Stephen Flynn
MP for Aberdeen South
SNP
12 Dec 2019 - Present
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
Depending upon the results in the elections next week, this may well be my final PMQs. I suppose that the same is perhaps true for the Prime Minister as well. But before then, does he understand that, yes, it is because of inaction on the cost of living crisis; yes, it is because of the debacle of the winter fuel payment; yes, it is because of the thousand jobs being lost a month in Scotland’s North sea and the closure of Grangemouth; and yes, it is because of his judgment on Matthew Doyle and Peter Mandelson; but above all else, the reason that his time in office will soon be coming to a close is that he promised change but has delivered chaos?
Keir Starmer
I am proud of what this Labour Government have achieved and I am proud of what we will achieve. If this is the right hon. Gentleman’s last session here, let us reflect on his great achievements in Westminster. He kicked out his predecessor and then lost 39 MPs at the next election. I hope he can keep up that record in Holyrood next week.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Let us be clear on this. Donald Trump's war in Iran is illegal and the situation that has unfolded since is verging on insane: oil is falling from the skies; sewers are exploding; and the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps is indiscriminately attacking both civilians across the region and cargo ships, as well as potentially even mining the strait of Hormuz, the economic consequences of which will be stark not just for the global economy, but for every single person living on these isles. Whether the Prime Minister accepts it or not, he did take us into that war when he allowed the Americans to use UK bases last week. Does he believe that to be a war crime?
Context
The conflict in Iran is escalating, with footage emerging of an American Tomahawk missile hitting a primary school and killing 110 children. The SNP is concerned about the legality of the conflict and the potential for war crimes.
Keir Starmer
We are all concerned by that footage, but let me absolutely clear with the right hon. Gentleman. We have 300,000 UK nationals, including Scottish citizens, in the region. Strikes, missiles and drones are being fired into the region, putting those people at great danger. We are taking action to protect them. I am astonished that the SNP is saying, “Don't take action to support Scottish citizens in the region.” That is outrageous.
Assessment
The attack on the primary school
We Are Taking Action To Protect Uk Nationals In The Region
I Am Astonished That The Snp Is Saying, “Don'T Take Action To Support Scottish Citizens In The Region.”
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
If I have just heard the Prime Minister correctly, he has essentially rolled the same pitch in relation to Matthew Doyle as he did with Peter Mandelson, in saying that they were not clear with him. He appears to be the most gullible former Director of Public Prosecutions in history. But he has a slight problem, because some of us do read the newspapers. Towards the end of last year, on 30 December, having written to the House of Lords Appointments Commission, I received a response from the chair, who advised me that as part of their vetting, they provide confidential advice to the Prime Minister on the propriety of the proposed nominees.
Context
There is a question about the confidentiality and propriety of appointments, specifically concerning Matthew Doyle's nomination.
Keir Starmer
I have made my position clear. The right hon. Gentleman knows how the system works. He says he reads the newspapers. He will have read that in nine days, his party's former chief executive goes on trial for embezzling money.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
During BBC's scam awareness week, advice is to report scams. Can the PM advise if he knows anyone who promised to reduce energy bills but increased them; promised to back business but taxed it; or promised to protect pensioners but took their winter fuel allowance?
Context
The question arises from BBC's scam awareness week, highlighting the issue of false promises made by the government.
Keir Starmer
It is very—[Interruption.] The answer was cut off due to interruption; no further details were provided.
Assessment
The specific ask about broken promises regarding energy bills, business taxes, and pensioners' winter fuel allowances was not addressed.
Interrupt
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Will the Deputy Prime Minister join me in applauding Labour staff members who campaigned against Donald Trump?
Context
The MP praised Labour staff for campaigning against Donald Trump.
Angela Rayner
I am loving this love-in. People often go and campaign on their own time with their own money, happening across all political parties.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
What changed regarding Labour's stance on ending child poverty?
Context
During the election campaign, Gordon Brown encouraged voters in Scotland to vote Labour to end child poverty. However, Labour MPs from Scotland were later instructed to retain the two-child cap.
Keir Starmer
The last Labour Government lifted millions of children out of poverty. We will approach the question with vigour, including introducing breakfast clubs and reviewing the decent homes standard.
Assessment
Explain the change in stance on child poverty
Last Labour Government Lifted Millions Of Children Out Of Poverty
Approach The Question With Vigour
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I was taken aback this week when a former Prime Minister spoke some sense. Alas, it was, indeed, David Cameron. What he said in relation to graduate route visas was that if any restrictions were implemented, it would lead to job losses, university closures and a reduction in research. Universities Scotland outlines that £5 billion of economic value is at risk. So, may I ask the Prime Minister: does he agree with the Foreign Secretary?
Context
The question was prompted by comments made by a former Prime Minister, David Cameron, about the potential negative impact of restricting legal migration.
Rishi Sunak
The Foreign Secretary also said that the levels of legal migration to this country are too high. That is what I also believe, which is why it is right that we are taking decisive action to bring down the numbers. And that plan is working. In the first three months of this year, the visas issued are down by 25% and migration is on its way to being returned to more sustainable levels.
Assessment
The impact of restrictions on graduate route visas was not directly addressed.
Under Review
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Mr Speaker, speculation is rife, so I think the public deserve a clear answer to a simple question. Does the Prime Minister intend to call a summer general election, or is he feart?
Context
The question was prompted by speculation in public discourse and media regarding when the next general election would take place.
Rishi Sunak
As I have said repeatedly to the right hon. Gentleman, there is—spoiler alert—going to be a general election in the second half of this year. At that moment, the British people will in fact see the truth about the right hon. and learned Member for Holborn and St Pancras (Keir Starmer), because that will be the choice at the next election.
Assessment
The exact timing of the general election was not provided, only a broad timeframe in the second half of the year.
Under Review
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Well, I am glad to hear that those on life sentences are not being released early. The Prime Minister may not think that releasing domestic abusers is a problem, but Labour has repeatedly called for domestic abusers to be exempt from the scheme to release prisoners early. His Government have shamefully ignored those calls. Now that we have the evidence that domestic abusers are being released early—the Lewes report—will he finally change course and back Labour's calls?
Context
Starmer questions the government's early release scheme, citing reports that domestic abusers are being released.
Rishi Sunak
Another week with no ideas and absolutely no plans for the country! The Opposition have had 14 years to think about nothing but the future, but all they can do is talk about the past.
Assessment
Exempting domestic abusers from early release scheme
Changed Subject To Economic Performance
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Let us be clear. What the Prime Minister did was not just equate my colleagues and I to dangerous despots across the world; he proactively compared almost half the Scottish population to a war criminal like Vladimir Putin, and he did so as their Prime Minister, as the man who represents them on the world stage and as the man who on these isles is tasked with defending their liberties and their democracy. We know that his sorry time in office is rapidly coming to a conclusion, but is this really how he wants to be remembered?
Context
Flynn questions the Prime Minister's legacy and his handling of Scottish independence.
Rishi Sunak
As ever, the right hon. Gentleman is distracting from the actual record of what the SNP is doing in Scotland. This obsession with independence means that Scottish schoolchildren are being let down, plummeting down international league tables; the Scottish NHS is the only place in the United Kingdom where funding is actually falling in real terms;
Assessment
Handling of Scottish independence and how he wants to be remembered
Criticized Snp'S Policies
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Let us be clear: the confidence that Israel has shown in its military ambitions in Rafah stems from the silence of its allies on the Front Benches in this place and elsewhere across the world. We all know that UK arms and tech are supporting Israel's activities in Gaza, and will be used in any attack on Rafah. Knowing that, and the devastation that will occur, surely the time has come to end our complicity and halt arms sales to Israel.
Context
UK arms and technology are supporting Israel's military activities in Rafah, which may lead to further devastation. The question arises from the silence of UK allies regarding this issue.
Rishi Sunak
Of course we take our defence export responsibilities extremely seriously. That is why we operate one of the most robust licensing control regimes anywhere in the world. We periodically review advice on Israel's commitment to international humanitarian law, and Ministers always act in accordance with that advice. Following the most recent assessment, our position on export licences is unchanged.
Assessment
Specific request to halt arms sales was not directly addressed
We Take Our Defence Export Responsibilities Extremely Seriously
Operating Robust Licensing Control Regimes
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
May I begin by also congratulating the fantastic John Swinney on becoming Scotland's First Minister? Our opponents should be very careful what they wish for. As we await the imminent Israeli incursion into Rafah, where 1.2 million people are sheltering, including 600,000 children, it has been reported that the United States has paused an arms shipment to Israel. The UK will now follow suit, will it not?
Context
The MP references the imminent Israeli incursion into Rafah.
Rishi Sunak
The right hon. Gentleman may not realise that the UK Government do not directly provide or ship arms to Israel. When it comes to the situation in Rafah, I have been very clear that we are deeply concerned about a full military incursion, given the devastating humanitarian impact; I have made that point specifically to Prime Minister Netanyahu whenever we have spoken.
Assessment
The specific ask was not directly addressed regarding pausing arms shipment.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Let us all be in no doubt: aid is required in Gaza. Will the PM confirm that before he makes a decision, all Members will be afforded a vote?
Context
There are concerns about potential UK military involvement in the Middle East, particularly regarding aid delivery to Gaza.
Rishi Sunak
I am not going to apologise for our armed forces playing a leading role in supporting international effort to get more aid in. Indeed, we are sending Royal Navy support ship RFA Cardigan Bay to the region to support that effort.
Assessment
not committing to parliamentary vote before decision
Refusal To Commit To Procedural Steps
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
On Monday, the Armed Forces Minister could neither confirm nor deny that UK troops may soon be deployed on the ground in the middle east. Can I ask the Prime Minister to provide some much-needed clarity: is he giving active consideration to the deployment of UK forces in the middle east—yes or no?
Context
There are concerns about potential UK military involvement in the Middle East, particularly regarding aid delivery to Gaza.
Rishi Sunak
Mr Speaker, you would not expect me to get into any operational planning details, but what I will say is that we are absolutely committed to supporting international effort to get more humanitarian aid into Gaza, which I think the whole House would support, by land, sea and air.
Assessment
not providing a yes or no answer
Refusal To Disclose Operational Details
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Gordon Brown was correct about Scottish independence not being off the agenda. Does PM welcome Labour party support in denying Scots a say over their future?
Context
The Scottish Trades Union Congress general secretary's statement that the issue of Scotland's future remains unresolved.
Rishi Sunak
A democratic vote was held, but SNP should focus on schools, hospitals, jobs instead of independence. Criticises SNP for wasting time.
Assessment
Focus on future priorities rather than addressing the specific question about denying a vote.
Shifts To Other Issues
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
References Gordon Brown's statement that the forces pulling Britain apart are greater than those holding it together. Does PM agree with this former Prime Minister?
Context
Gordon Brown's comments about the forces pulling Britain apart being stronger than those holding it together.
Rishi Sunak
Strongly agrees that Scotland would be far stronger inside the United Kingdom.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Of course there is a serious point to be made here, because the Institute for Fiscal Studies has warned of the conspiracy of silence that exists between the Labour party and the Conservative party when it comes to £18 billion of looming public sector cuts. Indeed, just last night it outlined that the fiscal rules of the Labour party and the Conservative party are, in effect, identical. With such continuity on offer, the public are right to be anti-Westminster, aren't they?
Context
Warning from the IFS about upcoming £18 billion of public sector cuts.
Rishi Sunak
I am surprised to hear the hon. Gentleman quoting the IFS, because it also described the recent SNP Budget as, in its words, “misleading”, and said that pain is almost certainly coming. It is a savage tax and axe budget, because here is the reality: while NHS spending in England is going up in real terms, in Scotland it is going down; while taxes are being cut by the UK Government, the SNP Government are putting them up.
Assessment
Confirmation or denial regarding public support for Westminster
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
With his Back Benchers looking for a unity candidate to replace him, which of the now numerous born-again Thatcherites on the Labour Front Bench does the Prime Minister believe best fits the bill?
Context
Discussion about the Conservative party's leadership issues and potential replacements.
Rishi Sunak
It was surprising, Mr Speaker, to hear all this talk about the 1970s from the shadow Chancellor in particular, but if you see what is happening in places like Birmingham, where taxes are going up by 21% and services are being cut—whether that is social care, children's services, or in some streets the lights literally being turned off—it is unsurprising why they are talking about the '70s. I just say that what they have done to Birmingham, the Conservatives will never let them do to Britain.
Assessment
Identification of suitable replacement among Labour Front Bench
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Sub-post-masters across the country will welcome today's announcement on introducing legislation to overturn wrongful convictions. Will my right hon Friend reassure us that this legislation will be passed quickly?
Context
The Government has announced legislation to overturn wrongful convictions of sub-postmasters. This question seeks assurances on the swift passage of this legislation.
Rishi Sunak
We owe it to postmasters who have campaigned for justice to progress this legislation as soon as possible before the summer recess. Redress will be paid regardless of location.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Your No. 10 office acknowledged an unacceptable rise in extremist activity seeking to divide our society and hijack democratic institutions. Is not this extremism your Tory donors' odious, racist, dangerous views?
Context
The previous question raised concerns about extreme statements made by a donor to the Conservative party. This follow-up seeks clarity on how these views are being addressed.
Rishi Sunak
There has been a rise in extremist activity that seeks to hijack democratic institutions. The strategy to tackle this threat will be released soon.
Assessment
The specific extremism referenced by No. 10.
Under Review
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Why has the Conservative party used Scotland's natural resources for tax cuts and nuclear power funding in England? This costs up to 100,000 jobs. Will you call a general election?
Context
The question arises from the UK government using Scotland's energy resources to fund tax cuts and nuclear power stations in England, which could negatively impact Scottish jobs.
Rishi Sunak
The government has cut taxes for everyone in Scotland since January, whereas the SNP proposed tax increases. This Conservative Government will continue cutting taxes for hard-working Scots.
Assessment
Question about the election was ignored
Focused On Tax Cuts Instead Of Calling An Election
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Is the Prime Minister in danger of turning his colleagues into nationalists by taxing Scotland's natural resources for a tax cut in England?
Context
The question addresses the reported anger within the Scottish Conservative party over plans to tax North Sea energy industries.
Rishi Sunak
Obviously, I would not comment on the Budget. However, it was clear last week that there has only ever been one party consistently standing up for the North Sea energy industry in Scotland: the Scottish Conservatives.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
We are approaching five months since this conflict began. In that time, this House has equivocated and abstained from voting for a ceasefire. Should this matter now come before the United Nations with a ceasefire potentially in sight, will the Prime Minister use his Government's vote to deliver that ceasefire?
Context
There are concerns about the Government's stance on a ceasefire at the United Nations.
Rishi Sunak
We support the United States' draft resolution that was discussed with colleagues at the United Nations last week. But just calling for an immediate, full ceasefire now which collapses back into fighting within days or weeks and does not include the release of hostages, including British ones, is not in anyone's interests.
Assessment
specific vote on a draft resolution
Supports Us Draft
Calls For Full Ceasefire
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Some 30,000 people dead; 70,000 injured. Does the Prime Minister share President Biden's confidence that a ceasefire may take place from Monday?
Context
There are 30,000 dead and 70,000 injured in Gaza due to the conflict with Hamas.
Rishi Sunak
We have consistently called for an immediate humanitarian pause, which would allow for the safe release of hostages—including British nationals—and more aid to Gaza. We welcome progress on a deal. As the hon. Gentleman said, there has been progress, and we urge everyone on all sides to seize the opportunity.
Assessment
specific timeframe for ceasefire
Welcomes Progress
Urges Seizing Opportunity
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Tonight, this House will have the opportunity to join the majority of the international community and say that enough is enough, that the killing in Gaza must stop and that the hostages must be released, and the best way to do that is to send a clear and united message that we back an immediate ceasefire. Surely, all of us, irrespective of our political allegiance, can agree on that very issue?
Context
The House will vote on a resolution regarding the conflict in Gaza, including demands for an immediate ceasefire and hostage release.
Rishi Sunak
Of course, we want to see the fighting in Gaza end as soon as possible. The best approach is a humanitarian pause to get hostages out and aid in, so that we can create the conditions for a sustainable ceasefire. We are doing everything we can to increase humanitarian aid into Gaza.
Assessment
The questioner asked for agreement on an immediate full ceasefire but the answerer proposed a phased approach involving a humanitarian pause first.
Under Review
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I begin by echoing the sentiments of the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition in relation to the heroic bravery of Alexei Navalny. We must all continue to be united in our opposition to Vladimir Putin. As it stands, some 60% of the buildings in Gaza are either damaged or destroyed. Much of the farmland is in ruin; some 30,000 people are dead, 70,000 are injured, and 1.4 million are currently sheltering in Rafah, awaiting an imminent Israeli onslaught. Surely the Prime Minister must accept that this does not amount to self-defence.
Context
In Gaza, a significant number of buildings are damaged or destroyed, with farmland in ruin. Approximately 30,000 people have died and 70,000 injured, while 1.4 million await an imminent Israeli onslaught.
Rishi Sunak
I share concerns about high rates of civilian casualties and the growing humanitarian crisis. We have called for an immediate humanitarian pause to allow safe release of hostages and more aid into Gaza, creating sustainable conditions for a long-term ceasefire. Our diplomatic efforts are focused on this.
Assessment
Directly addressing whether it amounts to self-defense was not answered
We Share Concerns
Our Focus Is
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
As ever, the Prime Minister does himself no favours, because the bet to which I refer was worth £1,000, and it came just hours before he ended cost of living support worth just £900. His justification for doing so was that the cost of living crisis is easing. What does he believe leaves him looking most out of touch with the public: gambling £1,000, or believing that the cost of living crisis is getting better?
Context
Mr Flynn questions the Prime Minister's actions regarding the cost of living crisis.
Rishi Sunak
The hon. Gentleman talks about the cost of living, but perhaps he can explain to the Scottish people why it is that, while the UK Conservative Government are cutting their taxes, the Scottish Government are raising them?
Assessment
Question regarding gambling £1000 and belief in easing cost of living was completely avoided
Scottish Tax Policy
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I begin by expressing my heartfelt sympathies to Brianna's mother, who is in the Public Gallery. I also send my best wishes to King Charles for what will hopefully be a quick and full recovery. The public are used to the Tories gambling on the lives of others: Boris Johnson did it with public health during the pandemic, and his immediate successor did it with household finances. Not to be outdone, on Monday this week the Prime Minister accepted a crude bet regarding the lives of asylum seekers. In doing so, he demeaned them as individuals and he degraded the office that he currently holds. Will he apologise?
Context
Mr Flynn references a bet involving asylum seekers, accusing the Prime Minister of degrading his office.
Rishi Sunak
We may have a principled disagreement on this: I believe, and we believe, that if someone comes to this country illegally, they should not be able to stay and they should be removed. That is why we are committed to our Rwanda scheme.
Assessment
The specific ask about apologizing for the bet was completely avoided
Principled Disagreement
Commitment To Rwanda Scheme
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Of course, scrapping the cap on bankers' bonuses was only made possible because of Brexit. What the Westminster parties are now telling the public is that it is OK for bankers to have unlimited Brexit bonuses, but the public who are sitting at home and struggling to feed their families have to suck up and deal with additional food costs as a result of Brexit red tape. That is the cost and that is the reality of broken Brexit Britain.
Context
The MP criticises the government's handling of post-Brexit economic policies, highlighting increased costs for food and living expenses due to red tape.
Rishi Sunak
We are actually delivering benefits for people across Scotland, not least the new free trade deals that are opening up markets for Scottish exporters, freeports that are attracting jobs and investment, and the Brexit pubs guarantee that is cutting the cost of a pint in Scottish pubs. The hon. Gentleman talks about the cost of living, but what he could do to help the most is ensure that Scotland is not the most highly taxed part of the United Kingdom—and not just for high earners; everyone earning £28,500 or more is paying more tax in Scotland than they would in England, thanks to the SNP.
Assessment
The MP's critique about public funding and economic disparity due to Brexit was partially acknowledged but not directly addressed with specifics on how these issues will be resolved.
Free Trade Deals
Jobs And Investment
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
When Tories scrapped the cap on bankers' bonuses in autumn amid a cost of living crisis, Labour rightly opposed it; now three months later, Labour supports scrapping the cap. Does this indicate the government's position is out of touch with public opinion?
Context
The government's decision to scrap the cap on bankers' bonuses during a cost of living crisis, initially opposed by Labour. Now Labour has changed its stance.
Rishi Sunak
Supported the independent regulator's decision for financial stability reasons, despite Labour previously opposing it. Criticizes Labour for inconsistent policy positions.
Assessment
Did not address whether supporting the decision on bankers' bonuses indicates being out of touch with public opinion
Attacking Opposition'S Inconsistency
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Asked if the House will show urgency in backing a ceasefire in Gaza following ITV News report.
Context
ITV News reported footage from Gaza showing an unarmed Palestinian man walking under a white flag being shot and killed by the Israel Defence Forces.
Rishi Sunak
No one wants conflict to go on longer; immediate humanitarian pause for aid, hostages out, creating conditions for sustainable ceasefire. Foreign Secretary in region today, pressing all allies and partners.
Assessment
The specific question about backing a ceasefire was not directly addressed.
Under Review
Considering
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Asked if shooting an unarmed man walking under a white flag constitutes a war crime.
Context
ITV News reported footage from Gaza showing an unarmed Palestinian man walking under a white flag being shot and killed by the Israel Defence Forces.
Rishi Sunak
Absolutely consistent that international humanitarian law should be respected, civilians protected; made point expressly to PM Netanyahu. Foreign Secretary in region making same point.
Assessment
The direct question about whether shooting an unarmed man walking under a white flag constitutes a war crime was not directly answered.
Under Review
Considering
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Would the PM join me in thanking everyone who helped save my life during my recent heart attack?
Context
MP had a heart attack five months ago, treated by the NHS emergency services.
Rishi Sunak
Thanking NHS staff for life-saving work, backing them with record resources and doctors to ambulance service. Grateful for their work.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Prime Minister, do you seriously want your time in office to be defined by the Rwanda Bill?
Context
MP criticising PM for weaponising vulnerable people and seeking to stop smuggler gangs.
Rishi Sunak
Stopping boats is important as illegal migration is not fair. Gangs exploit people and many lose lives, so we must break gangs and stop boats.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I do not think that the Prime Minister quite gets it. This is not just a plague on all their houses; it is a plague on this House itself, because injustice goes far beyond the sub-postmasters—just ask the Women Against State Pension Inequality Campaign, the victims of the Equitable Life scandal, the victims of the infected blood scandal, or the families of the victims of Grenfell or Hillsborough. The reality is that when the public come knocking on the doors of this Chamber seeking justice, the Government only ever answer when they have no options left. The Leader of the Opposition said last week that the public are right to be angry at Westminster. They are angry at Westminster because they know that this place never really changes, does it, Prime Minister?
Context
The public perceives Westminster as unresponsive to their needs, citing numerous historical injustices.
Rishi Sunak
I am sad that the hon. Gentleman is trying to politicise something that has happened over multiple decades, with multiple people at fault. The key thing is that after the 2019 High Court case the Government acted to establish an independent inquiry and independent compensation schemes, and as I said, we have paid out compensation to 2,500 people.
Assessment
The answer did not address the questioner's criticism about systemic failures in Westminster but instead highlighted government actions post-High Court case.
Politicising
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The Horizon system was introduced by Tony Blair, the former Labour party leader and of course now a Knight of the Garter. The Horizon system was defended by the current leader of the Liberal Democrats, himself a Knight Bachelor. The Horizon system scandal was overseen by a former Conservative Prime Minister who now hides in the House of Lords as a baron. The reality is that sub-postmasters never stood a chance against the Westminster establishment, did they?
Context
The Horizon system has caused significant harm to sub-postmasters over decades, with the current government addressing it now.
Rishi Sunak
As I have said, this is actually one of the greatest miscarriages of justice in our country's history. All our thoughts are with those who have worked so hard for their communities and have seen their lives and reputations destroyed. As the hon. Gentleman pointed out, this scandal has unfolded over decades, with multiple people clearly at fault.
Assessment
The answer did not acknowledge any specific commitment or action by the current government but recognized it as a miscarriage of justice.
Politicising
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
If the Israeli Government's actions continue, nearly 1,400 more children could die. How can you explain voting against a ceasefire when 153 nations voted for it?
Context
Estimates suggest over 1,400 more child deaths without a ceasefire; UK abstained from UN vote on ceasefire resolution.
Rishi Sunak
We are deeply concerned about civilian impact, pressing Israel on Kerem Shalom crossing and maritime corridors for aid flow.
Assessment
Did not address why UK abstained; only mentioned practical steps taken without a clear commitment to supporting the ceasefire resolution.
Hedging Language
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Will you share your Christmas message for children being bombed in Gaza this winter?
Context
Children in Gaza face high risks of death due to ongoing conflicts, with the UN voting for a ceasefire but the UK abstaining.
Rishi Sunak
Nobody wants to see the conflict continue. We need more humanitarian pauses, supporting hostage releases and life-saving aid into Gaza.
Assessment
Did not commit to a specific plan or action for a ceasefire; only stated general desire without concrete steps.
Hedging Language
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Why is it acceptable to ask people to care for our family members while disregarding theirs? How can you justify policies that contradict the positive impact of migration on communities?
Context
The question criticizes the government's approach to economic migration, suggesting it contradicts previous support for immigration benefits.
Rishi Sunak
We welcome those most vulnerable and have a proud track record. However, we must also take strong action to curb unsustainable levels of economic migration.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not fully justify restrictive policies in light of their positive impact on communities.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
As a fellow Thatcherite, is the Prime Minister worried about losing an election to another conservative leader? Also, how does he justify migration policies that contradict previous support for economic immigration?
Context
The question draws parallels between current Conservative leadership and Thatcherism, questioning the Prime Minister's electoral prospects.
Rishi Sunak
Margaret Thatcher's view was to cut inflation then taxes before winning elections, which is my current plan. We welcome the most vulnerable but must also curb high levels of economic migration.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not directly address concerns about electoral loss or fully justify restrictive policies.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I appreciate that it is difficult for the Prime Minister to empathise when he quite clearly cannot understand, but to be clear to him and, indeed, the whole House: this is not a matter of energy production. Scotland produces six times more gas than we consume and around two thirds of our electricity already comes from renewable resources. This is a consequence of decades of failed energy policy here in Westminster. Those of us on the Scottish National party Benches believe that Scotland's energy wealth and energy resource should benefit the people of Scotland. Why doesn't he?
Context
Scotland produces six times more gas than it consumes and two thirds of its electricity comes from renewable resources. This situation is seen as a consequence of failed energy policies by the Westminster government.
Rishi Sunak
The entire energy grid infrastructure in this country is integrated, which brings benefits to people in every part of our United Kingdom. When it comes to supporting people with energy bills, earlier this year we increased benefits to the highest rate on record. It is why we provided cost of living payments worth £900 on top of regular support. It was right not to wait until the last moment to give people that support; we gave it to them earlier this year so that they would have the security they need going into winter—as I said, on top of the money for pensioners. When there are cold snaps, we have cold weather payments that kick in and the warm home discount, which provides an extra £150 to the most vulnerable households. All that is the most considerable action taken by any Government to help people with their energy bills.
Assessment
The question was about Scotland's energy resources benefiting its own population due to historical underinvestment, but the response focused on general UK-wide support measures without addressing specific Scottish concerns or commitments.
General Statements About Uk-Wide Benefits
Failure To Address Specific Scottish Energy Issues
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Children see snow this morning and are delighted, but their parents look out and are filled with dread due to unaffordable energy bills. Does the Prime Minister regret offering no financial mechanism for these families?
Context
The MP mentions the joy children feel at seeing snow contrasting with parents' dread over high energy bills in winter.
Rishi Sunak
There has been considerable support this year for energy bills. Pensioner households will receive up to £300 alongside their winter fuel payment, right at a difficult time.
Assessment
Stephen Flynn's specific ask about regret was not directly addressed with an explicit admission or denial of regret.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Ultimately, what we need is not a pause in the killing of children, but an end to the killing of children, and I can think of no better time than now for the Prime Minister to advocate a permanent ceasefire. Given that he will not currently do that, will he instead lay the foundations for a two-state solution by finally recognising the state of Palestine?
Context
Continued hostilities in Gaza prompt questions about the future direction of Middle Eastern diplomacy.
Rishi Sunak
Actually, the agreement that has been reached demonstrates that it was not right to have a unilateral ceasefire. What was right was to do as we have done and consistently push for a pause that would allow not just for aid to reach the people in Gaza who desperately need it but for hostages to be released.
Assessment
Diverged from question about Palestine recognition
Changed Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I think all of us in the Chamber are united in our relief at reports that hostages are due to be released by Hamas in Gaza, but we cannot afford to lose sight of what will come at the other side of the temporary pause in hostilities that we are about to see. At the end of four days, will we simply see a return to the killing of children in Gaza every 10 minutes, or will we in this House choose instead to back a permanent ceasefire?
Context
Reports of a temporary pause in hostilities and hostage releases from Hamas have raised concerns about the future stability in Gaza. The MP references ongoing humanitarian crises.
Rishi Sunak
We welcome the agreement reached overnight. As I said, it is something that we have consistently pushed for and is a crucial first step as we try to resolve this situation and, indeed, the humanitarian crisis in Gaza. Of course, we want to see all hostages released as quickly as possible, including British nationals, and I urge all parties involved to deliver the agreement in full.
Assessment
Did not directly address backing a permanent ceasefire
Under Review
Consistent Push For Ceasefire
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Given the displacement of civilians due to the conflict, will the Government consider creating a refugee resettlement scheme akin to previous ones for Syrian and Ukrainian nationals?
Context
The ongoing conflict in Gaza has displaced many people, prompting discussions about a refugee resettlement scheme similar to those for Syrian and Afghan nationals.
Rishi Sunak
We support Palestinian refugees through UN funding, providing aid annually. We are working with allies to deliver humanitarian assistance in Gaza.
Assessment
The specific ask for a resettlement scheme was not directly addressed.
Supporting Refugee Funding
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
We all continue to condemn the terrorist attack on Israel and support the defeat of Hamas while protecting civilians. Given recent shocking images from Gaza, will the Prime Minister join others in calling for an immediate ceasefire?
Context
Recent attacks in Gaza have caused significant civilian casualties, prompting calls for a ceasefire. The questioner wants to ensure safe passage for aid and refugees.
Rishi Sunak
Israel has a right to defend itself against terrorism, and its forces operate within international law. We urge Israel to take precautions to avoid harming civilians.
Assessment
The specific ask for a ceasefire was not directly addressed.
Urging Israel To Be Cautious
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I do not think we heard a yes there, Mr Speaker. You will imagine my shock—my utter surprise—that we appear to have consensus once again between the Conservative party and the Labour party on this most important of issues, despite the promises that were made to the people of Scotland in 2014 and despite clear statements from the likes of Gordon Brown that the only way to protect pensions was to remain within the UK. How hollow those words are now. Who does the Prime Minister think will scrap the state pension triple lock first, his Government or the Labour party's Government?
Context
MP references past statements about protecting pensions and the benefits of remaining in the UK.
Rishi Sunak
Thanks to the actions of this Government, pensioners in Scotland are receiving record increases in their state pension—£870 this year—and extra support with the cost of living this winter. This is the Government who introduced and remain committed to the triple lock, but the hon. Gentleman raises a good point. Pensioners in Scotland should know that the reason they can rely on the state pension, not just today but for years to come, is the strength of our Union and the strength of our United Kingdom Government.
Assessment
The PM did not specify who will scrap the triple lock first or when it might happen.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Will he commit his party to maintaining the state pension triple lock beyond the next general election—yes or no?
Context
Concerns over the future commitment of the Conservative party to maintain the state pension triple lock beyond the next general election.
Rishi Sunak
The Conservative party introduced and delivered a £3,000 increase in the state pension since 2010; there are 200,000 fewer pensioners in poverty today.
Assessment
Specific commitment to maintain triple lock beyond next election
Highlighting Past Achievements Without Committing To Future
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
On his winter cost of living proposals, the PM does nothing for energy, mortgages or food bills. Is the Education Secretary right that everyone is doing nothing?
Context
Flynn criticized the Prime Minister's inaction on cost-of-living issues, noting the PM's plan is to do nothing regarding energy bills, mortgage bills, and food prices.
Rishi Sunak
Half a typical family's energy bill has been paid over past year, support worth £1,500 benefiting Scotland. Mortgage charter covers 90% of market, saving hundreds per month. Energy support secured for Scottish oil and gas industry.
Assessment
Did not fully address inaction claims regarding food bills or mortgages
Energy Bill Support
Mortgage Charter
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Today marks a year since Elizabeth Truss took office. Despite her speedy departure, unemployment is up, food prices are high, mortgage rates have risen, and economic growth is stagnant. When will the PM take action?
Context
Flynn noted the anniversary of a previous government's short tenure, highlighting rising unemployment figures, higher food prices, mortgage rates, and stagnant economic growth since then.
Rishi Sunak
We had the fastest recovery of any European economy after covid; figures demonstrate this fact.
Assessment
Did not mention unemployment, food prices, mortgage rates or growth stagnation
Fastest Recovery
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
On this Government’s watch, Grangemouth has shut and oil and gas jobs are being pushed off a cliff. In the last 20 minutes, it has been announced that 400 jobs are to be lost at the Mossmorran plant back home in Scotland. The company blames the UK Government’s policy environment. The Government stepped in to save jobs at the steelworks in Scunthorpe. Are they going to intervene to save jobs in Scotland?
Context
The MP highlighted job losses at Grangemouth and Mossmorran, blaming the UK Government’s policy environment. He mentioned 400 jobs to be lost at the Mossmorran plant.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero (Chris McDonald)
Of course, my thoughts and those of the Government are very much with the workers and their families at Mossmorran. The firm faces significant global challenges. The Government stand ready to provide support through DWP rapid response service and Ministers would be happy to meet the MP to discuss further support.
Session: Clean Energy Private Sector Investment
View All Questions -->
May I extend an invite to the Secretary of State to come to Aberdeen and meet the highly skilled energy workforce, whose jobs are being put at risk as a result of his policies?
Context
North sea energy workers' jobs are at risk due to the policies of the Secretary of State.
Ed Miliband
I absolutely meet North sea workers and companies. What we need to do for them is build the clean energy future so that they can transition. That is about carbon capture and storage, hydrogen and offshore wind, and it is about nuclear as well—something that SNP Members oppose. This Government are going to make the investments to make it happen.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I will tell the Secretary of State what is bad for town centres, and that is job losses. On this Government’s watch, Robert Gordon University has been forced to publish a report that outlines that there could be 400 job losses in the North sea every two weeks. That is a Grangemouth-type shutdown every two weeks. How many jobs have to be lost in my constituency for his Government to act?
Context
Robert Gordon University published a report indicating potential job losses in the North Sea. Stephen Flynn questions how many jobs need to be lost before the Government acts.
The Secretary of State for Scotland (Ian Murray)
The leader of the SNP in this House voted against the setting up of Great British Energy in his constituency, which is creating jobs in Scotland. He is against the EU trade deal, he is against the US trade deal, he is against the India trade deal; he is bad for jobs and should go.
Session: Town Centre Regeneration
View All Questions -->
The right hon. Gentleman asks how much energy bills are expected to increase before reaching their target reduction in 2030, given recent statements about future decreases.
Context
The Secretary of State mentioned that energy bills will fall by £300 by 2030. The question probes into the interim period where bills may rise due to transition costs.
Ed Miliband
The right hon. Gentleman is disappointed in his question, but the truth is that there's only one future for Britain: reducing bills through a clean power mission. We can carry on being vulnerable or with fossil fuels, left exposed to petrostates and dictators.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Can the Minister provide clarity on when a decision will be made regarding the north-east of Scotland's green freeport bid? If he cannot, will he and the Secretary of State meet me to discuss it?
Context
The north-east of Scotland's green freeport bid has been submitted for five months without a decision from the UK Government.
Lee Rowley
We know that freeports have transformative potential. We are looking forward to making announcements in due course.
Session: Local Service Delivery
View All Questions -->
When are the Government going to deliver the Acorn project in the north-east of Scotland?
Context
The MP is questioning the Government's plan to deliver the Acorn project, a critical energy infrastructure project in north east Scotland. The MP has pointed out that the speed of transformation at Downing Street contrasts with the pace of progress on the Acorn project.
Chris Philp
My right hon. Friend the Chancellor says that that is something we are examining carefully. The hon. Gentleman's characterisation of the growth plan is extremely unfair. The real risk is not having a growth plan. The real risk is in having taxes that are too high.
Session: Investment in Infrastructure
View All Questions -->
In Scotland, in the last year alone some 15,000 people were sanctioned by the Secretary of State. Given that she is such a stickler for rules, surely she will show the same resolve this evening and place a sanction on her party leader.
Context
In Scotland, some 15,000 people were sanctioned by the Secretary of State in the last year.
Therese Coffey
Mr Speaker, I was going to say that when we share taxpayers' money with people looking for work, it is important that they honour their side of the bargain. When they do not, there often have to be consequences. That is not something that we seek to do—we try to work with people—but it is really important that people do their bit of the bargain when they look for work.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Levelling up is described as a moral, social and economic programme by the UK Government's own website. Where is the moral argument in people not being able to feed their kids? Where is the social argument in people not being able to heat their homes? And where on earth is the economic argument in people having no money in their pockets?
Context
The UK Government's website states that levelling up is a moral, social and economic programme. However, the questioner raises issues regarding people not being able to feed their kids or heat their homes due to financial constraints.
Simon Clarke
Levelling up is a social and moral mission. We believe it's vital to close the gap between successful parts of the UK and the rest. On the cost of living, we have put together a £22 billion package of support, including £9 billion specifically on energy bills. The Chancellor will keep all these issues under review.
Session: Levelling Up Across the UK
View All Questions -->
You have to admire the brass neck of the Secretary of State because it is his Government who failed to deliver carbon capture and underground storage in Scotland, did not match fund the just transition fund, and oversee Scotland paying the highest electricity transmission charges in Europe. When will he stop doffing his cap to Westminster and stand up for Scotland's renewable future?
Context
The Secretary of State's Government faces criticism for failing to deliver carbon capture projects in Scotland, not matching funding for the just transition fund, and overseeing high electricity transmission costs compared to Europe. This raises concerns about their support for Scotland's renewable energy future.
Alister Jack
I agree with the hon. Gentleman on this point, and we have raised it many times with Ofgem, but it is an independent regulator, and it is looking again at transition charge reform.
Session: Transition to Net Zero
View All Questions -->
I ask the Foreign Secretary whether she knows who the Secretary of State for International Trade was at the time that the deal was agreed with one of Russia's richest oligarchs and whether the Minister in question personally authorised the agreement?
Context
The UK may face a £43 million bill for loans taken out by Russia's biggest coal company, underwritten by the Government's export agency.
Elizabeth Truss (Foreign Secretary)
I know from my time at the Department for International Trade that those agreements tend to be signed off by officials.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
That is why the Secretary of State mentioned Sir Ian Wood and his views on the oil and gas sector, but he will also be cognisant of Sir Ian Wood's views about his Government's decision to turn their back on Acorn. Will the Secretary of State finally admit to regretting the decision of his colleagues?
Context
The MP continued to question the government's decision regarding Acorn and mentioned Sir Ian Wood's views on the importance of industrial carbon in making the bid viable.
Alister Jack
Acorn was bringing the carbon from all parts of the UK and/or Europe to make the bid work. We are working on how to get more industrial carbon into the project, to make it more viable and to expedite it for 2023.
Session: Oil and Gas Sector
View All Questions -->
Marine Scotland's sea fisheries statistics have recently shown that the value of landings right across Scotland has fallen. In Aberdeen alone, it has fallen by some 34%, so I ask the Secretary of State: where is the sea of opportunity?
Context
Marine Scotland's statistics show a significant decline in landings value in Aberdeen.
George Eustice
The truth is that the impacts of covid have had an impact on fish prices over the last 18 months. They have gone from a historic high down to quite low levels; they have now recovered. It is also the case that some North sea stocks, notably cod, have been in a difficult place over the last couple of years, so fisheries administrations have taken the right and necessary decision to reduce some of those quotas.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
That is an incredibly important point. Of course, when the Prime Minister left the White House, he declared to Scottish and UK businesses that they would indeed once again be able to export their lamb to the United States of America, but we have seen from leaked memos from the Secretary of State's own Department that that was not necessarily the case. Perhaps he can shine a little more detail on that. When will Scottish producers be able to export their lamb to the United States?
Context
The Prime Minister declared that Scottish and UK businesses would be able to export their lamb to the United States after discussions with President Biden. However, leaked memos from the US Department suggest uncertainty about this declaration.
George Eustice
I cannot put a timescale on precisely when that will happen, but as I said, the Prime Minister had very positive discussions on this very issue with President Biden, and my officials have been continuing that discussion with US officials, who have confirmed their intention to enable the import of British lamb to the United States.
Session: Agricultural Exports to the United States
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions he has had with the (a) Prime Minister and (b) US Administration on agricultural exports to the United States?
Context
Discussions regarding UK agricultural exports to the US, specifically focusing on Scotch whisky, British beef, and now lamb. The background includes previous disputes and recent positive developments.
George Eustice
Recent discussions with the US have led to several positive outcomes for the UK. We have resolved the Airbus-Boeing dispute, leading to the suspension of the 25% tariff on Scotch whisky; for the first time in two decades, British beef is on US plates; and most recently, my officials spoke to their US counterparts, who confirmed their intention to enable the import of British lamb following the Prime Minister's discussions on that with President Biden.
Session: Agricultural Exports to the United States
View All Questions -->
Will the Government back Acorn as one of two clusters next month?
Context
Concern over the status of the Acorn carbon capture storage project and high grid charges for renewable projects.
Alister Jack
As the hon. Gentleman knows, that is under review. We want Acorn to be one of the tier 1 projects, and we are pressing for that. I think he should press for his colleagues and his Government in Scotland to support the oil and gas industry.
Session: Strength of the Union
View All Questions -->
UK Government Ministers talk about a single approach but travellers from India faced managed hotel quarantine in Scotland while not having to do so in England. Does he regret damage caused to Scotland's recovery?
Context
The MP recalls past inconsistencies in travel regulations between Scotland and other UK nations, questioning the impact on Scotland's covid-19 recovery.
David Duguid
What I regret is that despite repeated calls from oil and gas industry, MSPs, and MPs representing north-east constituencies, Scottish Government did not give oil and gas workers the same allowance for amber list countries as allowed in England.
Session: Covid-19 Guidance on International Travel
View All Questions -->
I am afraid that answer simply is not good enough. Not only are the Tories seeking to bypass devolution; they are also seeking to bypass the needs of Aberdeen. One hundred and twenty-three local authorities have been placed in pot 1, yet Aberdeen has been dumped in pot 2. The consequence of that is clear for all to see: it means that we will not have access to the funding that we need at this moment in time. Aberdeen accounts for a third of all job redundancies in Scotland since the start of the pandemic. If that is not a criterion for funding, what is?
Context
The question is a follow-up to the initial query and addresses specific concerns regarding how Aberdeen is being prioritised for levelling-up fund.
Luke Hall
It is published fully and frankly on the Government website. The hon. Gentleman can have a look at it; I would advise him to do so. Authorities are already receiving capacity funding, so it is not true in any way to infer that every single Scottish local authority will not receive support through this initiative. We are hugely excited about the opportunities this presents us with.
Session: Levelling-up Fund
View All Questions -->
What criteria the Government used to determine the prioritisation of areas for the allocation of levelling-up funding?
Context
The levelling-up fund is intended to support areas in economic recovery, transport connectivity, and regeneration. The question addresses the criteria used by the government for prioritising areas.
Luke Hall
The levelling-up fund will be allocated competitively and is open to all local areas. As we set out in the prospectus published at Budget, the index used for the levelling-up fund places areas in category 1, 2 or 3 based on their need for economic recovery and growth, improved transport connectivity, and regeneration.
Session: Levelling-up Fund
View All Questions -->
Can she confirm that she has made personal representations to the Chancellor on maintaining the full £20 uplift? If he chooses to ignore her, will she resign?
Context
The number of universal credit claimants in Aberdeen South has risen significantly, raising concerns about the impact of cutting the £20 uplift.
Therese Coffey
Government Ministers discuss policy while considering it. She is considering evidence-based decisions regarding support measures.
Session: Poverty Levels
View All Questions -->
Does the Secretary of State disagree with the Prime Minister who said that devolution was Tony Blair's biggest mistake?
Context
The question references the Prime Minister's statement that devolution was Tony Blair's biggest mistake, indicating a contentious view on the issue.
Alister Jack
What the Prime Minister said was that devolution was a mistake when it was set up to be put in the hands of separatists, and I completely agree with that. The Scottish National party is a campaigning organisation for independence masquerading as a party of Government.
Session: United Kingdom Internal Market Bill
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions has the Secretary of State had with Cabinet colleagues regarding the impact of the United Kingdom Internal Market Bill on Scotland?
Context
The question addresses the effect of the United Kingdom Internal Market Bill on Scotland, a contentious issue due to its perceived impact on devolution.
Alister Jack
I have frequent discussions with Cabinet colleagues on the United Kingdom Internal Market Bill, which is vital to protect seamless trade and jobs across all four corners of the United Kingdom following the end of the transition period.
Session: United Kingdom Internal Market Bill
View All Questions -->
In his spending review statement last week, the Chancellor failed even to mention Brexit, but the Office for Budget Responsibility was not quite so shy; indeed, it painted a particularly bleak picture. So can the Minister clarify this: does he accept the OBR's findings, and if so, does he therefore agree that Scotland's economic future will be detrimentally impacted by any Brexit on the watch of this Tory Government?
Context
The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) presented a bleak economic forecast regarding the impact of Brexit, especially in relation to Scotland.
Steve Barclay
What economic analysis has always shown is that Scotland's trade with the rest of the United Kingdom is much more important than its trade with Europe. However, Government Members have always been clear that we seek a deal. The asks that the negotiating team have put forward are extremely reasonable, and Lord Frost and the team continue to work to that effect.
Session: Fiscal Policy Household Income (Scotland)
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions has he had with his Scottish counterpart on the effect of his Department's fiscal policy on household income in Scotland?
Context
The question arises from discussions about the impact of UK government policies on Scottish households.
Steve Barclay
This year, the Government have put in place an unprecedented package of support to protect incomes and jobs right across the UK. Analysis published earlier this year shows that our interventions significantly protected people's incomes, with the least well-off in society supported the most.
Session: Fiscal Policy Household Income (Scotland)
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions has the Secretary of State had with the Scottish Government on the shared prosperity fund? The IFS said it is disconcerting that the shared prosperity fund is still not finalised. Will the Minister commit to continuing existing EU funding allocations for one more year?
Context
The IFS report suggested that it was disconcerting that the shared prosperity fund had still not been finalised.
Simon Clarke (Minister for Regional Growth and Local Government)
Obviously, I do not accept the hon. Gentleman's characterisation of the Government. We are working very hard to ensure that we deliver on the decision to leave the European Union. We will be in a position to give full details on the UK shared prosperity fund after the cross-government spending review.
Session: Shared Prosperity Fund
View All Questions -->
The Social Mobility Commission has highlighted that in the last seven years there has been 'little or no action' by the UK Government on a third of its recommendations, including ensuring child poverty is not exacerbated by universal credit. Indeed, its damning report criticised DWP for failing to provide a detailed assessment of how benefit changes are tied to these poverty rates. On that basis, how can the Minister possibly know whether Universal Credit is increasing or decreasing poverty?
Context
The Social Mobility Commission has highlighted that there has been little or no action on a third of its recommendations, including ensuring child poverty is not exacerbated by universal credit. The commission criticised the DWP for failing to provide a detailed assessment of how benefit changes are tied to these poverty rates.
Will Quince (The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Work and Pensions)
The statistics show that full-time work substantially reduces the chances of poverty. The absolute rate of poverty for a child where both parents work full time is 4% compared with 44% where one or more parents are in part-time work. We are supporting people into full-time work wherever possible, for example, through our childcare offer, and Universal Credit, where work always pays, is a fundamental part of that offer.
Session: Universal Credit (Reducing Poverty)
View All Questions -->
We learn our history through schools and museums, and erect statues for those we admire. Does the Secretary of State agree that statues honouring white men who enslaved and killed black people can be removed if there is a democratic desire to do so?
Context
Discussion about the removal of statues depicting individuals associated with slavery.
The Prime Minister (Priti Patel)
We live in an open democracy where processes must be maintained for people to voice their opinions democratically, without resorting to violence or breaking the law.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
In recent days, the price of oil has plummeted, yet in the Chancellor's Budget yesterday there was not a peep in relation to this hugely important industry. Does the Leader of the House share my concern in that regard, and will he commit to a debate in Government time on this hugely important matter?
Context
The MP is concerned about the lack of mention for the oil sector in the Budget.
Jacob Rees-Mogg
The oil sector is obviously important and the price of oil affects the whole of the economy. However, I would point out to the hon. Gentleman that, yesterday in this House, his right hon Friend the leader of the SNP raised the matter in the Budget debate, so it has just been raised.
Session: Business of the House
View All Questions -->
Stephen Flynn asks if discussions will be held with the Scottish Government regarding their recent report on immigration and whether the Australian regional visa approach would benefit Scotland, given its growing population due to migration.
Context
Scottish Government published a report suggesting immigration policies that could help Scotland's economy. The UK government is considering the feasibility of different immigration rules for various regions.
Kevin Foster (Minister of State for Immigration)
The independent Migration Advisory Committee has advised against applying different immigration arrangements to various areas in the UK, citing potential complications. The government aims to create a points-based system that benefits all regions, including Scotland.
Session: “Migration Helping Scotland Prosper”
View All Questions -->
What assessment her Department has made of the effect of the end of freedom of movement in the UK on bilateral trade with the EU in goods and services. Scottish Financial Enterprise told the Scottish Affairs Committee that the success of Scotland's financial industry was based on its ability to access and service all customers in the European Union. Does this not once again highlight the vital importance of freedom of movement to Scotland and show that the UK Government simply do not care about Scotland's interests or, indeed, Scotland's votes?
Context
The UK's decision to leave the European Union and end freedom of movement has led to concerns about its impact on trade relationships.
Conor Burns (Minister for Europe and the Americas)
Leaving the European Union frees the United Kingdom to introduce a fairer immigration system. My right hon. Friend the Prime Minister said at the UK-Africa investment summit this week that our system is becoming fairer and more equal as between all our global friends and partners. Treating people the same regardless, wherever they come from and by putting people before passports, we will be able to attract the best talent from around the world, wherever they may be. We will also be able to reach out and strike new global trade agreements to the benefit of all our constituents and UK consumers.
Session: EU Bilateral Trade
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Referral of Prime Minister to Committee of Privileges
28 April 2026
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The motion calls for the matter of Peter Mandelson's appointment as US Ambassador to be referred to the Privileges Committee due to claims that the Prime Minister misled the House. Kemi Badenoch argue...
Lord Mandelson Humble Address: Government Response Update
27 April 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Points of Order
27 April 2026
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Middle East: Economic Update
21 April 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Opposition Day
24 March 2026
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Lord Mandelson: Response to Humble Address Motion
11 March 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Lord Mandelson 2026-02-04
04 February 2026
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
I beg to move, that an humble Address be presented to His Majesty, that he will be graciously pleased to give directions to require the Government to lay before this House all papers relating to Lord ...
US Department of Justice Release of Files 2026-02-02
02 February 2026
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
As I know right hon. and hon. Members across the House will agree, Jeffrey Epstein was a despicable criminal who committed disgusting crimes and destroyed the lives of countless women and girls. His v...
China and Japan 2026-02-02
02 February 2026
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Prime Minister outlined the importance of engaging with both China and Japan to safeguard national interests. He discussed his recent visit, highlighting the strengthening of UK-US relations, rese...
Iran Protests 2026-01-19
19 January 2026
Urgent Question
Contributed to this debate
Will the Minister confirm the British Government’s response to the Iranian regime’s brutal crackdown on protests? The UK is deeply concerned about reports of protesters being killed in cold blood and ...
Attendance
32.8%
19 of 58 votes
Aye Votes
14
24.1% of votes
No Votes
5
8.6% of votes
Abstentions
39
67.2% of votes
24 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Opposition Day: Protections for children from online harms
Ayes: 69
Noes: 279
Failed
23 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: Amendment 1
Ayes: 161
Noes: 272
Failed
23 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 2
Ayes: 156
Noes: 273
Failed
23 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Industry and Exports (Financial Assistance) Bill Committee: New Clause 3
Ayes: 77
Noes: 280
Failed
23 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill Committee: New Clause 3
Ayes: 73
Noes: 256
Failed
23 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill: Third Reading
Ayes: 361
Noes: 84
Passed
11 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) (Extension to Marit...
Ayes: 362
Noes: 107
Passed
11 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Local Government Finance Report (England) 2026-27
Ayes: 277
Noes: 143
Passed
11 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Referendums Relating to Council Tax Increases (Principles) (England) Report 2...
Ayes: 279
Noes: 90
Passed
04 Feb 2026
VOTED AYE
Draft Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Scheme (Amendment) Order 2026
Ayes: 392
Noes: 116
Passed
03 Feb 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill: Second Reading
Ayes: 458
Noes: 104
Passed
28 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Opposition Day: British Indian Ocean Territory
Ayes: 103
Noes: 284
Failed
28 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Opposition Day: Youth unemployment
Ayes: 91
Noes: 287
Failed
28 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Draft Medical Devices (Fees Amendment) Regulations 2026
Ayes: 294
Noes: 108
Passed
27 Jan 2026
VOTED NO
Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill: Amendment 9
Ayes: 91
Noes: 378
Failed
27 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill: Amendment 2
Ayes: 61
Noes: 311
Failed
27 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill: Amendment 1
Ayes: 88
Noes: 310
Failed
21 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Insurance Contributions (Employer Pensions Contributions) Bill Commi...
Ayes: 191
Noes: 326
Failed
21 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Insurance Contributions (Employer Pensions Contributions) Bill Commi...
Ayes: 195
Noes: 317
Failed
21 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Insurance Contributions (Employer Pensions Contributions) Bill: Thir...
Ayes: 316
Noes: 194
Passed
21 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
The Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023 (Remedial...
Ayes: 373
Noes: 106
Passed
20 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Sentencing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 7
Ayes: 319
Noes: 127
Passed
20 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Diego Garcia Military Base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill: motion to...
Ayes: 344
Noes: 182
Passed
20 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Diego Garcia Military Base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill: motion to...
Ayes: 347
Noes: 185
Passed
20 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Diego Garcia Military Base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill: motion to...
Ayes: 347
Noes: 184
Passed
13 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: Clause 63 Stand part
Ayes: 348
Noes: 167
Passed
13 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 24
Ayes: 184
Noes: 331
Failed
13 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 25
Ayes: 187
Noes: 351
Failed
13 Jan 2026
VOTED NO
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: Clause 86 stand part
Ayes: 344
Noes: 173
Passed
13 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 9
Ayes: 181
Noes: 335
Failed
13 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 26
Ayes: 172
Noes: 334
Failed
12 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: Amendment 3
Ayes: 185
Noes: 344
Failed
12 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 7
Ayes: 188
Noes: 341
Failed
17 Dec 2024
VOTED AYE
National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill Commi...
Ayes: 100
Noes: 351
Failed
17 Dec 2024
VOTED AYE
National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill Commi...
Ayes: 206
Noes: 353
Failed
17 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill Commi...
Ayes: 196
Noes: 352
Failed
17 Dec 2024
VOTED AYE
National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill Commi...
Ayes: 195
Noes: 353
Failed
17 Dec 2024
VOTED NO
National Insurance Contributions (Secondary Class 1 Contributions) Bill: Thir...
Ayes: 354
Noes: 202
Passed
11 Dec 2024
VOTED AYE
Draft Movement of Goods (Northern Ireland to Great Britain) (Animals, Feed an...
Ayes: 375
Noes: 9
Passed
11 Dec 2024
VOTED AYE
Finance Bill Committee: Clause 47 stand part
Ayes: 338
Noes: 170
Passed
11 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Finance Bill Committee: Clause 48 stand part
Ayes: 332
Noes: 170
Passed
11 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Finance Bill Committee: New Clause 8
Ayes: 167
Noes: 329
Failed
11 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Finance Bill Committee: New Clause 6
Ayes: 105
Noes: 314
Failed
11 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Finance Bill Committee: New Clause 7
Ayes: 104
Noes: 313
Failed
10 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Finance Bill Committee: New Clause 5
Ayes: 105
Noes: 340
Failed
10 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Finance Bill Committee: New Clause 2
Ayes: 74
Noes: 350
Failed
10 Dec 2024
VOTED AYE
Finance Bill Committee New Clause 3
Ayes: 184
Noes: 359
Failed
10 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Draft Home Detention Curfew and Requisite and Minimum Custodial Periods (Amdt...
Ayes: 424
Noes: 106
Passed
09 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Terrorism (Protection of Premises) Bill: New Clause 1
Ayes: 89
Noes: 340
Failed
06 Dec 2024
DID NOT VOTE
Motion to sit in private
Ayes: 1
Noes: 49
Failed
93
PMQs Asked
29
Ministerial Questions Asked
161
House of Commons Debates Involved
0
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
58
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1370 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
+2441% above average
This MP:
93
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
+116% above average
This MP:
29
Average:
13.4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+3213% above average
This MP:
161
Average:
4.9
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-53% below average
This MP:
32.8
Average:
69.2
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Stephen Flynn's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.