Ian Blackford
MP for Ross, Skye and Lochaber
SNP
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
I thank hon. Members for that welcome. Ordinary people did not need to hear an IMF forecast to understand that the UK economy is the worst performer among the leading nations in the world. They live with it every day. People know that energy bills are through the roof and that 750,000 households face defaulting on their mortgages while house prices fall. They know that food prices are rising at a record rate of 16.7% as of today. The Prime Minister has had 100 days in office and his party 13 years in power. In all that time, does he ever reflect that the only thing that the Tory party has been good at is pushing people into poverty?
Context
Ordinary people face high energy bills, mortgage defaults, rising food prices, and the UK economy is performing poorly compared to other leading nations.
Rishi Sunak
Aah, it is wonderful to hear from the right hon. Gentleman and lovely to see him in his place. We are continuing to deliver for people across the UK, including in Scotland. He mentioned poverty, which is lower today than when the Conservatives first came into office; inequality is lower than when the Conservatives first came into office; and the number of people on low pay is the lowest on record.
Assessment
The specific ask about pushing people into poverty was not directly addressed
Poverty Levels
Inequality
Low Pay Statistics
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Once again, what we are seeing on Brexit is “better together”—we are used to that in Scotland. The problem for both the Prime Minister and the Labour leader when it comes to Brexit is that even their own voters do not agree with them. Can the Prime Minister finally tell people in Scotland what is the democratic path to escape Westminster control and deliver independence?
Context
Critiqued the Prime Minister's approach to Brexit, noting that many people now believe leaving the EU was wrong. Asked about the democratic path for Scotland to escape Westminster control and deliver independence.
Rishi Sunak
The right hon. Gentleman talks about democracy and votes. The difference between us is that I respect the result of referendums. Let us remember one thing: we had the fastest vaccine roll-out in the world because of our freedoms after leaving the European Union.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Let me wish everyone a happy St Andrew's day. That is why it is such a sad sight to watch this Prime Minister ram through a Bill that would rip up 4,000 pieces of European law—laws that protect workers' rights, food standards and environmental protections. And it is an even worse sight watching the leader of the Labour party desperately trying to out-Brexit the Prime Minister, ruling out freedom of movement and any hope of a Swiss-style deal.
Context
Sent condolences to Doddie Weir's family. Criticized the Prime Minister for passing a Bill that would rip up 4,000 pieces of European law protecting workers' rights, food standards, and environmental protections.
Rishi Sunak
I join the right hon. Gentleman in offering our condolences to the family and friends of Doddie Weir, to whom I pay tribute for his campaign to raise awareness of motor neurone disease, which has made a big difference.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
What right does a man with no mandate have to deny Scottish democracy?
Context
The Prime Minister's opposition to an independence referendum is now at stake.
Rishi Sunak
When it comes to Scottish democracy, I am pleased that the Scottish Government have one of the most powerful devolved assemblies anywhere in the world. Shortly after becoming Prime Minister, I was the first Prime Minister in over a decade to attend the British-Irish Council and sit down with the First Minister.
Assessment
The question about Scottish democracy and mandate for referendum
Change Of Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Will he at least be honest and confirm that the very idea that the United Kingdom is a voluntary Union of nations is now dead and buried?
Context
The Supreme Court has clarified a point of law, but the Prime Minister's opposition to an independence referendum is now at stake.
Rishi Sunak
Let me start by saying that we respect the clear and definitive ruling of the Supreme Court of the United Kingdom. I am looking forward to seeing the Moderator of the Church of Scotland tomorrow.
Assessment
The question about Scottish independence referendum
Change Of Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
This looks very corrupt. The PM should sack someone who is prioritising a position in the House of Lords over Scottish democracy. Does he now put a stop to his predecessors stuffing the Lords with cronies?
Context
The MP criticises a Secretary of State for Scotland planning to become a Lord, undermining democracy in Scotland.
Rishi Sunak
What the Secretary of State and I are jointly focused on is working constructively with the Scottish Government to deliver for the people of Scotland. I am pleased to be meeting the First Minister tomorrow.
Assessment
The specific question about removing from Cabinet those planning lordships was not answered directly.
Changing Subject To Cooperation With Scottish Government
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
We remember nuclear test veterans seeking justice. The Prime Minister's judgment is poor, as evidenced by recent events. Will he now remove from his Cabinet someone who is prioritising a position in the House of Lords?
Context
The MP refers to the loss of a Cabinet Minister and concerns over appointments to the House of Lords.
Rishi Sunak
I am not going to comment on speculation around such lists. Any list would follow normal procedures and processes that are in place.
Assessment
The specific question about removing the Secretary of State from the Cabinet was not answered directly.
Referring To 'Normal Procedures'
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The Prime Minister appointed a Home Secretary who was forced to resign for breaching the ministerial code. Given his promise of governing with integrity and humility, will he admit his mistake and sack the Home Secretary without delay?
Context
Ian Blackford questioned the Prime Minister's recent Home Secretary appointment, citing previous controversies.
Rishi Sunak
I spoke to the First Minister of Scotland on my first day in office, expressing desire for constructive work with the Scottish Government. We will collaborate on shared challenges.
Assessment
Did not address call to sack Home Secretary or admit mistake
Changed Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
A winter of uncertainty is coming, with millions facing a double whammy when the energy price guarantee is cut off while households are hit by austerity 2.0 and real-terms cuts to social security benefits. Will he reassure people today and guarantee that benefits will rise in line with inflation?
Context
The new Prime Minister promised to bring compassion to challenges. Ian Blackford tested this by asking about the upcoming energy price increase and social security benefit cuts.
Rishi Sunak
My record is clear: I protected the most vulnerable during difficult times. We will continue to act like this in the weeks ahead.
Assessment
Did not provide a specific commitment on benefits rising with inflation
Promised General Principles
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
It is not surprising that the Prime Minister's approval ratings are collapsing with an answer like that. She has just thrown 12 million pensioners under the Tory bus, and it is not just pensioners feeling the pain. In the last week alone—[Interruption.]
Context
The Prime Minister's approval ratings are low, and there is concern about the Scottish economy due to separatist policies.
Elizabeth Truss
I do not think the right hon. Gentleman can take yes for an answer. I have been clear that we are protecting the triple lock on pensions. If he is concerned about the economy, why does he continue to advocate for separatism, which would plunge the Scottish economy into chaos?
Assessment
Economic impact of pensioners facing cuts
Changing Subject
Attacking Opposition
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Can she perhaps turn to her Chancellor right now, get permission to make another U-turn and commit to raising the state pension at the rate of inflation?
Context
There have been multiple U-turns by the government, leading to concerns about state pension increases.
Elizabeth Truss
I honestly do not know what the right hon. Gentleman is talking about. We have been clear in our manifesto that we will maintain the triple lock. I am completely committed to it and so is the Chancellor.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The scale of this Tory crisis is frightening: 100,000 households are up for mortgage renewals each month; people cannot afford extra £4,500 in interest. The Prime Minister has lost control. Is that what she meant when declaring herself a “pro-growth” PM?
Context
Recent policies have led to a rise in mortgage costs and fears of economic instability.
Elizabeth Truss
We have taken action to help families heat their homes. Interest rates are rising globally, a fact for the independent Bank of England.
Assessment
Question about negative impact was not directly addressed; instead focused on global interest rate trends and independence of Bank of England
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
When the Prime Minister last stood at the Dispatch Box, the average two-year fixed-rate mortgage was 4.5%. It is now at 6.5% and rising, hitting families. Will she give up on her desperate plan to save her Chancellor's skin by scapegoating the Governor of the Bank of England?
Context
The Prime Minister's previous remarks did not include commitments to uprating social security benefits with inflation.
Elizabeth Truss
The action we have taken has meant that families are not facing gargantuan energy bills. We want to deliver economic growth, jobs and opportunities in Scotland.
Assessment
Question about mortgage issues and strategy was changed to focus on delivering economic benefits instead of addressing specific concerns
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
On her first full day as Prime Minister, she has failed to rule out—[Interruption.]
Context
Questions about oil and gas extraction from North Sea.
Elizabeth Truss
I am not quite sure what the right hon. Gentleman's position is, because on one hand he does not seem to want oil and gas extraction from the North sea, and on the other hand he wants them to pay more taxes.
Assessment
Did not provide specific stance on energy policy or funding
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I am sure that the thoughts and prayers of everyone in the House will be with the families caught up in the terrible shooting over recess in Kyle and Lochalsh, and indeed in Liverpool. I trust that the families will be fully supported. Let me congratulate the Prime Minister and her family on her appointment, but I am sorry to say that her reputation for straight talking is falling apart at the first PMQs. After nine questions, she has still not told us who will pay for her energy plan. Today, the public are waiting to find out the response to the economic crisis, and they want answers. Will she finally answer two very simple questions? Will she freeze energy prices at their current levels, and will that be paid for by a windfall tax—yes or no?
Context
Questions regarding energy costs for households and businesses, and the economic crisis.
Elizabeth Truss
No, it will not be paid for by a windfall tax. I do not believe that we can tax our way to growth.
Assessment
Did not confirm freezing energy prices or provide specifics on paying for the plan
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The energy price cap could rise by 65% in October to £3,244 a year. Many families cannot afford food or heating. Does the Prime Minister understand that people in Scotland want rid of Westminster?
Context
Scottish constituents are facing economic challenges due to high energy costs and cost-of-living issues, exacerbated by potential future increases.
Boris Johnson
The Government is cutting taxes for working people and low-income households. We used fiscal firepower to deliver the furlough scheme, supporting the whole country through massive transfers.
Assessment
The PM did not address the cost of living crisis or energy price cap increases in Scotland specifically
Changed Subject
General Statements
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The Tory leadership contest is descending into a race to the right. Will the Prime Minister endorse any of these candidates who pledge extreme policies, or does he fear whoever wins will make Genghis Khan look like a moderate?
Context
Discussion on the current Tory leadership contest, its implications for Scotland, and concerns over extreme Brexit policies.
Boris Johnson
I feel a twinge that this may be the last time I answer a question from the right hon. Gentleman. The next leader will ensure working with the Scottish Government to protect and secure our Union. My view is we are much better together.
Assessment
The question about endorsing candidates was not addressed; instead, future leadership and union were discussed.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Nothing to see, we should all move on—if we live in the world of the Prime Minister. A few weeks ago, I compared the Prime Minister to Monty Python's black knight. It turns out that I was wrong: he is actually the dead parrot. Whether he knows it or not, he is now an ex-Prime Minister, but he will leave behind two deeply damaging legacies. How many more Ministers need to quit before he finally picks up his pen and writes his own resignation letter? Perhaps that is what he is doing now.
Context
The Prime Minister has faced criticism for his handling of the government and Brexit.
Boris Johnson
I noticed that the right hon. Gentleman's remark that the Labour party had given up on returning to the European Union was not greeted with rapture by the Opposition. That was because it is not true: they want to go back in, just as he does. I think that that is a terrible mistake. It would be undemocratic.
Assessment
Did not address calling a general election or resignation.
Changed Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Nothing to see, we should all move on—if we live in the world of the Prime Minister. A few weeks ago, I compared the Prime Minister to Monty Python's black knight. It turns out that I was wrong: he is actually the dead parrot. Whether he knows it or not, he is now an ex-Prime Minister, but he will leave behind two deeply damaging legacies. How many more Ministers need to quit before he finally picks up his pen and writes his own resignation letter? Perhaps that is what he is doing now.
Context
The Prime Minister has faced criticism for his handling of the government and Brexit.
Boris Johnson
I noticed that the right hon. Gentleman's remark that the Labour party had given up on returning to the European Union was not greeted with rapture by the Opposition. That was because it is not true: they want to go back in, just as he does. I think that that is a terrible mistake. It would be undemocratic.
Assessment
Did not address calling a general election or resignation.
Changed Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
There is no case for the Union due to Westminster imposing policies without Scotland's support, breaking international law over Brexit and austerity cuts. Why are the UK Government scared of democracy?
Context
The debate on Scottish independence is ongoing with criticism that the UK Government fears democratic processes.
Dominic Raab
No lessons can be taken from SNP's governance issues like high tax burden, poor PISA rankings and Europe's highest drug death rates. People want both Governments to work together on day-to-day issues.
Assessment
The questioner's request for understanding of the UK Government's stance was not directly addressed; instead, there were criticisms towards SNP governance.
No Lessons Can Be Taken From The Snp'S Governance.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Our nation will have its independence referendum on 19 October 2023. Why not support Scotland's greater income equality and lower poverty rates as seen in Europe? Will the opposition make a case for continued Westminster rule?
Context
The First Minister has set a date for an independence referendum, raising debate on Scotland's economic performance versus European standards under Westminster rule.
Dominic Raab
No right time for another referendum given current challenges. The SNP has led Scotland into problems like high tax burden and poor PISA rankings; drug death rate in Europe's highest under their rule. People want both Governments to work together.
Assessment
The specific request regarding the UK Government's fears about democracy was not directly addressed, focusing instead on criticizing SNP governance.
No Right Time For Another Referendum.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Well, actually, that is not true. Of course, the Prime Minister can make all the excuses he likes, but the fact is that the UK economy is lagging behind on his watch. If he looks at France, inflation is less than 6% there. This morning's report from the Resolution Foundation and the London School of Economics is the latest in a string of devastating reports on the outlook for the UK economy. The report could not be clearer. The Tory Government's disastrous Brexit is driving wages down, pushing inflation up and will make us poorer over the next decade, but instead of reversing course, the Prime Minister is recklessly threatening a trade war at the worst possible time. Will he finally come to his senses and negotiate an economic agreement with the EU, or is he going to wilfully—wilfully—push the UK into recession?
Context
The UK economy is facing challenges including high inflation, wage cuts, and a report from the Resolution Foundation and the London School of Economics highlighting the negative impacts of Brexit.
Boris Johnson
Nobody wants a trade war, nor is there any need for one. I am afraid the right hon. Gentleman is underestimating what this country is currently achieving—not just the Moderna investment, but record venture capital investment in this country, which has now overtaken China as a venue for venture capital investment, to say nothing of what we are getting in tech, and of course the benefits of that are being felt throughout the whole of the United Kingdom.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not address whether he will negotiate an economic agreement with the EU.
Changed Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
May I associate myself with the remarks of the Prime Minister and the leader of the Labour party as we mark Armed Services Week? We thank all our service personnel for the services that they give. On Windrush Day, we celebrate all those who have made Scotland and the UK their home. My party backs calls for a major commemoration for the 75th anniversary next year so we can properly mark the valued contribution that those who came here have made. This morning, it was revealed that UK inflation is now at a 40-year high. Families right across these islands are seeing their incomes squeezed as prices rise, bills soar, and Tory cuts and tax hikes hammer home. After 12 years in government, the Tories have left the UK economy in the doldrums and pushed millions of people into poverty, so can I ask the Prime Minister: does he think his Government bear any blame for the fact that the United Kingdom is doing so much worse than our European neighbours?
Context
With UK inflation at a 40-year high, Ian Blackford is questioning the government's responsibility for the poor economic performance compared to European neighbours.
Boris Johnson
Actually, as I think the whole House knows and the whole country knows, we have a global inflationary problem, but this Government have the fiscal firepower to deal with it. That is, I think, of benefit to the whole of the United Kingdom, including Scotland, as we have seen throughout the pandemic, and I think it is a matter of fact that taxes are actually highest of all in Scotland.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not directly acknowledge whether his government bears blame for UK economic performance lagging behind other countries.
Under Review
Working With Partners
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Scotland has the option of independence as it is undemocratic to be stuck with a Prime Minister and party we do not trust or support. Can you explain how this situation is democratic?
Context
MP noted that Scotland has a choice of an independent future due to lack of support for the current government.
Boris Johnson
We had a referendum in 2014 and the mandate was to remain part of the UK. The only way to reverse this would be through another referendum, but there is no indication of one happening.
Assessment
Did not directly address democratic legitimacy issue
Reiterating Past Referenda Results
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I am concerned about the Prime Minister's continued leadership given that at least 41% of his own MPs do not support him, and even Unionist leaders in Scotland will not back him. How does he expect to continue?
Context
MP noted that at least 41% of Conservative MPs have no confidence in the Prime Minister.
Boris Johnson
The right hon. Gentleman's support for the United Kingdom has been consistent, though I disagree with his methods. The Prime Minister stated that he respects the mandate given in 2014 and believes that independence is not desirable.
Assessment
Did not address the specific ask about continuation of leadership despite lack of support
Redirecting To Past Referenda
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
These are serious matters, but it is all a joke to the Prime Minister. The Prime Minister has lost the trust of the public. He has lost what little moral authority he had left. The reality is that no apology will ever be enough for the families of people who lost loved ones—the families who followed the rules, who stayed at home while their nearest and dearest were dying, and who are now forced to look at photographs of the Prime Minister, surrounded by drink, toasting to a party in the middle of a lockdown. If the Prime Minister will not accept that he must resign, those on the Tory Benches must act. This Prime Minister, who has broken the law and shown a cavalier attitude to the truth, cannot be allowed to remain in office. Time is up, Prime Minister. Resign! Resign before this House is forced to remove you!
Context
The Prime Minister's conduct during the pandemic has been criticised for breaching lockdown rules. The issue of moral authority and public trust is central.
Boris Johnson
I thank the right hon. Gentleman very much, and I direct him to the report. I think it would be to his advantage to look through it and then I think we should return to it after PMQs.
Assessment
Did not address resignation or apology; shifted focus to future debate opportunity
Redirecting
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I want to join others today in expressing my deepest sorrow at the horrific events in Texas yesterday. Some 19 children and two teachers have needlessly lost their lives. Many of us in Scotland will be remembering the tragic events that took place in Dunblane 26 years ago. The thoughts and prayers of the SNP are with the families suffering today, but we also hope that lawmakers will finally act to bring to an end the scourge of gun violence that plagues the United States. Will the Prime Minister now take the opportunity and resign?
Context
A tragic shooting event occurred in Texas, leading to the deaths of 19 children and two teachers. This is reminiscent of the Dunblane tragedy that took place 26 years ago in Scotland.
Boris Johnson
I can tell the right hon. Gentleman that, much as I appreciate his advice, he will have a further opportunity, which I am sure he will take with his customary length, to debate that matter in the course of the statement that will follow directly after PMQs.
Assessment
Did not address resignation or gun violence in the US; shifted focus to future debate opportunity
Redirecting
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
My goodness, talk about an Aesop's fable! Every day that this Prime Minister remains out of touch, people remain out of pocket. By the way, Prime Minister, £20 a week was taken out of people's universal credit.
The Prime Minister has just confirmed that he does think it would be “silly” to intervene. The Tories' only response to this cost of living crisis has been insults and inaction. We have the Tory Back Bencher who thinks that poor people just need cooking lessons, the Tory Minister who thinks that people should just get a “better paid job”, and the Chancellor who thinks it would be “silly” to act now. This is the cost of living crisis from Westminster. For weeks, the Prime Minister has been briefing that it is the Treasury that is to blame for blocking financial support for struggling families. Well, Prime Minister, it is time to stop sniping from the sidelines. If this Chancellor will not deliver an emergency budget, it is time for the Prime Minister to sack the Treasury, to sack the Chancellor, and to put somebody else in office who will act.
The Prime Minister has just confirmed that he does think it would be “silly” to intervene. The Tories' only response to this cost of living crisis has been insults and inaction. We have the Tory Back Bencher who thinks that poor people just need cooking lessons, the Tory Minister who thinks that people should just get a “better paid job”, and the Chancellor who thinks it would be “silly” to act now. This is the cost of living crisis from Westminster. For weeks, the Prime Minister has been briefing that it is the Treasury that is to blame for blocking financial support for struggling families. Well, Prime Minister, it is time to stop sniping from the sidelines. If this Chancellor will not deliver an emergency budget, it is time for the Prime Minister to sack the Treasury, to sack the Chancellor, and to put somebody else in office who will act.
Context
The Prime Minister confirmed that he still supports his Chancellor's statement about acting now being 'silly'. The cost of living crisis is severe.
Boris Johnson
The right hon. Gentleman needs to understand. To get back to the crucial point, we have been through covid, and we are facing a spike in global energy prices which has been greatly exacerbated by what Putin is doing in Ukraine. To deal with that, we are putting billions and billions—already £9.1 billion—into supporting people with the cost of energy, cutting fuel duty by record sums, and helping elderly people in all sorts of ways, not least through local councils, with another £1 billion.
Assessment
The specific question about firing the Chancellor was not directly addressed
Global Context
Economic Foundation
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I am sure the whole House will want to join me in wishing Glasgow Rangers Football Club all the best in the final tonight. It is always a joy to see Scottish clubs get to the finals of European competitions.
People did not need to see this morning's official statistics to know that we are experiencing the highest inflation in 40 years. They know it because they are living with it. Families cannot afford food; they cannot pay their bills—and we are only at the beginning. As always, under the Tories, the poorest are punished the most. For months, people have been crying out for support, but, month after month, a distracted Downing Street has failed to lift a finger to help. Does the Prime Minister still support his Chancellor's insulting statement that acting now in this cost of living emergency would just be “silly”?
People did not need to see this morning's official statistics to know that we are experiencing the highest inflation in 40 years. They know it because they are living with it. Families cannot afford food; they cannot pay their bills—and we are only at the beginning. As always, under the Tories, the poorest are punished the most. For months, people have been crying out for support, but, month after month, a distracted Downing Street has failed to lift a finger to help. Does the Prime Minister still support his Chancellor's insulting statement that acting now in this cost of living emergency would just be “silly”?
Context
The UK is experiencing the highest inflation in 40 years. Families struggle with food and energy costs.
Boris Johnson
I support the Chancellor's work in lifting the living wage by a record amount, in making sure that people on universal credit pay £1,000 less in tax, in putting another £22 billion into supporting people with the cost of living, and in giving £9.1 billion already to help with the cost of energy.
Assessment
The specific question about whether acting now would be silly was not directly addressed
Under Review
Supporting Measures
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
We have children facing poverty, and the Scottish Government are responding with the child payment, but we get nothing but empty words from the Prime Minister. We heard plenty of desperate pre-election waffle, but I will take it as a no: there is no support for hard-pressed families. Here are three other ideas for the Prime Minister that would help families with their soaring costs right now: scrapping his national insurance tax hike, reversing the Tory cuts to universal credit and matching Scotland's 6% benefits rise instead of imposing a real-terms cut. Has the Prime Minister come to terms with the reality that if he fails to act now, the voters will send him and his sleaze-ridden party a message by voting SNP next Thursday?
Context
The Scottish Government introduced the child payment to support children facing poverty. The SNP is concerned about lack of action from the UK government despite previous promises.
Boris Johnson
We are helping families up and down the country with the universal credit taper. The right hon. Gentleman asks about universal credit; we are tapering it so that working people get another £1,000 in their pocket. We believe in championing work, championing employment and helping people into high-wage, high-skill jobs.
Assessment
The PM acknowledged providing support through the universal credit taper but did not commit to specific measures requested (scrapping national insurance tax hike, reversing cuts to universal credit, matching Scotland's benefits rise).
Working With Partners
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
May I associate myself with remarks about misogyny and sexism witnessed by the deputy leader of Labour? The Prime Minister should act to help families through the cost of living emergency. Will he match Scotland's game-changing child payment?
Context
The Trussell Trust confirmed that 830,000 children across the UK are relying on emergency food parcels due to the cost of living crisis.
Boris Johnson
We have increased funds available to local councils and introduced a holiday activities fund. We are supporting families throughout this period dealing with the aftershocks of the covid pandemic.
Assessment
Did not directly commit to matching Scotland's child payment
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Families are having to choose what rooms to heat or whether they can turn on the heating at all. Some in the Tory Cabinet clearly believe that better weather means that they can happily sit on their hands and do nothing until next winter. The Chancellor thinks his £200 loan, which is forcing people into energy debt, is somehow a solution, but it clearly is not. So before the Prime Minister and his Chancellor go off on their Easter holidays, will they, at the very least, turn this loan into a grant and finally put some cash into people's pockets when they need it, right now?
Context
Food banks are warning that people are having to choose their food based on whether they can afford the gas to boil it. The Chancellor's £200 loan is forcing people into energy debt.
Boris Johnson
The Government is making huge investments in supporting people right now through the household support fund and cold weather payments, and there are another £1 billion of funds available.
Assessment
The answer did not commit to converting the loan scheme into a grant but indicated ongoing support measures.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Last night, millions of families will have been desperately trying to figure out how they will possibly afford the £700 energy price hike that will hit them this Friday. At the very same time, Tory MPs were gathering across the street for a champagne bash in the Park Plaza. We all know that the Tories partied during lockdown, and now they are—
Context
Millions of families face a £700 energy price increase, while Tory MPs held a champagne bash in the Park Plaza.
Boris Johnson
The living wage is going up again by record amounts, and thanks to what the Chancellor has done we are putting £9.1 billion into helping people up and down the country.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not address any specific issue raised about energy price hikes or Tory MPs' partying.
Changing Subject
Highlighting Achievements
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Of course, we want to make sure we open our doors in Scotland and welcome refugees, and that we have that generosity of spirit—but we will leave that there for now. I say to the Prime Minister that inflation is at 6% and increasing. We need to make sure that those who are the most vulnerable have that increase in benefits that they need in order to pay for fuel. The Chancellor needs to ditch the official photographer and listen to Martin Lewis. Family finances are at breaking point; they cannot tighten their budgets any more. These families have no room to manoeuvre, but the truth is that the Chancellor does. Lower borrowing and increased taxes mean that he is sitting with £20 billion to spend today. But instead this Chancellor is making a political choice: the choice to push people further into hardship by hiking taxes, cutting universal credit, and giving companies free rein to slash workers' pay through fire and rehire. So the test for the Prime Minister is this: will the Government use the full £20 billion they are sitting on to scrap the national insurance tax hike and put money into people's pockets, or will he simply make this Tory poverty pandemic even worse?
Context
Inflation is at a record high, causing significant financial strain on families. The Chancellor has £20 billion to spend but is not using it to support those in need.
Boris Johnson
I just advise Mystic Meg over there that he has only 10 minutes to wait before he will have the answer to that question.
Assessment
The specific ask about using £20 billion was not addressed, instead deflected with a vague response about timing
Advising On Waiting For An Answer
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
This morning, we have official confirmation that inflation is at its highest level in 30 years, but families do not need official confirmation to know that the cost of food and energy is now at a price they simply cannot afford. The very people who bore the brunt of the health pandemic are now being hammered by the poverty pandemic. This is not just a cost of living crisis—this is an emergency. That is why, in Scotland, the SNP Government are doubling the Scottish child payment and raising the benefits they control by 6%—that is double the rate the Chancellor has proposed for the benefits that he has control over. So this is a very simple question for the Prime Minister: if he truly understands that this is an emergency, will he match the Scottish Government's commitment and lift all benefits by 6%?
Context
Inflation is at a record high, causing significant financial strain on families. The SNP Government in Scotland has doubled the Scottish child payment and raised benefits by 6%.
Boris Johnson
I thank the right hon. Gentleman very much. We all recognise that global inflation is causing a real cost of living crisis, not just here, but around the world; in the United States, inflation is now running at more than 8%, and we are at the levels in other European countries. We are doing everything we can to help people. The Chancellor has put another £9.1 billion into reducing the costs of energy for families.
Assessment
The specific ask about matching Scottish Government's 6% benefits increase was not directly addressed
We Are Doing Everything We Can To Help People
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
We need the Home Office to give us paperwork that will facilitate the urgent case involving nearly 50 vulnerable children from Ukraine. If even strong political pressure cannot make it happen, what hope is there for other refugee children? The UN estimates one child per second becoming a refugee due to the war in Ukraine.
Context
The question addresses delays in facilitating the entry of almost 50 Ukrainian children into UK for refuge. The Home Office's involvement and effectiveness are questioned due to high-level interventions being required.
Dominic Raab
The proper international practices on safeguarding must be followed. We are keen to explore family reunion options for children in state care in Ukraine with relatives in the region. The Government is making plans for 100,000 Ukrainian children arriving at UK schools.
Assessment
Did not commit to improving the efficiency of paperwork and processing times for refugees
We Are Keen To Explore Family Reunion Options
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
We have seen that too many times from a Tory Home Office: the Windrush scandal, the “Go home” vans, and the inhumane Nationality and Borders Bill. The UK Home Office is raising barriers and bureaucracy when we should be offering care and compassion. I say to the Prime Minister that he should not let the history of failure repeat itself. Scotland stands ready to offer sanctuary and refuge, so will he join the rest of the European continent and waive the visa restrictions for refugees fleeing war in Ukraine?
Context
The UK Home Office is criticised for its handling of Ukrainian refugees, with concerns over excessive bureaucracy and the continued application of the 'hostile environment' policy.
Boris Johnson
This country has an unparalleled record—Just since I have been Prime Minister, look at the numbers we have taken from Afghanistan and Hong Kong. We will be generous and we are being generous. What we are doing is making sure that, in those neighbouring countries, the UK is out in front giving humanitarian assistance and we are in every capital. This country is leading in every respect. We are also the single biggest donor of humanitarian aid to the Ukraine warzone—the single biggest donor.
Assessment
The Prime Minister did not commit to waiving visa restrictions for Ukrainian refugees, focusing instead on the UK's record of generosity and humanitarian assistance.
Changed Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Poland has taken over 1.2 million refugees; Hungary, over 190,000; Germany, over 50,000; Italy, over 7,000; and Ireland, three times its population in proportion to the UK's response of only 760 visas. Is this an acceptable record?
Context
The Home Secretary has granted only 760 visas in two weeks, while other countries like Poland, Hungary, Germany, and Ireland have taken hundreds of thousands of refugees.
Boris Johnson
The Government aim to increase the number of refugees welcomed from Ukraine, with a plan for hundreds of thousands. The Home Secretary's record since 2015 resettles more vulnerable people than any other European country.
Assessment
The specific ask about finding it acceptable was not directly answered with a commitment or stance.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
How can our allies trust this Prime Minister to clean up dirty Russian money in the UK when he will not even clean up his own political party?
Context
The MP offered to work with the Prime Minister five years ago. The Conservative Party has raised £2.3 million from Russian oligarchs since the PM took office.
Boris Johnson
People who give money to this country are registered on the UK register of interests, and we do not raise money from Russian oligarchs.
Assessment
Did not commit to giving up £2.3 million raised by his party from Russian oligarchs
Redirecting Criticism
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Why did the Prime Minister do nothing back then, and why is he still doing nothing now?
Context
The SNP Benches stood united against the Russian invasion of Ukraine. The MP raised concerns about limited partnerships moving $20.8 billion out of Russian banks.
Boris Johnson
We are going much further to uncloak the true owners of Russian companies and Russian properties in this country. No country is doing more than the UK to tackle this issue.
Assessment
Did not address why nothing happened when first raised by the MP five years ago
General Commitment Without Specifics
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The Prime Minister and his Chancellor tell nurses that their reward for seeing us through the pandemic is a £270 wage cut. Is this fair?
Context
During the pandemic, nurses sacrificed much while the Government held numerous parties. Now they face a £270 wage cut.
Boris Johnson
We back our fantastic nurses all the way, recruiting more of them. We increased starting salaries by 12.8%, in addition to bursaries and help.
Assessment
The question about fairness of pay cuts was not addressed
Changing Subject To Recruitment And Salary Increases
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
While changes in Downing Street continue, people face costs from the Tory leadership. Will the Prime Minister and the Chancellor scrap the regressive hike in national insurance?
Context
The Chancellor's national insurance hike will cause nurses to take a £275-a-year pay cut at the same time as soaring energy bills hit.
Boris Johnson
We recruit 50,000 more nurses, with 11,000 additional this year. Starting salary for nurses increased by 12.8%. We value our NHS and pay for it.
Assessment
The question about scrapping the national insurance hike was not addressed
Changing Subject To Recruitment Of More Nurses
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The PM cannot even tell us where he was, and his colleagues' expressions show they agree. He thinks everything is owed to him but never thinks what he owes the public. What does it mean for the PM that the Chair of the Defence Committee has submitted a letter of no confidence?
Context
The Prime Minister has been previously questioned about attending a party that he denied happened. The Chair of the Select Committee on Defence submitted a letter of no confidence.
Boris Johnson
It is more vital than ever to deliver our covid recovery plan, and we are doing that. That is what matters now.
Assessment
Changed subject entirely without addressing the specific question of the no confidence letter
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I respect the authority of Mr Speaker but I have a duty to represent public anger with the PM for attending a party that he previously denied happened. Can the Prime Minister update the House on where he was on 13 November?
Context
The Telegraph revealed that the Prime Minister attended a party in his flat on 13 November 2020, which contradicts his previous statement to the House. The police are now investigating this incident.
Boris Johnson
The right hon. Gentleman asked exactly the same questions a few days ago and knows that the process must go on. We have been delivering the fastest vaccine roll-out anywhere in Europe, getting people back to work, and helping to defy unacceptable threats against Ukraine.
Assessment
Changed subject entirely without addressing the specific question of his whereabouts
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Every moment the Prime Minister stays in office adds to a crisis caused by Tory cuts, Brexit, and soaring costs of living that have pushed millions into poverty. How much longer will Tory MPs let this go on?
Context
The Prime Minister is under police investigation, which has damaged public trust. The PM faced criticism for breaking his own laws.
Boris Johnson
I do not know who has been eating more cake, but behind the scenes I co-operate well with Scottish colleagues.
Assessment
Specific ask about duration was not addressed
Changing Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Every moment the Prime Minister stays in office drags out the agony for families who remind him of sacrifices made and further damages his party's reputation. How much longer will Tory MPs let this go on?
Context
The Prime Minister is under police investigation, which has damaged public trust. The PM faced criticism for breaking his own laws.
Boris Johnson
Behind the scenes, I co-operate well with Scottish colleagues, and I have no intention of doing what is suggested.
Assessment
Specific ask about duration was not addressed
Changing Subject
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The PM broke law and showed no shame; the public thinks he should resign. Will Tory MPs remove him?
Context
The PM's alleged partying violated laws set by his own Government, causing pain among the public.
Boris Johnson
Advice from the Scottish nationalist party is taken with a pinch of salt; most people would agree we have delivered the fastest vaccine and booster roll-out in Europe.
Assessment
Did not address whether Tory MPs will remove him, instead praising government achievements.
Changing Subject To Government Accomplishments
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Paul, an ex-soldier, wrote that the PM broke laws and followed no rules. The public thinks he should resign; will he?
Context
Jack Dromey was a fighter for workers' rights and his death prompted condolences.
Boris Johnson
The right hon. Gentleman's political advice is noted but I think most people would agree we have delivered the fastest vaccine and booster roll-out in Europe.
Assessment
Did not address whether he will resign or be removed by Tory MPs, instead praising government achievements.
Changing Subject To Government Accomplishments
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
So much for a new year, a new start: it is the same nonsense from this failing Prime Minister. We have had the year of Tory sleaze, but now we have the year of Tory squeeze for family budgets. Economists have warned that UK living standards will worsen in 2022, with the poorest households hit hardest by Tory cuts, tax hikes and soaring inflation driven by his Government's policy. In Scotland, the SNP Government are mitigating this Tory poverty crisis by doubling the Scottish child payment to £20 per week. Will he match the Scottish Government and introduce a £20 child payment across the UK?
Context
Economists have warned that UK living standards will worsen in 2022 due to Tory policies, with the poorest households being hit hardest. The Scottish Government are mitigating this by doubling the Scottish child payment.
Boris Johnson
The right hon. Gentleman is talking, I am afraid, total nonsense. This Government are absolutely determined, as I have said throughout this pandemic, to look after particularly the poorest and the neediest. That is what the Chancellor did: all his packages were extremely progressive in their effect.
Assessment
The Prime Minister avoided committing to a £20 child payment across the UK
Offensive Language
Denying Economic Warnings
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I wish you, Mr Speaker, colleagues and all staff a guid new year. Over the last few weeks, serious warnings have grown over the Tory cost of living crisis, which will hit the majority of families over the coming months. For the vast majority of families, losing £1,200 a year will be catastrophic. So will the Prime Minister apologise for leaving millions of families worse off, and will he commit to an emergency financial package to reverse his Tory cost of living crisis?
Context
Research from the Resolution Foundation indicates that UK families will be £1,200 worse off as a result of Tory policies, with low-income households being hit hardest.
Boris Johnson
I find that criticism hard to take from the humble crofter, if I may say so—with whom, I stress, I normally have very good relations off the pitch. What we are doing is helping families up and down the country with the taper rate, ensuring that a single mother with two kids gets £1,200 more on universal credit, £1,000 more as a result of the increase to the living wage.
Assessment
The Prime Minister avoided apologising for leaving families worse off and did not commit to an emergency financial package
Deflecting Criticism
Offensive Language
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
On 14 September, I led a Backbench Business debate asking for government action on footballers with brain injuries. A commitment was made by the Minister and the DWP Minister Tom Pursglove to meet us to discuss this issue. However, despite follow-up letters from me on January 18th and March 13th, as well as a Westminster Hall debate on April 24th, no meeting has been held yet. Can we get that meeting with the Industrial Injuries Advisory Council?
Context
A Backbench Business debate on footballers' brain injuries was held in the House of Commons on 14 September 2023. The debate resulted in a commitment from the Minister to arrange a meeting for cross-party discussion with the Industrial Injuries Advisory Council.
Mims Davies
I have met the chair of the Industrial Injuries Advisory Council and will continue engaging on this issue. The council is investigating any link between neurodegenerative diseases and professional sports, and their findings will be published once complete. I am also working with the Sports Minister to share information.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Acknowledging the Defence Minister's service, Richard Drax challenges the notion of being ready for war with existing armed forces. He cites increasing threats and asks if more money needs to be spent on defence.
Context
Richard Drax questions the idea that current armed forces are ready to fight a sustained war given the threats they face.
James Heappey
Colleagues will note that when invited to respond, Defence Ministers have not missed the opportunity. The Government's responsibility is to reinvest in warfighting capability, given the current 'pre-war era'.
Session: Armed Forces Readiness
View All Questions -->
What progress has been made on improving the readiness of the armed forces? The shadow Secretary of State commended the efforts of all those in the armed services, but the Defence Committee's report substantiates that our armed forces are constantly overstretched and being deployed above their capacity. When will the Government appropriately respond to geopolitical challenges by driving up recruitment and retention?
Context
The UK armed forces are meeting their commitments but are very busy during a turbulent geopolitical time.
James Heappey
The UK armed forces are meeting all commitments but remain busy. The Government is investing £1.95 billion extra in resilience and readiness, with services getting back into warfighting business. However, the world's complexity means extensive demands on the armed forces.
Session: Armed Forces Readiness
View All Questions -->
Scotland has been hammered by Westminster's imposition of a hard Brexit. The salmon industry alone suffers from £12 million in extra costs due to red tape. Has the Secretary of State considered the negative impacts on Scotland's economy and industries?
Context
The Scottish salmon industry has suffered an additional £12 million in costs due to Brexit red tape, affecting exports and access to vital workers.
Alister Jack
Our departure from the EU has allowed us to forge new relationships. As a result, Scotland's exports are performing well—they are up by 13%.
Session: Departure from the EU Impact on Scotland
View All Questions -->
What recent assessment has been made of the impact of the UK's departure from the EU on Scotland? Has the government recognized the negative effects?
Context
Following the UK's departure from the EU, there is concern about the impact on Scotland's economy and industries.
Alister Jack
The UK Government are working tirelessly to maximise opportunities following our departure from the European Union. Scotland continues to punch above its weight, both in exports of goods and services and in foreign direct investment, and I am delighted to be able to say that trade is now well above pre-Brexit levels.
Session: Departure from the EU Impact on Scotland
View All Questions -->
We need to step up the amount of ammunition and arms shipped to Ukraine. What talks are you having with our European allies?
James Heappey
Discussions happen regularly, including at donor conferences and NATO meetings, focusing on traditional armaments as well as precision weapons systems.
Session: Ukraine Military Support
View All Questions -->
I thank the Secretary of State for that response, particularly in relation to CfDs. Will he commit today to a clear pathway for the true commercial-scale development of tidal stream energy? A ringfence in the CfD auction is welcome, but it is only scratching the surface of what the industry can deliver. Investors in projects are stalling, as they need long-term visibility.
Context
The questioner thanks the Secretary for previous support and seeks a commitment to a clear pathway for true commercial-scale development of tidal stream energy.
Grant Shapps
Fortunately, the answer is pretty straightforward. As the right hon. Gentleman mentioned, we are doing tidal power in this CfD round. That is to be welcomed and we look forward to this industry expanding in the future, as some of the technicalities and technical difficulties are resolved.
Session: Energy Transition Projects Scotland
View All Questions -->
It costs an electricity generator almost £7.50 per megawatt-hour to connect to the national grid from the north of Scotland and £4.70 from the south of Scotland. That compares with 50p in England and Wales. Does he recognise that these unfair transmission charges penalise investment in Scotland's renewables sector, and if so, what is he doing about it?
Context
High transmission costs in Scotland compared to England and Wales, impacting the viability of renewable projects.
John Lamont
By law, transmission network charging is a matter for Ofgem as the independent regulator. Transmission charges are set to reflect the costs imposed on the grid by generators and demand in different locations. That means that generators in Scotland pay higher charges than counterparts in England and Wales, reflecting the higher levels of transmission investment they drive. Ofgem recognises the importance of transmission charges to the deployment of Scottish renewable generation and has announced a programme of transmission charging reforms. The Minister recently met with his colleague from West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine to discuss addressing concerns over connection costs.
Session: Renewable Energy
View All Questions -->
What actions will be taken regarding the extradition of Edgar (Iain Wares), an individual accused of inappropriate behaviour against dozens of boys?
Context
The Member is concerned about the recruitment and retention of teachers but prioritises keeping children safe from sexual predators, mentioning a Scottish child abuse inquiry.
Gillian Keegan
Child sexual abuse is an abhorrent crime and due process must be followed to allow investigatory and legal processes, maximising conviction chances. Due process is important to follow.
Session: Teacher Recruitment and Retention
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Valedictory Debate
24 May 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
In her concluding remarks, Harriet Harman reflected on her 42-year tenure in the House of Commons, thanking her constituents for their support and expressing pride in being a Labour MP. She emphasised...
Backbench Business
16 May 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The debate urges the UK Government to deliver prompt compensation to women born in the 1950s who had their state pension age raised. The Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman report highlights th...
Iran-Israel Update
15 April 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Women’s State Pension Age
25 March 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Cyber-security and UK Democracy
25 March 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Budget Resolutions
06 March 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Conservatives' record is marked by a recession, high tax burden, living standards decline, and fiscal irresponsibility. The Chancellor's new measures do not address these issues; they merely exace...
Ceasefire in Gaza
21 February 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Death of Alexei Navalny
19 February 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Situation in the Red Sea
24 January 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The situation in the Red Sea is increasingly dangerous due to attacks by Houthi proxies supported by Iran. These attacks are threatening global trade, with over $1 trillion worth of goods passing thro...
Defending the UK and Allies
15 January 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
151
PMQs Asked
9
Ministerial Questions Asked
98
House of Commons Debates Involved
0
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
0
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1370 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
+4025% above average
This MP:
151
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
-33% below average
This MP:
9
Average:
13.4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+1917% above average
This MP:
98
Average:
4.9
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-100% below average
This MP:
0.0
Average:
69.2
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Ian Blackford's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.