Caroline Lucas
MP for Brighton, Pavilion
Green
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Response classifications show how directly each question was answered.
Untreated sewage was pumped into English waterways for more than 3.6 million hours last year and into the sea off Sussex beaches three times in the last 24 hours. Since privatisation, water companies have racked up £64 billion in debts while shareholders received £78 billion in dividends. The majority of public want to end this legalised scam of privatisation. When is the Prime Minister going to listen and bring water back into public hands?
Context
Untreated sewage was pumped into English waterways for over 3.6 million hours last year, with three incidents off Sussex beaches in the past day alone.
Rishi Sunak
Our plans tackle sewage issues further than previous Governments. We monitor 100% of overflows, invest £56 billion into infrastructure, and enforce strict targets with unlimited fines for companies, holding them accountable.
Assessment
Specific ask about when PM will listen to public demand against privatisation
Emphasises Conservative'S Record
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
In February, the Foreign Secretary said that it would be difficult for a ground offensive on Rafah to avoid harming civilians and destroying homes, and just yesterday, the Deputy Foreign Secretary admitted that he was struggling to see how such an attack could be compliant with international humanitarian law. All the signs are that Netanyahu is about to defy the international community, and that an attack on the 1.5 million Palestinians sheltering in Rafah is imminent. If that attack begins, will that be the moment when the Prime Minister finally finds the moral backbone to ban arms exports to Israel, and if not, how much more suffering has to happen before he acts to prevent further UK complicity in crimes against humanity?
Context
The MP cited the Deputy Foreign Secretary's admission that an attack on Palestinians could violate international humanitarian law, questioning when arms exports would be banned.
Rishi Sunak
What the hon. Lady did not acknowledge at all is that Israel suffered an appalling terrorist attack that killed hundreds of its citizens, and it does have the right to defend itself. Of course, as I have been crystal clear, we want to see humanitarian law respected and adhered to by all parties. Too many civilians have been killed, and we want to see Israel take greater care to avoid harming civilians. I have made these points repeatedly to Prime Minister Netanyahu, specifically about the impact of any military incursion into Rafah, and we continue to say to the Israelis at all levels that we want to see more aid going in, and bring about a hostage deal so that we can move towards a sustainable ceasefire.
Assessment
The PM did not commit to banning arms exports if an attack begins.
Israel Has The Right To Defend Itself
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Until the UK Government calls for an immediate ceasefire, it is complicit in the horrors…in Gaza. Those are not my words but those of the head of Oxfam who, like every single agency trying to operate on the ground, is clear that aid cannot be effectively delivered while fighting continues.
Context
Oxfam head criticised the UK government's failure to call for a ceasefire, stating that aid cannot be effectively delivered without it. 24,000 people have already been killed.
Rishi Sunak
Of course we want to see a peaceful resolution to this conflict as soon as possible. A sustainable permanent ceasefire with an end to the destruction, fighting and loss of life, the release of hostages and no resumption of hostilities would of course be the best way forward, but in order to achieve that a number of things need to happen: Hamas would have to agree to release all the hostages; Hamas would have to no longer be in charge of Gaza; the threat of more rocket attacks from Hamas into Israel would have to end; and the Palestinian Authority, boosted with assistance, would need to return to Gaza in order to provide governance and aid.
Assessment
Did not specify any concrete steps or timeline for achieving a ceasefire
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
It is exactly a year to the day since UK temperatures hit a deadly 40°C for the first time, with 3,000 excess deaths last summer. Yet businesses and the Prime Minister's own climate advisers have said that his climate progress is worryingly slow. He likes to claim that the UK is decarbonising more quickly than the rest of the G7, but since the Paris agreement that is simply not true. He also likes to claim that it is not a top concern for the public, while recent polling shows that that is not true either. Experts, businesses and the public all want bolder climate action, but it is not even one of his top five priorities. Can he tell us why not?
Context
A year after UK temperatures hit a record-breaking 40°C, causing 3,000 excess deaths. Businesses and climate advisers have criticised the slow progress on decarbonisation.
Rishi Sunak
The hon. Lady just makes a completely bizarre point. Because we moved quicker and faster than everyone else, she thinks that somehow that is something we should now not be proud of. It is right that other countries are catching up; it is inevitable that they will have to decarbonise faster now to make up for the fact that over the past two decades they have not followed our example. I am not going to take any lectures from her on this topic, because our track record is a good one.
Assessment
The specific ask about why bold climate action should be prioritised was not addressed
I Am Not Going To Take Lectures
Our Track Record Is Good
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I referenced the PM's statement that his daughter is a climate change advocate in their household. The Rosebank oil field development would release more emissions than 28 of the world's poorest countries combined and costs taxpayers £4 billion to transfer funds to a Norwegian company. It does not contribute to energy security as most of the oil will be exported. Will he give this project approval if it undermines climate goals?
Context
The Prime Minister's daughter has been described as a climate champion, but the Rosebank oilfield project would reportedly blow climate targets and have severe environmental impacts.
Rishi Sunak
As acknowledged by the independent Climate Change Committee, we will need fossil fuels for several more decades during our transition to a greener future. It makes no sense not to invest in home-grown resources that can create jobs here instead of importing foreign fossil fuels with higher carbon emissions. This is an economically illiterate policy—expected from the Green Party.
Assessment
Did not directly address whether Rosebank will be approved or not
Criticised The Questioner'S Party
Shifted Focus To Economic Arguments
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
I am concerned about this Government's vile and immoral refugee ban Bill and the toxic language coming from the Home Office which are not even dog-whistle politics but a giant hard-right foghorn, blasting out a poisonous “them and us” narrative. The Government plumbed new depths last week when the Minister for Immigration claimed that people trying to come to the UK tend to have completely different values. Can the Prime Minister explain what he thinks is so different about the values held by the people of war-torn Sudan?
Context
The government's refugee ban Bill and Home Office statements have been criticised for their language. The Minister for Immigration made controversial remarks about the values of people from Sudan.
Rishi Sunak (Prime Minister)
This country has a proud history of welcoming almost half a million refugees over the past several years, and we will always continue to do so. However, our ability to help is hampered by tens of thousands of people illegally crossing the channel every year. We must break the cycle of criminal gangs and target resources on those who most need them.
Assessment
Creation of a Sudanese family visa scheme
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Ella Roberta's tragic death highlighted the impact of poor air quality. Yesterday, the environmental improvement plan pledged to improve air quality but not fast enough according to Ella's mother. Will the Prime Minister meet us both to discuss the proposed 'Ella's law' Bill?
Context
Ella Roberta was the first person to have air pollution listed on their death certificate, and her case highlights the need for urgent action. The Government's target of 2040 is seen as too slow by campaigners.
Rishi Sunak
It is very sad to hear about Ella Roberta's death. My right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs will make a statement later today on legislation. We are confident that measures we are putting in place will be world leading.
Assessment
Meeting request not addressed
Will Make A Statement Later
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Given the predecessor's damaging actions towards nature, millions of people from conservation organisations are demanding action. Will you reverse her decision to allow fracking, which is known to be unsafe, and uphold the 2019 manifesto commitment to maintain the moratorium?
Context
The previous Prime Minister's actions regarding fracking have raised significant concerns among environmental groups. The Conservative manifesto included a pledge to maintain the moratorium on fracking.
Rishi Sunak
I stand by the manifesto on that issue. This Government passed the Environment Act 2021, which provides substantial protection for the natural environment with a clear plan to deliver it.
Assessment
The specific ask about reversing fracking approval was not addressed.
Highlighting Other Achievements
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
With a backlog of 23,000 ARAP applications and only two processed since April, can I send casework for people from Chevening Alumni to the PM? Will he put more resources into the scheme? Will he lift the cap on the Afghan citizens resettlement scheme?
Context
There is a backlog of 23,000 applications under the Afghan relocations and assistance policy, with just two out of 3,000 having been processed since April. Staff working on the scheme have been slashed by a quarter.
Boris Johnson
The country is doing a generous welcome for people from Syria, Afghanistan, Ukraine, and Hong Kong. The PM will look at the cases but does not specify lifting the cap on the Afghan citizens resettlement scheme.
Assessment
Lifting the cap on the Afghan citizens resettlement scheme
Changed Subject To Broader Welcome
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Fifty-six Members of this House are under investigation for sexual misconduct, and that includes three members of the Prime Minister's Cabinet. He has just rightly said that there can be no place for sexism and misogyny in the House. Can he now confirm that he considers sexual harassment—unlike, apparently, bullying and lying—to be grounds for dismissal under the ministerial code?
Context
There are currently 56 Members of the House under investigation for sexual misconduct, including three Cabinet members.
Boris Johnson
Of course sexual harassment is intolerable, and it is quite right that Members should now have a procedure whereby they can bring it to the attention of the House authorities. I think that that is a good thing, and of course sexual harassment is grounds for dismissal.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Yesterday when I asked about Russian election interference, the PM looked shifty and said he was unaware. Yet in 2017 as Foreign Secretary, he corrected Lavrov by saying there was no 'successful' interference but evidence of 'unsuccessful'. Can the PM tell us what evidence he has seen of unsuccessful interference? Given his Defence Sec's statement that info is powerful like a tank, why turn a blind eye to Russian disruption?
Context
A report claims credible evidence of Russian interference in UK elections, contradicting the PM's previous statement.
Boris Johnson
I repeat what I told the hon. Lady: no evidence has been seen by me of successful Russian interference in any UK election event.
Assessment
Specific evidence of unsuccessful interference and explanation for ignoring credible reports were not provided
Repeating A Previous Statement
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Will he cancel those projects, and does he recognise that if he does not, he will need to ask forgiveness for losing the future of our children?
Context
COP26 showed the potential to end reliance on fossil fuels. However, the Government is pressing ahead with numerous oil and gas developments.
Boris Johnson (Prime Minister)
Not only are we powering past coal towards the ending of fossil fuel reliance in our energy generation by 2024, but what we have also done is stop the financing of overseas hydrocarbons.
Assessment
The PM did not directly address cancelling domestic projects.
Highlighted Different Actions
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Committee report calls for transformational change; 15% of UK species threatened with extinction, ebbing away of natural world. Will the Prime Minister look at Government amendment to Environment Bill that refers only to measures 'to further' rather than meeting biodiversity loss objective? One-word change from 'furthering' to 'meeting' would introduce legally binding target to halt biodiversity loss by 2030.
Context
Environmental Audit Committee's report calls for transformational change in Government approach to restoring nature. Current policy lacks teeth.
Boris Johnson
This Government are committed not just to halting, but reversing biodiversity loss around world. Can see this from conclusions of G7 summit and actions promoting biodiversity.
Assessment
Did not address one-word change or legally binding target introduction
Under Review
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The creation of a no-protest zone around Parliament, a 266% increase from a maximum of three months to 11 months' imprisonment for protest organisers, a direct attack on the Gypsy, Roma and Traveller community, up to 10 years in prison for any offence committed by destroying or damaging a memorial, and criminalising people for taking part in protests where they ought to have known police conditions were in place. Does the Prime Minister agree that if the UK is to be a force for good in a world where democracy is “in retreat”, as the Foreign Secretary is saying today, it needs to start at home with the protection of the long-standing, precious and fundamental right to peaceful protest, which is a cornerstone of liberal democracy?
Context
The proposed Police, Crime, Sentencing and Courts Bill has raised concerns about limiting protest rights. The questioner argues that protecting peaceful protest is essential for democratic values.
Boris Johnson
The hon. Lady is quite right to stick up for peaceful protest, and I understand and sympathise with that, but there are a couple of points. First, we are facing a pandemic in which, alas, we have to restrict human contact—[Interruption.] Although the hon. Lady shakes her head, I think the people of this country do understand that and do understand the restrictions we are now under. I think we also have to strike a balance between the need to allow peaceful protests to go ahead, and we do on a huge scale in this country, and the need to protect free speech and vital parts of the UK economy.
Assessment
Did not commit to fully protecting protest rights or addressing specific concerns raised by the Bill.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
There is a yawning gulf between the Government's green rhetoric and their action. Hot on the heels of sanctioning the first deep coalmine in 30 years, Ministers have broken yet another election manifesto promise and will keep sending plastic waste to developing countries, where they are regularly dumped or burnt. Nine-year-old schoolgirl Lizzie knows that this is wrong, and she has a simple message for the Prime Minister: protect our oceans and people living in poorer countries by banning these dirty plastic exports now. Will he listen to Lizzie and to the 90,000 signatories to her petition and stop this damaging and unethical practice—yes or no?
Context
The UK Government broke their election manifesto promise to ban the export of plastic waste to developing countries, causing environmental damage and health risks.
Boris Johnson
First of all, I must absolutely contest and deny what the hon. Member has said about action. She talks about coalmines, and she may not know that in 1970—I was alive; she may not have been alive—this country got 90% of its energy from fossil fuels, from coal, and we now get 5%. That is thanks to the green, active, technologically optimistic policies driven by Conservative Governments.
Assessment
Questioner's request for a ban on plastic waste exports was not addressed. PM discussed historical energy statistics instead.
Changed Subject
Historical Comparison
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Last week, we learned that UK Export Finance has been approached to back the east African crude oil pipeline. This is a climate catastrophe that will produce emissions equivalent to all the UK's annual flights. Not only that, but a recent response to one of my written parliamentary questions confirmed that UKEF has six more fossil fuel projects under consideration. Ahead of the climate ambition summit this weekend, how can the Prime Minister claim any climate credibility while ploughing public money into dirty fossil fuel projects overseas?
Context
Recent information indicates UK Export Finance is considering backing a significant crude oil pipeline project in East Africa, which would have massive climate impacts. This follows a previous inquiry by the MP about similar issues.
Boris Johnson
I hope the hon. Lady knows that we are moving away dramatically and at speed from UK Export Finance supporting fossil fuel exploration around the world, but, of course, hydrocarbons remain a significant industry in Scotland and many other places.
Assessment
no clear commitment to change policy
Moving Away Dramatically Statement
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Concerns are growing about illegal crossings across the channel. To deter these dangerous journeys, save lives and protect borders, will my right hon. Friend assure constituents that a comprehensive Bill dealing with this problem will be brought before the House following the next Queen's Speech?
Context
There is concern about rising illegal crossings of the English Channel, leading to dangerous journeys and border protection issues.
Boris Johnson
The legal position is currently difficult due to the Dublin regulation. People think there is an easy way in, leading to dangerous journeys. Once out of the EU, we will make our own return arrangements and settle laws on this matter.
Assessment
Did not commit to bringing a comprehensive Bill before the House following the next Queen's Speech without further details or timeline.
Discussed Broader Issues
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Last week, climate experts reported that green economic recovery packages deliver far higher returns than conventional stimulus spending. They also warned that how we emerge from this coronavirus crisis must not be in a way that deepens the climate and nature emergencies. Does the Prime Minister agree? Will he commit to action that will help us to build back better, and start by confirming that any airline queuing up for a taxpayer handout must be required to meet robust climate goals?
Context
Lucas discusses the economic recovery and its impact on climate change, asking if the PM agrees that airlines should meet robust climate goals to receive taxpayer handouts.
The Prime Minister (Boris Johnson)
I think the best and shortest answer I can give to the hon. Lady is that we totally understand the situation with aviation. Clearly, inadvertently this year the planet will greatly reduce its carbon dioxide emissions, and she is absolutely right that we need to entrench those gains. I do not want to see us going back to an era of the same type of emissions as we have had in the past. Aviation, like every other sector, must keep its carbon lower. We are certainly working on technological solutions to ensure that we can do that.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Given a recent judgment against Heathrow expansion, will the PM provide details on how many other national policy statements have been reviewed for compliance with the Paris climate agreement?
Context
A court ruling found that the Government's decision to proceed with Heathrow Airport expansion violated UK law by not considering the Paris Agreement.
The Prime Minister Boris Johnson
We will abide by the judgment and consider the Paris convention on climate change. However, this should not hinder our infrastructure development across the country.
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
The Prime Minister talks of avoiding hypocrisy but does he agree that we should also avoid ploughing taxpayers' money into overseas fossil fuel projects? Will he join me in agreeing no UK money should go into fossil fuels from the end of 2021?
Context
UK-Africa investment summit announced £2 billion for oil and gas projects.
Boris Johnson
We have doubled spending on tackling climate change, to £11.6 billion. No further penny will go into digging coal and we will do everything to help reduce CO2 emissions.
Assessment
Specific commitment to stop funding fossil fuels by the end of 2021
Doubled Spending
No Penny For Coal
Session: PMQs
View Full Session -->
Will the Secretary of State revise the Government's carbon budget delivery plan to embrace demand reduction measures?
Context
The Climate Change Committee criticized the government's narrow approach to solutions and urged a revision of the carbon budget delivery plan.
Claire Coutinho
We have made remarkable progress in renewable energy, which is why we overshot our first, second, and third carbon budgets. We are on track to overshoot our fourth.
Session: Net Zero Target
View All Questions -->
I welcome the Minister to his post, but he will know that most of our gas imports are not LNG and that they actually come via a pipeline from Norway, where gas production is half as polluting as it is in the UK. New oil and gas would not only be disastrous for our climate; it would also fail to boost energy security. Following the welcome announcement that the UK will finally withdraw from the energy charter treaty, will the Government also reverse their decision to license the Rosebank oil field, which will cost the climate and the public purse extremely dear?
Context
The MP welcomes the Minister to his post but raises concerns about licensing new oil fields like Rosebank, arguing it would be detrimental to both climate goals and public finances.
Justin Tomlinson
I thank the hon. Member for her kind comments. While we scale up our clean energy success, including in renewables, which have gone from 7% to 40%, there is still a need for oil and gas. A failure to issue a new licence would make no difference to the consumption of oil and gas, but it would increase imports, which typically have higher emissions, and also damage our economy.
Session: LNG Emissions Impact of Oil and Gas Licences
View All Questions -->
A new report from the Green Finance Institute and the IPPR notes that a lack of public investment and strategy is holding back progress on unlocking private investment, and that the chopping and changing of policy pathways has damaged investor confidence. The Secretary of State likes to say that she has a clear strategy, so will she tell investors what it is? Will she call on the Chancellor to deliver the scale of public investment we urgently need to restore investor confidence and lift the UK off the bottom of the G7 league table for private investment?
Context
A report notes that a lack of public investment and policy stability is hindering private sector investment in green technologies.
Claire Coutinho
The UK was the first in the G20 to halve emissions since 1990, with £60 billion of low-carbon private and public investment in 2023. The UK attracts investment through schemes like contracts for difference, capital allowances reforms, and the green industries growth accelerator.
Session: Green Technologies Private Investment
View All Questions -->
Last week, the IMF urged the Chancellor to prioritise public spending and investment rather than tax cuts. Will he deliver the level of public investment this country needs, including in a nationwide energy efficiency programme that would shield households from high gas prices, create jobs, and get fuel bills down for the long term? Or is he too scared of green investment?
Context
The International Monetary Fund urged the Chancellor to prioritise public spending and investment over tax cuts. The UK has not yet delivered on promised green investments.
Jeremy Hunt
I cannot discuss the Budget ahead of time. However, I celebrate that the UK recently decarbonised by more than 50%, exceeding France, Germany, Japan and the United States.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Are the Government scared of having their record scrutinised or determined to destroy any last shred of the UK's climate leadership? Will the Minister tell us now when selection will be announced?
Context
18 months on from Lord Deben's resignation, no replacement has been announced despite several applications and interviews.
Graham Stuart
The appointment of the Climate Change Committee's chair is not just a matter for the UK Government. It has to be agreed by devolved Administrations as well, and we are moving as quickly as we can.
Session: Net Zero Targets Businesses
View All Questions -->
It now seems clear that the funds that the Government plan to commit to loss and damage at COP28 will come from the UK's existing climate finance commitments. We cannot tackle the climate crisis by robbing Peter to pay Paul. Given that a properly resourced and operational loss and damage finance fund has to be a litmus test of success, will the Minister commit to looking at new and additional forms of funding, including a permanent windfall tax on fossil fuel companies and a tax on high-emission travel, to deliver new finance and make polluters pay?
Context
The Government plan to commit funds for loss and damage from existing climate finance commitments.
Graham Stuart
The hon. Lady is right to highlight loss and damage as we approach COP28. We were pleased to play our part on the transitional committee in getting a recommendation to COP, and we look forward to its being operationalised in the near future. I agree with her that, if we are to get the scale of finance that is required, particularly for the most vulnerable countries at the front end, we need to look at innovative ways of adding to that finance.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
The Minister has not really given any reassurance to the hon. Member for Blackpool North and Cleveleys (Paul Maynard). As we know, methane is a whopping 80 times more powerful than carbon dioxide over a 20-year period, so if the Minister is serious about tackling this issue, will he explain why the Government failed to use the Energy Bill to ban flaring and venting? Why did they whip their own MPs to vote against an amendment that would have outlawed it, and given that the practice has been illegal in Norway since the 1970s, will he finally recognise that this makes a mockery of Ministers' claims about UK oil and gas being greener?
Context
The question addresses the failure of the Government to use the Energy Bill to ban flaring and venting, highlighting the inconsistency with Norway's policy.
Graham Stuart
Unusually, the hon. Lady has got her facts wrong: I do not think that amendment was even selected for debate that day. According to the North Sea Transition Authority, flaring was reduced by more than 10% just last year, contributing to a reduction of nearly 50% between 2018 and 2022. As I have said, the North Sea Transition Authority estimates that methane emissions have fallen by more than 40% to fewer than 1 million tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent—a record low.
Session: Methane Leaks from Oil and Gas Production
View All Questions -->
Will the Chancellor consider introducing a windfall tax on banks' excess profits, given their significant increase and the Bank of England's expected payouts?
Context
Banks' profits have surged by 700%, yet the Bank of England is forecast to pay out billions in interest while the surcharge on bank profits has been reduced.
Andrew Griffith
With millions of jobs dependent on financial services, I hope the hon. Lady will join me in celebrating a sustainably profitable sector.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Could the Minister explain when the £11.6 billion will be delivered in full, broken down by each year? Could he also explain how the commitment will be met and assure us that it will not be by raiding the aid budget?
Context
Concerns exist that the UK may be reneging on its climate finance commitments, with cross-party MPs and peers writing to the Prime Minister about this issue.
Andrew Mitchell
The allocations for aid for next year are nearly double what they were this year. We have a commitment to greater transparency and I expect to be able to publish in full how we will reach the £11.6 billion, probably in September.
Session: Climate Finance Commitments
View All Questions -->
What recent steps has the Department taken to help meet the UK's international climate finance commitments?
Context
The question arises from speculation and concerns in the national media about the UK reneging on its climate finance commitments.
Andrew Mitchell
As the Prime Minister set out at COP27, we are committed to spending £11.6 billion on international climate finance over the timeframe originally envisaged.
Session: Climate Finance Commitments
View All Questions -->
A recent report shows that imports of gas will continue to rise significantly unless we tackle demand. New oil and gas licences simply will not deliver energy security as they cost taxpayers while being a disaster for climate change. Will the Government rule out new licences and commit instead to measures like home insulation, unblocking onshore wind, and solar installation?
Context
The MP questions the effectiveness of expanding domestic oil and gas production in ensuring UK's energy security.
Grant Shapps
From 14% of homes insulated under the previous Government to nearly 50% this year. An energy taskforce is set up to reduce usage and make it more efficient. However, the policy of importing all oil and gas without providing new licences is insane, putting Britain at risk of tyrants like Putin and doubling carbon use.
Session: Energy Security Gas Imports from Russia
View All Questions -->
Even nuclear fusion's most ardent advocates admit that it will be decades before an operational power station is built. At the same time, I remind the Secretary of State that his own Government's target for decarbonising the power sector is 2035, so nuclear fusion will be no help in meeting that target. Instead of wasting taxpayers' money on yet another nuclear white elephant, why will the Secretary of State not fully harness the things that we know will work, which means an energy system based on renewables backed up with interconnectors, batteries and storage, unblocking onshore wind and unleashing a rooftop solar revolution? Why is he not doing that, which will make the transition much quicker and much cheaper?
Context
The MP questions the feasibility of relying on nuclear fusion for meeting decarbonization targets by 2035, advocating for renewables instead.
Grant Shapps
Well, Mr Speaker, we are! When we came to power in 2010, just 7% of our electricity was coming from renewables. Right now, if I look at renewables plus nuclear—I know the hon. Lady does not like to look at nuclear—that figure was 57% in the last year.
Session: Nuclear Fusion Energy Provision
View All Questions -->
One of the most effective and long-term ways of getting people's energy bills down would be to invest in a comprehensive, street-by-street home insulation programme, which this Government are still failing to do. Research by the Energy and Climate Intelligence Unit shows that delays to legislating for minimum energy efficiency standards for the private rented sector could cost renters in the leakiest homes an additional £1 billion in higher bills, so with the Energy Bill making its way through the Commons later this year, will the Minister finally end the delay and ensure that those proposals, which the Government first started consulting about three years ago, are legislated for in that Bill?
Context
The MP questioned the delays in legislating for minimum energy efficiency standards and proposed a comprehensive home insulation programme to reduce energy bills.
Grant Shapps
Sometimes, we speak in this House as if we have not actually greened up any of our Victorian housing stock. In fact, back in 2010, only about 14% of houses in this country had A to C on their energy performance certificate; today, that figure is 47%. This year, we will have over half of our homes greened up. We are putting £12.5 billion-plus into it. So we are making rapid progress, which is sometimes not entirely reflected by Opposition parties.
Session: Energy Price Guarantee Extension
View All Questions -->
Saving historic footpaths is a vital way of enhancing engagement with nature. Given there are more than 4,000 pending applications, it is concerning that the government has reneged on their promise to scrap deadlines without a plan for this backlog. Will they rethink this decision?
Context
The MP is concerned about the government's decision to extend deadlines for saving historic footpaths, which has created a backlog of over 4,000 applications.
Trudy Harrison
The deadline was extended from 2026 to 2031. The government is improving access with Natural England, committing people to be within 15 minutes of a blue or green area, enhancing national trails, and designating the coast-to-coast route as a national trail. Additionally, the England coastal path spans 2,700 miles around England, offering extensive public access.
Session: Public Access to Nature
View All Questions -->
What steps she is taking to improve public access to nature?
Context
The MP is concerned about the steps being taken by the government to improve public access to natural spaces.
Trudy Harrison
Connectivity to rural areas is vitally important. The government is spending millions to ensure that rural areas thrive and people have access to nature.
Session: Public Access to Nature
View All Questions -->
I welcome the Minister's enthusiasm for solar and the progress that has been made so far. According to Solar Energy UK, the rate at which solar panels are being put on to domestic roofs is still only half of what is needed to meet the Government's own targets. I know that he wants to do much better, so is it not time to pick up the pace and give us a real rooftop revolution by making solar panels mandatory on all suitable new homes? Will he do that?
Context
The question is based on the need for faster progress towards renewable energy targets.
Graham Stuart
More than a million homes now have solar panels installed. According to data from the microgeneration certification scheme, a total of 130,596 solar panels were installed on UK rooftops last year alone, and that is more than 2019, 2020 and 2021 put together, but like the hon. Lady I want to see us go further and faster.
Session: Solar Power
View All Questions -->
What assessment has been made of the potential contribution of solar power to UK energy security and the 2050 net zero target?
Context
The question arises from the need for renewable energy sources to meet the government's targets.
Graham Stuart
Solar is a cheap and versatile technology. It is a key part of the Government's strategy for net zero and I share the hon. Lady's enthusiasm for it. We are aiming for up to 70 GW of installed solar capacity by 2035, and that represents a fivefold increase in our current capacity.
Session: Solar Power
View All Questions -->
With oil and gas companies making grotesque profits from high global prices, it is beyond belief that the Chancellor does not scrap the so-called investment allowance announced in the autumn statement. Will he now come clean about the cost to the taxpayer of this subsidy?
Context
Oil and gas companies are making high profits from global prices, but still receive investment allowance.
James Cartlidge
I am happy to confirm that the levy will raise £40 billion. A key purpose is to help fund support for businesses and constituents, with higher cost of living payments for vulnerable people on benefits.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
The best part of our asylum system is the safe route for Afghans who helped British forces. These people are often full of professional skills and speak good English. Will my right hon. Friend give a report on progress in getting more Afghan citizens out of hotels, so they can contribute to society?
Context
The asylum system's safe route created for Afghans who supported allied forces, and the need to move them on with their lives.
Suella Braverman
We support those who came through designated schemes such as the Afghan relocations and assistance policy. Far too many are accommodated in hotels, but we are working with the Ministry of Defence on all options, including service family accommodation, to properly accommodate Afghans so they can settle peacefully here.
Session: Asylum System
View All Questions -->
I am concerned about the Home Office placing vulnerable, unaccompanied asylum-seeking children in hotels in local authority areas. The Home Office is directly commissioning these hotels because it knows that local authorities do not have the funding or capacity required. Will the Home Secretary finally admit that these vulnerable children are legally the Home Office's responsibility so they are not left in legal limbo? Will she ensure her Department takes a strategic approach to address placement shortages, rather than its current ad hoc approach, and will she ensure police keep searching for those who have gone missing?
Context
The Home Office's handling of unaccompanied asylum-seeking children in hotels and the need for a strategic approach to address placement shortages.
Suella Braverman
We take seriously the position of unaccompanied asylum-seeking children. We will look at funding arrangements for local authorities to support these children, so their needs are properly met.
Session: Asylum System
View All Questions -->
The Foreign Secretary says he is working quickly, yet no Afghans have been resettled under the ACRS. With only 400 places offered out of more than 11,000 applicants and a target to help 20,000 people over five years, will the Government urgently supercharge the scheme, increase staff numbers, and allow those in danger to come now?
Context
The MP raised concerns about delays and inefficiencies in the UK's Afghan resettlement scheme, pointing out that zero Afghans have been resettled under the ACRS. She highlighted specific cases of individuals living in fear for over 16 months.
James Cleverly
I have to correct the hon. Lady. She says that we have not made any resettlements under the ACRS. As I said in my answer, we have granted indefinite leave to remain to 6,300 eligible people. We are working on pathway 3 which will help only 400 applicants and their families.
Session: Afghan Citizens Resettlement Scheme
View All Questions -->
In a letter to the Chancellor last week, Lord Deben said clearly that demand reduction is “now the biggest gap” in UK energy policy. Will Thursday's autumn statement include an emergency investment of at least £3.6 billion over the course of this Parliament, so we can finally roll out the long-awaited and very overdue home insulation programme that this country needs?
Context
Lord Deben, chair of the Climate Change Committee, highlighted demand reduction as a critical gap in UK energy policy.
Jeremy Hunt
Lord Deben speaks extremely wisely on environmental and climate change issues, and we would always take what he says with the utmost seriousness.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I welcome the Minister back to his place. Today will be the third day that Alaa Abdel Fattah—a pro-democracy activist and British citizen—has not consumed any water. The Minister will know that he has been in prison in Egypt for nine years and that he has been on hunger strike for more than 200 days. With the eyes of the world on COP27, will the Government not allow Egypt to get away with using the summit to paper over human rights atrocities and that every UK channel is being used to secure Alaa's release? And will he make really clear the consequences if Egypt were to allow Alaa to die in prison?
Context
The MP discusses Alaa Abdel Fattah, a pro-democracy activist and British citizen who has been on hunger strike for over 200 days.
Andrew Mitchell
I thank the hon. Lady for her kind remarks, her question and her concern. That matter was raised specifically by the Prime Minister at Cabinet this morning. He spoke to the Egyptian authorities and I have no doubt that the arguments that she put were strenuously emphasised by the Prime Minister in those discussions.
Session: Human Rights
View All Questions -->
Tens of thousands of migrants crossing the English channel in small boats is a potential security risk, increasingly unsustainable in terms of accommodation and housing, and costing the taxpayer ever growing sums. May I seek an assurance that my right hon. Friend the Home Secretary's Department will work with the Ministry of Defence on a push-back policy, to be implemented as soon as possible, and continue to pursue the Rwanda processing plan?
Context
There is a concern over tens of thousands of migrants crossing the English channel in small boats, which Henry Smith sees as a potential security risk, unsustainable in terms of accommodation and housing, and costly to taxpayers.
Simon Baynes
The rise in dangerous channel crossings is unacceptable, as my hon. Friend has said. Indeed, there is a push-back policy in place. Not only are these crossings an overt abuse of our immigration laws, but they risk the lives of vulnerable people who are being exploited by ruthless criminal gangs. Our new Nationality and Borders Act 2022 is breaking the business model of these evil criminals. We have introduced tougher sentences for those who facilitate illegal entry into the country, with 38 people already arrested and facing further action since the Act became law.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
I am concerned that the Government are planning to remove refugees to Rwanda who sought sanctuary in the UK from torture and trafficking. This is a new and despicable low even from this Home Office. Can you confirm whether you have read the medical analysis from the charity Medical Justice, and will you find some moral backbone, immediately release from indefinite immigration detention all those targeted with removal to Rwanda and finally abandon this shameful policy?
Context
Caroline Lucas is concerned about the Home Office's actions regarding refugee policies and police funding.
Priti Patel (Home Secretary)
Absolutely not because the immoral aspect is the role of people smugglers and the criminal trade that facilitates people smuggling. Not only is the migration and economic development partnership the first of its kind, but it is being looked at by other countries around the world. Our processes are not only legitimate but show that a deterrent factor can be achieved through this policy. It is absolutely right that we ensure that people are detained on the basis that they will be removed to Rwanda at the soonest possible opportunity.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
Considering Ukraine's crippling national debt of $94 billion in 2020, can you discuss any conversations with other Governments and international bodies about cancelling this debt?
Context
The question arises from the need to address Ukraine's significant national debt, which could hinder its ability to respond to Russian aggression.
Elizabeth Truss
The Chancellor has discussed debt cancellation with G7 Finance Ministers. We support Ukraine financially to resist Russian aggression and rebuild post-invasion.
Session: Support for Ukraine
View All Questions -->
I thank the Minister for her answer, but she will know that the UK has one of the most lax tax regimes in the world for the oil and gas sector. In 2019, companies got away with paying 12.5 times less tax for a barrel of oil produced here compared with in Norway. In 2020, Shell paid absolutely no tax in the UK, the only country where this was the case. For 2021, HMRC expects that the industry will pocket £910 million-worth of tax reliefs for decommissioning. Given our commitments under the Glasgow climate pact and the current situation of record profits for oil and gas companies versus household struggles with a real cost of living crisis, will the Minister address this imbalance and commit to reviewing the tax regime?
Context
Concerns over tax exemptions and lower tax rates for the UK oil and gas industry compared to other countries, such as Norway. The oil and gas industry is currently making near-record profits while households face a real cost of living crisis.
Lucy Frazer
The hon. Member will know that the oil and gas sector does pay significant taxes. Indeed, it pays additional taxes, and to date it has paid more than £375 billion in production taxes.
Session: Glasgow Climate Pact Fossil Fuel Taxation
View All Questions -->
What assessment he has made of the compatibility of his policies on the taxation of fossil fuels with the Glasgow climate pact. The Government's carbon pricing policies, including through the UK emissions trading scheme, have reduced carbon emissions, but there are concerns about the lax tax regime for oil and gas companies compared to international standards.
Context
The question arises from concerns about the compatibility of government policies on taxing fossil fuel companies with international climate commitments.
Lucy Frazer
I am pleased to underline the Government's commitment to reducing carbon emissions through taxation and the UK's success in limiting global emissions at COP26. The Government have reduced carbon emissions through their carbon pricing policies, including through the UK emissions trading scheme. We are committed to delivering on our carbon targets, and our net zero strategy sets out a roadmap for reaching net zero by 2050.
Session: Glasgow Climate Pact Fossil Fuel Taxation
View All Questions -->
The Government's recent decision to authorise a neonic, bee-destroying pesticide runs contrary to the advice of both the Health and Safety Executive and the Government's expert committee on pesticides. How on earth is this decision compatible with the Government's legal requirement to halt species loss by 2030, and will the Secretary of State look again at this particular decision?
Context
Government authorised a neonicotinoid pesticide despite advice from the Health and Safety Executive and the Government's expert committee against it.
George Eustice
I addressed this issue earlier. The chief scientist gave some analysis, along with others. We took a decision firmly based on the science. Twelve other EU countries have done so, too.
Session: Topical Questions
View All Questions -->
At the weekend, a young activist called Fatima challenged the Chancellor, asking why the Treasury is blocking action on the climate crisis. He replied that the Treasury has committed £12 billion of new money to the 10-point plan, but even that is not true, as he knows, and the President of COP26 has said that actually only a paltry £4 billion is new money. When will the Treasury start committing serious money to the green transition, in the region of the £85 billion that the TUC has said is necessary to put into green investment so that we go into COP26 as climate leaders, not climate laggards?
Context
An activist questioned why the Treasury is blocking serious action on climate change, pointing out that only £4 billion of new money has been committed to green transition compared to a need of £85 billion.
Kemi Badenoch
I will tell the hon. Lady what the Treasury is doing. We are issuing £15 billion of green bonds over the next year, and launching a world-first green savings bond ahead of COP26 to help finance the Government's green projects. We set up the UK Infrastructure Bank to invest in net zero, backed by £12 billion of capital, which will also help to unlock more than £40 billion of overall investment in infrastructure. We are committing £11.6 billion in international climate finance over the next five years to help developing countries tackle climate change. The Budget also announced three UK-wide competitions that are part of the £1 billion net zero innovation portfolio. We have the towns deal, which is helping people create new green spaces, build back greener, create sustainable transport routes and repurpose empty shops. The fact is that the Treasury is doing everything it can to support the transition to net zero.
Session: Net Zero Emissions and Green Investment
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Biodiversity Loss
15 May 2024
Responding: Rebecca Pow
Main Concerns
["Raw sewage continues to pour into waterways for over 4 million hours last year. Neonicotinoids, a harmful pesticide, have been repeatedly approved under emergency measures. The Government is considering backtracking on a peat ban. 'State of Nature' report highlights that the UK has lost nearly 20% of species abundance since the speaker's lifetime began. The natural world is falling silent due to acoustic fossils."]
Specific Asks
['Will the Minister publish a bold, co-ordinated and well-resourced plan with concrete steps ahead of COP16 in Colombia? Will she bring the global commitment to reverse nature loss by 2030 into UK law through a new climate and nature Bill?']
Rosebank Oilfield: Environmental Impacts
28 June 2023
Responding: Graham Stuart
Main Concerns
['Approving the Rosebank oilfield would release over 200 million tonnes of carbon dioxide, which is more than combined annual emissions of all low-income countries. The project does not align with climate targets and could harm marine ecosystems.']
Specific Asks
["The Government should review its approach to oil and gas licensing, scrap the investment allowance for fossil fuels, withdraw from the energy charter treaty, and stop Rosebank's development."]
Solar Rooftop Installations
22 March 2023
Responding: Graham Stuart
Main Concerns
["Ms Caroline Lucas is concerned about the current policy framework that has led to ups and downs in solar rooftop installations. She notes that while there has been a significant increase in installations, more needs to be done to meet the Government's target of increasing solar capacity from around 15 GW currently to 70 GW by 2035. Ms Lucas highlights that approximately two-thirds of existing solar power capacity is ground-based and one-third is on rooftops, with Solar Energy UK estimating this split among residential and commercial roofs. She also mentions a YouGov poll showing 80% public support for mandatory solar panels on suitable new-build homes."]
Specific Asks
['Ms Lucas calls for the Government to mandate solar panel installations on all suitable new-build homes as part of the future homes standard, without further consultation due to existing public support. She also asks for more joined-up, strategic approaches to address the skills shortage in the industry and how the Government plans to tackle under-representation of women and ethnic minorities.']
Fossil Fuels and Cost of Living Increases
11 January 2023
Responding: Graham Stuart
Main Concerns
['Ms Lucas expressed concern about the impact of fossil fuels on both the cost of living crisis and the climate emergency. She highlighted that over 9 million people spent Christmas in cold and damp homes due to high energy bills, with experts warning that gas prices are here to stay. She also mentioned a significant increase in health risks for those with cardiovascular or respiratory conditions unable to afford heating their homes. Ms Lucas noted the shocking fact that one-third of people with disabilities live in cold, damp homes and 25% of those with health conditions cannot heat their homes safely.']
Specific Asks
['Ms Lucas asked the Minister to commit to providing further support for vulnerable households given the increase in bills from April. She also called for a ban on forced installation of prepayment meters by court warrant and expressed concern about the lack of emphasis on energy efficiency measures, urging the Government to introduce a street-by-street home insulation programme.']
Non-proliferation Treaty: 50th Anniversary Review
13 July 2022
Responding: Graham Stuart
Main Concerns
["The nuclear non-proliferation treaty (NPT), having celebrated its 50th anniversary, faces challenges such as the UK's refusal to provide specific numbers on the size of its current stockpile or timelines for reduction. Concerns have been raised about undisclosed NATO nuclear weapon storage locations in Europe and potential capacity increases at Lakenheath. The Government has not yet decided which Ministers will attend the 10th review conference, potentially undermining the UK's commitment to strengthening the NPT."]
Specific Asks
['The Foreign Secretary should attend the review conference personally to underscore the importance of eradicating all nuclear weapons and calling on Russia and other nuclear weapon states to declare that they will not threaten or use nuclear weapons. The UK should also engage constructively with the UN treaty on the prohibition of nuclear weapons, which has been ratified by 63 nations.']
Climate Goals: Wellbeing Economy
30 November 2021
Responding: Helen Whately
Main Concerns
['The lead MP is concerned about the failure of current economic systems to address climate goals, inequality, and environmental destruction. She points out that ongoing economic growth threatens to exacerbate these issues. The petition calling for a wellbeing economy received nearly 70,000 signatures, highlighting public support for this approach. Scientific reports from IPCC/IPBES and business leaders like Paul Polman advocate for shifting away from GDP growth towards well-being and sustainability.']
Specific Asks
['The lead MP asks the Government to adopt new measures of economic success beyond GDP to prioritise climate, nature, and collective wellbeing. She seeks confirmation that the Government accepts this need and requests a timeline for progress.']
Legacy of Jo Cox
11 June 2026
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
I thank Jo’s family for their leadership and friendship, praising the tenacity and guts that have inspired others. I commend Kim Leadbeater for stepping into public life and continuing Jo Cox's legacy...
NHS 10-Year Plan 2025-07-03
03 July 2025
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Planning and Infrastructure Bill 2025-06-09
09 June 2025
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Police Accountability
23 October 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Grenfell Tower Inquiry Phase 2 Report
04 September 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Debate on the Address
17 July 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
I beg to move, that an humble Address be presented to His Majesty. The motion acknowledges the Gracious Speech and welcomes a legislative programme based on security, fairness and opportunity for all,...
Valedictory Debate
24 May 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
In her concluding remarks, Harriet Harman reflected on her 42-year tenure in the House of Commons, thanking her constituents for their support and expressing pride in being a Labour MP. She emphasised...
Political Violence and Disruption: Walney Report
22 May 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Infected Blood Compensation Scheme
21 May 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Coronavirus Act 2020 - Schedule 5 - Application of Chapter 1 of Part 1 to existing tenancies: transitional provision
24 April 2024
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
Mr. Jacob Young, the Member for Bermondsey and Old Southwark, moved that the clause be read a Second time. The specific amendment proposed in this speech does not provide detailed arguments but can be...
20
PMQs Asked
30
Ministerial Questions Asked
225
House of Commons Debates Involved
6
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
0
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 1457 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
+446% above average
This MP:
20
Average:
3.7
Ministerial Questions
+124% above average
This MP:
30
Average:
13.4
Westminster Hall Debates Led
+139% above average
This MP:
6
Average:
2.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+4530% above average
This MP:
225
Average:
4.9
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
9.5
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.5
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-100% below average
This MP:
0.0
Average:
69.2
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Caroline Lucas's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.