spent to help Scottish exporters.
Session: Food and Drink Exports
View All Questions -->
The end of the transition period has been described by Scottish businesses as a “catastrophic” situation. Some have argued that if they cannot trade with the EU, they are out of the game—it is an existential threat. Can I ask the Scottish Secretary to actually show some authority in the Cabinet and insist on a minimum six-month grace period, so businesses do not fall foul of regulations which are not yet developed for a deal that is not yet agreed, but which is supposed to be in place in barely three weeks' time? This needs to be done; it needs to be done today. Otherwise, businesses will struggle dreadfully on his watch.
Context
Scottish businesses are concerned about the transition to new trade regulations without a deal, potentially facing an existential threat.
Alister Jack
There has been a major public information campaign running for businesses and citizens, telling them exactly what they need to do. We have always been clear that, whether it is deal or no deal, there are steps that have to be taken when the transition period comes to an end. We are not going to delay the end of the transition period, because it is only by sticking to that date that people can prepare responsibly, and it also holds the EU's feet to the fire in getting a deal. We have been clear what measures they need to take. They need to look at the UK Government website, where they can see very clearly what preparations they need to make for the end of this month.
Session: End of the Transition Period Preparedness
View All Questions -->
Protecting food standards is crucial but the Minister's previous answer seems inadequate. UK egg producers cannot compete with imports from countries allowing higher density laying hens and other low-welfare practices. The public opposes lower standards, as highlighted by a recent Which? survey. Is it really the Government's intention to support such trade deals that harm our food standards and welfare?
Context
UK egg producers are struggling to compete with imported eggs produced under lower welfare standards, according to a recent Which? survey. The public is opposed to lowering these standards.
Greg Hands
The hon. Gentleman raised a Which? survey about national trade issues, which I was part of launching, reiterating our commitment to not lowering standards on food safety, animal welfare, and the environment. NFU Scotland supports a positive approach for the best interests of farming, food, and drink industry, urging him to reconsider his stance.
Session: Trade Agreements Food and Farming Standards
View All Questions -->
After a detailed discussion with NFU Scotland, I noted their concern over future trade deals due to high costs and stringent food standards in the UK compared to competitors abroad. They argue that they cannot compete with low-cost competition from countries with lower food standards. Is it time for the Government to include chapters on food, animal welfare, and standards in trade agreements?
Context
NFU Scotland is concerned about future trade deals, arguing that the UK cannot compete with low-cost competition from countries with lower food standards. The organisation is worried about the impact of these deals on UK agriculture.
Greg Hands
I studied carefully the hon. Gentleman's amendment during the passage of the Trade Bill, which was more extreme than Labour's attempts to dictate domestic production standards for our trade partners, potentially harming trade with developing nations. NFU Scotland president Andrew McCornick recently stated in The Scottish Farmer that putting a trade and agriculture committee (TAC) on a statutory footing is 'a huge step forward'.
Session: Trade Agreements Food and Farming Standards
View All Questions -->
It is just not the UK that is seeking to join CPTPP; Thailand, for example, is actively investigating it. Thailand's faculty of pharmaceutical sciences has assessed that because of the way CPTPP rules on patents and on market approval for generic drugs that impact on Government procurement and so on work, the costs of drugs would rise. Given the Bangkok Post headline that CPTPP would lead to “soaring” drugs bills, what guarantees can the Minister give that a similar rise in the cost of medicines to the NHS, for the same reasons, would not be the consequence here?
Context
Thailand's faculty of pharmaceutical sciences assessed that under CPTPP, the costs of drugs would rise due to patent and market approval rules impacting government procurement.
Greg Hands
Again, I thank the hon. Gentleman for that question. Nothing in any trade deal prevents us from setting domestic pharmaceutical prices, and that would remain true in respect of CPTPP. Let me have a look at why the Scottish National party is questioning the potential to join CPTPP. I have the feeling that the SNP is just not in favour of any trade agreements; I have had a look at CPTPP members, and the SNP was against doing a deal with Canada, against doing a deal with Japan in Brussels and against doing a deal with Singapore. So I feel that whatever intricate, detailed questions he has on CPTPP, he will not support our joining it.
Session: Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership
View All Questions -->
I thank the Minister for the update. However, when the non-partisan Centre for Economic Policy Research assessed the United States accession to the original and similar trans-Pacific partnership trade deal, it concluded that wages might rise for the top 10% of earners but fall for everybody else. What assessment has his Department made of the impact of CPTPP accession on income levels in the UK, and what guarantees can he give that worsening income inequality would not be a consequence here?
Context
The Centre for Economic Policy Research assessed that the US accession to TPP could lead to rising wages for top earners and falling incomes for others. Stewart Hosie is concerned about similar impacts on UK income levels.
Greg Hands
I thank the hon. Gentleman for that interesting question. I have not seen that study on the original TPP, but I will say two things. First, when the UK applies, we will be publishing a scoping assessment—an impact assessment—looking at how the deal will affect the UK economy. Secondly, liberal-minded, like-minded democracies such as Canada, Australia and New Zealand have embraced CPTPP with great enthusiasm, which gives me some encouragement in this space.
Session: Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership
View All Questions -->
The gravity analysis in the internal market Command Paper shows a border between Scotland and rest of UK would have an 1.1% GDP impact. With Brexit expected to be seven times larger—losses around 8% for Scotland—when discussing with Scottish Government, will he bring forward another Command Paper insisting on single market inclusion?
Context
Analysis suggests a border effect could impact Scottish GDP, and Brexit's effects are projected as much more significant.
Alister Jack
We are leaving the EU, and I do not recognise his figures. We saw many projections on Brexit that were wrong. With good trade deals and UK legislation, we will strengthen the Scottish economy.
Session: UK Internal Market
View All Questions -->
Given that Which? tells us that 95% of the public want to maintain current food standards, why do this Government continue to rule out real legislative protections in a trade Bill that would accord with the views of our farmers, our doctors and the general public?
Context
MP seeks assurance from the Secretary of State on legislative measures to maintain high food import standards amidst ongoing free trade negotiations.
The Secretary of State for International Trade Elizabeth Truss
These standards, such as the ban on chlorinated chicken and hormone-injected beef, are already in UK law as part of the EU withdrawal Act. I have been explicit: it is not a matter for trade policy; it is a matter for our domestic law what standards we have in this country, and we are not trading it away.
Session: Free Trade Agreement Negotiations Food and Farming
View All Questions -->
I am glad that that is being looked at because, right now, if an agreement is not reached between the UK and the European Union, UK legal practitioners—lawyers—will no longer be protected by legal or professional privilege inside the European Union. May we have a specific focus on that to ensure that jeopardy is removed, but also, more importantly, to ensure that the associated disincentive to trade in legal services is removed?
Context
There is a concern that UK legal practitioners will no longer be protected by professional privilege inside the European Union.
Greg Hands
Again, this is really a matter for Taskforce Europe, but I will pass on the hon. Member's question to it to give him a more detailed response. What I can say is that the DIT team promote trade in legal services, particularly the mutual recognition of qualifications, in all our talks. I have done that personally in this role, and the Secretary of State is committed to doing so.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Will the Secretary of State update the House on the progress being made to ensure that the legal services trade between the UK and the European Union can be maintained after the end of this year?
Context
There is a need to maintain legal service trade after the end of this year.
Greg Hands
That is properly a question for a different Question Time, because it is Taskforce Europe that is responsible for our future trading relations with the European Union. What I can say to the hon. Member is that the mutual recognition of professional qualifications is one of the key aspects we are looking at in free trade agreements with counterparties across the world.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Extremism Definition and Community Engagement
14 March 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Budget Resolutions
06 March 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Conservatives' record is marked by a recession, high tax burden, living standards decline, and fiscal irresponsibility. The Chancellor's new measures do not address these issues; they merely exace...
UK Economy
19 February 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Backbench Business
07 December 2023
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The debate focuses on the rise of Islamophobia in the UK, with a particular emphasis on the Government's reluctance to officially acknowledge and address this issue. The speaker highlights internation...
Storm Babet: Flooding
23 October 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Tata Group Gigafactory Investment
20 July 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Contest: UK Strategy for Countering Terrorism 2023
19 July 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Financial Services Reforms
11 July 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Opposition Day
27 June 2023
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The shadow Chancellor opened by criticising the government's economic policies, highlighting a decline in public services and an increase in national debt. He emphasised the need for fiscal responsibi...
Mortgage Charter
26 June 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
1
PMQs Asked
31
Ministerial Questions Asked
67
House of Commons Debates Involved
0
Westminster Hall Debates Led
9
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
0
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1370 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
-73% below average
This MP:
1
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
+127% above average
This MP:
31
Average:
13.7
Westminster Hall Debates Led
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+1284% above average
This MP:
67
Average:
4.8
Statements / Bills Proposed
-5% below average
This MP:
9
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.4
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Stewart Hosie's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.