Douglas Chapman
MP for Dunfermline and West Fife
SNP
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
Although the Prime Minister is absent, I hope he later gets the chance to watch the BBC's dramatisation of the Brink's-Mat robbery in the 1980s, when the police team assigned to recover the stolen gold got back only half. That sum pales into insignificance compared with the measly 1% recovered from the £1 billion in business grants lost to fraud under the Prime Minister's watch as Chancellor. The fingerprints show that this massive fraud now lies at No. 10 Downing Street. To quote the Government's former fraud Minister, Lord Agnew of Oulton, when will this Government “get their acts together” and step up the recovery efforts on behalf of the taxpayer?
Context
The Prime Minister was criticized for the low percentage of recovered business grants from fraud, with blame attributed to his time as Chancellor.
Dominic Raab
Tackling fraud has become more complex because of the online incidence, but the hon. Gentleman will have noted the massive increase in funding for tackling it in the recent Budget, and we are confident that will give us the resources we need to deal with this often invisible but very damaging crime.
Assessment
The specific ask about getting their acts together was not directly addressed; instead, general improvements were outlined.
Changing Subject To Broader Plans
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Douglas Chapman welcomes the PM's mandate but asserts that it is insignificant compared to the SNP's mandate. He urges the PM to commence discussions on Scottish independence.
Context
The SNP won a majority in Scotland, leading to demands for discussions on an Edinburgh agreement regarding Scottish independence.
The Prime Minister (Boris Johnson)
Johnson reiterates that the people of Scotland decided in favour of remaining part of the UK and that this decision should be respected without giving any indication of willingness to discuss independence further.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The Brexit pain continues, with £140 billion wiped off the UK economy and more regulation making it tough for exporters. Relative to similarly sized countries, Scotland's exports are under real pressure. Two themes in the First Minister's industrial strategy were to become an independent nation and to rejoin the EU. All the evidence points to the fact that that is the correct course of action, does it not?
Context
The question highlights the economic downturn caused by Brexit, with £140 billion lost from the UK economy and increased regulatory burdens for exporters. It questions whether Scotland should seek independence and rejoin the EU.
John Lamont
No, it does not. Scotland continues to punch above its weight in exports, goods and services and foreign direct investment. Trade is now well above pre-Brexit levels.
Session: Leaving the EU Import and Export Requirements
View All Questions -->
In my country, energy debt is rising, as Scottish consumers pay a premium on their energy bill. In light of that imbalance, has the Minister discussed abolishing Ofgem? If not, should his Government give full responsibility for energy pricing in Scotland to the Scottish Parliament?
Context
The question arises from concerns about the impact of UK-wide energy policies on Scottish consumers, who pay a premium for their energy bills.
Graham Stuart
We have acted decisively to support families, with the price cap falling by half since its peak last year. We are targeting our support at vulnerable customers and working on plans to increase Britain's power independence from foreign fossil fuels.
Session: Consumer Energy Debt
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions she has had with Ofgem on trends in the level of consumer energy debt. I am concerned about the rising number of households unable to pay their bills, which is why we need to address this issue promptly.
Context
The question arises from increasing consumer energy debts and recent discussions with Ofgem on trends in such debts.
Graham Stuart
Ministers regularly meet Ofgem to discuss issues, including a November meeting where the Secretary of State met suppliers alongside Ofgem to discuss consumer energy debt and vulnerable customer protection. The Government is providing £104 billion in cost of living support between 2022 and 2025.
Session: Consumer Energy Debt
View All Questions -->
Last week, the CBI conference raised the serious issue of a lack of people to do vital jobs that we need filling, especially in hospitality and food production. Both the Fraser of Allander Institute and the highlands MSP Kate Forbes have suggested localised worker visa solutions to boost the economy. Why is the Secretary of State not listening to those smart voices, and why is he not acting in the best interests of the Scottish economy?
Context
CBI conference raised concerns about job vacancies, especially in hospitality and food production. Suggested localised work visa solutions by Fraser of Allander Institute and highlands MSP Kate Forbes.
Alister Jack
Because we have a specific Scottish occupation list for shortages, which gives us flexibility. The salary rate is set at £20,960. We believe that the best way is for stakeholder bodies to make representations to the Home Office to add to the shortage occupation list.
Session: Scottish Work Visa Scheme
View All Questions -->
The price of school meals has increased by more than a third in some parts of the UK, yet the Government, and indeed the Labour Front Benchers, will not commit to universal free school meals for primary school-age children. The Scottish Government are rolling out free school meals across all primary schools. The question is when this Government will take the lead from the Scottish Government and act decisively to help struggling families.
Context
Increase in the price of school meals, with Scottish Government implementing universal free school meals.
Nick Gibb
Record numbers of pupils in England are now eligible for a free school meal. Under universal infant free school meals, all infant pupils get a free meal. A third of children in our schools are receiving a free school meal. We believe very strongly, however, that we should focus the funding on the children in the greatest need. We keep the issue under review, but our focus is always on the most disadvantaged.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
What discussions has the Minister had with the Prime Minister to find out what they can do now for farmers, growers and producers and to protect beleaguered shoppers? The plan needs improvement as current actions are not working.
Context
Food inflation is at a record 45-year high, causing significant costs for both farmers and consumers.
Mark Spencer
I think the hon. Gentleman will be aware that we are not responsible for Russia's invasion of Ukraine, which has had a significant impact on global energy prices. The good news is that those global energy prices are coming back to a level, and that is starting to feed back into our food supply chain. That is why we are helping and supporting farmers, investing in new technology and investing in their businesses to make them more sustainable and more profitable going forwards so that they can continue to deliver great quality British food at a reasonable price.
Session: Food Production Costs
View All Questions -->
Does the Secretary of State welcome the Scottish Government's focus on promoting global Scotland, considering recent issues with higher taxes for whisky and post-Brexit trade barriers?
Context
The Scottish whisky industry and food sector face challenges such as higher taxation and post-Brexit regulatory issues.
Alister Jack
Yes, I welcome those efforts but also highlight that the UK government works within reserved areas and does not support any actions by Scotland that undermine these areas like banning whisky advertising.
Session: Promoting Scotland Overseas
View All Questions -->
HMS Prince of Wales currently lies in Rosyth for repairs and I hear it has been cannibalised for spare parts. Will this £3 billion asset be back on full operational duties by the end of the year?
Context
HMS Prince of Wales is undergoing repairs in Rosyth. Reports suggest the ship has been cannibalised for spare parts.
Ben Wallace (Minister of State for Defence)
Yes, by the autumn. It is perfectly normal for ships to take ship stores from each other. HMS Prince of Wales is not being cannibalised because it is off to be mothballed. The ship will be back in full service in the autumn.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Pension credit continues to be a serious issue, with £1.7 billion going unclaimed each year. Will the Minister introduce an effective strategy in the coming year, perhaps following some of the initiatives we see in Scotland, to make sure everyone gets what they are entitled to in these very difficult times?
Context
Pension credit remains unclaimed by many eligible individuals, amounting to £1.7 billion annually.
Laura Trott
The Department for Work and Pensions is straining every sinew because this is incredibly important to us, and to me. We need to make sure we are doing all we can to reach those vulnerable customers. We have done a nationwide advertising campaign, which the hon. Gentleman may have seen. We are doing a lot in the build-up to 19 May, and I want to work with everyone in the House to make sure we use Members of Parliament as much as possible to reach out to vulnerable pensioners in our constituencies.
Session: Pensioners Cost of Living
View All Questions -->
This Government seem hellbent on destroying the Scottish seafood sector. Some £60 million has been spent on additional Brexit paperwork alone, while export delays and exclusions undermine our export potential. What has happened to the Brexit sea of opportunity that was promised, and does the Minister accept the assessment of the Scottish White Fish Producers Association that Brexit has failed to deliver any benefits of a coastal state?
Context
Brexit has cost the UK £60 million in additional paperwork, leading to export delays and exclusions.
Alister Jack
I do not accept that assessment. Certain sectors of the fishing industry have made much progress and seen many benefits. On the processing sector, we are looking at what the shortage occupation list could do to help the sector and at further investment in the north-east. I am confident that there is a sea of opportunity, which we will see over the five-year period, and that, at the end of those five years, the fishing sector will not be jumping up and down saying, “Let's get back into the common fisheries policy.”
Session: Impact of Leaving the EU
View All Questions -->
Last week's Bloomberg report suggests that levelling up in Scotland is just not happening. Given that Scotland is self-sufficient in gas and has great offshore renewables, should not the stewardship, licensing and revenues be linked to the Scottish Government budget, rather than to Her Majesty's Treasury? Minister, when will these negotiations start?
Context
A Bloomberg report suggests levelling up has not been happening in Scotland despite its self-sufficiency in gas and offshore renewables.
Michael Gove
I am grateful to the hon Gentleman for raising the issue of the importance of the Scottish Government and the UK Government working together on levelling up. That is why I am pleased that, working with the Finance Minister in the Scottish Government, Kate Forbes, we have been able to agree a prospectus for two new freeports in Scotland.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
What actions has the Secretary of State taken to assist in introducing a direct ferry service from Scotland to critically important export markets in Europe?
Context
The MP inquired about the Secretary of State's actions towards introducing a direct ferry service from Scotland to export markets in Europe.
Iain Stewart
I was pleased to reply to a debate that the hon. Gentleman and other colleagues spoke in a couple of weeks ago on exploring the potential for restoring the Rosyth to Zeebrugge link, which ceased operating a few years ago. There are lots of potentials for reopening that.
Session: Coastal Communities
View All Questions -->
I endorse the comments of the Secretary of State on the Olympic and Paralympic teams, and the tartan army result last night; I am absolutely delighted with second place in the group at the moment, but let us go on to be first and get qualification. The Secretary of State will be aware of recent dismal export figures in the wake of Brexit, the need to reduce lorry miles to help us get to net zero and the current HGV driver crisis that make up the hat-trick of events that would seem to make the need for a ferry service from Scotland to mainland Europe almost self-evident. However, there are barriers, including the commitment of Border Force to provide the resources and personnel to support that new route. Next week, we celebrate London International Shipping Week—
Context
In light of recent export figures post-Brexit, the need to reduce lorry miles for net zero targets, and the current HGV driver crisis, there is a pressing case for considering direct ferry services between Scotland and mainland Europe.
Alister Jack
I think the hon. Gentleman is requesting a meeting, and I would be happy to meet him. As he knows, the ferry service between Rosyth and Zeebrugge ran from 2002 to 2018, but from 2010 was not a passenger service. We would want any service that comes forward to be economically viable.
Session: Ferry Services Scotland to Europe
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions he has had with Cabinet colleagues on the potential merits of creating direct ferry services from Scotland to mainland Europe.
Context
There has been ongoing discussion about the benefits and feasibility of establishing direct ferry routes from Scotland to mainland Europe. This question arises in the context of economic, environmental, and logistical considerations.
Alister Jack
Let me start by saying that the Scottish athletes of Team GB have returned triumphant from the Tokyo 020 Olympic games with a record total of 14 medals, surpassing the 13 medals won by Scottish athletes at both the London and Rio Olympics. At the Paralympic games, the Scots of ParalympicsGB won an impressive 21 medals. I congratulate every athlete who competed. I also congratulate the Scottish football team on their victory in Vienna last night. I regularly discuss a wide range of topics with Cabinet colleagues, including transport and the Union connectivity review. There are of course merits to any direct ferry services from Scotland. I understand that discussions for a new service to mainland Europe have been taking place for some time.
Session: Ferry Services Scotland to Europe
View All Questions -->
What support will the Department provide to maritime and shipping sectors as part of the commitment to net zero shipping?
Context
The shipping industry is a significant contributor to carbon emissions, necessitating support from the government towards decarbonisation.
Grant Shapps
That is absolutely right. The shipping industry is one of the harder to decarbonise areas of the economy. However, technologies such as hydrogen have a big part to play, so this Government are putting a lot of research and development investment behind hydrogen in particular with a view to shipping. We have just announced the Teesside hydrogen hub, the country's first, to help develop more of those technologies, and the hon. Gentleman will not be disappointed by our ambition through our transport decarbonisation plan.
Session: Transport Decarbonisation
View All Questions -->
What recent steps has the Department taken to help facilitate transport decarbonisation in line with commitments to the Paris agreement and COP26?
Context
The question arises from the UK government's commitment to decarbonisation under international agreements and upcoming COP26 discussions.
Grant Shapps
The transport decarbonisation plan will set out transport contributions to net zero, and we continue to work with our international partners ahead of COP26.
Session: Transport Decarbonisation
View All Questions -->
In March, the Secretary of State told the House that he would reach out to the devolved Government to help get more clarity on the organisation and delivery of the shared prosperity fund in Scotland. On this issue, when did he last meet with Scottish Ministers? What specific Scottish Government policy objectives will be met by the shared prosperity fund?
Context
The Secretary of State had promised to meet with Scottish Ministers to help clarify the organisation and delivery of the shared prosperity fund.
Robert Jenrick
I met representatives of the Scottish Government two weeks ago.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I thank the Minister for his response. Any delay in the submarine dismantling programme is of grave concern to my Dunfermline and West Fife constituency, where we accommodate many of these redundant submarines. Can he confirm whether the Government's commitment to endorse the recommendations of the Public Accounts Committee in 2019 still holds?
Context
The MP is concerned about delays in the submarine dismantling programme and its impact on his constituency, particularly regarding a previous Public Accounts Committee recommendation.
Jeremy Quin
I believe I am right in saying that we have now adopted all the recommendations of the PAC report, and we remain committed to continuing to decommission these boats in a safe and swift way. There were, and I have written to the hon. Gentleman, some small delays due to covid, but they were minimal, and we are continuing with the programme and are committed to continuing to do so.
Session: Submarine Dismantling Programme
View All Questions -->
What recent discussions has he had with representatives of the Submarine Delivery Agency and Office for Nuclear Regulation on the progress of the submarine dismantling programme?
Context
The MP is concerned about delays in the submarine dismantling programme and its impact on his constituency.
Jeremy Quin
Ministers have regular discussions with the Submarine Delivery Agency on the progress of the submarine dismantling project and the MOD holds regular discussions with the Office for Nuclear Regulation, which is satisfied with the safety performance at Rosyth dockyard.
Session: Submarine Dismantling Programme
View All Questions -->
What is the Minister's assessment of the damage Brexit will do to the UK's financial sector, and how many own goals can we expect in the future?
Context
Shares worth billions of euros have moved out of London to other European capitals after the EU exit. A trader called this a “stunning own goal” and predicted more such moves.
Greg Hands
The memorandum of understanding on financial services ensures financial stability and consumer protection, and we look forward to that being negotiated. I was not surprised by this question, but I was a little bit surprised that the hon. Gentleman was the one asking it.
Session: Services EU Relationship
View All Questions -->
You most certainly can, Mr Speaker, and thank you. I listened carefully to the right hon. Gentleman's answer, and yes, we are grateful for the vaccine, but I did not hear a response as to why he thinks that Scottish independence has now become the settled will of the Scottish people. This is not like him. He is usually quick to give his views about certain things, so why does he think that Scottish independence has sustained majority support, reaching a height of 58%, and is now the settled will of the Scottish people? Why is that the case?
Context
A poll showed that 58% of Scots would vote for independence, marking the 17th consecutive poll showing majority support. Chapman questioned why this trend is occurring.
Michael Gove
Why will he not engage with the facts? The facts show that, in Scotland, per capita spending including on our shared NHS is greater as a result of the broad shoulders of the UK Treasury. As I pointed out earlier, but as he declined to acknowledge, folk in Scotland are being vaccinated now, thanks to the efforts of the UK Government in a world-leading programme.
Session: Strengthening the Union
View All Questions -->
Today, a poll revealed that 58% of Scots would vote for independence. This is the 17th consecutive poll to show a positive result and we are seeing a rise in support for independence across all age groups. The Cabinet Office can hoist as many Union flags as it wants, but what part of 'We are leaving' does the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster not understand?
Context
A poll showed that 58% of Scots would vote for independence, marking the 17th consecutive poll showing majority support. Chapman highlighted rising support across all age groups.
Michael Gove
Of course, surveys of opinion are always fascinating, but the figures that I am interested in are those which show that the UK Government are spending more per capita in Scotland than they are in other parts of the United Kingdom and that thousands of Scots are now being vaccinated thanks to the efforts of the UK Government. If we look at a map of the world to see which countries are having their citizens vaccinated, Scotland, Northern Ireland, Wales and England are ahead of the pack: stronger together.
Session: Strengthening the Union
View All Questions -->
It was reported last week that the Government are considering reducing our international aid spending from 0.7% to 0.5% of our GNI, despite that being a commitment enshrined in UK law and a firm Conservative manifesto promise. Does the Secretary of State agree that the pandemic landscape has changed things in such a way that this spending is probably needed now more than ever, and the FCDO must build up the resilience of vulnerable and developing countries to tackle current and future pandemics? Is the 0.7% commitment written in stone?
Context
The MP is concerned about potential changes to UK international aid spending from 0.7% of GNI.
Dominic Raab
The hon. Gentleman is right to point to the important work that we do through ODA and on development. The Prime Minister hosted the Gavi summit, working with countries around the world to ensure that there is equitable access to a new vaccine. In relation to the 0.7% commitment and our future ODA spending, I am afraid he will have to wait for the spending review tomorrow.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Around 250,000 businesses export to the EU but not elsewhere. Many of them are small and not VAT-registered, making it hard to reach them. To continue trading post-Brexit, they need to go through a lengthy process to get an economic operator registration and identification number. As the party committed to reducing red tape, what action is being taken by the Government to reduce this burden for SMEs exporting to Europe?
Context
The MP is concerned about the difficulties faced by small businesses, especially those not VAT-registered, in acquiring an economic operator registration and identification number required for exporting to the EU.
Graham Stuart
We are working to engage with businesses, and I recommend that all businesses go to gov.uk/transition for practical steps. However, Scottish businesses are more concerned about Scottish independence than business support, which would shrink Scottish business opportunities.
Session: Business Exports Administrative Burden
View All Questions -->
What are the Chancellor's economic advisers telling him about the Government's preparations for mass unemployment and the sectors that will be worst hit?
Context
With dual threats of Brexit and the pandemic, there is a risk of significant economic downturn leading to high unemployment rates. The question arises from concerns over adequate preparation.
Jesse Norman
The Chancellor has been very clear that because we are in the midst of a pandemic, we are likely to see some redundancies. There is no doubt about the seriousness of the financial and economic situation that we are in. I remind the hon. Gentleman with regard to Scotland that there has been some £7 billion of support for the Scottish Government in dealing with the pandemic and its economic effects, over and above the £21.3 billion provided through the regular Barnett process.
Session: Fiscal Support Covid-19
View All Questions -->
What fiscal support he is providing to mitigate the economic effects of the covid-19 outbreak?
Context
The question arises from the need to mitigate economic impacts of the pandemic. There is a demand for government assistance.
Jesse Norman
The Government have provided an unprecedented package of support for people, businesses and public services throughout the UK, totalling more than £200 billion. That has included helping to pay the wages of 9.6 million people through the job retention scheme and protecting the livelihoods of 2.6 million self-employed workers through the self-employment income support scheme.
Session: Fiscal Support Covid-19
View All Questions -->
What recent steps the Government have taken to support the UK transport sector and its supply chains during the covid-19 outbreak?
Context
The question arises from the need to maintain supply chains and operations within the UK transport sector amidst the ongoing pandemic.
Robert Courts
The Government have undertaken activity across the freight sector to ensure that supply chains are maintained, from vehicle inspections to drivers' hours and the temporary establishment of freight public service obligation contracts.
Session: Transport Supply Chains Covid-19
View All Questions -->
What assessment has he made regarding the impact of a reduction or loss of the P&O Cairnryan to Larne service, and what discussions has he had with P&O and trade unions on safeguarding this vital link between Scotland and Northern Ireland?
Context
The Secretary of State is informed about the potentially devastating job losses at P&O.
Brandon Lewis (Secretary of State for Northern Ireland)
I announced a £17 million package to protect the five ferry routes ensuring connectivity for Northern Ireland with the rest of the UK. I have had conversations with P&O and other ferry operators only in the past few days.
Session: Covid-19 Support for Businesses
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Sentencing Bill 2025-10-21
21 October 2025
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
Proposes amendment to clause 1, page 1, line 14, by replacing 'not more' with 'less', changing the presumption for a suspended sentence order to apply to sentences of less than 12 months instead. This...
Coronation: Policing of Protests
09 May 2023
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Finance Bill - New Clause 6
18 April 2023
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
Ways and Means
21 March 2023
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Chancellor has brought people back into the workforce through the Budget, highlighting the productivity challenge in the UK and addressing it with welfare reforms to support those disengaged from ...
Down’s Syndrome (Access to Services) Bill
26 November 2021
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
The MP Liam Fox, the proponent of the Down's Syndrome (Access to Services) Bill, highlights the significant challenges faced by individuals with Down’s syndrome and their families. He mentions medical...
Army Restructuring: Future Soldier
25 November 2021
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Employment Rights
08 June 2021
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Gaming Hardware (Automated Purchase and Resale)
24 March 2021
General Debate
Led by this MP
Moves to prohibit the automated purchase and resale of games consoles and computer components, highlighting unfairness to consumers caused by scalping through bot attacks. Emphasises the need for legi...
Participation in Debates
16 November 2020
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Covid-19 Update
02 November 2020
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
2
PMQs Asked
28
Ministerial Questions Asked
15
House of Commons Debates Involved
0
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
0
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1457 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
-45% below average
This MP:
2
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
+109% above average
This MP:
28
Average:
13.4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+209% above average
This MP:
15
Average:
4.9
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-100% below average
This MP:
0.0
Average:
69.2
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Douglas Chapman's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.