← Back to House of Commons Debates
Claim of Right for Scotland
27 January 2020
Lead MP
Patricia Gibson
Debate Type
Adjournment Debate
Tags
TaxationBrexitDemocracy & Elections
Other Contributors: 3
At a Glance
Patricia Gibson raised concerns about claim of right for scotland in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Lead Contributor
Opened the debate
The debate tonight comes at a critical time for Scotland, with the UK on the cusp of withdrawing from the European Union. The people of Scotland rejected this by a significant majority in the referendum. However, due to the democratic will difference between England and Scotland, Scotland is being dragged out of the EU against its wishes. This shows the myth of the union of equals, as the devolved legislatures in Scotland have refused consent to the UK's withdrawal agreement. The SNP won 80% of the seats in Scotland but the Government still refuses to accept Scotland’s democratic right to choose its own future. Despite not winning over 50% of the popular vote in the election, the Tories continue to deny Scotland’s claim of right to exercise its democratic will.
David Mundell
Con
Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale
In his constituency and others during the general election week, SNP candidates told voters that the election was about voting against Brexit or Boris Johnson, but by 10 o’clock on December 12th it became clear that it was all about independence.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
While many people voted for the SNP due to their hard work and dedication, a proportion of those who voted Scot Nats do not accept the case for independence.
David Linden
SNP
Glasgow East
The three Scottish Tory Members rushed from Holyrood to Westminster, questioning why they did so. If the only tool in the Government’s arsenal is not winning over 50% of the popular vote, then where is the democratic mandate for this version of Brexit?
Government Response
While acknowledging Patricia Gibson's efforts to secure the debate, Douglas Ross stated that in his constituency and others during the recent general election campaign, issues such as the claim of right for Scotland did not come up frequently. He noted that healthcare funding and service delivery were critical issues raised by constituents, indicating a focus on tangible matters rather than constitutional debates. Referring to SNP leaflets promoting votes against Brexit or Boris Johnson but not explicitly advocating independence, Ross argued that the SNP's campaign was misleading. On the issue of once-in-a-generation referendums, he cited the 2014 White Paper which stated such referenda were rare events. He also highlighted recent council by-election victories for the Scottish Conservatives as evidence of shifting public opinion. Finally, Ross emphasised focusing on issues like hospital building and police station conditions rather than constitutional wrangling.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.