Claire Coutinho
MP for East Surrey
Con
12 Dec 2019 - Present
Questions Asked by This MP
Parliamentary questions and government responses.
Prime Minister's Questions
No PMQs questions found for this MP.
That is frankly another patronising non-answer from the Secretary of State. I am not sure whether he got the memo, but his party is fed up with the sexist boys club. What is crucial is that the public have lost faith in the Labour party. This is a serious moment. Does he accept that when he stands at the Dispatch Box and tells the public that by his calculation their bills are falling, not rising, they simply do not believe him? Does he also accept that when he does not set out what any of his plans—such as doubling the carbon tax or clean power 2030—will do to bills, he makes a mockery of his party's pretence that it cares about the cost of living? Does he not reflect on all this—the £300 nonsense pledge, the Great British Energy fig leaf—and realise that when it comes to loss of trust, he is not their salvation but their problem?
Context
The Secretary of State has claimed that bills are falling, not rising. The public does not believe these claims.
Ed Miliband
We will take no lectures from the right hon. Lady on the cost of living crisis, because her Government presided over the worst cost of living crisis in generations. Let me tell her what we are doing: £150 off bills; the warm home discount extended; the warm homes plan. We have done more in 18 months to cut bills for people than they did in 14 years.
Session: Topical Questions 2026-02-10
View All Questions -->
Last week, the Labour party voted to increase the carbon tax, which has already doubled due to its policies. It now accounts for over 10% of household electricity bills and represents a £5 billion annual tax burden. Can the Minister explain why Labour wants to impose higher costs on industry and households?
Context
Concerns have been raised about the impact of increased carbon taxes on households and industry, with some arguing that it discourages investment and increases reliance on dirtier imports.
Chris McDonald
I am not sure if the shadow Secretary of State is conflating the various carbon taxes with the emissions trading scheme, but to be clear: the Government do not set or comment on the value of the carbon in the emissions trading scheme. That is a matter for the market.
Session: UK Emissions Trading Scheme 2026-02-10
View All Questions -->
Last year, the Secretary of State signed a secret energy deal with China, which he has refused to publish. This is simply unheard of. We have heard repeatedly from intelligence services that China might seek to disrupt our energy system, so it is crucial that the public get to see what he has signed us up to. Will the Secretary of State commit to publishing the full text of his secret energy deal with China, and if not, will he tell the House what it is that he is trying to hide?
Context
The Secretary of State signed a secret energy deal with China, which has not been published. Intelligence services have raised concerns about China's potential to disrupt the UK's energy system.
Ed Miliband
May I give the right hon. Lady a piece of advice? Wacky conspiracy theories that she gets on the internet are no substitute for a proper policy.
Session: Topical Questions 2026-02-10
View All Questions -->
In the case of Gorton and Denton, we heard this week that The Muslim Vote has decided to endorse the Green party. This is overt sectarism in our midst. We know where sectarian politics leads—conflict and strife. Even one of Labour’s candidates at the last election was threatened with beheading. Will the Secretary of State call out this problem?
Context
The Muslim Vote has endorsed the Green Party in Gorton and Denton, leading to sectarian conflicts. A Labour candidate at a previous election was threatened with beheading.
The Minister for Women and Equalities (Bridget Phillipson)
I am not aware of the particular case that the right hon. Lady describes. What I can say is that violence, intimidation or harassment has no place in our politics. No political candidate or Member of Parliament should be subject to that kind of experience.
Session: Topical Questions 2026-01-28
View All Questions -->
Nurses up and down the country, including Darlington nurses and Jennifer Melle, are being hounded and harassed by the NHS simply for recognising that biological sex is real. I am grateful that the Minister has previously agreed to meet Jennifer. Will she hold accountable those in the NHS, the Nursing and Midwifery Council, and unions who have harassed and victimised these nurses?
Context
Nurses across the country are facing harassment from the NHS, unions, and other bodies for recognising biological sex as real. One such nurse is Jennifer Melle.
The Minister for Women and Equalities (Bridget Phillipson)
I look forward to meeting Jennifer soon to discuss her experiences and what more we can do to ensure that women in the NHS are safe at work. I am determined to ensure that the rights, voices and spaces for women who work in the NHS and women who are patients in the NHS are protected.
Session: Topical Questions 2026-01-28
View All Questions -->
Jennifer Melle, a black nurse with a faultless record, was racially abused by a convicted paedophile for correctly referring to his biological sex in a medical context. She was called the N-word multiple times in her workplace, yet she was the one who was punished by her NHS trust and the Nursing and Midwifery Council. She is still suspended from the job she loves, 18 months later. Does the Secretary of State agree that the dedicated nurses who are being punished for asserting that biological sex is real are facing a gross injustice, and will she meet Jennifer to hear her story?
Context
A black nurse, Jennifer Melle, was racially abused and suspended from her job after correctly referring to a convicted paedophile's biological sex in a medical context. She continues to face injustice 18 months later.
The Minister for Women and Equalities (Bridget Phillipson)
No one should face racist abuse or violence in any workplace, and that includes the NHS. As we have also seen with the Sandie Peggie case, coming to decisions on these cases in a timely manner is incredibly important. I hope that the matter the right hon. Lady refers to can be resolved as swiftly as possible. I would, of course, be happy to meet Jennifer to hear her experience.
Session: Topical Questions 2025-12-10
View All Questions -->
At this COP, acres of the Amazon were chopped down so that the Secretary of State can lecture us about saving the planet. Can the Minister justify why his Government did not even put a single penny into the forest fund, which could have at least repaired some of the damage?
Context
During the COP, forests in Brazil were deforested despite the Secretary of State lecturing about saving the planet. The UK did not put any money into the forest fund.
The Minister for Energy (Michael Shanks)
I think the shadow Secretary of State has a bit of a cheek talking about anyone’s action on the climate crisis when she has completely reversed her own position on it. The UK’s climate leadership is an incredibly important contribution to the world’s action on the climate crisis. That crisis is not a future threat, but a very present reality. The UK has been a part of the forest initiative; we have supported Brazil and others to make that happen. Of course, coming up to a Budget and with tight fiscal considerations, we want to make sure that every pound of British taxpayers’ money is spent.
Session: Topical Questions 2025-11-18
View All Questions -->
Labour’s previous definition of “Islamophobia” was adopted by councils that had grooming gang scandals, and it said that even talking about grooming gangs was an example of “anti-Muslim racism”. Public servants did not speak up because they were scared of being called racist. The Government are now bringing in a new definition but refuse to publish it before adoption. Will the Minister commit to publishing the draft definition for full public scrutiny?
Context
The context is criticism towards the previous Labour government's definition of 'Islamophobia' which was adopted by councils involved in grooming gang scandals, limiting discussions about such issues as ‘anti-Muslim racism’. The current Government are bringing a new definition but refuse to publish it before adoption.
The Minister for Equalities (Olivia Bailey)
Wherever there is abuse, it should be tackled, and we will publish details in due course.
Session: Diversity, Equality and Inclusion Public Sector 2025-11-05
View All Questions -->
In January, the Supreme Court ruled that sex means biological sex—a victory for women’s rights. However, there is concern over delays in releasing Equality and Human Rights Commission's (EHRC) guidance despite no legal changes being necessary. Will the Minister release this guidance to ensure women’s rights are protected?
Context
The Supreme Court ruled that sex means biological sex, affirming women’s rights. There are concerns about the delay in releasing guidance.
The Minister for Women and Equalities (Bridget Phillipson)
We are committed to protecting single-sex spaces. The Supreme Court ruling provides clarity, which providers should follow. We are working through the EHRC’s code of practice. Any suggestion of delay is incorrect; we must consult devolved Governments. A full regulatory impact assessment has not been required.
Session: Topical Questions 2025-11-05
View All Questions -->
I welcome the new Ministers to the Front Bench. On the first day of recess, away from scrutiny, the Labour party published the prices for its allocation round 7 of the renewables auction. Labour used to say that renewables were nine times cheaper, but the prices that the Secretary of State has said he is willing to pay are 40% higher than the current cost of electricity—they are the highest prices in a decade—and he has extended the contract length to 20 years. Those are not just the prices that we will be paying; they are the prices that our children will be paying. Will the Minister explain how locking us into higher prices for longer will cut bills by £300?
Context
Labour's proposed allocation round 7 of the renewables auction has sparked debate over its cost efficiency and long-term impact on consumer bills. Claire Coutinho questions the rationale behind such a proposal.
Martin McCluskey
The right hon. Lady’s comparison is absolute nonsense, and she knows it. She compares the cost of building and operating new renewables, which is what the contract for difference relates to, with the cost of operating—not building—gas plants. Once we make a fair comparison, the truth is that renewables are cheaper to build. We will take no lessons on energy policy from the Conservative party, which abandoned its commitment to clean energy at its party conference.
Session: Energy Prices Economic Growth 2025-10-14
View All Questions -->
The Secretary of State tried to argue yesterday that he is a climate change believer and everybody else who disagrees with him is a denier, because he does not want to engage with any legitimate criticism of his policies. He is offshoring British industries—in other words, replacing British goods with dirtier imports with higher emissions. Can the Minister confirm what the scientific evidence is that doing so will help to tackle climate change?
Context
The Secretary of State had argued that he is a climate change believer, dismissing any legitimate criticism as denial. The shadow Secretary of State criticized this stance and accused the government of offshoring British industries.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero (Kerry McCarthy)
Perhaps if the right hon. Member had been here yesterday, she would have been able to engage with the Secretary of State on this. The science is absolutely clear: every avoided fraction of a degree of warming makes a difference to the severity of climate impacts. That is why the Prime Minister went to the global leaders summit at COP29 last year to announce a new 1.5°C-aligned nationally determined contribution, and we will continue to show international leadership.
Session: Net Zero Policies 2025-07-15
View All Questions -->
Why will the Government not support sensible legislation to ban this practice?
Context
The MP references the right hon. Friend's tabled legislation to ban cousin marriages, which are known to significantly increase birth defects and risk coercive relationships.
Bridget Phillipson
The Government will of course always keep such issues under review, and I will ensure that the Minister in the relevant Department speaks with the right hon. Lady on this topic.
Session: Topical Questions 2024-12-18
View All Questions -->
That is not my figure; it is a figure from industry—£12 billion in lost North sea tax receipts, in addition to £8 billion for an energy company that will not generate energy, and at least £200 billion for a 2030 target that we now know will not cut bills. Is it not true that pensioners will be sitting in the cold this winter to pick up the bill for this Secretary of State?
Context
The MP reiterates concerns about the loss of North sea tax receipts, additional costs for an unproductive energy company, and high targets.
Ed Miliband
The truth is that there is only one way to get bills down sustainably in this country, which is to drive towards clean energy. The Conservatives used to believe that, too; then, in September 2023, the former Prime Minister took them on an anti-net zero crusade, and it is only getting worse.
Session: Topical Questions 2024-12-17
View All Questions -->
Given the Secretary of State's support for a high carbon tax that could devastate British industry, how many jobs would be lost due to this policy?
Context
The MP challenges the Labour party's promise, citing a potential £147 carbon tax in 2030 as detrimental to industry and job creation.
Sarah Jones
I do not recognise those figures at all. We inherited a mess in this country, with no stability or economic growth. Now we are fixing the foundations and putting that right by creating hundreds of thousands of jobs in the green sector.
Session: Great British Energy Job Creation 2024-12-17
View All Questions -->
Labour's policy on the North sea will cost the country £12 billion in tax receipts, which would be enough to cover the winter fuel payment for many, many years. Pensioners will be in the cold this winter, and this is a policy that no other major economy is pursuing. How can the Government possibly justify it?
Context
The MP is questioning the Government's North sea policy, citing industry figures that suggest it will cost £12 billion in lost tax receipts.
Ed Miliband
These are more fantasy numbers from the right hon. Lady. The truth is that the North sea has lost a third of its employment in the past decade. The only future for the North sea is in what this Government are doing: investing in carbon capture and storage, in offshore wind and in hydrogen.
Session: Topical Questions 2024-12-17
View All Questions -->
At the end of this month, For Women Scotland v. Scottish Ministers will be heard in the UK Supreme Court. Can the Government assure the House that they are now clear that the definition in 'sex' in the Equality Act 2010 means biological sex?
Context
The Conservative party committed to clarifying the definition of “sex” in the Equality Act 2010.
Bridget Phillipson
The right hon. Lady will appreciate that I will not comment on ongoing cases. However, I can be clear that the Equality Act 2010 sets out that providers, for example, have the right to restrict access to service on the basis of biological sex. This Government are proud of our achievements in legislating for the Equality Act. We will ensure providers can continue to support single-sex exemptions, and it is important that providers have clarity in this area. I would be happy to work with her to ensure that is the case.
Session: Topical Questions 2024-11-13
View All Questions -->
Does the Secretary of State agree that equality is not about group identities or placing one section of society on a platform above another, but about individual freedom and responsibility?
Context
The MP was honoured to take on the role of shadow Minister for Equalities.
Bridget Phillipson
I welcome the right hon. Lady to her place. I look forward to working with her on areas where we can agree and where we can take such concerns forward on a cross-party basis, wherever possible. I believe that she, like me, is passionate about tackling violence against women and girls. As she sets out, I believe that everyone in our country should have the chance to achieve all that they are capable of achieving. Our mission across Government is to ensure that where people are from does not determine what they can go on to achieve.
Session: Topical Questions 2024-11-13
View All Questions -->
This is the ministerial team who told the electorate they were going to cut their bills by £300, without doing any homework to find out how those plans would work. They voted against our amendment to hold them to account on their own pledge just two weeks ago, and now they are trying to claim that the NESO report shows that their approach will lower bills when in fact it shows in black and white that the system will be much more expensive. Does the Minister not see that if they follow this plan, we will be a warning, not an example, to the rest of the world and that the British people will be colder and poorer as a result?
Context
The government is criticized for making claims about lowering bills based on the NESO report, which suggests higher costs if certain conditions are not met.
Michael Shanks
Time and again, the Conservatives run away from their record on this in office. The reason why people right across this country are paying more on their energy bills is that the Conservatives did not get us off the rollercoaster of fossil fuel markets, but we are now moving at pace. The right hon. Lady may want to keep us in the vulnerable state where we are reliant on international gas markets, but we are determined that we will not do that. We will bring down bills and deliver energy security. I am not ashamed to say that we will move with great ambition to deliver what this country needs and to deliver the good jobs that go with it.
Session: Clean Energy by 2030 2024-11-12
View All Questions -->
Last week, the National Energy System Operator published a full systems cost analysis of the Secretary of State's flagship project to carbonise the grid by 2030. This morning, the Secretary of State said on several media outlets that the report shows that his plans will lower bills. I remind the House that the report assumes that gas prices are 40% higher than the Department's own estimates, that the price of carbon is at least double what it is now, and that they can build the grid at a pace we have never seen before in this country, without any delays. Even if all that is achieved, page 78 of the report shows that the cost of the system will be higher. For clarity, would the Minister like to repeat at the Dispatch Box the Secretary of State's claim that the NESO report shows that Labour's system will lead to a lower cost of electricity?
Context
The NESO report provides a full systems cost analysis of the Secretary of State's plan to carbonise the grid by 2030, which was mentioned as lowering bills despite assumptions that contradict these claims.
Michael Shanks
What the shadow Secretary of State has just outlined quite coherently is that the Conservatives have no ambition in this space whatsoever, but we do. I am very happy for the right hon. Lady to outline where our ambition is. We will build faster than the previous Government, although I have to say that that would not be difficult. The shadow Minister sitting next to her, the hon. Member for West Aberdeenshire and Kincardine (Andrew Bowie), said quite clearly at their conference that the previous Government had built infrastructure far too slowly, and their former Energy Minister, the right hon. Member for Beverley and Holderness (Graham Stuart), said that their onshore wind ban was “always mad”. We are quite happy to pick up where they left off and deliver the clean power that this country needs.
Session: Clean Energy by 2030 2024-11-12
View All Questions -->
Given the Prime Minister's announcement of higher carbon emission targets despite contributing only 1% of global emissions, and with leaders of major emitters absent; does the Minister agree that this approach could lead to more sacrifice for British people without significant benefits?
Context
The question addresses concerns about the UK's stringent carbon emission targets, their global impact, and reliance on imports from China.
Kerry McCarthy
I think the shadow Secretary of State needs to seek a debate if she wants to elaborate on these issues. Having attended COP last year as part of a cross-party delegation, I found it incredibly depressing to see the way the UK was received.
Session: Topical Questions 2024-11-12
View All Questions -->
What is my right hon. Friend's strategy to tackle grid capacity issues, and will he meet me and local businesses to discuss this?
Context
Grid capacity issues are holding back house building and green businesses in west London.
Michael Shanks
My hon. Friend is right about the issue holding back projects, which is why we are tackling it from day one by attempting to release network capacity and prioritising the queue for viable projects. We are building on what was done previously but should have been built over 14 years.
Session: Topical Questions 2024-10-08
View All Questions -->
Will the Secretary of State do the decent thing and set out the full systems cost of his approach so that the public can see what he will do to their bills?
Context
The Secretary of State is being criticized by his own party and others for an ideological approach to energy policy.
Ed Miliband
After three months, people have breathed a sigh of relief with our Government's plan for the country. The former networks Minister and Energy Minister criticised previous policy decisions by her party on nuclear power bans and solar consents delays.
Session: Topical Questions 2024-10-08
View All Questions -->
Other Parliamentary Activity
Debates led and petitions presented.
Offshore Wind 2026-01-14
14 January 2026
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
COP30 2025-11-25
25 November 2025
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Small Modular Nuclear Reactor Power Station Wylfa 2025-11-17
17 November 2025
Urgent Question
Contributed to this debate
Will the Minister confirm the development of the UK’s first small modular reactor (SMR) power station at Wylfa on Anglesey? The urgency is due to the potential economic and social benefits for the reg...
Energy 2025-11-12
12 November 2025
General Debate
Led by this MP
The House calls on the Government to introduce a plan for cheap power by cutting public expenditure, removing the Carbon Tax from electricity generation and ending Renewable Obligation subsidies. The ...
Electricity Market Review 2025-07-10
10 July 2025
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Heathrow Substation Outage NESO Review 2025-07-02
02 July 2025
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Minister made a statement on the publication of the report from the National Energy System Operator (NESO) following its review into the fire at the North Hyde substation, which occurred on March ...
The Great British Energy Bill - Clause 5 and related amendments
29 October 2024
Bill Debate
Contributed to this debate
I propose to move new clauses 2 and 3, which would give Great British Energy a duty to contribute to the achievement of Environment Act targets through nature-based solutions. Additionally, I propose ...
VAT: Independent Schools
08 October 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Government has decided to impose Value Added Tax (VAT) on independent school fees, a move that many critics believe undermines educational provision and parental choice. This policy is particularl...
Carbon Capture, Usage and Storage
07 October 2024
Ministerial Statement
Contributed to this debate
Making Britain a Clean Energy Superpower
26 July 2024
General Debate
Contributed to this debate
The Government's plan aims to address the challenges of energy insecurity, skyrocketing consumer bills, job creation in industrial heartlands, and climate change by investing in clean energy. The Ener...
Attendance
18.2%
4 of 22 votes
Aye Votes
3
13.6% of votes
No Votes
1
4.5% of votes
Abstentions
18
81.8% of votes
03 Feb 2026
VOTED NO
Universal Credit (Removal of Two Child Limit) Bill: Second Reading
Ayes: 458
Noes: 104
Passed
28 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Opposition Day: British Indian Ocean Territory
Ayes: 103
Noes: 284
Failed
28 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Opposition Day: Youth unemployment
Ayes: 91
Noes: 287
Failed
27 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill: Amendment 9
Ayes: 91
Noes: 378
Failed
27 Jan 2026
VOTED AYE
Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill: Amendment 1
Ayes: 88
Noes: 310
Failed
27 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Medical Training (Prioritisation) Bill: Amendment 2
Ayes: 61
Noes: 311
Failed
21 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Insurance Contributions (Employer Pensions Contributions) Bill Commi...
Ayes: 195
Noes: 317
Failed
21 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
The Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023 (Remedial...
Ayes: 373
Noes: 106
Passed
21 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Insurance Contributions (Employer Pensions Contributions) Bill: Thir...
Ayes: 316
Noes: 194
Passed
21 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
National Insurance Contributions (Employer Pensions Contributions) Bill Commi...
Ayes: 191
Noes: 326
Failed
20 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Diego Garcia Military Base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill: motion to...
Ayes: 347
Noes: 184
Passed
20 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Sentencing Bill: motion to disagree with Lords Amendment 7
Ayes: 319
Noes: 127
Passed
20 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Diego Garcia Military Base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill: motion to...
Ayes: 344
Noes: 182
Passed
20 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Diego Garcia Military Base and British Indian Ocean Territory Bill: motion to...
Ayes: 347
Noes: 185
Passed
13 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: Clause 63 Stand part
Ayes: 348
Noes: 167
Passed
13 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 26
Ayes: 172
Noes: 334
Failed
13 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 9
Ayes: 181
Noes: 335
Failed
13 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: Clause 86 stand part
Ayes: 344
Noes: 173
Passed
13 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 25
Ayes: 187
Noes: 351
Failed
13 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 24
Ayes: 184
Noes: 331
Failed
12 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: New Clause 7
Ayes: 188
Noes: 341
Failed
12 Jan 2026
DID NOT VOTE
Finance (No. 2) Bill Committee: Amendment 3
Ayes: 185
Noes: 344
Failed
0
PMQs Asked
22
Ministerial Questions Asked
11
House of Commons Debates Involved
0
Westminster Hall Debates Led
0
Statements / Bills
0
Petitions Presented
22
Voting Record
Activity Compared to Peers
How does this MP's parliamentary activity compare to the national average across 649 MPs?
Prime Minister's Questions
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
1.9
Ministerial Questions
+177% above average
This MP:
22
Average:
7.9
Westminster Hall Debates Led
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
1.5
Commons Chamber Debates
+365% above average
This MP:
11
Average:
2.4
Statements / Bills Proposed
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
5.1
Petitions Presented
-100% below average
This MP:
0
Average:
2.2
Voting Attendance Rate (%)
-76% below average
This MP:
18.2
Average:
75.6
Important Context
- - Ministers answer questions rather than asking them, so have different activity patterns
- - Activity quantity doesn't measure quality or effectiveness of representation
- - Some MPs focus more on constituency work than parliamentary questions
- - Newly elected MPs will have less parliamentary history
About This Page
This page tracks Claire Coutinho's parliamentary activity including questions asked, debates (Commons Chamber + Westminster Hall), statements/bills, and petitions presented.