Mike Penning
MP for Hemel Hempstead
Con
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
As a former firefighter, I am sure the whole House will pray for the firefighter in Scotland who is today fighting for his life. Our emergency services go one way, into the danger, while we go the other way. Our thoughts and prayers should be with them. Dacorum Borough Council, the Conservative-led council in my constituency, has done a fantastic job of building new houses, including social housing and council houses. Can the Prime Minister assure me that we will not be pushed into the green belt any more than we already have been and that we can protect the Chilterns in my constituency?
Context
The MP discusses the tragic incident involving a firefighter in Scotland and expresses concerns about green belt development.
Rishi Sunak
I join my right hon. Friend in praising his local council for ensuring we build homes in the right places so that our young people can fulfil the dream of home ownership. He is also right to say that this Government will always protect our precious green spaces. The recent changes in our planning reforms will ensure that we can protect the green belt everywhere. His local community and others will benefit from those protections as we keep our local areas beautiful.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Will the PM meet to discuss Hemel Hempstead's new hospital future? On another note, many children suffer from specific seizures treatable with medical cannabis prescribed by consultants. Currently only two children get it for free; the rest face financial hardship. Will the Prime Minister use his political will to push forward this matter so these children can receive their prescriptions?
Context
Some children suffer from a specific form of seizure that can be managed by medical cannabis prescribed by a consultant. Only two children in the country receive this free through the NHS, while others must pay out-of-pocket.
Boris Johnson
I am delighted my right hon. Friend has secured a meeting, and I confirm we have already amended laws for doctors to prescribe cannabis products when clinically appropriate.
Assessment
The PM did not directly address the request regarding political will or accelerating progress beyond existing law changes.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The Prime Minister cheered all of my constituents up when he came to south-west Hertfordshire and said that we were going to have a new hospital. Sadly, even though the money is there, the local management of our trust have blocked it; they are going to refurbish Watford's hospital and not give us a brand-new hospital on a greenfield site, which is what we want. Will the Prime Minister meet me and some of my constituents to unblock this and tell the NHS that it needs to build a new hospital for Hemel Hempstead?
Context
A new hospital was promised for Hemel Hempstead, but local management is blocking the project.
Boris Johnson
I will be very happy to secure a meeting with my right hon Friend the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care, who I am sure will be able to unblock things, one way or the other.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not commit to resolving the issue directly or immediately but offered a meeting with another official
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Before the Prime Minister became Prime Minister, we had a discussion to do with the prescribed medical use of cannabis, and how it was helping to save really seriously ill children—not hundreds or thousands, but about 150. We changed the law in November 2018 to make it legal for those prescriptions to be written by top consultants. Today, we have three children who have it free on the NHS, and about 150 children whose families have to beg and borrow and remortgage their homes so that they can pay about £2,000 a month. I say to the Prime Minister that this is wrong. As a father, like I am, we would do everything possible for our families, and these families are doing everything possible for their children. Can we have a follow-up meeting to the one in 2018, where I will bring one of the mothers who gets it free—not to stop her getting it free, but to explain to the Prime Minister how wrong it is that children's lives are going to be lost if we have to go through the process that the NHS is proposing?
Context
The law was changed in November 2018 to allow top consultants to prescribe medicinal cannabis. However, many families still face financial difficulties accessing treatment.
Boris Johnson
This is the second time I have been asked about this; I thank my right hon. Friend very much, and he is right to raise it. We will make sure that we have a proper meeting with the Department of Health so that we can resolve the issue of how to make sure that the supply of the Bedrocan or the cannabis-based products that are coming from Holland can be made secure, and can continue.
Assessment
Did not commit to specific actions for families paying out-of-pocket
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I am concerned that if someone is charged with death by careless driving, the case cannot be appealed for leniency by victims compared to death by dangerous driving cases. Is this still under review?
Context
The question stems from the speaker's previous role as Victims Minister, where he advocated for victim rights in cases involving death by careless driving. Currently, there is no appeal process for leniency when a loved one was killed due to careless driving.
Laura Farris
I share my right hon. Friend's concern about death caused by either dangerous or careless driving. The Conservative Government created a criminal offence of death by careless driving, and on 28 June 2022, the maximum penalty for death by dangerous driving was increased to life. We have also agreed to extend the unduly lenient sentence scheme so that complainants will have 28 days to appeal to the Attorney General and Solicitor General, who then have 14 days to contact the court.
Session: Public Confidence in Victim Support
View All Questions -->
Why isn't the Environment Agency taking serious action against water companies that repeatedly cause sewage flooding, instead of just saying they will work with them?
Context
The MP is concerned about repeated sewage flooding on the River Ver in his constituency and requests action from the Environmental Agency.
Steve Barclay
I agree. That is why we are increasing fourfold the number of inspections, so that water companies are not marking their own homework. It is why we have the plan for water introduced by the former Secretary of State, my right hon. Friend the Member for Suffolk Coastal (Dr Coffey), and significant additional investment. It is why we are taking tougher enforcement action, with the biggest ever criminal prosecution of water firms by the Environment Agency. It is also why we are taking action on things such as bonuses for companies that commit serious wrongdoing.
Session: Natural Flood Management Programme
View All Questions -->
Is the Disability Confident scheme still in place and can I have confidence that it remains a priority?
Context
The MP asks if the Disability Confident scheme, which he launched, is still in place.
Mims Davies
The Disability Confident scheme is at the heart of our disability action plan, which Members will hear more about in the new year. All employers are advised to focus on being disability confident.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Does the Minister acknowledge the need for veterans of Operation Banner to know the truth about what happened to Captain Robert Nairac? The veteran groups in Mike Penning's constituency and that of Dean Russell seek support from the Minister for Veterans' Affairs as they go forward.
Context
Today marks the day that Captain Robert Nairac from 1st Battalion was taken by the IRA and murdered. His murderers are still free, and truth about his death is unknown.
James Heappey
I agree with sentiments. The case is particularly barbaric. There is a lot of work going into legacy of troubles, how investigations should progress. Minister for Veterans' Affairs leads on this issue.
Session: Veterans UK
View All Questions -->
To promote men's coming forward to see their GPs for diseases such as prostate cancer, particularly on Movember day (1 November), what will the Secretary of State do?
Context
The MP highlights the importance of men seeking regular GP appointments, especially for conditions like prostate cancer, and asks what initiatives will be taken to encourage this.
Steve Barclay
I pay tribute to the work my right hon. Friend is doing to raise awareness. Campaigns such as Movember are great for raising awareness, and we aim to ensure patients can access face-to-face appointments.
Session: GPs Continuity of Care
View All Questions -->
Since covid, commuter bus routes from Hemel Hempstead into London have been cut. The reason for that is lack of demand, because people are working from home and there is no encouragement for them to come back into London. We observe that dangerous development when we drive into London each day and see that there is less and less traffic.
Context
The MP is concerned about commuter bus routes from Hemel Hempstead into London that have been cut due to lack of demand, which has worsened since the start of the pandemic.
Lucy Frazer
The Government have broadly welcomed people back to work—my right hon. Friend will know that we are encouraging civil servants to come back to work and leading by example here in Parliament—and we do encourage people into our towns and cities: as he will also know, we recently spent £60 million on introducing a £2 fare cap for single tickets on most bus services in England outside London between January and March to encourage travel across the country.
Session: Bus Services
View All Questions -->
My hon. Friend the Minister knows my passion for looking after children and young people around the SEND sector. I welcome the Green Paper and the consultation, because this is a debate that we have needed to have for some considerable time. But the issue in Hertfordshire is going to be around capacity, because the special educational needs schools in my constituency, which are brilliant, are full and double-oversubscribed. This is not all about money—it is sometimes about how it is provided—but there are serious financial problems in Hertfordshire, and I wonder if he would look at that seriously for me.
Context
The questioner expresses concern about capacity issues in special educational needs schools in his constituency, which are full and double-oversubscribed.
Will Quince
My right hon. Friend has raised this issue with me on numerous occasions. He is a doughty champion for children with SEND and their parents and carers in his constituency. Of course I will look at this very closely. These are not just words: we are backing this up with £2.6 billion of capital funding to build about 33,000 or 34,000 SEND places across our country, including in Hertfordshire.
Session: SEND Review
View All Questions -->
Will there be no delay in functions of Government to reach a conclusion on legislative proposals, so that veterans can live their lives in peace?
Context
The MP emphasized the need for timely resolution in addressing issues affecting veterans.
Brandon Lewis
My right hon. Friend makes an important point regarding the need to address issues affecting veterans without delay and leaving it to another generation who deserve to live their final years in peace.
Session: Veterans Protection from Prosecution
View All Questions -->
If the closure of RAF Halton gets the go ahead—frankly, I do not think it should—the largest town in Hertfordshire will have no military capability on its boundaries. Is there any way we can have a reserve capability at RAF Halton for the Army and the RAF?
Context
The RAF is considering closing RAF Halton, which could leave Hertfordshire's largest town without military presence.
Ben Wallace
My right hon. Friend makes an important point. I have asked to look again at that and some of the rebasing options.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Penning inquires if Theresa Villiers can confirm that post-Brexit, the practice of exporting live animals will cease.
Context
Animal rights activists have long called for an end to exporting animals on the hoof.
Theresa Villiers
We want to see an end to live exports and are consulting on measures to improve the welfare of live animals in transport. We hope that ultimately this will result in an end to live exports overseas.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
BACKBENCH BUSINESS
15 June 2023
Responding: Victoria Atkins
Main Concerns
["The VAT on audiobooks at 20% is an anomaly that penalises individuals with disabilities, including those who are dyslexic or visually impaired. Mike Penning points out the discrepancy between the VAT exemptions for books and e-books while audiobooks remain taxable, highlighting this as a discriminatory practice under the Equality Act 2010. He mentions Scope's report indicating that people with disabilities are £970 per month worse off due to such taxes. Penning also refers to the Prime Minister's promise to abolish the 'reading tax' for e-books and printed books but not including audiobooks."]
Specific Asks
['Penning asks the Government to review the VAT rules on audiobooks, citing moral and ethical concerns under existing legislation like the Equality Act. He requests a fair taxation system that does not penalise those with disabilities who rely on audiobooks for education and employment purposes.']
Motorways: Litter
25 April 2023
Responding: Richard Holden
Main Concerns
['I am concerned about the health and safety risks that litter poses to highways workers who are tasked with cleaning it up. Key concerns have been raised regarding legal responsibilities and KPIs, which currently cause confusion among local councils and transport authorities. Mike Penning is concerned about the state of litter on motorways in his constituency, boundaried by the M1, M25 and A41. He mentions that some litter comes from refuse lorries lacking proper tarpaulins and highlights the impact on wildlife in areas of outstanding natural beauty. Penning also criticizes Highways England for renaming itself multiple times despite a decent brand and questions the effectiveness of their claims about checking motorways, suggesting they are not monitoring contractors adequately. He cites instances where individuals have threatened to take legal action against National Highways under section 91 of the Environmental Protection Act. Litter on motorways is a serious issue affecting safety, the environment, and wildlife. In 2020, Channel 4 reported huge piles of rubbish covering areas around the M25, raising questions about the effectiveness of private firms contracted to keep motorways clear. National Highways has statutory duties but there are concerns over its performance in addressing littering.']
Specific Asks
['I ask the government to ensure clarity on legal responsibilities for litter management on motorways and A roads, in addition to strengthening existing KPIs. Penning asks for better enforcement using technology such as cameras and stronger penalties for littering, including driver awareness courses. He also requests that key performance indicators be introduced to monitor litter clearance on motorways by National Highways. The Minister should confirm the number of fines for motorway littering and ensure that all contracts offer taxpayers good value for money. The Government must also address delays in introducing deposit returns for drinks containers, which could cut down on littering.']
Accountability in the NHS
30 November 2022
Responding: Will Quince
Main Concerns
["MP Mike Penning highlighted a lack of ministerial accountability within the NHS, citing examples where constituents faced bureaucratic nightmares when trying to address mistakes made by the health service. One example was an operation in 1986 that had detrimental long-term effects on a constituent's life and another involved a vulnerable young lady left unattended for five hours during a heatwave. Penning also noted that MPs often face similar cases from their constituents where there is a lack of joined-up thinking within the NHS, with various trusts passing responsibility back and forth."]
Specific Asks
["Penning requested that the Government address these issues early on and not draw up the 'drawbridge' when problems occur. He asked for ministerial oversight to be established in situations where the NHS makes mistakes."]
Medical Cannabis Prescriptions For Children With Severe Conditions
03 November 2021
Main Concerns
['I am concerned about the lack of clarity in the prescription of medical cannabis for children and young adults with severe conditions, despite previous Home Office promises to allow its prescribed use. The debate highlights that some brave consultants are under enormous pressure not to sign prescriptions, while others who wish to prescribe it face potential disciplinary action or refusal from their employers to honour the prescription.']
Specific Asks
["I urge the medical profession to take responsibility and support these children's survival by prescribing medical cannabis when necessary. I also call for a review of the current policy framework to ensure that consultants are not discouraged from issuing prescriptions due to fear of repercussions or employer refusal."]
Ukraine and Georgia
15 May 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
International Health Regulations
14 May 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Defence Personnel Data Breach
07 May 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Animal Welfare (Livestock Exports) Bill - Instruction to allow the Committee to make provision for the whole of the United Kingdom
15 January 2024
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
Moves an instruction motion to include Northern Ireland in the scope of the Bill. Argues that excluding Northern Ireland is a gap in animal welfare legislation as significant numbers of live exports o...
The Livestock Export Prohibition Bill - Clause 1 - Amendments to the definition of 'livestock'
15 January 2024
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
This amendment would add alpacas to the list of livestock covered by the Bill, ensuring that these animals are protected from export for slaughter. It is a continuation of efforts to enhance animal we...
Not specified in the provided text, but inferred to be a finance bill - Clause 2 stand part; Schedule 1; New clause 1 (Review of reliefs for research and development); New clause 3 (Assessment of impact of Act on business investment and economic growth)
10 January 2024
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
The new clauses proposed by Eleanor Laing aim to enhance transparency around the financial measures introduced in the bill. New clause 1 requires the Chancellor of the Exchequer to publish a review de...
Tackling Spiking
18 December 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Infected Blood Inquiry: Government Response
18 December 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Global Combat Air Programme Treaty
18 December 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Trial of Jimmy Lai
18 December 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Bennetts End Road
07 December 2021
The petition highlights the concern about numerous incidents, likely accidents, occurring on Bennetts End Road in Hemel Hempstead due to residents crossing the road for various reasons, posing a signi...
View Full Petition -->
4
PMQs Asked
10
Ministerial Questions Asked
45
House of Commons Debates Involved
4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
1
Petitions Presented
0
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1370 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
+9% above average
This MP:
4
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
-27% below average
This MP:
10
Average:
13.7
Westminster Hall Debates Led
+58% above average
This MP:
4
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+830% above average
This MP:
45
Average:
4.8
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-59% below average
This MP:
1
Average:
2.4
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Mike Penning's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.