← Back to House of Commons Debates
Independent Fan-led Review of Football Governance
25 November 2021
Lead MP
Nigel Huddleston
Debate Type
Ministerial Statement
Tags
Culture, Media & Sport
Other Contributors: 22
At a Glance
Nigel Huddleston raised concerns about independent fan-led review of football governance in the House of Commons. A government minister responded. Other MPs also contributed.
How the Debate Unfolded
MPs spoke in turn to share their views and ask questions. Here's what each person said:
Government Statement
The minister thanked Tracey Crouch, the advisory panel of experts, and football fans for their contributions to the report on football governance. He acknowledged that football clubs are central to communities but noted issues with fan representation in governance. The review was triggered in April following incidents at Bury, Macclesfield Town, and the European Super League. A comprehensive final report has been presented, setting out 10 strategic recommendations and 47 detailed ones. The minister emphasised that fundamental change is needed and endorsed the primary recommendation for a strong, independent regulator, with the Government committed to working at pace to determine its implementation.
Jo Stevens
Lab
Cardiff East
Question
Congratulated Tracey Crouch on her work, thanked fans, and called for an independent regulator. She questioned the Government's commitment based on previous tweets and statements, seeking confirmation that both principle and detail will be accepted and enshrined in legislation. Asked about delays and timelines for a Bill, also inquired about discussions with Welsh clubs.
Minister reply
Acknowledged the shadow’s concerns but could not commit 100% to all proposals today due to the need for formal responses. Emphasised moving at pace and intended to proceed quickly.
Question
Recognised her unique position as a sitting MP chairing the review, urging the Minister to accept recommendations as a package. Thanked fans who contributed to the review.
Minister reply
Agreed with Tracey Crouch and thanked her for extensive work. Emphasised moving at pace in formulating Government's response.
Question
Praised Scottish teams’ success and governance changes, suggesting similar moves in England to counter oligarchic ownership. Questioned further actions against problematic investors like those at Newcastle United.
Minister reply
Acknowledged sport is a devolved matter but highlighted learnings from the review that could apply in Scotland too.
Damian Collins
Con
Thames Estuary
Question
Welcomed the report and asked if the Government accept that an effective regulator must have real-time access to financial information about football clubs.
Minister reply
Acknowledged the importance of adequate powers for the regulator and confirmed that such elements will be part of the package being considered.
Clive Betts
Lab
Sheffield South East
Question
Asked if the regulator must have real powers to redistribute funding to address financial discrepancies between leagues.
Minister reply
Agreed that the regulator needs adequate powers and mentioned that flow of finance recommendations will be considered in the response.
James Daly
Con
Bury
Question
Asked if all stakeholders should work together to ensure Bury FC can return to Gigg Lane.
Minister reply
Agreed and offered support for efforts to bring football back to the historic stadium.
Jamie Stone
Lib Dem
Caithness, Sutherland and Easter Ross
Question
Asked if the Minister will have close negotiations with Scottish Government Ministers and consult Scottish fan base.
Minister reply
Confirmed ongoing constructive meetings and shared learnings with Scottish sports Ministers.
Jane Hunt
Con
Loughborough
Question
Complimented the review being fan-led and asked if fans will have both resource and legal capacity to exercise control.
Minister reply
Acknowledged that detailed elements including scope, powers, and resources need further work but supported in principle.
Tony Lloyd
Lab
Manchester Central
Question
Asked if supporters will have both resource and legal capacity to exercise control, highlighting the importance of community ownership.
Minister reply
Confirmed that details including scope, powers, and resources need further work but supported in principle.
David Jones
Con
Clwyd West
Question
Asked if Minister will liaise closely with the Welsh Government considering five Welsh football clubs in English pyramid.
Minister reply
Confirmed close liaison and legislative consent from Welsh Government for any changes affecting clubs.
Barry Sheerman
Lab
Huddersfield
Question
Praised the report and highlighted community importance of football clubs, suggesting co-operative ownership.
Minister reply
Acknowledged the community role of football clubs and encouraged football authorities to implement common sense recommendations.
Chingford and Woodford Green
Question
Welcomed the report on football governance, emphasised the importance of successful league management and preventing money from entering sport under suspicious circumstances. Mentioned the need to stop people bringing in dodgy money into football.
Minister reply
Acknowledged the points made by Iain Duncan Smith; highlighted the unique nature of football requiring regulation due to its inability to reform itself. Emphasised the economic value of football, citing a report stating that inbound tourism for football matches was worth £1.4 billion to the UK economy.
Jessica Morden
Lab
Newport East
Question
Praised the review and highlighted Newport County as an example of community ownership benefits. Asked if the Minister would look at the model as an example for other clubs.
Minister reply
Agreed with Jessica Morden, praised the positive models like the one in Newport, emphasised the need to adopt successful co-operative models across the country.
Philip Hollobone
Con
Question
Congratulated Tracey Crouch on her report and raised concerns about grassroots funding. Asked for more money from transfer fees to flow down to grassroots clubs.
Minister reply
Acknowledged Philip Hollobone's question, emphasised the importance of grassroots success in football finance ecosystem and mentioned existing changes moving funds from top tiers to lower tiers.
Peter Grant
Lab
Question
Pointed out disparities in resources between premier league clubs and smaller clubs. Asked for action on preventing unsuitable individuals or organisations from taking over football clubs.
Minister reply
Agreed with Peter Grant, highlighted the need to consider financial flows within sport as part of future regulatory environment.
Question
Praised Tracey Crouch's report and mentioned local clubs in Worksop Town. Emphasised the importance of a partnership between fans and owners.
Minister reply
Agreed with Brendan Clarke-Smith, stressed the need for all clubs to take their responsibility towards fans seriously.
Chris Elmore
Lab
Bridgend
Question
Complimented Tracey Crouch and pushed for a formal Government response detailing timelines.
Minister reply
Acknowledged Chris Elmore's urgency, mentioned ongoing work to respond formally to the report.
David Johnston
Con
Question
Praised Tracey Crouch’s report and highlighted small clubs in his constituency. Asked how recommendations could protect such clubs.
Minister reply
Agreed with David Johnston, emphasised the importance of putting smaller clubs on a sustainable footing.
Margaret Ferrier
Ind
Question
Asked about the impact of lifting ban on drinking alcohol in stands and asked for measures to mitigate antisocial behaviour.
Minister reply
Agreed with Margaret Ferrier, mentioned a pilot programme as one of the recommendations rather than full removal.
Scott Benton
Lab
Blackpool South
Question
Welcomes the new owners and directors test for clubs proposed in a review, which aims to prevent situations like that seen at Blackpool FC over the past decade.
Minister reply
Acknowledges the importance of the current owners and directors test not meeting all expectations. The minister's hon. Friend (Tracey Crouch) has made recommendations which will be seriously considered. Praises new ownership changes for positively impacting clubs' position in their communities.
Jim Shannon
DUP
Strangford
Question
Praises the hon. Member for Chatham and Aylesford (Tracey Crouch) for her work on football club governance reforms. Questions how reforms will allow structured approach without stifling innovation, highlighting the balance between responsibility and encouraging investment in football.
Minister reply
Acknowledges the delicate balance required to encourage success and sustainability while ensuring responsible management of clubs' financial considerations.
Shadow Comment
Jo Stevens
Shadow Comment
The shadow welcomed the review's key recommendation of an independent regulator but called for more fan involvement and commitment from the Government. She expressed concern over the Minister’s statement on endorsing in principle, seeking confirmation that both the principle and detail will be accepted and enshrined in primary legislation. The shadow also questioned the timeline for legislative action and the need to discuss breakaway league proposals with supporters’ shadow boards.
▸
Assessment & feedback
Summary accuracy
About House of Commons Debates
House of Commons debates take place in the main chamber of the House of Commons. These debates cover a wide range of topics including government policy, legislation, and current affairs. MPs from all parties can participate, question ministers, and hold the government accountable for its decisions.